FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT729E Ceremonies in Practice: Weddings, Funerals and Baptisms

Lecture 3-3: Traditions That Differ

Contents 31
PT729E Ceremonies in Practice: Weddings, Funerals and Baptisms
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Threshold and a Community
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Ceremonies at the Thresholds of Life
Chapter 1 · Week 1: What a Ceremony Is
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Community Before God at a Threshold
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Logic of an Order of Service
  3. Lecture 1-3: Choosing and Writing Words
  4. Lecture 1-4: Room, Time, Music, Cameras and the Officiant's Place
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, One Order on One Page
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Wedding
  1. Lecture 2-1: Order and Vows
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Wedding Address
  3. Lecture 2-3: Meeting the Couple Before the Day
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Day Itself
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Vows and Questions
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Baptism, Dedication and Membership
  1. Lecture 3-1: Order, Words and Water
  2. Lecture 3-2: Babies, Children and Adults
  3. Lecture 3-3: Traditions That Differ
  4. Lecture 3-4: After the Water: Welcome and Follow-Up
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Baptism or Dedication on One Page
Chapter 4 · Week 4: The Funeral and Memorial Service
  1. Lecture 4-1: From the Death to the First Visit
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Order of a Funeral or Memorial Service
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Address and the Prayers
  4. Lecture 4-4: Customs, Ancestor Rites, Burial and Cremation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The First Visit and the Order
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Hard Places
  1. Lecture 5-1: Remarriage and Marriages Across Cultures and Faiths
  2. Lecture 5-2: Requests the Officiant's Community Does Not Settle
  3. Lecture 5-3: Hard Funerals
  4. Lecture 5-4: Divided Families and Mixed Crowds
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Answering a Hard Request
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Care Before and After; Ethics
  1. Lecture 6-1: Fees, Gifts and Transparency
  2. Lecture 6-2: Records, Certificates and Privacy
  3. Lecture 6-3: Care After the Ceremony
  4. Lecture 6-4: Limits, Rest and Saying No
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Three Months of Ceremonies

Jump to the key points ↓

18 min

Sooner or later an officiant meets a family whose tradition is not their own. A grandmother who was baptised as a baby asks whether her grandson's dedication "counts". A man baptised in a river as an adult wants to join a parish that baptises infants. A woman raised in a church with no water ritual asks what the water is for. A couple of different traditions want to hold one service. The officiant has to answer them, and the answers need courtesy and accuracy.

This lecture is a map. It describes how several families of churches practise baptism and initiation, and how each tends to receive a baptism done in another tradition. It does not decide which is right. That question belongs to The Church Year and the Sacraments (PT731E), and the course is not trying to settle it.

The aim is practical. When you can describe another tradition in a form its own members would recognise, you can serve a mixed family without wounding anyone. And when you must say "my community does it differently", you can say it without saying the other is wrong.

What these 18 minutes give you

  • Describe, fairly, infant baptism traditions, believer's baptism traditions, Catholic and Orthodox rites of initiation, and communities with no water baptism.
  • State the range of ways that traditions receive a baptism performed elsewhere.
  • Say what your own community's rule is, and speak of other practices without a judging word.
  • Respond kindly to a family whose tradition differs from yours and refer the larger dispute to PT731E.

one Lord, one faith, one baptism," — Ephesians 4:5

World English Bible

Peter said to them, “Repent, and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit." — Acts 2:38

WEB

For the promise is to you, and to your children, and to all who are far off, even as many as the Lord our God will call to himself.”" — Acts 2:39

WEB

Christians of every tradition read these verses. Some hear in "one baptism" a reason to recognise each other's baptisms. Some hear in the order of Acts 2:38 a pattern in which repentance comes before water. Some hear in "you and your children" a promise that includes the youngest. These are honest readings, and each is held by serious people. In this lecture the verses are not used to choose between them. They are here as the common ground that every tradition below stands on: Christians have always spoken of one baptism, and have always differed about its shape.

1. Why a fair description matters

Describe a tradition fairly if you would be content to hear it described to its own members. If a Catholic priest, an Orthodox , a Baptist pastor and a Quaker friend were all in the room, would each recognise their own practice in what you said, and feel it was set out in its strongest form? That test protects the people at the ceremony and it protects you. An officiant who misdescribes another tradition teaches the family that the church is careless with the truth.

What follows is a sketch. It cannot be complete. Many communities have local custom that differs from the summary. When in doubt, ask someone from that tradition.

2. Infant baptism traditions

Many churches baptise infants and small children. They include Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Lutheran, Reformed, Methodist and others, and also many independent churches. Their reasons differ, but in the strongest form they say something like this: God's grace comes before our response; a child is brought into the family of God as a gift, before the child can ask; and the community and the sponsors promise to bring the child up in the faith, so that the child comes to own it. Many of these churches then hold a later service in which the young person affirms the faith for themselves.

Many of these traditions use pouring or sprinkling for infants, and some immerse infants. Most require the Trinitarian words, and many allow lay people to baptise in an emergency.

3. Believer's baptism traditions

Other churches baptise only those who can speak for themselves and who ask for baptism. They include Baptist, many Pentecostal and charismatic, many Mennonite and Anabaptist, and many independent congregations. In the strongest form, their reason is this: in the stories of Acts, people hear the message, repent and believe, and then are baptised. The act is a public sign of a decision already made in the heart, so it belongs where there is a decision to show. Many of these churches immerse the candidate. Most hold a dedication or blessing for infants.

In these traditions a person who was baptised as a baby may be asked to be baptised again as a believer. Those who ask this do not regard it as a second baptism, but as the first one they themselves have chosen. Those who hold another view find it painful. A fair officiant names both.

4. Catholic and Orthodox rites of initiation

In both of these churches, "initiation" means a set of acts that belong together: baptism with water, anointing with oil (called chrismation or confirmation), and first communion. The Orthodox churches and the Eastern Catholic churches usually do all three together, for infants as well as adults. In the Latin Catholic church, the practice differs by age and place: infants are baptised, and the other parts follow later, usually at a time chosen by the bishop or the community. Adults are initiated together at one service, often at Easter, after a period of preparation.

Both churches speak of baptism as something that cannot be repeated. In both, water and the Trinitarian words are central, and the anointing is not an optional extra. An officiant from another tradition who leaves out the anointing, or who treats it as decoration, will give offence, and a family from these churches may find the omission puzzling or painful.

5. Communities with no water baptism

Some communities do not practise a water baptism, or any outward . They include the Quakers and the Salvation Army, among others. In the strongest form their reason is this: what matters is the inward change, and an outward act can become a substitute for it. They honour many of the same things in other ways, such as a testimony, a commissioning, a simple welcome into membership. A person from one of these communities is not "unbaptised" in the sense of being cold toward Christ. They belong to a tradition that holds a different view of how God works. An officiant who meets them should ask what they want, not assume.

6. How other traditions' baptisms are received

Here the practice of churches varies widely.

  • Some churches receive any baptism made with water in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, by any Christian community, and do not repeat it. A person joining from another church is welcomed, perhaps with confirmation or a profession of faith, without a second baptism.
  • Some churches receive some baptisms and not others, depending on the words used, the intention, or the community that performed it. They may ask questions to decide.
  • Some churches do not receive an , and ask a person joining to be baptised as a believer. Those who do so say that they are not denying the first act's sincerity, only holding that the baptism they recognise is the one made on the person's own confession.
  • Some churches receive a person by a rite other than baptism, such as chrismation or a profession of faith. Practice among Orthodox communities, for example, varies among churches and over time.
  • Some communities hold no rule of reception at all, since they have no water baptism.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that baptism is one act for the whole church and cannot be repeated, so any water baptism in the Trinitarian name should be received everywhere. This view has a strong history and is held, in different forms, by the Catholic, Anglican, Lutheran and Reformed traditions and by some Orthodox churches (others in the Orthodox world receive converts in other ways, as noted above). Others hold that baptism, as the New Testament describes it, belongs to those who believe and who ask for it, so an infant baptism, however sincere, is not the baptism the Scripture describes, and a person who comes to faith should be baptised as a believer. This view has a strong history too, and is held by many Baptist, Pentecostal and Anabaptist churches. A third group holds that the outward water is not the centre, and honours other signs of faith. Each position is held by people who love Scripture and who wish to be faithful. What this course requires is less than any of them requires: state your own community's rule plainly; describe the other practices in words their own members would recognise; use no word that judges a family's tradition; and send the dispute itself to The Church Year and the Sacraments (PT731E).

7. Worked example: a family between two traditions

(an invented example)

A man whose family belongs to a church that baptises infants asks that his own daughter be baptised in the church where his wife worships. That church baptises believers only and holds a dedication for babies. The couple are uneasy. He fears that the dedication "is not enough". She fears that an infant baptism would "not be hers".

A careful officiant would not argue. The officiant would say something like this:

"In my church, we hold a dedication for babies. We do not use water until a child is old enough to ask for it. I know that in your own church, a baby is baptised. I do not say your church is wrong. I would like to hear how each of you thinks about this, and then we can look together at what you can both honour." (an invented text, not from any service book)

Then the officiant listens. There may be several outcomes: the couple choose the dedication, and the grandmother's church gives a blessing; the couple choose the infant baptism in the husband's church, with the wife's church community invited to attend and to pray; they wait. Each is a possible answer. The officiant's work is to keep the conversation kind, to name the options without pressure, and to say honestly what their own community can and cannot do.

If the officiant's community cannot do what a family asks (for example, cannot baptise an infant, or cannot recognise a baptism from another church), the answer is a plain "no" with an honest reason, a kind word, and an offer to refer the family to a community that can.

8. Sharing a service across traditions

Sometimes two communities hold a joint service. That needs a conversation before the day with the officiants of each.

  • Whose rule governs the act itself, and whose words?
  • Who holds the water, and who says the declaration?
  • Will there be an anointing, and will each side recognise it?
  • How will each tradition's guests be told what they are seeing?
  • Who will speak to the family afterward?

A shared service honours both churches if the parts are named in advance and neither officiant is surprised. It dishonours both if one is made to watch the other do something they find difficult, without having been told.

9. Words to avoid, and words to use

Avoid "real baptism", "proper baptism", "only a ceremony", "just a blessing", "not valid" (unless your community's rule uses this word, and then explain it kindly), and any phrase that puts another church in the position of an inferior.

Use phrases such as these:

  • "In my community we ..."
  • "In the Orthodox tradition they ..."
  • "Many Baptist churches hold that ..."
  • "Different churches understand this differently, and I would be glad to tell you how mine does."

These are honest, short and kind. They leave room for the family to say what they hold.


Diagram 1. A map of practice

Four families of practice, described not ranked A sketch. Local custom varies. Ask someone from the tradition. Infant baptism Water with a baby or child. Parents and sponsors promise; the church supports. Often a later service where the young person affirms the faith. Many receive any water baptism in the Trinitarian name. Believer's baptism Water with a person who asks for it. The candidate speaks for themselves. Often by immersion. Babies may be dedicated, not baptised. Some ask a person baptised as an infant to be baptised on confession. Catholic and Orthodox Initiation: water, anointing with oil, first communion. Orthodox and Eastern Catholic: usually all together, even for babies. Latin Catholic: baptism first, the rest often later. Baptism is not repeated. No water baptism Some communities hold that what matters is the inward change. They honour faith by testimony, commissioning, or a welcome into membership. Ask what the person wants. Do not assume. The officiant's three duties State your community's rule. Describe others fairly. Send the dispute to PT731E.

Diagram 2. Ways a baptism from elsewhere is received

A person arrives with a baptism from another church Received Any water baptism in the Trinitarian name is accepted, not repeated Received on terms Some baptisms accepted, others examined by words, intention or community Received by another rite Anointing, a profession of faith or both; practice varies by church Believer's baptism asked The baptism recognised is the one made on the person's own confession

In short

  • Describe another tradition in words its own members would recognise.
  • Infant baptism, believer's baptism, Catholic and Orthodox initiation, and communities with no water baptism are four families of practice, each with a reason in its strongest form.
  • Churches differ in how they receive a baptism done elsewhere: accepted, accepted on terms, received by another rite, or a believer's baptism asked.
  • Say your own community's rule plainly, use no judging word, and send the dispute to PT731E.
  • A joint service needs the officiants to agree beforehand whose words, whose water and whose anointing.
Front Back
Four families of practice Infant baptism; believer's baptism; Catholic and Orthodox initiation; communities with no water baptism.
Initiation (Catholic and Orthodox) A set of acts that belong together: water, anointing with oil, first communion.
How a baptism from elsewhere is received Accepted, accepted on terms, received by another rite, or a believer's baptism is asked.
What this course requires Say your rule; describe others fairly; use no judging word; send the dispute to PT731E.

One sentence to remember You are ready to serve a mixed family when its own members would recognise their tradition in your description of it.

This week's action Write one fair paragraph about a tradition other than your own, then ask someone from that tradition whether they would sign it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the four families of practice is closest to your own? Could a member of one of the others read your description of them and feel fairly treated?
  • What is your community's rule on receiving a baptism from another church, and how do you explain it kindly?
  • A grandmother asks whether her grandson's dedication "counts". What do you say that is true and does not wound?
  • Why is the anointing in Catholic and Orthodox initiation not an optional extra for those traditions? What follows for an officiant from another church?
  • List three phrases you will avoid and three you will use when a family's tradition differs from yours.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.