Lecture 6-3: Application and the Preacher's Responsibility
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Map of the New Testament
- Lecture 1-2: One Passage, One Thrust
- Lecture 1-3: Letting the Passage Set the Form
- Lecture 1-4: How Preaching Traditions Differ
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Naming the Kind of Writing
- Lecture 2-1: What Kind of Writing a Gospel Is
- Lecture 2-2: Telling a Gospel Scene
- Lecture 2-3: Miracles and the Hearer Who Is Not Healed
- Lecture 2-4: Preaching a Parable
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Scene or a Parable
- Lecture 3-1: Signs and Discourses in John
- Lecture 3-2: Preaching the Passion
- Lecture 3-3: The Resurrection Accounts
- Lecture 3-4: Preaching in the Church's Year and the Short Homily
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Sign or a Resurrection Scene
- Lecture 4-1: Between Description and Rule
- Lecture 4-2: The Speeches in Acts
- Lecture 4-3: The Community and the Hard Passages
- Lecture 4-4: Preaching Acts as a Series
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, One Scene from Acts
- Lecture 5-1: A Letter Is a Letter
- Lecture 5-2: Following an Argument
- Lecture 5-3: Doctrinal Passages and the Traditions
- Lecture 5-4: Household Codes, Authority and Hard Commands
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Mapping One Letter Passage
Application is the point in a sermon where the passage meets the hearer's week. It is also the point where a preacher can do the most good and the most harm. Until now the sermon has been tied to the text. In application, the preacher's own hopes, anger, worries and opinions are free to come in, and they often do so quietly.
This lecture asks three things. What kinds of application are there? How do I keep what the text says apart from what I think? And what must I check, before I stand up, about who is listening and what my sentences may do to them? The second and third questions are the practical form of the course's central claim: preaching is service in front of the text, not a use of the text.
How the general craft of a sermon works, including the power of the pulpit and what a hearer's trust costs, is taught in PT726E. This lecture asks only what changes when the passage is a New Testament one and the application is yours to supply.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Name four kinds of application and say what each asks of the sermon.
- Separate in a draft what the text says from what you think, and label the second honestly.
- Recognise five ways the pulpit is misused and say what each does to hearers.
- State three views on how far the pulpit goes into public and political matters, each in its strongest form.
- Use a five-question check before you preach.
For we don’t preach ourselves, but Christ Jesus as Lord, and ourselves as your servants for Jesus’ sake;" — 2 Corinthians 4:5
World English Bible
Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly; neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock." — 1 Peter 5:2-3
WEB
Let not many of you be teachers, my brothers, knowing that we will receive heavier judgment." — James 3:1
WEB
Paul says what a preacher is for. Peter says how a leader should hold authority. James says what is at stake for a teacher. Read them as a description of the job, not as a rebuke.
1. Four kinds of application
Not every sermon asks the hearer to do something. Application has at least four kinds, and a preacher who knows them can choose.
Belief. The sermon asks the hearer to trust, or to see something differently: God keeps his word; Christ is present; this death was not wasted. The hearer leaves changed in what they hold, and there may be nothing to do on Monday.
Action. The sermon asks the hearer to do or stop doing something. This is the kind most preachers think of first. It is the easiest to turn into pressure.
The community. The sermon asks the assembly, together, to be or to do something: to welcome, to forgive its own, to review how it uses its money. It is addressed to "we", and the preacher is inside the "we".
The neighbour and public life. The sermon asks how the passage touches the street, the workplace, the town. This kind raises the hardest questions in this lecture, and we come to it below.
A fifth ending is not an application in the usual sense: wonder, thanks, silence. Some passages, a resurrection scene for example, are best left standing without an instruction. A preacher who always ends in a task has made every passage into the same passage.
Most traditions, in their own words, put what God has done before what the hearers are asked to do. The Lutheran distinction between law and gospel, the Reformed order of grace and then gratitude, the Wesleyan grace that sets life in motion, the Catholic homily that leads toward the and the Orthodox preaching inside the all keep some form of this order. A sermon whose application comes before the news has usually missed the passage.
Here is the difference it makes (an invented example).
Before: "Therefore, this week, forgive everyone who has wronged you." After: "God has already forgiven us at great cost. If there is someone you cannot yet forgive, this passage does not tell you to feel nothing. It tells you what God has done, and it asks you to begin where you are able."
The second version does not take back the call. It puts the call after the gift. It also leaves room for a hearer who has been harmed, and whom a blunt command would send back into danger. That is the beginning of responsibility.
2. What the text says and what I think
Every application sentence belongs to one of two kinds. Either the text says it, or the preacher thinks it. Both are allowed. The fault is to give the second the authority of the first.
A simple habit helps. Take a page, draw a line down the middle, and write The text says on the left and I think on the right. Each application sentence goes in one column. Then, in the sermon, say which column it came from, in plain words: "the passage says this", "I think this follows, and faithful people disagree".
An example (invented). A preacher is on a passage that tells God's people to welcome the stranger. The left column reads: the stranger is to be welcomed; God's people were themselves strangers. The right column reads: I think a certain proposal before the city council is unjust. The preacher may hold the second view with conviction. But the sermon that says "the passage tells us to oppose the proposal" has put the preacher's opinion under the passage's name. The sermon that says "the passage tells us to welcome the stranger, and I believe that includes how we vote on this, though others in this room will think differently" has done the honest thing. Hearers can then weigh the opinion for what it is.
This habit protects the preacher as well. It is hard to preach for twenty years and never find that a favourite application was only a favourite.
3. Five ways the pulpit is misused
The list below is not a list of villains. These are patterns that sincere preachers fall into, usually without noticing, and each one does a specific thing to hearers.
Grievance. A quarrel with a member, a leader or a former friend finds its way into the sermon through a text that seems to fit. Those who know the story feel used. Those who do not feel something is wrong and cannot say what. The sermon becomes about the preacher.
Attack on an absent person or group. A person or a group is named, or described so that everyone knows who is meant, and is shamed from the front. They cannot answer. The preacher takes no risk. Whatever the preacher's reason, this is not what the text is for.
Pressure for money. Scripture speaks of giving, and a sermon on giving is a legitimate sermon. Readers also differ on questions such as the tithe and on how a church ought to raise funds. The fault is pressure: a sermon that leaves hearers feeling that they will be judged if they do not give, or that ties giving to the preacher's own income or to a building. The text is not a lever.
Bargaining and prosperity promises. A sermon says, or implies, that if the hearer gives, believes or speaks in the right way, then God will give health or wealth in return. Many who hold this view are sincere, and they point to passages on blessing. The difficulty is what it does to a hearer who gives, believes and still stays sick or poor. They are left with a verdict on themselves. Speak of God's goodness and of Scripture's promises as the text states them. Do not turn a promise into a contract, and never imply that a person's suffering is their own failure. Lecture 2-3 made the same point about healing.
The preacher's own authority. "I am God's servant, so do not question this." Peter warns against lording it over those entrusted to you. A leader who shelters behind the pulpit teaches hearers not to speak, and the hearer who most needs to speak will be the quietest. James says teachers will be judged more strictly. That is not a threat to preachers; it is the weight of the job.
4. How far the pulpit goes into public matters
This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians who love the same Scripture disagree about this.
Some hold that the pulpit must address public justice. The biblical story is full of kings, courts, harvests and the poor. A preacher who is silent about oppression is not neutral, because silence also takes a side. For these readers, the sermon that avoids public matters has made God's word smaller than it is.
Others hold that the pulpit keeps to the text and leaves politics to conscience. The pulpit's authority is the passage. A preacher who speaks on policy gives a personal opinion the authority of Scripture and may divide a community that Christ gathered from every party. For these readers, the faithful way to shape public life is to form the consciences of the hearers and let them act.
Others hold that the pulpit speaks to rulers and poor alike. The text names duties for both, the sermon names both, and it does not take a side in party terms. For these readers the pulpit has something to say that neither side wants to hear.
What this course requires is less than any of these requires. Separate what the passage says from what you think, using the two columns above. Follow your community's own rules and the law of the place where you preach about political campaigning, because rules differ from country to country and from community to community, and some places limit what a religious body may say about elections. Never shame a named person. And weigh who carries the risk. In some places a sermon is overheard by people with power, and the hearers who bear the consequences are not the preacher.
5. A check before you preach
Before the sermon, put five questions to it. They take ten minutes. They are the practical form of "we don't preach ourselves."
- Who is listening? Think of the hurt one, the doubter, the visitor, the child, the person you disagree with, and the one who is quietly in danger.
- Who may be hurt by this sentence? Read the application sentences aloud as if you were that person.
- Am I standing under the text, or using it? Could I preach this if the text said the opposite of what I want?
- Which sentences are the text's and which are mine, and have I said so?
- Would I say this to the person's face? If a sentence is aimed at someone, say it to them in private, if it needs saying at all.
If the check shows that a hearer may be in harm, a sermon is not the tool. Speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, follow the written rules of your community and the law where you live, and if someone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
A preacher who runs the check will not always change the sermon. The aim is that every sentence that goes out has been put through the question of who it is for.
Diagram 1. The pre-sermon check
Diagram 2. Five misuses of the pulpit, and what each does
| Misuse | What it does to hearers |
|---|---|
| Grievance | Makes the sermon about the preacher; some hearers feel used |
| Attack on the absent | Shames someone who cannot answer |
| Pressure for money | Turns the text into a lever; leaves hearers feeling judged |
| Bargaining and prosperity | Leaves the sick or poor hearer with a verdict on themselves |
| The preacher's own authority | Teaches hearers not to question, and silences the one who needs to speak |
In short
- Application comes in four kinds: belief, action, the community, and the neighbour in public life. A sermon may also end in wonder or silence.
- Most traditions put what God has done before what hearers are asked to do; an application that comes before the news has usually missed the passage.
- Keep two columns: what the text says and what I think. Say aloud which is which.
- The pulpit is misused by grievance, attack on the absent, pressure for money, bargaining promises and the preacher's own authority.
- Readers differ on how far the pulpit goes into public matters. Follow your community's rules and local law, and shame no named person.
- Before you preach, ask who is listening, who may be hurt, whether you stand under the text, whose sentence it is, and whether you would say it to a face.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four kinds of application | Belief; action; the community; the neighbour and public life. |
| The two columns | What the text says; what I think. Say which is which in the sermon. |
| Five misuses | Grievance; attack on the absent; pressure for money; bargaining promises; the preacher's own authority. |
| The pre-sermon check | Who listens? Who may be hurt? Under or using? Whose sentence? To the face? |
One sentence to remember Give the text its own authority, and call your own opinion by its own name.
This week's action Take your next sermon draft, mark each application sentence "text" or "mine", and say aloud, in the draft, which is which.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four kinds of application do you use most? Which do you almost never use, and why?
- Take a recent or imagined application sentence. Does the text say it, or do you think it? How would you say so in the sermon?
- Which of the five misuses is hardest for you to see in your own preaching, and who in your community could tell you gently?
- Which of the three views on public matters is closest to your community's, and what does it require of a preacher there?
- Who in your community would hear the sentence you most want to say as an accusation? What do you do with the sentence?