FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT729E Ceremonies in Practice: Weddings, Funerals and Baptisms

Lecture 5-3: Hard Funerals

Contents 31
PT729E Ceremonies in Practice: Weddings, Funerals and Baptisms
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Threshold and a Community
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Ceremonies at the Thresholds of Life
Chapter 1 · Week 1: What a Ceremony Is
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Community Before God at a Threshold
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Logic of an Order of Service
  3. Lecture 1-3: Choosing and Writing Words
  4. Lecture 1-4: Room, Time, Music, Cameras and the Officiant's Place
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Order on One Page
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Wedding
  1. Lecture 2-1: Order and Vows
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Wedding Address
  3. Lecture 2-3: Meeting the Couple Before the Day
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Day Itself
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Vows and Questions
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Baptism, Dedication and Membership
  1. Lecture 3-1: Order, Words and Water
  2. Lecture 3-2: Babies, Children and Adults
  3. Lecture 3-3: Traditions That Differ
  4. Lecture 3-4: After the Water: Welcome and Follow-Up
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Baptism or Dedication on One Page
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Funeral and Memorial Service
  1. Lecture 4-1: From the Death to the First Visit
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Order of a Funeral or Memorial Service
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Address and the Prayers
  4. Lecture 4-4: Customs, Ancestor Rites, Burial and Cremation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The First Visit and the Order
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Hard Places
  1. Lecture 5-1: Remarriage and Marriages Across Cultures and Faiths
  2. Lecture 5-2: Requests the Officiant's Community Does Not Settle
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hard Funerals
  4. Lecture 5-4: Divided Families and Mixed Crowds
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Answering a Hard Request
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Care Before and After; Ethics
  1. Lecture 6-1: Fees, Gifts and Transparency
  2. Lecture 6-2: Records, Certificates and Privacy
  3. Lecture 6-3: Care After the Ceremony
  4. Lecture 6-4: Limits, Rest and Saying No
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Three Months of Ceremonies

Jump to the key points ↓

28 min

Lecture 4-2 gave the order of an ordinary funeral. This lecture is about the services that are not ordinary: the funeral after a death by suicide, the service after a miscarriage or a stillbirth, the funeral of a child, and the service after a sudden death that no one expected. Officiants often fear these. The fear is reasonable. The family is in shock, the words they need are hard to find, and the old phrases that help at other funerals can hurt here.

This lecture teaches a few things only. It teaches language without stigma: how to speak of these deaths so that no one is blamed and no one is told what God has decided. It teaches what to leave out, which is the method of a death, the means, and any description of a body. It teaches how to name the dead, how to include children, and how to meet a family's guilt without arguing with it. And it teaches what to do if, in the middle of the work, you meet a person who is in danger now.

The long accompaniment of a bereaved family, the psychology of grief and the shape of mourning over months and years belong to Grief and Bereavement Care (PT724E). Here we cover only the time from the news to the service and the first words afterwards.

A few terms. A stillbirth is the death of a baby before or during birth, late in a pregnancy; a miscarriage is the loss of a pregnancy earlier. Words differ by place and by medical practice, so use the words the parents use. Commendation means giving the dead person into the care of God in prayer. Safe messaging is the name some health bodies give to ways of speaking about suicide that do not increase risk for others; what it asks of an officiant is set out below.

What these 28 minutes give you

  • Use language about suicide, miscarriage, stillbirth and a child's death that blames no one and passes no verdict on the dead.
  • Explain why a service leaves out method, means and any description of a body.
  • Describe how to name the dead, and how to include children at the service, in plain and honest words.
  • Respond to a family's guilt without arguing with it and without falsely absolving it.
  • Know what to do, in principle, if someone present is in danger now.

Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalms 34:18

World English Bible

It is because of Yahweh’s loving kindnesses that we are not consumed, because his compassion doesn’t fail. They are new every morning; great is your faithfulness." — Lamentations 3:22-23

WEB

The first verse speaks of God's nearness to the brokenhearted. The second was written in the shadow of ruin, and it speaks of mercy that does not run out. Neither verse explains a death, and neither should be used to. They are given for the room, not for the cause: God is near, and mercy is new each morning. Use them only if you can say them as comfort and not as correction. Someone who has lost a child may hear "new every morning" as an insult on the first day. Read slowly, offered, never pressed.

1. Three rules before anything else

Three rules apply to every service in this lecture, and the rest of the lecture rests on them.

Rule one: no method, no means, no description of a body. At no point in the service, in the address, in the printed order or in conversation do you say how a person died if they died by their own hand. You do not name a method, a place, a tool or a substance. You do not describe what a body looked like, in any death. You do not describe how a child's last hours went. The family may need to speak about these things in private, and you may need to listen. A public service is not the place. Hearing such detail can harm people in the room who are already at risk, and it adds nothing the family needs.

Rule two: no blame, and no verdict. No sentence in the service says or hints that the dead person, the parents or any relative caused the death or could have prevented it. No sentence says that the dead are saved. No sentence says that they are lost. You cannot know, and neither can anyone in the room. What you can do is commend the person to God, and the section below describes how.

Rule three: the family decides what is said about them. Ask the family what they want people to know. Ask what they do not want said. If a family wants the cause of death named in plain general terms (for example, "died suddenly" or "died by suicide"), that is theirs to choose. If they do not, you do not go further than they permit.

2. Language without stigma

Words carry weight. A few small changes remove a great deal of pain.

Instead of Say
"committed suicide" "died by suicide" or "took their own life" or, if the family prefers, "died suddenly"
"failed attempt" or "successful" do not use these at all
"He was weak" / "She was selfish" say nothing of this kind; say "He was in pain that was too heavy to carry" only if the family agrees
"God needed another angel" "We do not know why. We know that God is near."
"Everything happens for a reason" "I have no explanation, and I will not pretend to."
"At least you can have another child" say nothing like this, ever
"He is in a better place" use only if the family asks and your tradition says it; otherwise, "We commend him to God's care."
"Sleeping" (of a dead child) "died"

The word "committed" is the old word for a crime, and it keeps the stigma alive. Many families and many helping bodies avoid it for that reason. If a person in the room uses it, you do not correct them in public; you use the better phrase yourself.

The word "died" is kind when it is plain. Children, in particular, understand "died" and are confused by "gone," "lost," "passed" or "fell asleep," which can make them afraid of sleep or of the person who is "taking people away."

3. What can be said of the dead

This is a point where readers will not agree. Communities differ on what may be said about the eternal future of a person who has died, and the difference is sharpest when the death is by suicide or when a baby dies before baptism. Some traditions commend every dead person to God's mercy in the words of their service book, without pronouncing on the person's destiny; they hold that judgment belongs to God alone and that the Church's work is to pray. Some traditions speak with firm hope about believers only, and are quiet or silent about those who were not known to be believers; they hold that the promises of Scripture are given to those who trust God and that honesty requires saying only what is promised. Some traditions say very little at all at the graveside, leaving the dead in silence before God. In the past, some communities limited or refused certain rites for those who died by suicide. Many have since changed their rule, and others have kept some limits; the rule of your own community will tell you where you stand. Each of these positions comes from a wish to be faithful: to say neither more nor less than is known. What this course requires is that you neither condemn nor pronounce. You commend the person to God in the words your community uses. If your community's rule limits the rite you are asked for, you tell the family so, honestly and kindly, as a rule of the community and not a judgment on the person; you offer the prayer and the presence that you can give; and you refer, if there is a colleague who can do more.

For many bereaved people, the question Where is she now? is the real question under every other one. Do not answer it with more certainty than you have. You can say what the words of your community say. You can say that you do not know everything and that you trust the mercy of God. You can say that the family's love for her is itself something God honours. Do not say that the family should have prayed more, or believed more, or taught her better.

4. The funeral after a death by suicide

The family has been given a double grief. They have lost someone they love, and they often carry questions, silence from neighbours and a sense of shame that nobody has earned. Some will be angry at the dead. Some will be angry at God, at each other or at you. Some will say, over and over, If only.

What helps:

  • Say the person's name, and say who they were. Their kindness, their humour, their work, their love for particular people. Not only the way they died.
  • Do not make the death the story. The service honours a life that was larger than its ending.
  • Keep the cause in general terms, or leave it out, as the family wishes.
  • Speak truthfully of pain. You may say that some people live with a pain that others cannot see, and that it can become too heavy to carry. You may say that this is not anyone's fault.
  • Offer help to the living. Many people in the room are at higher risk of their own distress in the weeks after such a death. A short sentence at the end of the service tells them that help exists: "If you are carrying a heavy burden of your own, please speak to someone this week, a friend, a pastor, a doctor, or a crisis line in our country." Do not list methods or numbers beyond what the local helping bodies recommend. At most name the category (a crisis line) and, if you know a local one is reliable, say so in the printed order.
  • Leave the family time. Do not hurry the first visit. Sit. Listen. Let them say the questions.

(an invented text, not from any service book)

We give thanks for the life of Daniel: for his laughter, for his care for his sister, and for the hours he spent with his hands in the garden. We do not understand, and we will not pretend to. We ask you, merciful God, to receive him, to hold his family in their sorrow, and to keep all of us from blame. We commend him to your mercy.

5. The service after a miscarriage or a stillbirth

Many parents who lose a baby in pregnancy or at birth are told, by kind people, that they should move on. They have lost a child they carried, and often a name, a room, a hope. Some will want a service. Some will want only a prayer, a private word or a quiet moment. Some will want nothing and later wish they had asked. Offer, without pressing.

What helps:

  • Ask what they call the baby. If they have a name, use it. If they have not chosen one, ask whether they would like to, and do not suggest it. If they say "the baby," say "the baby."
  • Let the parents decide the shape. A short service at home, in a chapel or at a graveside may fit. Some parents want a blessing of their arms or their empty room. Some want to plant something. Ask what would be a comfort.
  • Speak of the mother with care and of the father with care. Fathers and partners are often forgotten. A sentence for them: "You grieve too, and your grief matters."
  • Do not describe the loss. Do not speak of what happened to the mother's body or to the baby's.
  • Do not speak of sin, of a test or of a plan. Never say that God took the baby or that it was a punishment. Do not offer reasons.
  • Do not make a claim about the baby's destiny that your community does not make. You can commend the child to the mercy of God, and say that you trust that mercy. If your community has its own wording for the unbaptised or for children who die early, use it, and say that it is the community's wording.
  • Remember that the grief is real even if no one else knew the baby. Many mothers carry it alone.

(an invented text, not from any service book)

God, we give you thanks for the short life of this child, whom Anna and Michael loved before they could hold. We give you their sorrow, and their love, which has nowhere to go. Be near them, and hold the child in your care. Amen.

6. The funeral of a child

This is the hardest service most officiants will ever lead. Do not expect to be steady. A cracked voice is not a failure. Prepare so that you do not need to be a rock. Have a colleague present to take over a reading or a prayer if you cannot continue.

Some principles:

  • Keep the service short and gentle. The parents will often be unable to take in more than a few minutes of speech.
  • Name the child, and say something true and specific about them. A favourite toy, a way of laughing, a kindness. Not "such a happy child" unless it was true.
  • Do not explain. There is no explanation that will not wound. "We do not know why" is the only honest sentence, and it is enough.
  • Let there be a place for the parents' voice, if they wish. Some will want to read something. Some will want to be silent. Offer either; allow either.
  • Do not ask the parents about the last hours, and do not report them.
  • Be careful with the word "gift." "A gift that God gave and took back" hurts many parents, because it suggests God chose the death. Say "we give thanks for the gift of her life," and leave out "taken."

7. A sudden death

A sudden death by accident, an illness that moved too fast, a heart that stopped: the family has had no time to prepare. They are often numb for days, and the service may be the first time they have sat still. Do not speculate about cause or timing. Do not say that it was quick, or painless, or that the person "did not suffer," unless a doctor has told the family so, and they wish you to say it. You do not know.

What often helps is a simple, honest sentence: "We had no time to say goodbye. We say it now, together, and we give him to God."

8. Children at the service

Children are often kept away from hard funerals, or sent to the back with a screen. Sometimes that is right. Often it is better to include them, with care, and a small number of honest words.

  • Use plain words. "Grandpa died. That means his life has ended and he will not come back. We are sad. We are here to say goodbye and to remember him." Avoid "sleeping," "gone away," "lost."
  • Tell them what will happen. A few sentences before the service about where they will sit, what they will see, how long it will last, and that they may leave if they wish.
  • Give a task if they want one. Carrying a flower, drawing a picture, lighting a candle with an adult. Never force one.
  • Name a trusted adult who will sit with the child and take them out if they are overwhelmed.
  • Do not tell them that the family member is "watching over them" unless the family says so, because some children are frightened by it.
  • If a child asks if they caused the death, answer plainly: "No. Nothing you did or said or thought caused this." Children often carry a private fear that they did.

When the dead person is a child's parent or sibling, the child needs all of this, and they also need an adult beside them in the weeks after, which is more than the funeral can give. A single sentence to the family: "If it would help, I can talk with you about who will be near the children over the coming weeks."

9. The family's guilt

Whatever the kind of death, many family members will say some version of: I should have noticed. I should have called. I should have gone with her. I should have made him go to the doctor. They are not asking you to agree. They are not quite asking you to disagree. They are saying the thing that hurts most, out loud, to someone who might bear it.

What not to do: do not argue ("It was not your fault"), because they will hear that you do not understand. Do not agree ("You could not have known" works better than "yes, you should have," but is still an argument). Do not give a theory.

What to do:

  • Listen. Let them finish.
  • Say that the guilt is a measure of the love. "You are saying this because you cared so much."
  • Say what is true: "None of us sees everything. Love does not give us that."
  • Offer to keep listening. "You can tell me again, as often as you need."
  • Do not push forgiveness. Whether the family needs to forgive the dead or themselves is for them, and often for a later conversation. It is not for the funeral.

10. If someone is in danger now

In the course of any of these services, you may meet a person who says they want to die, or who seems at risk of harming themselves or others. This is not a matter for a pastoral technique. The rule is simple.

Do not leave them alone. Stay with them, calmly. Ask directly and kindly whether they are thinking of hurting themselves. Asking does not put the idea in their mind. Do not promise secrecy. Contact the local emergency number or the crisis line for your country, or ask someone else to do it while you stay. Tell a trusted senior person or pastor afterwards. Check locally in advance for the crisis lines and emergency services in your area, and write the numbers where you will find them.

You are not a counsellor. You are a carer who knows when to call for more care. Lecture 6-4 returns to your own limits, and the counselling ethics course (PT723E) treats referral in depth.

11. Your own limits

These services cost the officiant. A child's funeral may stay with you for years. Tell someone: a supervisor, a colleague, a mentor. Take rest after. Do not take two such services in a week if you can avoid it. Lecture 6-4 treats this.


Diagram 1. What a hard funeral leaves in and leaves out

WHAT A HARD FUNERAL LEAVES IN AND LEAVES OUT Lecture 5-3 -- a card to keep beside the order of service Leave in The name of the person, and who they were. Plain words: died, died by suicide if the family agrees, or died suddenly. A prayer that commends the person to God in your community's words. A place for the family's voice, if they wish. A sentence telling the room that help exists for the living. Leave out Method, means, place or tool of a death. Any description of a body. Blame of the dead or of the family. Any verdict that the dead are saved or lost. Reasons and explanations: God took, a plan, a test, a punishment. Words such as committed, sleeping, gone, passed. If someone is in danger now Stay with them. Ask directly. Do not promise secrecy. Call the local emergency number or crisis line.

In short

  • Every hard funeral follows three rules: no method, no means, no description of a body; no blame and no verdict on the dead; the family decides what is said about them.
  • Use plain, kind words: "died by suicide," not "committed"; "died," not "sleeping" or "gone."
  • Neither condemn nor pronounce. Commend the dead to God in your community's words, and say so honestly if its rule limits the rite.
  • Name the dead, whether a child or an adult, and name a baby lost in pregnancy if the parents wish.
  • Meet guilt by listening and saying it measures love. Do not argue with it, and do not push forgiveness.
  • If someone is in danger now, stay with them, ask directly, and call the local emergency number or crisis line.
Front Back
Three rules for every hard funeral No method, means or body description; no blame and no verdict; the family decides what is said.
Why "died" and not "gone" or "sleeping"? It is plain and kind, and it does not frighten children or imply someone took the person away.
How do you respond to a family's guilt? Listen; say the guilt measures the love; do not argue and do not push forgiveness.
If someone is in danger now Stay with them, ask directly, do not promise secrecy, call the local emergency number or crisis line, tell a trusted senior person.

One sentence to remember A hard funeral says who the person was, blames no one, tells no one's destiny, and commends the dead to God's mercy.

This week's action Write down the local emergency number and crisis line for your area and the name of one person you would call after a hard service.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why does the course say a hard funeral leaves out method, means and any description of a body? Who is protected by the rule?
  • Choose one phrase from the table of "Instead of" and "Say." Why does the first phrase hurt?
  • How does your community commend the dead to God? Write the words, or note where you would find them.
  • What would you say to a parent who says, "I should have known"?
  • If a child at a funeral asks, "Did I make him die?", what do you say?
  • What do you need in place, before the first call, so that you know whom to ring if someone is in danger now?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.