Lecture 6-3: Calling, Discernment and the Ones Who Stay Home
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Sent and Welcomed: Scripture and the Long History of Going
- Lecture 1-2: The Honest Argument About Short-Term Trips
- Lecture 1-3: Whose Work Is It? Hosts, Guests, Power and Money
- Lecture 1-4: Kinds of Teams, Kinds of Trips
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Why We Want to Go
- Lecture 2-1: Beginning With an Invitation
- Lecture 2-2: Designing the Days: What a Visit Leaves Behind
- Lecture 2-3: Teams With Special Skills: Medical, Teaching, Building, Youth
- Lecture 2-4: Near Home and Far Away: Local Trips and Online Teams
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Shared Plan With the Host
- Lecture 3-1: Choosing the Team
- Lecture 3-2: Training the Guests
- Lecture 3-3: Health, Safety and Documents: Preparing Without Giving Advice
- Lecture 3-4: Safeguarding Children and Vulnerable People
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Code of Conduct
- Lecture 4-1: What a Trip Costs and What It Is Worth
- Lecture 4-2: Raising Support Honestly
- Lecture 4-3: Photographs, Stories and Social Media
- Lecture 4-4: Reports and Testimonies That Tell the Truth
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Checking a Fundraising Letter and a Post
- Lecture 5-1: The Guest's Posture: Serving Under Local Leadership
- Lecture 5-2: Planning for Crisis and for Withdrawal
- Lecture 5-3: Team Conflict, Tiredness and Spiritual Care
- Lecture 5-4: When Harm Has Happened: Honest Reporting and Accountability
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Crisis Scenario
- Lecture 6-1: The First Days Home: Debriefing and Hearing the Host
- Lecture 6-2: What Remains: Continuing, Changing or Ending a Partnership
- Lecture 6-3: Calling, Discernment and the Ones Who Stay Home
- Lecture 6-4: Judging the Programme: Evaluation With Humility
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Statement of Principles for Our Church
Some people come home from a trip with a question. It may be small: "Did I enjoy that because it was new, or because it was right?" It may be large: "Was this a call? Should I go back, or go for longer, or change my life?" Others come home with no such question and a little guilt that they feel none. And in every sending church there are many who never went at all: the ones who prayed, gave, cooked, minded the children or kept the office, and the ones who could not go because of health, money, age or family.
This lecture argues that a call is tested over time, among people, and confirmed by a church. It is not settled by a feeling at the end of a trip, and it is not a verdict on those who stay. It also argues that the church's mission is carried by those who go, send, pray, give, host and stay home, and that none of these is a lesser part.
It carries the course's central claim. A short-term trip is a humble partnership, and one thing humility requires after a trip is patience with what a trip stirs up. The claim closes two doors. One door treats the trip as an experience for the traveller that ought to end in a decision: if you were moved, you must now act. The other treats the host as a place where vocations are found, a field in which the visitors discover their calling. Neither is honest. A person's future is not a result of a visit, and the host's home is not a testing ground.
The lecture does not say that a trip cannot be the beginning of a call. It does not say that feelings after a trip are to be distrusted. It does not make going a duty or staying home a failing. It gives no medical, psychological or legal advice, and it does not tell a person what to do with their life. It describes how a church can help a person ask the question well.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Explain why a question about calling after a trip needs time, a community and a church's confirmation.
- Describe the risks of collective emotional pressure, an instant vow and a public call as a requirement, and state fairly the different practices of public invitation.
- Describe how a church can accompany a person who asks "was this a call?", including the teenager who is swept up in feeling and the person who comes back and goes no further.
- Name the ways in which those who stay home are part of the mission, without making staying a consolation prize.
- Say where to look next for longer service and for the care of those sent.
Then he said to them, “The harvest is indeed plentiful, but the laborers are few. Pray therefore to the Lord of the harvest, that he may send out laborers into his harvest." — Luke 10:2
World English Bible
How then will they call on him in whom they have not believed? How will they believe in him whom they have not heard? How will they hear without a preacher?" — Romans 10:14
WEB
And how will they preach unless they are sent? As it is written: “How beautiful are the feet of those who preach the Good News of peace, who bring glad tidings of good things!”" — Romans 10:15
WEB
Now in the assembly that was at Antioch there were some prophets and teachers: Barnabas, Simeon who was called Niger, Lucius of Cyrene, Manaen the foster brother of Herod the tetrarch, and Saul." — Acts 13:1
WEB
As they served the Lord and fasted, the Holy Spirit said, “Separate Barnabas and Saul for me, for the work to which I have called them.”" — Acts 13:2
WEB
Then, when they had fasted and prayed and laid their hands on them, they sent them away." — Acts 13:3
WEB
Jesus tells his disciples first to pray, and what they are to ask for is that the Lord of the harvest will send. In Romans, Paul sets out a chain: those who call, believe, hear, preach and are sent, and the sending is one of its links. In Antioch the call comes in the middle of a church at worship and fasting, among a group named one by one. Barnabas and Saul are not alone; the church prays, lays hands on them and sends them. We read these passages for one point: in Scripture, a sending is something the Spirit does within a community, and the community takes part. It is not described as a private decision made on the way home from a meeting. These verses are not a command that every person should go. They are not a verdict on anyone who stays.
1. "Was this a call?"
A person comes home and says, quietly or loudly, "I think God is me to go." Or, "I do not know whether this was a call." Or, "I felt something there that I cannot find here." These are all ordinary things to say, and they deserve to be heard. Some of them, over time, become a call. Some of them are a deep response to a new experience that will settle. Some of them are tiredness. And some are a mixture that cannot be separated for months or years.
The church's task is not to decide for the person, and not to push, and not to say "That is just a feeling." It is to help the person ask the question well, over time, among people who know them. That is what discernment means in this lecture: patient, shared, prayerful testing of a sense of call, which is neither hurried nor dismissed.
Traditions differ in how they speak of this. Some speak of an inner call confirmed by the church. Some speak of a call that comes first through the church, which invites a person to a task. Some speak of a vocation tested by a spiritual director. Some speak of discernment in a community of the religious order or the diocese. Pentecostal and charismatic churches often expect the Spirit to speak, sometimes through a prophetic word, and then ask for confirmation by the leaders. Catholic and Orthodox churches have long practices of testing a vocation under a priest or a spiritual father or mother. These practices are different, and this course does not rank them. What they have in common, in their wisest forms, is that a call is not checked by the one who feels it alone.
2. Three things a call needs: time, a community and confirmation
Time. A trip is short, and a strong feeling may be strongest in its last days or its first week at home. The first weeks after a return are often a time of tiredness and unusual feeling (lecture 6-1). A decision made in this time is a decision made in unusual weather. Waiting is not a lack of faith. A call that is real can usually bear a few months of patient testing. A person who feels a pressure to decide before the feeling fades should treat the pressure itself with care.
A community. "Discernment" is not meditation alone. It is done with a few people whom the person trusts and who are free to say what they honestly think: a pastor or priest, a mentor, an older member of the church, a spouse or a close friend. Ideally the person chooses them, and chooses some who will not simply agree. A group like this asks questions: What did you do on the trip, and what did the host say about it? What gifts have others seen in you? What would you leave behind? What does your family need? Why this, and why now?
Confirmation by the church. A church confirms a call by looking at a person's life, character and gifts, and by testing whether the church can support the person. That confirmation may be given by a congregation, a leader, a board, a diocese or an order. It may be a "yes". It may be "not yet", or "not this", or "yes, but first this". A "not yet" is not a rejection. It can be a gift: time to grow, to learn the language, to finish training, to repay a debt, to look after a parent, or to be sure.
Notice that the host also has a voice. If the person is thinking of going back to the place where the trip was, the host church is not a testing ground and not a convenience. The host may welcome the person, or may say "Come as a guest again, but we do not need a long-term helper." The host may know the person better than the team knew. A person's sense of call to a place has to be put to the people of that place, with the same honesty as any other plan, and with their freedom to say no. A person who arrives to stay because "God called me" and does not ask the host church first has reversed the order that lecture 1-1 found in Luke 10: the guest is received first, and does not arrive as an owner.
And the host has callings too. Members of the host church may feel called to serve in their own town, in another region or in another country. They are not only receivers of visiting vocations. A church that is serious about partnership wants to hear how a local person is called and wants to help send them.
3. Pressure, vows and the public call
This is the part of the subject where good people disagree.
This is a point where readers will not agree: whether a trip should end with a public call to long-term service. Some churches and youth movements hold that a public invitation at the end of a trip, or at a service when the team reports, is a good and biblical thing: a person who has felt a stirring needs a moment to say yes, the Spirit moves in such moments, and a church that never asks never hears. They add that many people who serve have said that such an invitation was the point at which they first dared to answer. Others hold that discernment needs months and a community, not a meeting: a public moment puts pressure on the young, the tired and the moved, it rewards the emotional over the steady, and it can bind a person to a vow before they know what they have promised. A third group holds that a public call is fine if it is understood as a first step and not a vow, and that what matters is what comes after the meeting.
All three describe real things. The first notices that some calls are heard in a moment. The second notices that some "yeses" in a moment are later wished unsaid. This course requires less than any one of these demands. No pressure, no instant vow, time and a chosen group of advisers, and respect for the one who goes home. A church may hold a public moment if it likes, provided that nobody is made to stand, nobody is watched to see who stands, nothing said there is treated as binding, and a way to talk more slowly is offered at once. A church that does not use a public moment is not cold. Both may do the same good work afterwards.
Three kinds of pressure are worth naming, because they are often unintended.
Collective emotional pressure. A room of tired and moved people, a moving song, and a leader's heartfelt plea can produce a wave in which many feel the same thing at once. That feeling may be real. It is also strong enough to be a poor guide. Notice what a decision depends on if the music were stopped.
The instant vow. "I will go back." "I will give my life to this." "I will do whatever God asks." These sentences can be sincere and still be too early. A church that records a vow, or a group that treats a spoken promise as a debt, makes it harder for a person to change their mind. Encourage "I want to think and pray about this", and honour it.
The public call as a requirement. If the only recognised way to respond to a trip is to come forward, those who do not will feel judged. A person who is thoughtful, shy, private or simply slow, who prefers to talk with one person later, should not be seen as less committed. A church should say aloud that a quiet conversation is as good as a public gesture.
4. The teenager swept up in feeling
Young people often return from a trip with strong feelings and little to compare them with. This is not a defect. It is part of being young: everything is new, and the experience of being useful, trusted and part of a team may be remarkable. A young person may then say, with great sincerity, "I want to be a missionary."
The church's best response is warm and slow. It does not laugh. It does not say "you will grow out of it." It does not make the young person into a public example. It says: "Thank you for telling me. That sounds important. Let us talk about it again in a few months, and in the meantime, what would you like to learn?" It can offer a mentor, a book, a language lesson, a later trip, a sharing of the young person's own gifts in the home church, and parents who are included and not ignored. A young person's feeling is real, and the way to honour it is to give it room.
This links to the argument of lecture 2-3. A youth trip serves the host first, and the young person's formation is a second fruit. The second fruit may include a sense of call. It is not the aim.
5. The one who comes back and goes no further
Not everyone who goes on a trip is called to longer service, and the honest ones say so. A person may come home and find that the trip, however good, showed them that their place is here. They may learn that they are good with a hospital waiting-room, a classroom, a business, a home. They may learn that they are not suited to the work, or that their family cannot move, or that they simply do not feel drawn. A person who says "I now know I am not called to go further" has learned something real and deserves thanks, not disappointment.
The church's task is to say so. "Your trip has been of use to the host and to us. You have done what was asked. You are not required to do more." A trip must not be treated as a first step on a ladder that every traveller is meant to climb. A church that does this will tend to lose those who returned and went no further: they will feel that they have not lived up to something. That loss is silent, and it is preventable.
And such a person has real work at home. They bring back what they learned: an eye for the guest, a patience with a language not their own, a habit of prayer for a particular place, a skill at welcoming those from far away. These are gifts to the church.
6. The ones who stay home
In every church there are many who will never go on a trip, and the reasons are good ones: health, money, age, a family to care for, work, a disability, a fear, a place where they are needed, or simply the sense that they are not called to travel. This lecture argues, without reservation, that they are part of the mission, and the mission could not go without them.
Think of what staying home involves. Sending is the work of those who pray, who choose and prepare a team, who give, who write to the host, who hold the home end of an emergency plan, who keep records, who welcome the team back and listen to it, who receive the host's letters, who give a hand to the family of someone who has gone, who hold the congregation steady while others are away. Romans 10:15 says "how will they preach unless they are sent?" The question is not only about those who go. It is about those who send. A church in which only the travellers are honoured will soon find its senders tired.
And the host also stays home. In the host church, almost everyone stays. The pastor, the interpreter, the cook, the neighbours whose street has been visited, are the ones who stay, year after year, in the place where the work lasts. A theology that honours only the going has little to say to them. A theology of the whole church speaks of the sending, the receiving and the remaining as parts of one mission.
Two cautions. First, do not make staying home a failing. Do not use a verse as a stick: "the harvest is plentiful and the laborers are few" is not a reproach to a person who cannot go. Jesus tells his disciples to pray that the Lord will send, and a church that prays is already taking part. Second, do not make staying home a consolation prize. Do not say "you can still help by praying" in a way that suggests that praying is what is left for those who cannot do the real thing. Prayer, giving, hosting and sending are real things.
(An invented example.) At the Harbourlight Chapel, a mission evening was held after the youth team returned from a town called Ostrith. The pastor, Father Daniel, asked all who had been part of the trip in any way to stand. The travellers stood. He asked more. The woman who had run the fundraising supper stood. The man who had driven the minibus to the airport at four in the morning stood. The retired nurse who had prayed daily by name for each member stood. The mother who had cared for a traveller's children stood. Two thirds of the room were on their feet. "This," he said, "is the team." A traveller said afterwards that she had not realised how many people had carried her.
7. Where to look next
For a person who truly wishes to explore longer service, the next steps are longer, slower and more structured than a short trip. A good church will help the person find an organisation or a body with a proper process of selection, training and care (the matters discussed in the courses on missions and on caring for those we send), will ask whether the host would welcome the person, and will tell the person plainly about the costs. The care of long-term missionaries and their families is the subject of the course on caring for those we send, and the person should read it before deciding. That course will say much that this one cannot.
Diagram 1. Discernment after a trip: time, community, confirmation
In short
- A call is tested over time, among people, and confirmed by a church. A strong feeling at the end of a trip is not yet a verdict.
- Avoid collective emotional pressure, the instant vow and the public call as the only way to answer. Quiet conversation is as good.
- Readers differ about a public invitation. This course requires no pressure, no instant vow, time, chosen advisers and respect for the one who goes home.
- The host is asked first about any return. Local believers have callings too and should be helped to be sent.
- Those who stay home, send, pray, give and host are part of the mission. A person who goes no further is thanked, not pitied.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three things a call needs | Time, a community of advisers, and the church's confirmation, which may be "yes", "not yet" or "not this". |
| Three pressures | A wave of shared feeling, an instant vow, and a public call as the only way to respond. |
| The warm and slow reply | "Thank you for telling me. Let us talk again in a few months. What would you like to learn?" |
| Who stays home | Those who pray, give, host, send and keep the home end. The host church mostly stays. None is a lesser part. |
One sentence to remember A call is tested over time among people who know you, and no one is shamed for going, sending or staying.
This week's action Write the names of three people who carried the last trip, or any work of your church, without going. Thank one of them in person.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does the lecture say that a call needs time, a community and confirmation? Which of the three is most often left out in your church or tradition?
- State the three positions on a public call at the end of a trip, each in its strongest form. What does the lecture require whichever you prefer?
- What would a warm and slow response look like for a teenager who says "I want to be a missionary"? What should the church not say?
- Why might a person who comes back and goes no further feel that they have failed? What can a church say to them?
- In the story of the Harbourlight Chapel, who stood? Who in your church would stand, and who might be forgotten?
- If a person feels called to a place where the trip took them, whose voice must be heard before they go? What might the host say?