FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT736E Short-Term Mission Teams: Planning, Sending and Following Up Honestly

Lecture 5-2: Planning for Crisis and for Withdrawal

Contents 31
PT736E Short-Term Mission Teams: Planning, Sending and Following Up Honestly
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Sent, Welcomed, Accountable
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Sent, Welcomed, Accountable, and What This Course Does Not Teach
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Sending and Welcoming: Why We Go and How We Argue About It
  1. Lecture 1-1: Sent and Welcomed: Scripture and the Long History of Going
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Honest Argument About Short-Term Trips
  3. Lecture 1-3: Whose Work Is It? Hosts, Guests, Power and Money
  4. Lecture 1-4: Kinds of Teams, Kinds of Trips
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Why We Want to Go
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Planning With the Host
  1. Lecture 2-1: Beginning With an Invitation
  2. Lecture 2-2: Designing the Days: What a Visit Leaves Behind
  3. Lecture 2-3: Teams With Special Skills: Medical, Teaching, Building, Youth
  4. Lecture 2-4: Near Home and Far Away: Local Trips and Online Teams
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Shared Plan With the Host
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Choosing, Preparing and Protecting the Team
  1. Lecture 3-1: Choosing the Team
  2. Lecture 3-2: Training the Guests
  3. Lecture 3-3: Health, Safety and Documents: Preparing Without Giving Advice
  4. Lecture 3-4: Safeguarding Children and Vulnerable People
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Code of Conduct
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Money, Words and Pictures
  1. Lecture 4-1: What a Trip Costs and What It Is Worth
  2. Lecture 4-2: Raising Support Honestly
  3. Lecture 4-3: Photographs, Stories and Social Media
  4. Lecture 4-4: Reports and Testimonies That Tell the Truth
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking a Fundraising Letter and a Post
Chapter 5 · Week 5: On the Ground and When Things Go Wrong
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Guest's Posture: Serving Under Local Leadership
  2. Lecture 5-2: Planning for Crisis and for Withdrawal
  3. Lecture 5-3: Team Conflict, Tiredness and Spiritual Care
  4. Lecture 5-4: When Harm Has Happened: Honest Reporting and Accountability
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Crisis Scenario
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Coming Home and What Remains
  1. Lecture 6-1: The First Days Home: Debriefing and Hearing the Host
  2. Lecture 6-2: What Remains: Continuing, Changing or Ending a Partnership
  3. Lecture 6-3: Calling, Discernment and the Ones Who Stay Home
  4. Lecture 6-4: Judging the Programme: Evaluation With Humility
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Statement of Principles for Our Church

Jump to the key points ↓

27 min

Most trips go by without a serious crisis. Some do not. A team member falls ill or is hurt. A road is closed. A dispute in the town turns tense. A storm, a strike or an outbreak of illness changes what is possible. A family at home has a death. The host's own household has an emergency. In each case, people have to decide something quickly, with partial information and with strong feelings.

This lecture makes one argument: a team that has planned for the worst can respond with calm, honesty and care, because the hard decisions were agreed before the hard day. Nobody can foresee every event. But a team can agree in advance who decides, who may stop the trip and on what grounds, who is told, and how the host is consulted. A crisis is a poor time to discover that nobody knows who is in charge.

This lecture applies the central claim of the course to the worst days. A humble partnership does not treat the host as a stage for the team's bravery, and it does not treat the team's safety as the host's problem. Evacuation and caution are signs of love, not of weak faith. A trip that is cancelled or cut short for good reasons has not failed.

This lecture gives general principles only. It is not safety, medical, legal or security advice. It names no products and gives no numbers. For what to do in your place, ask your organisation's written rules, the host's leaders, qualified professionals and the local authorities, and write the answers down before you travel.

What these 27 minutes give you

  • List the parts of a crisis plan that should be written before departure: roles, decision rights, grounds for stopping, and communication.
  • Explain how a decision is shared between those on the spot and those far away, and why the host is part of it.
  • Describe what honest communication to families, church and donors looks like during and after a crisis.
  • Say why the care of the person who was hurt or frightened continues after the event.
  • Explain why withdrawal agreed in advance is a mark of love and not a lack of faith.

When many days were fulfilled, the Jews conspired together to kill him, but their plot became known to Saul. They watched the gates both day and night that they might kill him, but his disciples took him by night, and let him down through the wall, lowering him in a basket." — Acts 9:23-25

World English Bible

A prudent man sees danger and takes refuge; but the simple pass on, and suffer for it." — Proverbs 27:12

WEB

The book of Acts tells how Saul, after he began to preach in Damascus, learned of a plot. His friends did not tell him to stand and be brave. They took him by night and let him down through the wall in a basket. The text does not call this a failure. It is what his friends did, and Saul went on. We take from it a narrow point: leaving a place of danger, with help and at the right time, is something the New Testament narrates without embarrassment. The proverb says that a prudent person sees danger and takes refuge. We do not use either verse to say what any team must do in any place. We use them to say that planning for danger is not a lack of faith.

1. Why plan before

When a crisis comes, there is little time and a great deal of feeling. People are afraid. Some want to stay and help. Some want to go home at once. Some think the host is being careless, and some think the team is. Leaders are asked to decide things they have not thought about before. Families at home hear fragments and fear the worst.

A plan written in calm cannot remove the fear, but it can answer some questions beforehand. Who is in charge? Who may say "stop"? Whom do we call first? Who tells the families? These are not clever questions. They are the questions that, left unanswered, produce a quarrel in the worst hour.

A plan also protects the host. A host who has agreed in advance what will happen if the team has to leave is not left to carry a sudden departure alone. A host who has been consulted is not surprised.

Planning for withdrawal does not mean expecting disaster. Most teams who plan never use their plan. It is like a lifejacket: it is worth having because of what it does on the one day it is needed, not because the day is likely.

2. The parts of a crisis plan

A crisis plan can be one or two pages. It should exist in writing, before departure, with copies where people can reach them (lecture 3-3). These are the parts.

1. Roles. Who is the leader on site? Who is the deputy, if the leader is the one in trouble? Who is the safety contact, if the team has one? Who is the contact at home, a named person with a phone that is answered, and a deputy for them? Who is the host's contact for the team? Write names, not titles only, and write what each person decides and what each person only advises.

2. Decision rights. Who may decide what, and who must consult whom? On the spot, the leader will usually have to decide fast. Some decisions the leader may make alone, such as moving the team to another room or delaying an outing. Some the leader makes only with the home contact, such as ending the trip early. Some the leader makes only with the host, such as anything that affects the host's household or church. Write this down. A leader who has to guess whether he is allowed to decide, in the middle of a crisis, is carrying a burden that a page could have lifted.

3. Who may stop the trip, and on what grounds. This is the part many plans leave out. Agree, in advance and in writing, who may say that the team will stop, pause, move or go home. It should not be only the leader on site, who may be tired, loyal to the project or afraid to disappoint. It should include the person at home. And it should include a rule that any team member may raise a concern, and that raising it is never punished. The grounds are described in general terms: a serious threat to the health or safety of team members or of the host's people; the advice of the host's leaders that the team's presence is now a risk or a burden; instructions from the authorities of the place; the judgement of those the organisation has asked to advise. Each organisation writes its own, and the grounds are found out in advance from the host country's and the organisation's rules.

4. Withdrawal criteria. A short list, agreed in advance, of the kinds of event that lead to a pause or a return. We name no particular events, because they differ by place and season. The value of the list is that a leader can say, "We agreed this before we came," instead of having to argue it out in front of a frightened group. Criteria agreed in calm are easier to follow than decisions made in fear.

5. The host's part. The host is consulted, not informed afterwards. The host knows the place better than the team. The host may see a danger the team does not see, or may judge that a danger is smaller than the team fears. The host may also have reasons for wanting the team to stay or go that are not about the danger at all: money, relationships, reputation, a visit that took a year to arrange. The team must be able to hear the host's view without letting it settle the matter alone. Where the host and the team disagree, the agreement written in advance says who decides, and the answer is usually that the safety of the team's members is decided by the team's own responsible people, after listening to the host. We say "usually" because structures differ.

6. Records. During a crisis, someone keeps a plain log: times, who said what, who decided what, who was told. It is not for blame. It is so that the facts are known afterwards, and so that decisions can be learned from. Keep personal details to what is needed, and keep the log where only those who need it can read it.

7. Communication. Who tells the families, and when? Who speaks to the congregation, to donors, to the press if any? The answer should be one named person per audience, and a rule that team members do not post about a crisis online until the families concerned have been told and the host agrees. Lecture 4-3 explained why real-time posting is dangerous. In a crisis it can cost a family the news of a death by a screen and can expose a host to danger.

8. Care. Who looks after the person who was hurt or frightened? Who looks after the rest of the team? Who looks after the leader? We return to this below.

9. Where to find the rules. Add to the plan a line saying where each of these things was found out: the host country's rules on emergency medical access, insurance, entry and exit, the organisation's written policy, the contact lists. Write the date. Keep the plan updated. This lecture is not advice about any of these; the plan says who to ask.

3. Sharing the decision across distance

A crisis often splits the team into two groups: those who are there and those who are not. Each has information the other lacks.

Those on the spot can see, hear and smell what is happening. They know how the host's people are behaving. They know how frightened or calm their own members are. But they are tired, they may be frightened, and they are too close to see the whole.

Those far away have a wider view. They may know of events the team cannot see, can reach authorities and advisers, and are calmer. But they cannot see the room. They may be tempted to give orders on a half-picture, or to hold back help because they do not want to interfere.

A good plan says both are needed. The person on the spot has the authority for immediate action. The person at home is the check, the advice and the link to the wider world. When they disagree, the plan says who decides, and the person on the spot who is overruled is not blamed.

Two warnings follow from this.

First, do not let the one who is furthest from the danger overrule the one in it without very good reason, and do not let the one who is closest to the danger decide alone on matters of great weight, such as whether to stay in a place that others judge unsafe. Neither has the full picture.

Second, treat the voice of the host as a voice, not a vote and not a veto on the team's own safety. The host's advice is weighty. The host also lives there after the team has gone. A team that leaves quickly against the host's advice may owe the host an explanation and care afterwards, but the team's members are the team's responsibility.

4. Honest communication

In a crisis people at home want news, and the leader wants to reassure them. There are two temptations: to say too little and to say too much.

Saying too little leaves families to imagine the worst, and later discover that things were hidden. Families should be told early what is known, in plain words, by a named person, and told when they will hear next, even if the answer is "nothing new yet".

Saying too much can harm. A family should hear first. A name should not be published until the family has been told. Private health information should go only to those who need it. A host's name, place or church should not be named in public without the host's consent. And details that would put local people at risk should not be shared.

For the congregation and donors, a short and honest account is better than silence or a polished one. It says what happened, what was done and what is not yet known. It does not turn the event into a story of courage or a story of blame. It says what the host said and how they were cared for. Lecture 4-4 sets out how reports are written.

Here is a small example of a message to the sending congregation, before and after.

Before: "Our team faced a frightening situation yesterday but stood firm in faith and God protected us all. Please pray that we will be bold."

After: "Yesterday a road to our host town was closed and we agreed with Pastor Dray to remain in the church for the night. Everyone is well. We are meeting this morning with the host's leaders to decide what to do next, and we will write again this evening."

The first message makes danger a story of bravery and tells the reader how to feel. The second says what happened and when the next news will come.

5. The one who was hurt, and the afterwards

When a person on a team is hurt or frightened, the first duty is to that person. We do not decide what the injury means for the programme. We do not move the person out of sight for the team's comfort. We make sure the person is cared for by those who are qualified, in the way the plan describes, and that the person is not left alone.

The person's own wishes are heard. If the person wishes to go home, we help. If the person wishes to stay, and it is safe and right, we do not push them out. If the person cannot say what they want, those responsible decide with care and tell the person afterwards.

Care does not end when the danger ends. A frightening event can leave a person unsettled for a long time, and others in the team may have been affected as well. This lecture gives no mental-health advice. A trusted person should be available to listen, a health professional should be available to those who need one, and nobody should be told that their reaction shows weak faith. Lecture 6-1 returns to the days after the trip.

The host's household is affected too. If the team has to leave suddenly, the host may have to explain, may lose money that was counted on, and may have to continue with a smaller programme, or none. A team that withdraws should say what it can and cannot do for the host afterwards, keep the promises it made, and ask the host what the withdrawal has cost.

6. Withdrawal is not failure

Some groups feel that to withdraw is to quit and that a faithful team stays. This may come from admiration of those who have stayed in dangerous places, which is real and deserves respect. But it can become a pressure on teams to take risks that nobody agreed to and that the host did not ask for.

The honest account is plainer. A person who sees danger and takes refuge is called prudent in the proverb. A friend lowered Saul over a wall. Neither the proverb nor the story says the one who left lacked faith. Some people accept risk freely, with their eyes open, as part of a long . A short trip with a group of volunteers, some of them young, is a different thing, and the team's members have not all chosen the same degree of risk. The leader's duty is to those he leads.

A team that goes home early with love and honesty, having spoken with the host, has done something good. A team that stays too long to prove its courage has put its host in the position of caring for people who should have been protected. Do not make danger a badge. Do not make staying a test of faith.

(An invented example.) Northfold Fellowship sent a small team to the town of Quillon at the invitation of Pastor Emeka Dray. The team's leader, Ines Calder, and the fellowship's home contact, Mr Paul Hargreave, had written a crisis plan before departure. It named who might stop the trip, and it said that any member could raise a concern without penalty.

On the fourth day heavy rain closed the main road, and a rumour spread in the town that a bridge was damaged. The team had a plan to travel to a second village the next morning. Pastor Dray said he thought the road would reopen and the team should not worry. A young team member, Tobias, privately told Ines he was frightened. Ines remembered that raising a concern was never to be punished. She thanked him and asked the team to stay in the church while she called Mr Hargreave and spoke again with Pastor Dray.

The talk was not easy. Pastor Dray had spent months arranging the second village and had told the people there. He feared the cancelled visit would shame them. Mr Hargreave, hearing both, asked Pastor Dray what the people in the village would need to feel respected, and asked Ines what the plan said. The plan said that the safety of team members was decided by the team's own leader with the home contact, after listening to the host. They postponed the visit, Pastor Dray went himself to the village to explain, and the team offered to cover the cost of the visit's food already bought. Nobody was happy, and nobody was ashamed. The road reopened two days later and the team went, with a day less in the village than planned.

Look at it from each side. From the host's side, a cancelled visit risked his name and a month of work, and he spoke honestly about that. From the team member's side, the one who spoke was frightened and was heard, which was exactly what the plan promised. From the sender's side, a home contact was able to hold the middle between a worried leader and a host who wished to go on. Nobody was weak in faith. The plan did what a plan can do: it made a difficult conversation possible.


Diagram 1. A crisis plan on one page: who, whom, when

Planning for Crisis and for Withdrawal Agree in calm what is hard to decide in fear. General principles, not advice. On the spot Leader, deputy, safety contact Sees and hears the situation Acts first on immediate matters Is tired and close to it Any member may raise a concern The host Consulted, not told afterwards Knows the place Has stakes of his own Stays after the team goes A voice, not a veto on team safety Far away Home contact and deputy Wider view, calmer Reaches advisers and authorities Cannot see the room Checks, advises, links Written before departure 1. Roles, with names 2. Who decides what 3. Who may stop the trip, and the grounds 4. Withdrawal criteria 5. The host's part 6. A plain log 7. Who tells whom 8. Care for the hurt, the team, the leader and the host 9. Where each rule was found out, and the date What goes wrong Nobody knows who may say stop. Danger is made a badge. The family hears from a screen. The host hears of a departure after it happens. The hurt person is moved out of sight. Withdrawal agreed in advance is love, not weak faith.

In short

  • A team that agrees in calm who decides, who may stop the trip and who is told can respond with care in a crisis.
  • A plan names roles, decision rights, grounds for stopping, the host's part, a log, communication and care.
  • The person on the spot acts first; the person at home checks and links; the host is consulted and his voice heard.
  • Any member may raise a concern without penalty. The one who raised it is thanked.
  • Honest communication tells families first and tells the truth without stories of bravery or blame.
  • Withdrawal agreed in advance is a sign of love, and the hurt, the team and the host are cared for afterwards.
Front Back
Who may stop a trip? Named in advance, in writing: not only the leader on site. Any member may raise a concern without penalty.
The host in a crisis Consulted and heard, not informed afterwards. A voice, not a veto on the team's own safety.
Honest communication Families first, one named person per audience, plain facts, no posting until families and host agree.
Withdrawal A sign of love when agreed in advance. Danger is not a badge and staying is not a test of faith.

One sentence to remember Decide in calm who decides in fear, and let nobody be punished for saying "I am afraid".

This week's action Write down, for a team you know or an invented one, who is the leader on site, who is the home contact and who may stop the trip. Notice any blank.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why is a crisis a poor time to decide who is in charge? What questions can be answered in calm?
  • Why should the power to stop a trip not rest with the leader on site alone? Who else should have it?
  • In the story of Quillon, what did the plan make possible? What did it not remove?
  • How should the host's voice be heard in a crisis, and why is it a voice and not a veto on the team's own safety?
  • What is the difference between the "before" and the "after" message in the lecture? Which would you want to receive if you were a family member at home?
  • Where have you heard danger treated as a badge of faith? How would you answer it kindly?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.