Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Answering a Hard Request
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Community Before God at a Threshold
- Lecture 1-2: The Logic of an Order of Service
- Lecture 1-3: Choosing and Writing Words
- Lecture 1-4: Room, Time, Music, Cameras and the Officiant's Place
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Order on One Page
- Lecture 2-1: Order and Vows
- Lecture 2-2: The Wedding Address
- Lecture 2-3: Meeting the Couple Before the Day
- Lecture 2-4: The Day Itself
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Vows and Questions
- Lecture 3-1: Order, Words and Water
- Lecture 3-2: Babies, Children and Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Traditions That Differ
- Lecture 3-4: After the Water: Welcome and Follow-Up
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Baptism or Dedication on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: From the Death to the First Visit
- Lecture 4-2: The Order of a Funeral or Memorial Service
- Lecture 4-3: The Address and the Prayers
- Lecture 4-4: Customs, Ancestor Rites, Burial and Cremation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The First Visit and the Order
- Lecture 5-1: Remarriage and Marriages Across Cultures and Faiths
- Lecture 5-2: Requests the Officiant's Community Does Not Settle
- Lecture 5-3: Hard Funerals
- Lecture 5-4: Divided Families and Mixed Crowds
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Answering a Hard Request
This is the Practice Lab of the week of hard places. Every lab in this course asks you to do something rather than to agree with something, and this one is small and exact. You will write one reply to a hard request, on one page, in three parts: welcome, honesty and referral.
Lectures 5-1 to 5-4 gave you a shape for the reply: hear the person first, say whose rule it is, say what you can and cannot do, refer if you can, and keep confidence. Knowing the shape and speaking it are not the same. People often find, the first time they try, that a plain honest sentence is harder to write than a long careful one, and that a "no" can be said without a single judging word. This lab is a place to find that out, where nothing is at stake.
Four promises of privacy govern this lab, and they come first. (1) Nobody reads what you write. (2) Nothing here is marked or graded. (3) You may pass on any part. (4) The leader fills in a sheet too. If you record yourself speaking, only you watch it. The form asks for no real name, no real congregation and no real ceremony. If you ever find that the lab has brought something painful to the surface, the lab stops, and you speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
What these 16 minutes give you
- Write a reply to a hard request in three parts: welcome, honesty and referral.
- Check a reply against a short list for judging words, false promises and legal claims.
- Say the reply aloud in a plain, steady voice.
- Run the lab in a small group using the four promises of privacy.
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
World English Bible
Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." — Colossians 4:6
WEB
The first verse is a short rule for being present with people, whether they rejoice or weep. The second asks that speech be gracious and fitted to each person. Keep both in front of you as you write.
1. What the lab is for
The lab trains one skill: saying something difficult to a person, kindly and truthfully, within your own community's rules. It does not decide any question. It does not ask you to hold a position on a contested matter. It does not ask you to say yes or no to a request. It asks you to write the reply you would be able to say honestly, whatever your answer is.
A good reply has three parts.
- Welcome. The first words tell the person that they have been heard and are not a problem. They are a person who has asked a serious thing.
- Honesty. The reply says plainly what you can do and what you cannot, and whose rule it is. It does not hide behind a delay. It does not make a promise you cannot keep. It does not make a legal claim.
- Referral. If you cannot help, you say who might, or say that you will try to find out, or offer a continuing welcome.
Confidence runs under all three: what you were told stays with you.
2. Three ways in
1. In your own place. If you officiate or help with ceremonies, take a kind of request that you have met or may meet. Do not name the person. Think only of the kind: for example, a second marriage that your community does not celebrate, a request for a ceremony you are not able to lead, a funeral that the rule of your community limits, a baptism a family opposes. Fill in the form for that kind of request, in your own words, using your own community's rule. Do not write anything about a real case.
2. The observer's way. If you do not officiate, or if you would rather not start from your own place, use the short invented dialogue below. Fill in the form from it, as though you were the officiant. Then use the checklist to look at the three invented replies. Never use this lab to judge a real officiant, a real conversation or a real recording.
(an invented example) Three people have each made a request, and the officiant's community has a rule that the officiant cannot go beyond. The request is the same in all three: a man whose wife has died asks for a funeral service in a church whose rule allows only members to use the building, and he and she were never members.
Reply A. "I am sorry for your loss. I cannot help you. It is the rule. You will need to go elsewhere."
Reply B. "I am so sorry. Thank you for asking me. In our community, the church building is used for members' services, and I am not able to change that rule. I know that is hard to hear. What I can do is come to your home, sit with you, and say a prayer, and I would be glad to lead a short service at a graveside or a hall that you choose. If you would like a church service, I know a pastor in the next district who welcomes families who are not members. I can ask her to call you, if you tell me you wish it. Whatever you decide, I will keep what you tell me private."
Reply C. "I can arrange it, don't worry, we will find a way, I will talk to the elders." (He has not checked with the elders and does not know whether they will agree.)
Use the checklist below. Reply A is honest and has no welcome and no referral. Reply B has all three parts and a limit stated as the community's. Reply C is warm, and it makes a promise the officiant cannot keep. Fill in the form from the point of view of the officiant in Reply B, and then rewrite Reply A in three sentences.
3. The partner's way. Find a trusted partner. Take turns. One reads an invented request aloud (use one of the lines below), and the other answers aloud, using the form beside them. Then swap. Do not tell personal stories. Afterwards, the one who answered says what it was like to say it, and the one who listened says which part felt the kindest and which part was hardest to hear. No one gives advice unless asked.
Invented requests for the partner's way:
- "We would like a service for our baby, who died before birth, but we belong to no church. Is that possible?"
- "I am getting married again. My first marriage ended years ago. Will you marry us?"
- "My sister and her partner would like a blessing. Can you do that?"
- "My father says he will not come to my baptism. Should I go ahead?"
3. How to do it
Six steps
Step 1. Read the request, from your own place, from the observer's dialogue, or from your partner. Write the kind of request at the top of the form, with no names.
Step 2. Write the welcome. One or two sentences. Thank the person. Say you are glad they asked.
Step 3. Write what you can do within your community's rule. Name it plainly.
Step 4. Write what you cannot do, and say whose rule it is. No judging word. No legal claim.
Step 5. Write the referral, or the promise to find out. Name a role (a colleague, a pastor, a safeguarding person), not a person. Add what you will keep confidential.
Step 6. Check the reply against the list on the form. Then say it aloud, once, slowly. Cross out one phrase that is longer than it needs to be.
4. What usually goes wrong
"I wrote three paragraphs." A long reply is often a way of putting off the hard sentence. The reply should be short enough to say in a minute.
"I couldn't write a no without sounding cold." Warmth is in the welcome and the referral, not in softening the no. A clear no with a kind frame is warmer than a vague maybe.
"I wrote 'we are not able to do this for people in your situation.'" The word situation is a judgment. Replace it: "our community does not do this."
"I don't know my community's rule." That is a real result. Write: "I will find out and come back to you by [day]." And write the name of the person you will ask.
"It brought something up." If writing the reply brought back something painful, stop. You do not need to finish the form. Speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. This is not a failure of the lab. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
5. Leader's note, for running this in a small group
Privacy first, and the leader writes too
Say the four promises aloud before anyone writes. Nobody reads the form. Nothing is marked. Anyone may pass. The leader fills in a sheet too, and sits down to do it. Say it even if you said it last week.
Give fifteen minutes in silence for the form, then ten for partners, then five for a closing round. Do not fill the silence.
Ask about feelings, never about contents. Ask "What was it like to say that aloud?" and not "What did you write?"
Allow anyone to pass, and move on at once.
Do not use real cases. If someone starts to tell about a real person, gently stop them: "Let us keep to the kind of request, and not to the person." Then, afterwards, offer a private conversation.
Know what to do if the lab turns up a harm. If someone discloses abuse, violence, or danger, stop the exercise, stay calm, speak to them privately, and say that you want them to talk to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. If there is danger now, call the local emergency number. Do not promise secrecy you cannot keep.
Do not rank replies. No reply is the best. A group that finds the reply that sounds most like the leader has not done the lab.
Diagram 1. The form: My Reply Sheet
Diagram 2. Checklist for a reply
In short
- The lab trains one skill: saying something hard to a person, kindly and truthfully, within your own community's rules.
- A reply has three parts: welcome, honesty and referral, with confidence under all of them.
- A short reply is better than a long one. Warmth is in the welcome and the referral, not in softening the no.
- Check each reply for judging words, promises you cannot keep and legal claims.
- You can do the lab in your own place, from an invented dialogue, or with a partner. Nobody needs a real case.
- Run it in a group with four promises: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, anyone may pass, and the leader writes too.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The three parts of a reply | Welcome; honesty (what I can do, what I cannot, whose rule); referral. |
| What do you check for? | Judging words, promises you cannot keep, legal claims. |
| Four promises of privacy | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; anyone may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| The question the leader asks | Not "what did you write?" but "what was it like to say that aloud?" |
One sentence to remember A hard reply can be short, kind and true: welcome, honesty, referral.
This week's action Write one reply on one page, say it aloud once, and cross out the phrase that is longer than it needs to be.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What was it like to say the reply aloud? Answer with a feeling, not with the contents.
- Which of the three parts, welcome, honesty or referral, was hardest to write? Why might that be?
- What phrase did you cross out as longer than it needed to be?
- How did you word "whose rule it is" so that it was clear and not cold?
- Whom would you name, by role only, as a referral? If you have no one, who could you ask this week?
- If you pass on a part, what would you want the group to do?