Lecture 3-4: Safeguarding Children and Vulnerable People
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Sent and Welcomed: Scripture and the Long History of Going
- Lecture 1-2: The Honest Argument About Short-Term Trips
- Lecture 1-3: Whose Work Is It? Hosts, Guests, Power and Money
- Lecture 1-4: Kinds of Teams, Kinds of Trips
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Why We Want to Go
- Lecture 2-1: Beginning With an Invitation
- Lecture 2-2: Designing the Days: What a Visit Leaves Behind
- Lecture 2-3: Teams With Special Skills: Medical, Teaching, Building, Youth
- Lecture 2-4: Near Home and Far Away: Local Trips and Online Teams
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Shared Plan With the Host
- Lecture 3-1: Choosing the Team
- Lecture 3-2: Training the Guests
- Lecture 3-3: Health, Safety and Documents: Preparing Without Giving Advice
- Lecture 3-4: Safeguarding Children and Vulnerable People
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Code of Conduct
- Lecture 4-1: What a Trip Costs and What It Is Worth
- Lecture 4-2: Raising Support Honestly
- Lecture 4-3: Photographs, Stories and Social Media
- Lecture 4-4: Reports and Testimonies That Tell the Truth
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking a Fundraising Letter and a Post
- Lecture 5-1: The Guest's Posture: Serving Under Local Leadership
- Lecture 5-2: Planning for Crisis and for Withdrawal
- Lecture 5-3: Team Conflict, Tiredness and Spiritual Care
- Lecture 5-4: When Harm Has Happened: Honest Reporting and Accountability
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Crisis Scenario
- Lecture 6-1: The First Days Home: Debriefing and Hearing the Host
- Lecture 6-2: What Remains: Continuing, Changing or Ending a Partnership
- Lecture 6-3: Calling, Discernment and the Ones Who Stay Home
- Lecture 6-4: Judging the Programme: Evaluation With Humility
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Statement of Principles for Our Church
This lecture is about prevention and procedure. It says how a team is chosen, how its members behave, how a child or a host can speak, where a concern goes and what the organisation then does. It does not describe any act of harm, and it will not. The reader who needs to understand why the rules matter does not need to be told what they prevent.
The argument is this. A visiting team is a risk to children and to vulnerable people, and the risk is real, however good the team's intentions. The reason is not that guests are wicked. The reason is the shape of the situation: strangers arrive for a short time, they are welcomed warmly, children are curious and trusting, adults in the host community may find it hard to refuse a guest, and no one has a long relationship in which anything could be noticed. Good people can be careless in such a situation. A very few people who intend harm may look for exactly such a situation. Rules written in advance protect the child, the host, the team member and the reputation of the work at the same time.
This is the fourth lecture of a chapter on choosing, preparing and protecting the team. It carries the central claim directly: guests who serve under local leadership protect the vulnerable and tell the truth. A team that treats safeguarding as paperwork has turned the host's children into a backdrop. A team that treats it as part of hospitality has put the host's children first.
The lecture does not say that every team member is a suspect, that every adult is dangerous, or that children should be kept from all contact with visitors. It does say that rules apply to everyone, including the most respected, that where practice differs, the stricter rule stands, and that no team should depend on a person's reputation instead of a procedure.
This lecture gives no legal advice. Child protection law, reporting duties, screening rules and the age at which a person is a child differ greatly between countries and may differ between the team's own country and the host's. Find out in advance, from the organisation's written policy and from the host country's own rules, what applies. Write it down and keep it where it can be reached. If a child or another person is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
What these 33 minutes give you
- Explain why visiting teams carry a real risk to children and vulnerable people, without suspecting any one person.
- State the core rules of a team: two adults always, no adult alone with a child, no private contact, no gifts to individual children, and consent for photographs.
- Describe how a team member is screened and how a child or a host reports a concern, and say who receives it and why the team does not investigate.
- Say what to do when a child tells an adult something troubling, using the four steps in this lecture.
- Explain how the rules extend to vulnerable adults, and why the stricter rule stands where practice differs.
Whoever receives one such little child in my name receives me," — Matthew 18:5
World English Bible
but whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to stumble, it would be better for him that a huge millstone should be hung around his neck, and that he should be sunk in the depths of the sea." — Matthew 18:6
WEB
But Jesus said, “Allow the little children, and don’t forbid them to come to me; for the Kingdom of Heaven belongs to ones like these.”" — Matthew 19:14
WEB
Jesus puts a child in front of his followers and says that how they receive that child is how they receive him. He also speaks with great severity about anyone who causes a child to stumble. We take from these verses the weight that Jesus gives to a child, and the seriousness of the duty to protect. We do not use them to frighten, to blame a particular person or to stir up shame. A child's welcome and a child's protection belong together.
1. Why visiting teams are a risk
Almost everyone who joins a team is a decent person. That is the first thing to say, and it is true. The second thing is that decency is not a safeguard. A safeguard is a rule that works whether or not the person is decent, because nobody can see inside a person, and because even a decent person can act carelessly when tired, when moved or when a child has asked for help.
A visiting team has a particular shape that makes risk greater. These are features of the situation, not of any country or people.
- Strangers arrive and are trusted. A host receives guests with kindness. A child is told that the guests are friends. Children may be taught to be polite, to obey adults and to be grateful for visitors.
- The stay is short and nobody knows the guests. In a normal community, adults who spend time with children are known, and their past is known. A visiting team is not known.
- Gifts, attention and the glamour of the foreign guest. A child may be drawn by a person who brings attention, treats and a different life. A guest may begin to treat a particular child as a favourite without thinking.
- Hosts who cannot refuse. A host pastor, teacher or parent may feel unable to say no to a guest who has paid for something, who gives money to the church, or who is respected in the sending body. A host may see something troubling and not know whether it is his place to speak.
- Language and distance. A child who wishes to say something may not have the language, or the person to say it to. The team goes home, and the child cannot easily follow up.
- A guest who is exempt in his own mind. A person in a position of respect, a pastor, a teacher, a doctor, may feel that rules are for others.
This is why the rules apply to everyone. If the rules are lifted for a respected person, they are no longer rules; they are a way of treating people with a reputation as exceptions. The rules say nothing about whom the team suspects. They say that a child is precious enough that safety must not depend on anyone's character.
What this looks like from the host's side. The host pastor, the teacher and the parents know these children by name. They will be there when the team has gone. They carry the risk and the consequences of any harm, and they often have the least power to refuse. A host who is offered a safeguarding policy by a team may be glad of it, because it gives him words to use. He may also be offended, if it is presented as if his community were dangerous. Present it as the team's promise about itself: "This is what we promise, and we would like you to tell us anything we have missed." Ask what the host's own rules and customs are for visitors with children, and listen.
2. Choosing and screening members
Selection (lecture 3-1) is the first safeguard. Several steps belong to it, and they are applied to everyone, including the leader and any person who travels as a "guest".
- A written role. Every member has a stated role. Nobody is on the team only because they are "helping".
- An application and an interview that includes a question about work with children and about the person's own boundaries.
- References from people who will be asked real questions, not only a friendly sentence. The one who asks should be someone other than the leader's friend.
- A record check or screening, according to the organisation's rules and local law. Whether such a check is available, what it covers and what the law allows differ greatly between countries. Find out in advance, write it down, and do not skip a step because a person is well known. If the check cannot be done, the organisation's policy says what happens next. A check does not prove that a person is safe, because many people who cause harm have no record. It is one step, not the safeguard.
- Training, including this lecture's rules and the reporting steps (lecture 3-2).
- Supervision. A new member works alongside an experienced one, and the leader is not the only person who watches.
- The code of conduct signed, with consequences told in advance.
A person who objects to any of these steps, saying "I have worked with children all my life" or "don't you trust me?", should be answered gently: "The rules are the same for everyone, and they protect you as much as the children." A person who still refuses does not join the team. This is not a verdict on the person's character. It is the policy.
3. The rules for the team
The rules are simple, and they are meant to be easy to keep. Each can be checked by a second person.
1. No adult is alone with a child. Children are met in open view, or with another responsible adult present. If a child asks to speak privately, the adult says kindly, "Let us find a place where we can sit with another person near," and then does so. There is no exception for a kind person, a family friend, a team member's own relative or a long-serving worker.
2. Two adults at all times in any activity with children. At least two adults of the team, and where the host has teachers or leaders, the host's own adults are present and take the lead.
3. No private contact and no social media with children. No personal messages, no friend requests, no giving of a personal phone number or email, and no promise to write. If a child or a young person asks, say, "Our team does not do that, and it is a rule for everyone. If you want to say something to us, you may say it through your teacher or your pastor." Personal contact with a child after the trip is not begun by a team member.
4. No gifts to individual children. A gift to a single child makes that child a favourite, and a gift can be a way of building trust that is not deserved. If the team wishes to give something, it gives to the whole group through the host, as the host decides.
5. Photographs and stories only with consent, which means permission from the child's parent or guardian and the host and, where the child is old enough, from the child, given in advance and in writing, and according to the organisation's rules. No pictures of children are posted online in public places. (The next section returns to this.)
6. No private lodging, transport, bathing or changing with a child. Where a child's care needs such things, they are done by the child's own family or by the host's own people.
7. No touch that is not open and appropriate. The team's training gives plain guidance about which kinds of contact are suitable in the host's setting. Where the host's custom is different from the team's, the stricter rule stands unless the host's own leadership asks otherwise and the organisation agrees.
8. Nobody keeps a secret that a child asks to be kept. An adult never promises secrecy to a child.
9. Say what you see. A team member who sees a rule being broken, or something that troubles them, says so to the named person. A member who reports in good faith is never punished for it.
10. The leader is under the rules.
(An invented example.) On the third afternoon of a trip to the town of Sorrel Bay, Hassan, a retired teacher and a much-liked member of a team, was asked by a boy of about nine whether he would walk with him to the river to see the boats. Hassan had been warm with all the children, and there was no reason to suppose anything but kindness. He answered, "Yes, let us go and ask your teacher, and she will come too." The teacher, Mrs Tavish, said that she would be glad to come, and so did the boy's older sister. Nobody commented. Hassan said afterwards that for a moment he had felt foolish, because he knew his own heart. But he had also felt that the rule had taken something heavy off him: he did not have to decide, on his own, in the moment, whether a walk was safe.
That is the aim of the rules: to remove the decision from the moment and from the individual's judgement. A good person is protected from having to prove that he is good.
4. A disagreement about photographs
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that no picture of a child should ever be taken by a visiting team, because a camera makes a child an object, a pictured child may become known to strangers, and a host's children are not material for the team's story. Others allow pictures with documented consent, kept privately and never put online, because a team's memories, a host's own record of its school and a report to donors are legitimate uses. A third group goes further and holds that no picture of a host's poverty or need should be taken at all, whoever is in it, because such pictures make a person's circumstances into an advertisement. Each position has seen real harm and real value.
This course requires less than any one of them requires, and says the same thing in lecture 4-3: consent, dignity, no children's pictures in public places online, no picture that hides a person's name and humanity behind a cause, and the host's veto. A team that follows this may take a few pictures with permission and keep them safe. A team that does not follow it breaks the code of conduct. A host may say "no pictures at all" and the team obeys without argument.
5. How a child or a host reports a concern
A rule that cannot be reported is not a rule. The reporting route must be simple, known to everyone and independent of the people who might be reported.
1. At least two named persons, at least one of them outside the team and outside the field, so that a concern about the leader or about a person with authority on the spot has somewhere to go. A second route is available if the concern is about one of the two. The names and the ways to reach them are written on the code and given to the host.
2. A way that the host and the child can use. A host who wishes to say something about a team member needs to know whom to tell, in a language he speaks, without a fee or a form. A child needs a trusted adult in his own community to tell, and the host's own adult should know the team's procedure. Where a child's school or church has its own procedure, the team follows it and does not set up a rival one.
3. A promise that a person who reports in good faith will not be punished. If it is wrong, it is wrong honestly; a mistaken report made in good faith is not a fault.
4. A clear statement that the team does not investigate. A team leader is not a detective, a judge or a counsellor. When a concern is raised, the leader takes the steps in the policy: ensures the child's immediate safety; separates the person concerned from any contact with children, as the policy provides and without judging; reports to the named persons and to the authorities as the written policy and local law require; and records what was said and done. The leader does not question the child, confront the person, search anything or try to settle the matter quietly.
5. A record kept factually. What was reported, to whom, when and what was done. It is kept securely and shared only as the policy and the law require.
6. What to do when a child tells an adult something troubling
Whatever the organisation's policy, any team member may be the one a child speaks to. The steps are four, and each is simple. A team should practise them in training, because the moment arrives without warning.
1. Listen calmly. Do not show shock or horror. Sit near, at the child's level, in a place where others can see you. Let the child say what he or she wants to say, in their own words and at their own pace. Do not ask leading questions or press for detail. It is not your job to find out what happened.
2. Say what the child needs to hear. "Thank you for telling me. I believe you. It is not your fault. You are not in trouble." Do not make promises you cannot keep. Never promise to keep it secret. Say instead: "I need to tell someone whose job is to keep you safe, and I will tell you who."
3. Write it down afterwards, as soon as you can, in the child's own words where you remember them, with the date, the time and who was present. Do not add your own opinions.
4. Tell the named person at once. If the concern is about the named person, use the second route. Do not discuss it with the team, do not talk to the person concerned, and do not wait. If a child is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
After this, the adult's work is finished. Do not stay awake all night trying to solve it. Someone else's work begins.
Where distress may be deep, for the child, for the adult who heard, for the host's family and for the team, the organisation should have named people to turn to: a trusted pastor or priest, the safeguarding contact, a health professional and the local emergency service. A team member who has heard something hard should not carry it alone.
7. What the organisation does next
When a concern has been reported, the responsible body, not the team, takes up the work. In general terms:
- It protects the child first. The child's safety is the first duty, before the reputation of the work or the person.
- It informs the child's parents or guardians, unless doing so would put the child at risk, and works with the host's leaders, who know the family.
- It informs the proper authorities as the written policy and local law require. These rules are found out in advance.
- It treats the person who is accused fairly, without presuming guilt or innocence, and keeps that person apart from children while the matter is handled according to the policy.
- It keeps a factual record and does not move the person elsewhere, hide the matter or settle it quietly.
- It tells the truth to the host, the families and donors about what has been done, within what the law and the child's privacy permit.
- It continues care for the child, the family, the host's community, the person who reported and, where appropriate, the accused. Care for a person who is accused goes with accountability and with protection of children. Care is never a way of hiding misconduct. (Lecture 5-4 takes up what a team does on the ground when harm has happened.)
8. Vulnerable adults
The same principles reach beyond children. A vulnerable adult is a person who, because of age, disability, illness, a dependent position, poverty or another condition, is less able to protect themselves, to refuse, to understand or to speak up. Elderly people in a home, a patient in a clinic, a person with a disability, a woman dependent on a man who works with the team and someone whose legal position makes them afraid to complain may all be in this position.
The rules carry over:
- A team member is not alone with a vulnerable person in private, and the person's care is given in the open or by their own carers.
- Consent is asked for, and it is real consent: a person who is afraid to refuse has not consented.
- Photographs and stories follow the same permission.
- The same reporting route is open to vulnerable adults and to those around them.
- A person is not made a subject of the team's ministry without their free agreement. A visit to a sick person is a visit, not a demonstration.
What a clinic or a home sees. A nurse, a care worker or a patient's family knows these people by name and will be there afterwards. If the team's rules and the home's rules differ, the stricter rule stands. A team that asks, "What are your rules for visitors, and what would you like us to do?" will be received better than one that arrives with its own.
9. Where practice differs, the stricter rule stands
Teams cross borders and traditions. A common practice in one place may be unacceptable in another, and what is lawful in the team's own country may not be in the host's, or the other way round. The principle is easy to state, though sometimes hard to keep: where two rules differ, the stricter stands. A team does not argue that "it is normal here" to loosen a rule, or that "it is normal at home" to override a host's. If the host asks for a stricter rule, the team accepts it. If a team has stricter rules than the host, the host is informed, and the team keeps its own.
Where there is any uncertainty about what the law requires, in the host place or at home, ask the organisation and the proper authorities before the trip, not after. This lecture cannot tell you what the law requires. It can tell you to ask.
10. Not a form to be filled, but a way to receive a child
Everything in this lecture is also hospitality. A team that has read and kept the rules arrives at a host's church saying, in effect, "Your children are precious to us, and we will receive them as people whose safety is not negotiable." That is a way of keeping the word of Jesus: to receive one such child is to receive him. The rules are not a barrier between the team and the children. They are the way the team earns the right to be near them.
Diagram 1. Rules, reports and what follows
In short
- A visiting team is a real risk to children and vulnerable people because of the situation, not because of any one person. Decency is not a safeguard.
- Core rules: two adults, no adult alone with a child, no private contact, no gifts to individual children, consent for photographs, no promised secrets.
- Every member is screened and trained, the leader included. Where practice differs, the stricter rule stands.
- A report goes to at least two named persons, one outside the team. The team does not investigate or settle it quietly.
- If a child speaks: listen, say "I believe you; it is not your fault", promise no secrecy, write it down, tell the named person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why a team is a risk | Strangers are trusted, stays are short, gifts and attention draw children, hosts find it hard to refuse. The situation, not the person, creates the risk. |
| The simplest rule | No adult is alone with a child. Two adults, in open view, every time, with no exception for a respected person. |
| When a child tells you something | Listen calmly, say you believe them and it is not their fault, promise no secrecy, write it down, tell the named person. |
| What the team does not do | Investigate, confront, question the child, settle it quietly or move the person elsewhere. The responsible body acts. |
One sentence to remember Rules that apply to everyone, a way to speak that does not run through the person reported, and a body that acts: that is how a team receives a child.
This week's action Find out whether your church or team has a written safeguarding policy with two named persons, one outside the team, and ask where it is kept.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does the lecture say that decency is not a safeguard? Does that make you suspicious of anyone, or does it relieve you of something?
- Which of the features of a visiting team (strangers trusted, short stay, gifts, hosts who cannot refuse, language and distance) is easiest to forget? What could a team do about it?
- In the story of Hassan, what did the rule take off him? How might it have felt to be told "no" by a rule if he had not been warned beforehand?
- If a host's own custom is looser than the team's rule, what does the team do? What if the host's custom is stricter?
- Why does the team not investigate a concern, even though the leader is often the person who knows the people best?
- State the three positions on photographs of children fairly. What does this course require, whatever position a reader holds?
- A host pastor says, "In our village we do not need such rules; everyone knows everyone." How would you reply so that he feels respected and the rule still stands?