Lecture 4-1: What a Sacrament Is
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: God's Time, the Church's Time
- Lecture 1-2: How the Church Year Grew
- Lecture 1-3: Churches That Keep the Year and Churches That Do Not
- Lecture 1-4: The Shape of the Year
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Read a Year
- Lecture 2-1: Advent, Christmas and Epiphany
- Lecture 2-2: Lent and Holy Week
- Lecture 2-3: Easter and Pentecost
- Lecture 2-4: Ordinary Time and Days Your Country Keeps
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Shape One Season in a Service
- Lecture 3-1: Season and Word
- Lecture 3-2: Children and All Ages Together
- Lecture 3-3: Making Room at Home
- Lecture 3-4: When the Season Hurts
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, One Small Practice
- Lecture 4-1: What a Sacrament Is
- Lecture 4-2: The Supper: What Happens
- Lecture 4-3: Word and Table
- Lecture 4-4: Who Presides
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Table of Understandings
- Lecture 5-1: Who Comes to the Table
- Lecture 5-2: Bread, Cup and Body: Access and Health
- Lecture 5-3: Sick, Elderly and Housebound
- Lecture 5-4: Worthiness, Self-Examination and Online Communion
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, A Welcome Note and an Access Check
The first three weeks of this course were about time. This week turns to the second thing that forms the church: the sacraments. A season tells the story of Christ over a year. A sacrament puts the story into water, bread and wine, and hands it to a person.
Christians share the practice and disagree about the word. Some say the church has seven sacraments. Some say two. Some say the church has no sacraments at all, only ordinances. Some gather every week with no water and no bread, and say that all of life is the sacrament. Each group has reasons that come from its reading of Scripture and its life with God. This lecture lets each one speak first, in its own words.
The principle of the week is the guide: a sacrament is a place where the word is handed to us visibly; traditions understand how differently. The central claim of the course returns here. The church is formed by time and sacrament to live inside the story of Christ. A sacrament, whatever it is called, is one of the ways a person is received into that story and helped to stay.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain, in plain words, what "sacrament," "mystery," "ordinance," "sign" and "means of grace" mean.
- State the Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, Reformed, Anglican, Baptist and Quaker or Salvation Army positions on the number of sacraments, each in its own terms.
- Describe the different ways traditions understand what a sacrament does.
- Name what almost all of these groups share when they speak of word and sacrament.
- Say what your own community teaches about the sacraments and who decides.
Go, and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit," — Matthew 28:19
World English Bible
teaching them to observe all things that I commanded you. Behold, I am with you always, even to the end of the age.” Amen." — Matthew 28:20
WEB
Or don’t you know that all we who were baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death?" — Romans 6:3
WEB
We were buried therefore with him through baptism to death, that just like Christ was raised from the dead through the glory of the Father, so we also might walk in newness of life." — Romans 6:4
WEB
The cup of blessing which we bless, isn’t it a sharing of the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, isn’t it a sharing of the body of Christ?" — 1 Corinthians 10:16
WEB
Two of these verses name actions the church does: baptizing, and breaking bread and blessing a cup. Matthew 28 gives the first as part of a commission, with a promise attached: "I am with you always." Romans 6 says what the first action means: a person is joined to Christ's death and rising. First Corinthians 10 calls the second a "sharing" in the body and blood of Christ. Christians read these verses together, and most of this week is about how they read them.
1. Where the word comes from
The word "" is not in the Bible. It comes from the Latin church. In everyday Latin, sacramentum could mean a pledge or an oath, and also something set apart as holy. When the New Testament was put into Latin, the translators used it in some places for the Greek word mysterion, "mystery." An example is Ephesians 5:32, where Paul says "This mystery is great." The Greek word does not mean a puzzle. It means something God has hidden and then shown.
The Greek-speaking churches never needed a different word. They said "mystery," and many still do: the Holy Mysteries. Paul calls the leaders of the church "stewards of God's mysteries" (1 Corinthians 4:1). So the two words, sacramentum in the West and mysterion in the East, start from the same place: God acts in ways we do not fully see, and the church receives and guards what God has given.
A very old description of a sacrament is "a visible sign of an invisible grace." It is often traced to Augustine, a bishop in North Africa in the early fifth century, who also called a sacrament "a visible word." The meaning is simple. A word is something we hear. A sacrament is something we also see, touch and taste. The same promise comes to the ear and to the body.
2. Four words to hold
- . A way God ordinarily gives his help and presence to people. Almost every tradition would name hearing Scripture and prayer as means of grace. Many add baptism and the Supper. Many add fellowship, confession and care.
- Sign. Something that points beyond itself. Water points to washing and to death and new life. Bread points to being fed.
- Seal. A mark that confirms a promise, as a seal on a letter. Some traditions speak of the sacraments as "signs and seals" of God's promise: the sign shows the promise and the seal confirms it.
- . An act the church keeps because Christ commanded it. Some traditions prefer this word because it stresses the command and the believer's obedience, and they keep "sacrament" for something else, or do not use it.
3. Word and sacrament
Many traditions speak of the church as living by two things at once: the word and the sacraments. In one form of this teaching, the church is found where the gospel is truly preached and the sacraments are rightly given. In another, the Sunday has two tables, one of the word and one of the Eucharist. Whatever the arrangement, the idea is the same. God does not speak only to our minds. He gives himself to whole people, who have ears and hands and mouths.
This is why the sacraments belong to the central claim of this course. A person comes into the story of Christ by hearing it. A person also comes into it by being washed, fed and gathered. Hearing and sharing work together. Lecture 4-3 comes back to this.
4. What each tradition says, in its own words
Here is how several traditions describe themselves. Each description is short and cannot hold everything a tradition teaches. Where a community has a or a written statement, that statement is the authority, not this lecture.
Catholic. The Catholic Church teaches that there are seven sacraments: baptism, confirmation, the Eucharist, reconciliation (confession), the anointing of the sick, holy orders and marriage. It teaches that Christ instituted them and that in each one Christ himself acts through the church. The church uses the Latin phrase ex opere operato, "from the work done," to say that the sacrament gives grace because of what Christ does in it, and not because of the holiness of the minister. The person receiving it must be willing, and must not stand against it. The effect in the person's life grows with their faith and their openness.
Orthodox. The Orthodox Church speaks of the "holy mysteries." Many Orthodox teachers list seven that match the Catholic list: baptism, chrismation (anointing with oil, given at baptism), the Eucharist, confession, anointing of the sick, ordination and marriage. Many Orthodox teachers also say that the number seven is a way of counting and not a boundary, because the whole life of the church is a mystery in which God acts. The Orthodox generally decline to explain exactly how a mystery works. They say that a mystery is received and lived, not solved.
Lutheran. Lutheran churches commonly count two sacraments, baptism and the Supper, because each has a visible element and a promise of God's forgiveness joined to it by Christ's command. Many Lutherans also speak of confession and absolution (the pastor's word of forgiveness) in very similar terms. Lutherans stress that the sacrament is God's word with an element, and that its gift is received by faith. The word comes first. The water or bread alone, without the word, would be only water or bread.
Reformed (including many Presbyterian churches). Reformed churches count two sacraments, baptism and the Supper, and call them "signs and seals" of God's promise. They teach that the Holy Spirit works through the sacrament, together with faith, to join the believer to Christ. They stress that the sacrament does not work by itself and that the sign must not be confused with the thing signed.
Anglican. Anglican churches name two sacraments as given by Christ in the gospel, baptism and the Supper. They also keep and value other rites, such as confirmation, marriage, ordination, reconciliation and anointing, and they do not count them at the same rank. Anglican provinces differ among themselves in how much weight they place on each. Some stress the church's continuity with the early church and the full richness of the mysteries. Others stress the Reformation emphasis on faith and Scripture.
Methodist. Methodist churches count two sacraments, baptism and the Supper, and speak of them as means by which God works in the believer's life. Many also stress that God's grace goes before a person, which is why some baptise infants.
Baptist and many independent, Pentecostal and evangelical churches. These communities usually prefer "ordinances," and they keep two: believers' baptism and the Lord's Supper. They teach that Christ commanded these acts, that they proclaim the gospel in picture, and that they are a response of faith and obedience. Many in these communities also say that Christ is truly met by faith in these acts, and that they are more than an empty picture. Others stress remembering and witness. Some communities add other acts, such as foot washing, which they also keep in obedience to Christ's example.
Salvation Army, Quakers and some other communities. These communities do not practise water baptism or the bread and cup in their worship. They do not say these acts are bad. They teach that the baptism and the supper that matter most are inward and spiritual, and that the whole of life lived with God is itself sacramental. They hold that the outward acts are not needed, and that insisting on them may draw attention away from what they point to.
Notice what you have just read. No tradition in this list says that Christ is unimportant in baptism or the Supper. They differ on how many acts, what kind of acts, and how the grace and the act are joined. That difference needs to be described correctly before it can be discussed honestly.
5. How the effect is understood
The hardest question is not the number. It is the effect: when water is poured or bread is shared, what happens? Traditions answer in at least four broad ways.
- God acts through the sacrament itself. The sacrament is Christ's own action. It gives grace by what is done, as Christ promised, when it is received without refusal. This is the Catholic teaching and a very old Orthodox understanding, held in different words.
- God acts through the sacrament with the word and with faith. The sacrament is a promise of God, made visible, and it gives what it promises to those who trust it. This is the common Lutheran and Reformed teaching, and Methodists and many Anglicans hold it in their own terms.
- God acts in the believer's faith and obedience; the act bears witness. The act shows and confirms what God has already done in the believer, and the church obeys Christ's command by doing it. This is the common Baptist and evangelical teaching of ordinances.
- God acts inwardly, and the outward act is not required. This is the Quaker and Salvation Army teaching.
These do not line up neatly with any ranking, and the descriptions are not exact. For example, many Baptists would say they hold the second view, and many Reformed Christians would say their church holds the first and second together. The honest way to speak of a tradition is to ask a person in it, or to read its own statement.
This is a point where readers will not agree. The disagreement is about the number of sacraments and what they do. Those who hold seven, or the mysteries of the East, say that Christ gave his church a fuller life than two acts, and that the church's early and continuous practice of anointing, ordination and reconciliation shows it. Those who hold two say that only baptism and the Supper were clearly commanded and given by Christ, and that the other rites, though valuable, do not rest on the same command. Those who hold ordinances say that the word "sacrament" has been used to suggest that grace is given through an act without faith, and that Scripture's stress is on obedience and trust. Those who keep no outward acts say that a spiritual life does not need an outward form and that the form may be mistaken for the substance. This course requires less than any of them: say what your community teaches, say who decides it, and speak of other traditions with respect.
6. What nearly all of them share
It is easy to leave this lecture with a list of differences, so here is what is shared.
- Christ is the centre. The act is about him, and not about a person's skill or feeling.
- God gives; we receive. Nobody earns a sacrament. Everyone who practises one says that the gift is first God's.
- Word and act belong together. No tradition thinks bread and water mean anything apart from the story of Christ.
- The church receives and shares them together. Even those who say the acts are private matters of faith do them in a gathering, with other people.
- They are for people, with bodies. Washing, eating and drinking are physical, and that is why the lectures of the next two weeks have to think about bodies: who can eat what, who can come, who can reach the table.
7. A short card for your own community
Whatever your tradition, a leader should be able to say, in plain words, what the community teaches. Write it on a small card. Here is an invented sample, for a small independent church. It is a sample of the shape and not the content your community must hold.
(An invented example.) "We keep two acts that Jesus gave us: baptism and the Lord's Supper. We call them ordinances. We keep them because Christ commanded them. We believe Christ is with us when we obey, and that these acts show the gospel in a way we can see and taste. The elders decide how they are held. We respect the churches that call them sacraments or hold a different number."
A Catholic parish, an Orthodox community or a Lutheran congregation would write a different card. Each begins "we," names the practice, gives the reason, says who decides, and respects others. A person who can write that card has understood this lecture.
Diagram 1. Who counts what
Diagram 2. How the effect is understood
| Way of speaking | Short statement | Often heard in |
|---|---|---|
| Christ acts in the sacrament itself | Christ gives grace by what is done, when it is received without refusal | Catholic; Orthodox, in the language of mystery |
| Christ acts through word, element and faith | The sacrament is a visible promise, and it gives what it promises to those who trust it | Lutheran, Reformed, Methodist, many Anglican |
| The act is obedience and witness | The act shows and confirms what God has done, and the church does it because Christ commanded | Baptist and many independent churches |
| God acts inwardly; no outward act is needed | The baptism and the supper that matter are spiritual and fill the whole of life | Quakers, Salvation Army |
Read this table as a rough map. A person inside a tradition may say it more finely.
In short
- "Sacrament" comes from Latin, and "mystery" from Greek; both name what God does and the church receives and guards.
- Catholic and Orthodox teaching counts seven; Lutheran, Reformed, Anglican and Methodist commonly count two; Baptists and many others say ordinances.
- Quakers and the Salvation Army keep no outward water and bread and hold that the inward matters most.
- Traditions describe the effect in different ways, from Christ's own action to faith and obedience to inward grace.
- Say what your community teaches and who decides, and speak of other traditions with respect.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Sacrament, mystery | Latin and Greek words for what God does and the church receives and guards. |
| Sacrament and ordinance | A sacrament stresses what God gives through the act; an ordinance stresses Christ's command and the believer's response. |
| What nearly all share | Christ at the centre, God gives and we receive, word and act together, shared in the church, for bodies. |
| The one rule asked of every tradition | Say what your community teaches and who decides, and speak of other traditions with respect. |
One sentence to remember A sacrament, whatever a community calls it, is a place where the word is handed to us visibly.
This week's action Write your community's card of three or four sentences on the sacraments. If you do not know the answer, ask the person in your community who decides.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what is the difference between a sacrament and an ordinance? What does each word protect that the other might lose?
- Which description in this lecture is closest to what your community teaches? Where would a member of your community say it more carefully?
- Why might a church that keeps no water or bread still say that it has a sacramental life? What would a Catholic, an Orthodox Christian and a Baptist each want to say in answer?
- Four of the five things that "almost all share" are about how the church lives together, not about what it believes. Why might that matter for a small community with many traditions in it?
- What sentence on your community's card would be hardest to write? Whom would you ask?