Lecture 5-2: Bread, Cup and Body: Access and Health
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: God's Time, the Church's Time
- Lecture 1-2: How the Church Year Grew
- Lecture 1-3: Churches That Keep the Year and Churches That Do Not
- Lecture 1-4: The Shape of the Year
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Read a Year
- Lecture 2-1: Advent, Christmas and Epiphany
- Lecture 2-2: Lent and Holy Week
- Lecture 2-3: Easter and Pentecost
- Lecture 2-4: Ordinary Time and Days Your Country Keeps
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Shape One Season in a Service
- Lecture 3-1: Season and Word
- Lecture 3-2: Children and All Ages Together
- Lecture 3-3: Making Room at Home
- Lecture 3-4: When the Season Hurts
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, One Small Practice
- Lecture 4-1: What a Sacrament Is
- Lecture 4-2: The Supper: What Happens
- Lecture 4-3: Word and Table
- Lecture 4-4: Who Presides
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Table of Understandings
- Lecture 5-1: Who Comes to the Table
- Lecture 5-2: Bread, Cup and Body: Access and Health
- Lecture 5-3: Sick, Elderly and Housebound
- Lecture 5-4: Worthiness, Self-Examination and Online Communion
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, A Welcome Note and an Access Check
The Supper is a meal with real bread and a real cup, shared by real bodies. Some of those bodies cannot eat wheat. Some cannot drink wine. Some cannot swallow safely, or reach a high table, or see the bread, or hear the words. Some are recovering from a dependence on alcohol, and for them the cup is not a small thing. Some are pregnant, some are children, some take medicines, and some are afraid of catching an illness from a shared cup.
If a table is wide open in words but closed in practice, it is not open. This lecture is about the practical work that makes the table available to the bodies actually in the room. It does this without asking anyone to give up what their tradition teaches about the elements, and without giving any medical advice. We are not doctors, and the course will say so again below.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Name the common ways a body, an illness or an addiction can keep a person from the bread or the cup, and one way to prepare for each in advance.
- Describe wine, grape juice, shared cup, individual cups and dipping, each by its reasons, strengths and cautions, without ranking them.
- Explain why access is arranged quietly beforehand and not announced at the table.
- Say who to ask: your community's authority about what may be varied, and a health professional about any medical question.
- Describe the minimum a community should do so that nobody is excluded by body, illness or addiction.
He causes the grass to grow for the livestock, and plants for man to cultivate, that he may produce food out of the earth: wine that makes glad the heart of man, oil to make his face to shine, and bread that strengthens man’s heart." — Psalms 104:14-15
World English Bible
Jesus answered them, “Those who are healthy have no need for a physician, but those who are sick do. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance.”" — Luke 5:31-32
WEB
The psalm names bread and wine among the gifts of the earth, and says what they do: they gladden and strengthen the heart. The table takes up things that bodies need. Jesus' saying about the physician is not about the table at all, and we do not stretch it to say so. We take from it only one plain thing: the Lord's care has always been for the people whose bodies and lives are not in good order. A table that is hard for such people to reach has a problem worth fixing.
1. Begin with the people, not the rules
Most failures of access are not rules. They are things nobody thought about. A step to the front. A cup that is one wine only. A bread that has wheat and no alternative. A line that moves too fast. An announcement that says "all may come" and no sign of how.
So the first work is to ask quietly and ahead of time. At a membership class, in the welcome sheet, or in a chat with a person you know: "Is there anything that makes it hard for you to receive the bread or cup, and could we arrange something?" Notice what this question does. It does not require a medical story, and it does not ask for proof. It lets a person say as much as they want.
Three principles hold for every point below.
- Prepare in advance. A person should not discover at the table that there is nothing for them.
- Ask your tradition's authority whether the elements may be varied. Communities differ on this, and for good reasons. Do not decide on your own what bread, wine or cup may be used. Ask the person or body that decides for your community: a bishop, a priest, an eldership or a congregation.
- For any medical question, ask a health professional. This course does not tell anyone what is safe to eat, drink or swallow. It tells you to ask someone qualified, and to follow your local health guidance.
2. Wine and juice
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some traditions use fermented wine only, and give reasons from the Gospel accounts, from long use and from the community's own teaching about the element. Some use unfermented grape juice only, and give reasons of care: for people recovering from alcohol dependence, for children, for those who by conviction do not drink, or for the whole community's witness in its place. Some offer both, as a plain way to include everyone. Some are in places where grape wine is hard to get, and each community asks its own authority what to use then.
What this course requires is small: say what your community uses and who decides, speak of other traditions with respect, and make sure that anyone who cannot take what is offered has a way to take part. Some traditions teach that receiving the bread alone, or the cup alone, is a full sharing in the Supper; others teach differently. If you serve someone who cannot take one element, ask your authority what is taught, and tell the person kindly what your community says.
For a person with a dependence on alcohol, the cup may be a hard place. A person who does not say anything may be struggling alone. A community that always has a juice option, offered the same way as the wine and not as an exception, makes it unnecessary for anyone to explain. Still, a person may want to talk to a pastor privately, and that offer should be real. For any question about alcohol, pregnancy or medicines, the person should ask a health professional, not the leader.
3. Bread
Bread is wheat in many places, and a few people cannot eat it. Wheat allergy and coeliac disease are the best-known reasons, and there may be others. A person may know exactly what they can eat. A community should ask, and should not guess.
- Some communities keep a separate small supply of a bread without wheat for anyone who asks. Others receive the cup only. Some have a rule about what bread is permitted, and a person should hear the rule from the one who decides.
- If bread without wheat is made, keep it apart, serve it first, use clean hands, and label it plainly. A crumb of ordinary bread can matter to a person who cannot eat it, and the person is the one who knows. Ask them how they would like it handled.
- Do not ask a person to eat something and say they will manage. A person who says "I cannot" is giving you information about their body.
4. Shared cup, individual cups, dipping
Each practice has its reasons, and each has its cautions.
- One shared cup. The reasons: it is the plainest sign of one body who drink from one cup, it is how many traditions have kept the Supper through the centuries, and it needs no extra equipment. The caution: in a season when illness is passing through a community, some people will be afraid of it, and some have reason to be.
- Individual cups. The reasons: each person has their own, and it is easy to see who is taking juice and who wine. The caution: a tray of small cups is a different sign from one cup, and some communities feel the loss of that sign.
- Dipping. The bread is dipped by the minister or by the person into the cup. The reasons: the person receives both elements at once, and a person who cannot manage a cup can still receive. The caution: it needs a clear, steady hand, and not every community uses it.
No one of these is right everywhere. Ask your authority which your community may use, and when. Where there is a risk of infection in a season, follow your local health guidance and ask a health professional what is advised. Do not scold those who are afraid, and do not scold those who are not.
5. Swallowing, height, sight, hearing and other needs
- Difficulty swallowing. Some people cannot swallow bread or liquid safely. This is a medical matter. Ask the person, or their carer, what they can do, and ask a health professional; do not offer advice about what is safe. In many cases the person can still receive in a form that they and their carer have chosen, or take part in another way. Some communities hold that a person may receive in a very small amount, or by touch or by blessing. Ask your authority what your community teaches.
- Height and movement. A table should be reachable by a person in a wheelchair, or someone who cannot stand. The usual solution is to bring the bread and cup to where the person sits, or to place a low table. Do not make a person ask for this in public.
- Sight. A person who cannot see well needs to be told what is happening in words: "The bread is in front of you, at your right hand." Printed words in large type are a plain help.
- Hearing. Words should be spoken clearly and, where you can, written down. A person who cannot hear should not need to guess what is being said at the key moment.
- Sensory needs. Some people are troubled by smell, bells, crowds or the feel of the bread. A quiet time or place, a warning beforehand, or a seat at the end of a row may help. Ask the person, and follow what they say.
- Infection seasons. In a season of illness, a community may change how it serves. Follow local health guidance, ask a health professional, and tell people beforehand what you will do, so that nobody has to choose in public.
An invented example
(An invented example.) A congregation of about thirty has a woman who cannot eat wheat, a young man who has been a year without alcohol, and a man in a wheelchair. The leader asks them each, separately, in the week before: "Is there something that would make it easier for you to receive, and could we arrange it?" The woman says she would like a small piece of bread made without wheat, kept apart. The young man says juice would be a relief, and he would like it to look just like the wine. The man in the wheelchair says he is fine if someone brings the cup. The leader writes down what each asks, speaks to the community's elders, and gets agreement for each. On Sunday the bread without wheat and the juice are brought as part of the ordinary service, without announcement. Nobody explains anything.
6. Do it quietly
The best access is the kind nobody notices. Alternatives that are set out as part of the ordinary meal, with a clear label, are better than a special arrangement that needs a speech. Where you cannot make it ordinary, speak to the person beforehand, and let them decide how visible it will be.
Keep one more rule. A person's health is theirs. Do not discuss it with the congregation, and do not write it on a list that others can see. What the person asked for belongs to the care team that needs to know, and no more. Religious information is sensitive, and so is health information; follow your local rules and your community's written rules about keeping records, and keep as little as you need.
7. What to do when you cannot do it
Sometimes a community has no way to offer a bread without wheat, or no juice, or a table that cannot be reached. Do not pretend. Tell the person the truth, kindly, and say what you can do: a blessing, a form of the Supper that suits them, a visit afterwards, a plan for next time. Then make a plan, and do it.
Diagram 1. Around the table: who might be left out, and the quiet preparation for each
Diagram 2. Who to ask
In short
- Prepare in advance for the bodies in the room: wheat, alcohol, swallowing, height, sight, hearing, sensory needs and infection seasons.
- Ask your tradition's authority whether the elements may be varied, and ask a health professional about any medical question; this course gives no medical advice.
- Wine, juice, one cup, individual cups and dipping each have reasons and cautions, and none is ranked here.
- Arrange access quietly and ahead of time; a person's health is private and is not announced.
- If you cannot provide what a person needs, say so kindly, offer what you can, and make a plan.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three principles | Prepare in advance; ask your authority what may be varied; ask a health professional about any medical question. |
| Where to ask about a need | Quietly, beforehand, not at the table. |
| Wine and juice | Traditions differ; say what yours uses and who decides; make sure everyone has a way to take part. |
| If you cannot meet a need | Say so kindly, offer what you can, and make a plan. |
One sentence to remember A table that is open in words and closed to bodies is not yet open.
This week's action Ask two people in your community, quietly, whether anything makes it hard to receive, and write down what they say only if they agree.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the needs in this lecture would your community find hardest to meet, and what is one small step toward it?
- Why is it better to ask a person quietly beforehand than to announce an alternative at the table?
- State two views about wine and juice in their strongest honest form. What does this course ask of both?
- A person says they cannot swallow bread. What is the leader's part, and what belongs to a health professional?
- How can a community describe its practice about the cup in a way that a person who is afraid of infection, and a person who is not, can both hear kindly?