Lecture 5-2: Care and Counselling
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What the Word "AI" Points To
- Lecture 1-2: How a Language Model Makes Words
- Lecture 1-3: Sounding Right Is Not Knowing
- Lecture 1-4: Reading a Conversation Closely
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Read an AI Answer
- Lecture 2-1: Invented Facts
- Lecture 2-2: Old Knowledge, Missing Sources, Uneven Coverage
- Lecture 2-3: Scripture and Theology, Where to Be Most Careful
- Lecture 2-4: Building a Checking Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Find the Errors
- Lecture 3-1: Asking Well
- Lecture 3-2: Checking What You Are Given
- Lecture 3-3: What Must Never Be Typed In
- Lecture 3-4: Keeping Notes and Giving Credit
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, Mend the Prompts, Mark the Secrets
- Lecture 4-1: Hand It Over, Help With It, Keep It
- Lecture 4-2: Office Work and Communication
- Lecture 4-3: Teaching and Study Materials
- Lecture 4-4: Where Teachers and Leaders Draw the Line
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Hand Over, Help, or Keep
- Lecture 5-1: Preaching and AI: A Theological Question
- Lecture 5-2: Care and Counselling
- Lecture 5-3: When Members and Young People Use AI
- Lecture 5-4: The Minister's Own Life
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Judge the Scene, Write a Position Paragraph
Preaching speaks to many people at once. Care speaks to one person at a time, and it asks for something a sermon does not: the minister has to be with someone. This lecture asks what an AI system can and cannot be in that place.
The answer has three parts. First, care is a relationship, and a tool does not enter one. Second, many members already turn to AI systems when they are troubled, and a minister should meet that without scorn. Third, there are moments when the right move is not to use any tool at all but to move toward a person. Signs of danger are among these moments, and this lecture is firm about them.
This is not a course in counselling, and it gives no medical, legal or psychological advice. It does not diagnose anything. Where a person needs a qualified helper, it says so.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Explain why care is a relationship and what a tool cannot do within it.
- Say why a minister does not use an AI system to generate counselling answers for a person.
- Respond to a member who has sought comfort from an AI system, without scorn.
- Name the signs that call for a person and not a tool, and state what to do next.
- Explain what keeping a confidence means and why it must not be broken by typing into a tool.
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
World English Bible
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13
WEB
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18
WEB
Two of these verses are about being with people: weeping with the weeping, bearing a burden that belongs to someone else. One is about trust. The last says where God is found, and it should remind us that a person in pain may be nearer to God than anyone around them knows, and that we are sent to be near too.
1. Care is not an output
The thing a grieving person most often needs is not information. It is someone who comes, sits down, is not in a hurry, and remembers on Thursday what was said on Monday. Paul's instruction is to weep with those who weep. The verb is "with." You cannot do it from a distance, and you cannot do it by sending words.
Think of what happens when a minister visits a home after a death. The family hardly remembers what was said. They remember that the minister came. They remember a hand on a shoulder, a prayer said quietly, a kettle put on. The words matter, but the presence carries them.
An AI system has no presence. It does not know the family. It will not remember on Thursday. It is not accountable to anyone for what it says, and it cannot notice that the person across the table has stopped speaking and is looking at the door. It continues language plausibly, and the language it produces may sound kind. Sounding kind is not the same as being with someone.
That is the central point of this lecture, and everything else follows from it: care is a relationship between persons, and a person must be the one to carry it.
2. Why people turn to AI systems anyway
A minister who dismisses this will lose the conversation. People turn to an assistant at night, when no one else is awake. They turn to it because it does not seem to judge, because it answers at once, and because it costs nothing. A young person may find it easier to type a question than to say it to a face. A lonely person may be glad of any answer. A person ashamed of a question may ask it there first.
These are real needs. They are also, quite often, signs that something is lacking in the community: that people do not know whom to ask, or feel that they will be judged. A minister can take that as information about the community and not only as a problem with a tool.
3. What a minister does not do
A minister does not use an AI system to generate counselling answers for a person.
Here are the reasons, put plainly.
- The system does not know the person. It cannot know the family, the history, the illness, the fear. A fluent answer to a general question may be wrong for this person.
- It cannot be held responsible. If it says something harmful, there is no one to account for it. The minister who passed it on is the one who answers.
- It can say what is false. Earlier weeks showed that these systems invent facts and state them calmly. In a time of pain, an invented comfort or a wrongly stated fact can do real damage.
- To ask it, you must type something. To get an answer about a person you must describe the person. That is the very thing this course says must never be done.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Communities hold different views on how far AI belongs in care. Some hold that it has no place at all: is a gift of the Spirit and of the office, and anything that puts a machine between the minister and the sufferer weakens it. Others hold that a minister may use a tool for general, impersonal matters, such as asking what a grief support group usually involves, or for turning a long document into plain words, as long as every person-to-person act stays with a person. Others again work in settings where a trained counsellor uses approved tools under professional rules, and they will rightly follow those rules. Each has its reasons, and a reader may hold any of them.
What this course asks of every reader is the common minimum: do not deceive, keep confidences, and a person stays responsible. A minister never types a member's story, name or trouble into a tool, never passes on a generated answer as if it were his or her own pastoral judgement, and never leaves a person in distress with a machine as the only listener.
4. Meeting the member who asked a machine
(An invented example.) A woman tells her pastor, a little embarrassed, that when her mother was dying she spent several nights asking a chat assistant what to do and how she should feel. "It was kind," she says. "I know it's silly."
There is a wrong way to answer this, and it is to say that she should not have done it. She is already ashamed. A good answer begins with the facts: she was alone at night and she reached for something. The pastor can say, "I'm glad you had something to hold on to. I'm sorry I was not there." Then, gently, ask what she found helpful. She may say that it said it was normal to feel numb. That may or may not be true for her; the pastor can talk about it with her as a person who knows her. The pastor can then say the thing a machine could not: "Come and tell me about her."
The aim is not to win an argument against the tool. It is to move the woman back toward people, and to make it easy to do.
5. Signs that call for a person
Some things a person says or shows must never be handed to an AI system, and the minister must never treat the tool as a way of judging them. These include:
- talk of not wanting to live, or of being a burden to everyone, or of ending one's life;
- talk of harming oneself, or signs that someone has been doing so;
- signs that a person, and especially a child, is being hurt or frightened by someone;
- a person who seems in danger now, or who says someone else is in danger.
This list is a set of signs, not a method of diagnosis. You are not asked to decide what is wrong. You are asked to take the next step, and the next step is always to move toward a person.
What to do.
- Stay with the person. Do not leave someone in distress alone if you can help it. Listen. You do not need to find the right words; being there is the first thing.
- Ask plainly if you are worried. Asking someone whether they are thinking of ending their life does not plant the idea. A calm, direct question is a kindness. Then listen to the answer.
- Involve a person who can help. That may be a pastor or priest, the person responsible under your community's written rules, a qualified professional, or a doctor.
- If there is danger now, call the local emergency number. Do not wait. Do not look for an answer from a tool. Stay with the person until help arrives if you can do so safely.
- Write nothing about the person into any tool. Not for advice, not to draft a message, not for anything.
This lecture gives no details of methods of harm, and none should ever be given in teaching or in conversation with a person at risk. It also does not give medical or legal advice. For those, the minister's task is to point to the qualified person. Many places have a crisis line; find out the number for your area and keep it where you can reach it. Do not rely on a number read from a tool, because it may be wrong or out of date. Ask a person you trust, or check your community's written rules.
6. Confidences
Proverbs says that a trustworthy spirit keeps a secret. In pastoral care, what is told in confidence is a trust. In some traditions it is protected most strictly, as in the seal of confession. In others the minister's duty is set out in written rules or in local law, and it may have limits. For example, a minister may be required to report certain kinds of harm to a child. Do not assume. Learn what your community's written rules and your local law say, and tell people the limits before they tell you something, where that is possible and kind.
Whatever those limits are, there is one thing that applies everywhere in this course. A confidence must not be put into an AI tool. Not the name, not the details, not a summary, not a "made-up version" with a few changes. Once typed, you no longer control where it goes, and different services handle it differently. Nothing in this course can promise you that masking makes it safe.
This also applies to sermon illustrations. A story from the counselling room does not belong in a sermon without the person's real permission, and it does not belong in a tool at all.
7. Condolence, visiting, and the written word
A visit, a prayer said aloud, a hand held, a meal brought: these are the work of a person. So is a card to a grieving family. A minister may sometimes find a phrase hard to put together, and may be tempted to ask a tool for a "kind message." Lecture 4-2 explained why comfort to a particular person is written by a person. What this lecture adds is the reason of care: the receiver is trying to learn from the message that someone thought of them. A message that nobody thought through is not that.
An office notice about the time of a funeral is different. It is information, and ordinary rules for office work apply.
8. Knowing when to refer
No minister is expected to be everything. A minister is expected to know the edge of his or her ability, and to refer. Refer when:
- the person may be in danger, or says someone else is;
- there is a medical or psychological question, or a question of law;
- the trouble has gone on long and does not ease;
- the matter is beyond your training or your time;
- you are too close to the person to help well.
Referral is not abandoning someone. It is a handover, done with the person's knowledge and, where possible, with the minister continuing to visit. A good minister keeps a short list of trusted local helpers and has met them, so that a referral is a name and not a guess.
Diagram 1. When someone tells you something heavy
Diagram 2. What a person does, and what a tool cannot
| In care, a person can | A tool cannot |
|---|---|
| Come to the door and sit down | Be present in the room |
| Remember on Thursday what was said on Monday | Know the person at all |
| Notice that the person has gone quiet | See the face |
| Be held responsible for what was said | Answer to anyone |
| Keep a confidence under rules the community knows | Promise where typed words go |
In short
- Care is a relationship between persons. A tool has no presence, does not know the person, and answers to no one.
- Members turn to AI systems for real reasons: night, privacy, no judgement. Meet this without scorn and move them toward people.
- A minister does not generate counselling answers with an AI system, and never types a member's story or name into one.
- Signs of danger (talk of ending life, self-harm, someone being hurt) are never handed to a tool. Stay, ask plainly, involve a person, and call the local emergency number if danger is now.
- A confidence is never typed in, not even in disguise. Learn the limits set by your community's rules and local law.
- Condolence and visiting are done by a person. Know when to refer.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why care is not an output | It is a relationship; a tool has no presence and answers to no one. |
| Signs that call for a person | Talk of ending life or self-harm; a person or child being hurt; danger now. |
| First steps | Stay, ask plainly, involve a person; local emergency number if danger now. |
| What never goes into a tool | A confidence: no names, no details, no summary, no disguised version. |
One sentence to remember Care is carried by a person who comes, listens and answers for what is said; a tool cannot do that, and signs of danger always go to a person.
This week's action Find out and write down the local emergency number and the name of the person your community's written rules name for concerns about harm. Keep both where you can find them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time when someone simply came to you in a hard hour. What did they do that mattered? What did they say?
- Why might a member prefer to ask a machine before asking you? What might that tell a community about itself?
- What would you say to a person who is ashamed of having asked an AI system for comfort?
- Why is typing "a made-up version" of a person's story still not safe?
- Where in your community is the written rule about harm, children and reporting? If you do not know, how will you find out?
- Which three people or services would you name if you had to refer someone today? Name the kinds if you would rather not name individuals.