Lecture 1-2: How the Church Year Grew
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: God's Time, the Church's Time
- Lecture 1-2: How the Church Year Grew
- Lecture 1-3: Churches That Keep the Year and Churches That Do Not
- Lecture 1-4: The Shape of the Year
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Read a Year
- Lecture 2-1: Advent, Christmas and Epiphany
- Lecture 2-2: Lent and Holy Week
- Lecture 2-3: Easter and Pentecost
- Lecture 2-4: Ordinary Time and Days Your Country Keeps
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Shape One Season in a Service
- Lecture 3-1: Season and Word
- Lecture 3-2: Children and All Ages Together
- Lecture 3-3: Making Room at Home
- Lecture 3-4: When the Season Hurts
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, One Small Practice
- Lecture 4-1: What a Sacrament Is
- Lecture 4-2: The Supper: What Happens
- Lecture 4-3: Word and Table
- Lecture 4-4: Who Presides
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Table of Understandings
- Lecture 5-1: Who Comes to the Table
- Lecture 5-2: Bread, Cup and Body: Access and Health
- Lecture 5-3: Sick, Elderly and Housebound
- Lecture 5-4: Worthiness, Self-Examination and Online Communion
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, A Welcome Note and an Access Check
Nobody sat down in the first century and drew up the church year. It grew slowly, over several centuries, in many places, and not at the same speed everywhere. Some parts are very old. Some are later. Some were fixed by councils, but many were simply the custom of a city that spread to others. Some were reduced or removed at the time of the Reformation, and some have been recovered since.
This lecture gives a short, careful history. It is short because the evidence is thin in places, and careful because several of the best-known stories (about Christmas, about Lent, about the date of Easter) are told with more confidence than the evidence allows. Where scholars disagree, we will say so. Where we are not sure of a date or a detail, we will use general words.
The principle of the week is a good guide to the history: the church's time is not a calendar; it is a story. The year grew because people wanted to tell the story of Christ in time, and not because someone wanted to fill a calendar.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Explain why the Lord's Day came first, and what the New Testament does and does not tell us about it.
- Describe in outline how Easter, Pentecost, Epiphany, Christmas, Lent and Holy Week came to be kept.
- Explain why the date of Easter changes each year, and why East and West sometimes keep it on different days.
- State fairly the main explanations for the date of December 25, and say what is known and what is debated.
- Describe in general terms what happened to the church year at the time of the Reformation and since.
On the first day of the week, when the disciples were gathered together to break bread, Paul talked with them, intending to depart on the next day, and continued his speech until midnight." — Acts 20:7
World English Bible
On the first day of the week, let each one of you save, as he may prosper, that no collections be made when I come." — 1 Corinthians 16:2
WEB
I was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day, and I heard behind me a loud voice, like a trumpet" — Revelation 1:10
WEB
These three verses are all that the New Testament offers about a regular day of Christian gathering. None of them says "Sunday worship is commanded." But together they show that, within a generation of Christ, the first day of the week was already a day on which Christians met, broke bread and gave. One of them uses a phrase, "the Lord's day," that already seems to be a name. Scholars read these verses with some care and do not agree on how strong the evidence is. This lecture reads them as early signs, not as proof of a full system.
1. The Lord's Day came first
The oldest repeated rhythm of the church is the week. Acts 20:7 shows believers gathered on "the first day of the week" to break bread, and Paul speaking to them at length. In 1 Corinthians 16:2 Paul asks the Corinthians to set money aside "on the first day of the week." In Revelation 1:10 John says he was "in the Spirit on the Lord's day." Christians from the second century onward wrote of Sunday as the day of gathering and of the resurrection. We should say clearly what this does and does not show. The verses do not tell us how often each church met, what the meeting contained, or whether the phrase "the Lord's day" always meant Sunday in the first century. Some scholars think it did; some think the meaning developed. Even so, the pattern is clear enough: a weekly gathering on the first day grew early, and it was about the risen Lord.
Everything else in the church year rests on that weekly rhythm. Every Sunday was, in a sense, a small Easter. The great yearly feasts came later, and they gathered up what the week already said.
2. Easter first among the feasts
The oldest yearly feast we can trace is the one that Greek-speaking Christians called Pascha, from the same root as Passover. It celebrated the death and rising of Christ, and it came at about the time of the Jewish Passover. In the second century, churches in different places did not agree on the day. Some kept it on the day of the Jewish Passover whatever day of the week it fell. Others kept it on a Sunday. We know of a dispute about this between churches in the east of the Mediterranean and the church of Rome, and of efforts to settle it. The matter was discussed at the in the year 325. The details of what Nicaea decided and how it was carried out are debated, and the dates were worked out in later centuries, especially by those who made tables of calculation in Alexandria and Rome.
The rule that came to be used, in outline, is that Easter falls on a Sunday after the spring full moon. Because the full moon and the Sunday both move against the calendar, Easter moves too. It can fall in March or April in most years of the Western calendar. This is why the date changes: it is tied to a pattern of the moon and the week, and not to a fixed day of the month. That tie to the Passover season is one clue to the feast's roots.
3. East and West
The East and the West do not always keep Easter on the same day. There are two reasons, and neither is a quarrel over doctrine. First, the Western churches (Catholic and most Protestant) use the Gregorian calendar, introduced in 1582 as a correction of the older Julian calendar. Many Orthodox churches kept the Julian calendar for working out Easter, and the two methods give different dates in most years. In some years they fall on the same Sunday. Second, the rule about the full moon is applied to different tables.
Churches have tried at various times to find a common date. It has not been agreed. For a congregation, the practical lesson is simple: ask what your own community keeps, and know that your neighbours of another tradition may keep it on another Sunday. Christians who share a town sometimes mark the difference with a joint greeting, and some churches in mixed communities choose to keep a common date by agreement. That is a matter for the people involved.
4. Pentecost and Ascension
Pentecost means "fiftieth." It was already a Jewish festival, the Feast of Weeks, fifty days after the Passover, and Acts 2 places the coming of the Spirit on that day. By about the year 200, writers speak of a period of fifty days after Easter kept as a time of joy, and the fiftieth day marked as a feast. The commemoration of the on its own day, forty days after Easter, is attested later, in the fourth century. These details show again that the year grew outward from Easter. Pentecost was not an afterthought; the fifty days were a single season at first.
5. Epiphany and Christmas
Here the evidence is thinner, and the stories are told with more confidence than they deserve.
Epiphany means "appearing" or "showing." In the East, a feast on January 6 is attested by about the fourth century. Its focus was Christ's baptism, and in some places also his birth and the coming of the visitors from the east. In the West, January 6 came to be associated especially with the visit of the wise men, and with the baptism and the first sign at Cana in some traditions of reading. The different weights given in East and West are one reason the day looks different in different churches.
Christmas, a feast of the birth of Christ on December 25, is first clearly attested in the city of Rome in the fourth century. The Gospels do not give a date for the birth. So why December 25? This is a point where readers will not agree about the origin, and scholars offer at least two explanations.
The calculation explanation: some early Christian writers held that Jesus died on a particular date in spring, and that a great person's life was a whole number of years, so that he was conceived on the same date as he died, and born nine months later. If the date was March 25, then nine months later is December 25. This reasoning appears in early writings, and some scholars think it is the main cause.
The history-of-religions explanation: the Roman world held a festival of the sun around the same date, and some scholars think the church chose it, or was helped by it, to draw attention to Christ as the light of the world. Other scholars point out that the earliest sources for the sun-festival date are about the same time as the earliest sources for the Christian one, and that it is not easy to tell which came first.
Some scholars hold a mixed view, in which both lines of thought mattered. This course requires only that you say what is known and what is not: the date appears in Rome in the fourth century; the Gospels give no date; the origin is debated. Nothing in Christian faith depends on the choice of day, and the Eastern churches that count January 6 or use a different calendar say the same thing about the same event.
6. Lent and Holy Week
Lent is the season of preparation before Easter. The idea of a fast before the Paschal feast is early; some churches fasted for a day or two, and others for a week. A forty-day period took shape later, and its length and counting varied from place to place: whether Sundays were counted, which days were kept as fasts, and where it began. The word "forty" recalls the forty days of Jesus in the wilderness, and other forty-day periods in Scripture. Exactly how the number came to be fixed, and how early, is debated, so we speak of it here in general terms. Lent was also a time for the final teaching of those who were to be baptised at Easter (lecture 6-3 returns to this), and for the restoration of those who had been separated from the church by serious sin.
Holy Week, the days from Palm Sunday through Easter Eve, took shape most clearly in Jerusalem, where pilgrims could walk to the places named in the Gospels. A fourth-century pilgrim wrote an account of the services in the city. The pilgrims carried what they had seen to other lands, and in this way the custom of marking each day of the last week spread. This is an example of a pattern: a local custom, kept where the event was remembered, became a common custom.
7. The shape that came
By about the fifth or sixth century, the main outline in the West was in place: a weekly Lord's Day, a cycle around Easter that included Lent, Holy Week and fifty days, a cycle around the birth of Christ with a time of preparation before it (Advent) and the Epiphany after it, and the days of martyrs and saints through the year. In the East, the main outline was similar but shaped differently, with its own great feasts, its own fasts and its own calendar. Neither is a copy of the other; both grew from the same roots.
8. Reform, removal and recovery
In the sixteenth century, the Reformation led to different decisions in different places. Some Reformers kept much of the calendar and simplified it. Some reduced it to the Lord's Day and a few feasts. Some held that days not commanded by Scripture should not be required, and removed them. Different reasons were given, and we meet them again in lecture 1-3. In some regions, keeping certain feasts was even forbidden by law for a time. In the centuries that followed, some churches that had set the year aside gradually took parts of it up again, and in the twentieth century many Protestant communities rediscovered the seasons, often through shared tables of readings. Others continue to keep no set seasons, for reasons of conscience that they hold seriously.
The point of this short account is not to say who was right. It is to show that the church year is neither a single unbroken inheritance nor a late invention. It grew from early roots in the week and Easter, it expanded in some places and times, it was reduced in others, and it is still changing.
9. A worked example of reading the evidence
(An invented example.) A class is asked: "Is Christmas pagan?" A good answer from this lecture runs in four steps. First, state what is known: the feast is attested in Rome in the fourth century and the Gospels give no date. Second, give both explanations fairly: the calculation explanation and the sun-festival explanation. Third, note what cannot be shown: which came first, and whether any one cause was sole. Fourth, state what the community teaches: "In our tradition the day is kept as a feast of the birth of Christ" or "In our tradition we do not keep set days, for these reasons." Notice that nothing in this answer needed a judging word.
Diagram 1. A timeline of how the year grew
Diagram 2. Two explanations for December 25
| Explanation | In brief | What it cannot settle |
|---|---|---|
| Calculation | Conception on the date of the death (March 25), birth nine months later | Whether this reasoning came before the feast or after it |
| History of religions | A Roman sun festival on the same date, used or answered by the church | Which date came first in the sources |
| Mixed | Both lines of thought mattered | How much weight each carried |
In short
- The weekly gathering on the first day is the oldest rhythm; New Testament verses show an early pattern but not a full system.
- Easter is the oldest yearly feast; its date depends on the Sunday and the moon, and East and West often differ.
- Pentecost and Ascension grew from Easter; Epiphany and Christmas are later, and the origin of December 25 is debated.
- Lent and Holy Week took shape slowly; Jerusalem pilgrimage helped spread the days of the last week.
- The Reformation kept, trimmed or removed parts of the year, and some have since been recovered.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The oldest rhythm | The weekly gathering on the first day of the week, the Lord's Day. |
| Why Easter moves | It follows a Sunday after the spring full moon; East and West use different calendars and tables. |
| Two explanations for December 25 | Calculation from the date of the death; a Roman sun festival on the same date; some scholars hold both mattered. |
| What the Reformation did | Different communities kept, trimmed or removed parts of the year; some later recovered them. |
One sentence to remember The year grew outward from the week and from Easter, and where its origins are debated we say so.
This week's action Pick one feast your community keeps and write two sentences on where it came from, marking each fact as "known" or "debated."
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Acts 20:7 and 1 Corinthians 16:2 name the first day of the week. What can we safely say from these verses, and what would be going too far?
- Why might a feast of the death and rising of Christ have come before a feast of his birth?
- Easter moves each year and Christmas does not. What does each choice say about what is being remembered?
- Look at the two explanations for December 25. Which parts of each seem strong to you, and which seem uncertain? Why is it better to say "debated" than to pick one?
- How does your community explain where its seasons came from? Is that account fair to what this lecture says?