Lecture 5-4: Worthiness, Self-Examination and Online Communion
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: God's Time, the Church's Time
- Lecture 1-2: How the Church Year Grew
- Lecture 1-3: Churches That Keep the Year and Churches That Do Not
- Lecture 1-4: The Shape of the Year
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Read a Year
- Lecture 2-1: Advent, Christmas and Epiphany
- Lecture 2-2: Lent and Holy Week
- Lecture 2-3: Easter and Pentecost
- Lecture 2-4: Ordinary Time and Days Your Country Keeps
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Shape One Season in a Service
- Lecture 3-1: Season and Word
- Lecture 3-2: Children and All Ages Together
- Lecture 3-3: Making Room at Home
- Lecture 3-4: When the Season Hurts
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, One Small Practice
- Lecture 4-1: What a Sacrament Is
- Lecture 4-2: The Supper: What Happens
- Lecture 4-3: Word and Table
- Lecture 4-4: Who Presides
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Table of Understandings
- Lecture 5-1: Who Comes to the Table
- Lecture 5-2: Bread, Cup and Body: Access and Health
- Lecture 5-3: Sick, Elderly and Housebound
- Lecture 5-4: Worthiness, Self-Examination and Online Communion
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, A Welcome Note and an Access Check
One sentence of Paul has stopped many people at the edge of the table: "whoever eats this bread or drinks the Lord's cup in a way unworthy of the Lord will be guilty of the body and the blood of the Lord." Some have heard it read as a warning against receiving. Some have stayed in their seats for years because of it. Some have been kept from the table by others who used the verse to hold power over them. And some, who truly needed the bread, never came because they were sure they were not good enough.
This lecture reads the verse where it stands, in the passage where Paul wrote it. It then turns to people who carry heavy guilt, who cannot stop examining themselves, or who have been hurt by someone they must share a table with. The last part sets out three positions on online communion fairly and decides for no one.
The principle of the week applies in full: the table should be wide open, the teaching honest, the care quiet.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain, from the passage itself, what situation Paul was writing about, and why the verse is not an instrument of fear.
- State two common readings of "discerning the body" fairly.
- Describe how to care for a person with heavy guilt or constant self-doubt, without diagnosing or condemning.
- Explain why the call to make peace first does not mean that a person who has been harmed must meet the one who harmed them.
- State three positions on online communion in their strongest honest form, and say what your community teaches.
When therefore you assemble yourselves together, it is not the Lord’s supper that you eat. For in your eating each one takes his own supper first. One is hungry, and another is drunken. What, don’t you have houses to eat and to drink in? Or do you despise God’s assembly, and put them to shame who don’t have? What shall I tell you? Shall I praise you? In this I don’t praise you." — 1 Corinthians 11:20-22
World English Bible
Therefore whoever eats this bread or drinks the Lord’s cup in a way unworthy of the Lord will be guilty of the body and the blood of the Lord. But let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread, and drink of the cup. For he who eats and drinks in an unworthy way eats and drinks judgment to himself, if he doesn’t discern the Lord’s body." — 1 Corinthians 11:27-29
WEB
Therefore, my brothers, when you come together to eat, wait for one another. But if anyone is hungry, let him eat at home, lest your coming together be for judgment. The rest I will set in order whenever I come." — 1 Corinthians 11:33-34
WEB
If therefore you are offering your gift at the altar, and there remember that your brother has anything against you, leave your gift there before the altar, and go your way. First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift." — Matthew 5:23-24
WEB
Read the three verses from Corinthians together with the verses before them. Paul writes about a meal at which each person eats their own supper first, one is hungry and another drunk. The verses on worthiness stand in the middle of this. They are written to a community that is treating its poorer members badly at the very meal that is meant to join them. Matthew 5 is a saying about reconciliation placed at the altar. We will read both for what they say, and we will not stretch either to a case it does not name.
1. What the passage is about
Begin with the whole scene. Paul is writing to a church in which the Lord's Supper has become a divided meal. Those with food and time eat early, and eat well. Those who work long hours, or have little, come late and have nothing. The verse before the passage says plainly that it is not the Lord's supper that they eat. Paul's anger is at a table where the rich shame the poor.
Then he reminds them what the meal is, in the words of the Lord's own supper, and says that to eat and drink "in an unworthy way" is to do it without regard for the Lord's body. The word describes the way of eating, not the person who eats. Then he says: "let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread, and drink of the cup." Look at the order. The examination is a step toward the table, not away from it. He ends the passage with a practical instruction: when you come together to eat, wait for one another.
Read like this, the passage is an instruction to a divided community: look at how you treat one another at the table, and mend it. It is not a test that each person must pass in private in order to be allowed to eat. It is not a reason to keep a believer from the table because they have sinned, or to frighten one who comes in need.
2. This is a point where readers will not agree
What does "discern the body" mean? One reading holds that the "body" is the church: the people gathered, who are one body in Christ. To fail to discern it is to eat in a way that ignores the poor, the divided, the neglected. Another reading holds that the "body" is the body of Christ in the bread: to fail to discern it is to treat the Supper as ordinary food, without reverence for what it is. Many Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran and Anglican writers and communities emphasise this second sense, with reasons drawn from the wider passage and from long tradition. Many Reformed, Baptist and other communities emphasise the first, with reasons drawn from the context in Corinth. Many hold both: that the Lord is truly given in the meal, and that to honour him there is to honour the people he gave himself for.
What this course requires is less than either reading requires. Say what your community teaches and who decides, and speak of other traditions with respect. Neither reading permits the verse to be used to frighten a person away from the table.
3. Self-examination, in its right place
Most communities give some form of self-examination before the table. It may be a silent moment. It may be a prayer of confession said together. It may be a private confession to a priest or a pastor, which is part of the practice in some traditions. It may be an invitation to ask: "Have I wronged someone? Am I at odds with someone in this room? Do I trust Christ?" Each community has its own form, and each has good reasons.
Three cautions apply to every form.
- It is a preparation, not an entrance exam. The meal is where grace meets people who need it. A community that makes the examination so long or hard that only the confident come has turned the verse upside down.
- It is for the person, not for the leader to check. A leader does not stand at the front and watch who comes. The examination is between the person and God, and, if the person wishes, a trusted minister.
- The words should leave a way in. A good invitation names the sin, says that Christ welcomes sinners, and says the way is open. A bad one names the sin and says "be careful."
4. When guilt is heavy
Some people carry guilt that does not lift. They have confessed and been told they are forgiven, and a week later they are sure they are not. They examine themselves again and again, and each time they find more. Some of them stay away from the table for years, and some come in dread. This heavy, repeated self-doubt may have many sources, and some of them are matters for a health professional. We are not able to tell the cause in any person, and the course does not try.
What a community can do:
- Do not diagnose. Do not say "you have scrupulosity" or "you are depressed". Say what you can see: "You seem to be carrying a lot." Offer to listen.
- Do not condemn. Do not tell the person they are too sensitive, or that they should have more faith.
- Do not use the verse. To a person already afraid of the table, "examine yourself" is not help. Offer the invitation of the meal: it is given for you.
- Offer a trusted pastor, priest or counsellor, and suggest that they see a health professional, as you would for any illness. Do not make the visit a condition of anything.
- Keep it private. A person's conscience is theirs.
If a person speaks of harming themselves, take it seriously. Stay with them, call the local emergency number if they are in danger now, and help them reach a health professional or a crisis line. Give no method and no detail. For care of those in grief or crisis, see the courses PT724E and PT720E.
5. Peace first: and the one who was harmed
Jesus says in Matthew 5 that if you bring a gift to the altar and remember that a brother or sister has something against you, you should leave your gift, be reconciled, and then offer it. Many communities place a sign of peace before the table for this reason: people greet one another, and in some places a person who is at odds with another goes to them first.
This is good, and it has a limit. The saying is addressed to the person who has done the wrong. It is not a command to the person who was harmed. A person who has suffered abuse, including spiritual abuse, is not required to go to the one who harmed them, to forgive them to their face, or to share a sign of peace with them. And a person who must share a room, and a table, with the one who harmed them has a hard thing to bear.
What a community can do:
- Never press a person to be reconciled in order to receive. Do not say "you cannot come to the table until you have made peace."
- Give the person choices. A different seat, a different time, receiving at a distance, or not receiving, without questions. Let them decide.
- Protect first. If you suspect abuse or danger, do not investigate it yourself, and do not confront anyone. Tell a responsible person or body: a safeguarding person in your community, a senior leader, or the proper authority. If someone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
- Do not make the harmed person carry the community's peace. If there is a case, the leaders are responsible for the way forward, with the person's wishes at the centre.
An invented example
(An invented example.) A woman in a small church has been told by a trusted leader that she must forgive a family member before she can receive the bread. For months she has stayed seated. A new pastor hears of it and speaks to her privately. He does not ask what happened. He says: "The table is open to you. You do not have to do anything before you come. If there is something you wish to tell someone, I will help you find the right person. And if you would rather not receive, that is also yours to decide." He then reports to the church's safeguarding contact what he has been told about the earlier leader, as the church's rules require. He tells the woman he has done so, and why.
6. The place of confession
Traditions treat confession differently. Some have private confession to a priest, with a form of absolution. Some use a general confession said by all together. Some encourage confession between believers. Some do not have a set form, and rely on the person's own prayer. A community that tells people where confession is found, and how to use it, does them a kindness. A community that makes confession a gate to the table, with the leader as the one who admits, risks turning care into control. Say what your community teaches and who decides, and keep the door open.
7. Online communion
Since people began to join worship through a screen, communities have had to ask whether the Supper can be shared this way. It is a new question, and a hard one. We give the positions, as their holders would, and decide for no one.
1. It needs the bodily gathering. The Supper is a meal shared by people in one place, who eat from one loaf. Paul writes of those who "come together", and one bread making one body. On this view, a screen can bring people to the Word and to prayer, but the meal needs a room. Those who cannot come may be visited, and the table may be brought to them (lecture 5-3).
2. It is permitted. The Lord is present with his people wherever they gather in his name. If a community is gathered by a screen, with one voice, one prayer, and one meal, and each person has their own bread and cup, then it is one table. Some hold this in special cases, for example for people who cannot travel, and some more widely.
3. It is left to those who decide. Some communities hold that this is a question for their bishop, their elders or their assembly, and that no individual leader should decide it alone. They may allow it, forbid it, or allow it in limited ways, and they may change their mind.
This is a point where readers will not agree, and the reasons are good on all sides. What this course requires is the same: say what your community teaches and who decides, and follow your community's order. Do not take it on yourself to start, or to stop. Do not describe another community's decision as careless or as cold.
Some practical points hold whichever view you follow. If your community does permit it, ask whether the person has the bread and cup ready beforehand, and whether any health need is met (lecture 5-2). Speak plainly about who is gathered. Keep the privacy of those who join: do not record their faces without their consent, and do not share a recording more widely than people agreed. Follow local rules about personal information. If you cannot offer the table by screen, say so kindly, and offer a visit or another form of care.
Diagram 1. Reading 1 Corinthians 11 in order
Diagram 2. Three positions on online communion
In short
- In Corinth the Supper had become a divided meal; "unworthy" describes the way of eating, and self-examination is a step toward the table.
- "Discerning the body" is read as the church, as Christ in the bread, or as both; this course asks every community to say what it teaches.
- A person with heavy guilt is not diagnosed or condemned; offer the invitation of the meal, a trusted pastor, and a health professional.
- Peace first is addressed to the one who did wrong; a person who was harmed is never pressed to meet the one who harmed them.
- Online communion has three positions: it needs a gathered body, it is permitted, or it is left to those who decide; follow your community's order.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The setting of 1 Corinthians 11 | A divided meal in which some ate first and some went hungry; Paul says wait for one another. |
| Two readings of "the body" | The church gathered; Christ in the bread; many hold both. |
| Care for heavy guilt | Do not diagnose or condemn; offer the invitation, a trusted pastor and a health professional; keep it private. |
| Online communion | Needs the bodily gathering; permitted; left to bishop or elders; follow your community and decide for no one. |
One sentence to remember Examine yourself, and then come: the examination leads to the table and never away from it.
This week's action Read 1 Corinthians 11:17-34 from start to finish, and write what Paul is angry about in one sentence.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What situation was Paul addressing at Corinth, and how does that change the way you hear "in an unworthy way"?
- State the two readings of "discerning the body" in terms their own holders would accept.
- A person tells you they never receive because they are sure they are not good enough. What would you say, and what would you not say?
- Why does the saying about leaving your gift at the altar not oblige a person who has been harmed to meet the one who harmed them?
- Which of the three positions on online communion does your community teach, and who decided it? How would you speak of the others?