FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting

Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers

Contents 31
PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Church, Mental Health and the Leader's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Noticing
  1. Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
  2. Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
  3. Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Other Kinds of Difficulty
  1. Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
  2. Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
  3. Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Staying Beside and Connecting
  1. Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
  2. Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
  3. Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
  4. Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Families, Carers and the Leader's Own Mind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
  3. Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
  4. Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Congregation Friendlier to Mental Health
  1. Lecture 6-1: Words, Preaching and Prayer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Small Groups and Gatherings
  3. Lecture 6-3: Access: Space, Time, Cost and Language
  4. Lecture 6-4: Systems and Many Contexts
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Mental Health Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

28 min

A mother stops a deacon in the car park after a service. She does not ask about her son directly. She says, "We are managing," and looks at the ground. A husband tells his small-group leader that his wife "has not been herself", and then adds quickly that he does not want her to be talked about. A young woman, whose brother is unwell, sits at the back of the meeting every week and leaves before the last song. None of them has asked for anything. Each of them is carrying something.

Up to now this course has looked mostly at the person who is struggling. This week turns to the people around that person and to the leader. This lecture is about the family and the other people who care for someone every day: a husband, a wife, a parent, an adult child, a brother or sister, a friend, a neighbour. They are often forgotten. The church prays for the person and does not notice that the person's household is worn out, afraid, ashamed or angry.

The central claim to which every week of this course returns is this: a church leader is not a diagnostician but someone who notices, stays beside, and connects. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. The leader has a mind and limits too, and receives help. In this lecture the same three verbs are used for the family: the leader notices the household, stays beside it, and connects it to help of its own.

This course is not medical or psychological advice, not diagnosis and not treatment, and it does not replace professional care. This lecture does not teach a family how to manage anyone's difficulty. Questions about a person's care belong to the person's own doctor or treating professional.

What these 28 minutes give you

  • Describe, in general terms, what a household may carry when someone close is struggling in mind or mood.
  • Explain why a family should be neither blamed nor treated as the person's spokesperson.
  • Say how a leader can care for a family while respecting the struggling person's own wishes and confidentiality (check locally).
  • Name three kinds of practical help and three kinds of words that help a carer.
  • Say what a leader does when a family and the person disagree about getting help, and where the leader's limit lies.
  • Explain why children in the household need honest, simple words, and where to turn for child protection questions.

Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2

World English Bible

Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15

WEB

So they sat down with him on the ground seven days and seven nights, and no one spoke a word to him, for they saw that his grief was very great." — Job 2:13

WEB

God sets the lonely in families. He brings out the prisoners with singing, but the rebellious dwell in a sun-scorched land." — Psalm 68:6

WEB

Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their labor." — Ecclesiastes 4:9

WEB

For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow; but woe to him who is alone when he falls, and doesn’t have another to lift him up." — Ecclesiastes 4:10

WEB

We exhort you, brothers, admonish the disorderly, encourage the faint-hearted, support the weak, be patient toward all." — 1 Thessalonians 5:14

WEB

He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13

WEB

The Bible does not picture trouble as something that touches one person only. Job's friends, in the one good thing they did, sat with him on the ground and said nothing, because they saw how great his grief was (Job 2:13). Paul asks the church to carry one another's burdens, to weep with those who weep, to support the weak and to be patient toward all (Galatians 6:2, Romans 12:15, 1 Thessalonians 5:14). The writer of Ecclesiastes says that two are better than one, and that there is trouble for the person who is alone when he falls (Ecclesiastes 4:9-10). Psalm 68:6 says that God sets the lonely in families. The family is one of God's gifts, and it needs care too.

1. Who is a "carer"?

In this course a carer is anyone who, day after day, gives time, attention or worry to a person who is struggling in mind or mood. The word does not mean a paid worker. It may be a wife who keeps the household going, a father who lies awake, a grown daughter who travels every weekend to a parent's home, a brother who answers every late call, a friend who has become the only one the person trusts. It may be a child. Some do not use the word about themselves. They say, "I am just his mother" or "this is what a husband does."

A leader who wants to care for a congregation will find carers in every pew. They do not always say so, and they do not always think of themselves as needing anything. This lecture asks the leader to see them.

2. What a household may carry

A leader does not need to know a household's story to understand that it may be heavy. In general, people close to a struggling person may carry some of these things. They are listed so that a leader can notice, not so that anyone can be labelled.

  • Worry that does not stop, and a feeling of always being on watch.
  • Tiredness, because the day is longer, nights are broken, or the household's work is shared among fewer hands.
  • Fear of what may come, and of saying the wrong thing.
  • Guilt: "Did I cause this?" "Should I have seen it sooner?" "Am I losing patience?"
  • Anger, sometimes at the person, sometimes at the situation, sometimes at God, and shame about the anger.
  • Grief for the person as they were, or for a life that had been planned.
  • Isolation, because the family stays home, stops inviting people, or does not know whom to tell.
  • Shame, because of what the neighbours or the church may think. Lecture 1-2 explained how stigma reaches families as well as the person.
  • Confusion, because the family has been given different advice by different people, some of it conflicting.
  • Money and time pressure, where work is lost or reduced, or costs of care rise.

None of these is a sign of weak love or weak faith. They are what happens when people who love one another meet a long trouble.

(an invented example) Harbour Lane Fellowship is a small congregation of about thirty people in a port town. When the husband of one of its members, Isidro, becomes unwell, the congregation prays for him each week. Nobody asks Isidro's wife, Lucinda, how she is. She works, looks after the children and goes to the clinic with him. One Sunday a visiting speaker prays, "for all who are weary and heavy-laden", and Lucinda weeps through the prayer. Afterwards an older woman, Birgit, sits down beside her and says, "I have been wondering how you are, not how he is." Lucinda says it is the first time anyone has asked.

3. Two mistakes about families

The first two lectures of the course named two mistakes about the person. There are two about the family as well, and neither is anyone's fault.

The first is to blame the family. The old reflex asks what the household did wrong. Perhaps it prayed too little, or raised a child badly, or has "a spiritual weakness", or "a family curse", or "a lack of faith". In many places the belief that a family causes a person's struggle is strong, and it adds shame to worry. A leader should not say, imply or allow it. Lecture 3-3 comes back to spiritual explanations. For now it is enough to say that the Bible's own example of the reflex to blame, in John 9:2-3, is answered by Jesus: it was not that this man sinned, or his parents.

The second is to forget the family. The leader gives all attention to the person and treats the household as a background. Or the leader takes the family's account as the whole truth, and talks to the family about the person as if the person were not there. Both leave someone out.

The way between these two is to treat the family as people with their own needs, and to treat the struggling person as someone with a voice.

4. The person's voice and confidentiality

A family often wants the leader to "do something about" a person. A leader is not a diagnostician, and the person is not a problem to be handled. Three principles help.

  1. The person's own wishes matter. An adult who is struggling has the right to be asked what they want, including what they want the family and the church to know. If the person is a child or is unable to decide, a different set of questions applies, and the leader goes to those with the proper role. Rules about who may decide differ by country and region: check locally.
  2. A leader can listen to a family without sharing anything about the person. The leader can hear a mother's worry and give nothing back that the leader has heard from the person. "Thank you for telling me. I will keep what you said private. I cannot share anything I have been told by others, but I can listen to you, and I can sit with you."
  3. Never promise absolute secrecy to anyone. If there is danger to someone's safety, or the law requires a report, the leader cannot keep silent. The course on counselling ethics, confidentiality and referral principles explains the general principle. The limits differ by country and role, and a leader checks locally in advance.

A leader should also not become a messenger who carries news between a person and the family. If the family and the person are not speaking, the leader does not hold the secrets of both. The leader tells each, kindly, that the leader will not pass messages, and offers to be present while they talk if both agree.

5. What helps a carer

A leader's help to a household is usually small and practical. These are the kinds that carers most often describe as welcome. They are not a programme, and each needs asking first.

Practical help. Specific offers work better than "call me if you need anything". "I can bring a meal on Tuesday. Would you like that?" "I can collect the children from school on Thursdays." "I can sit with him for two hours on Saturday morning so you can go out." The household can say yes or no. A refusal is not a rejection.

Words that help. A carer needs to hear, in plain words:

  • "How are you? I mean you."
  • "You are not alone in this."
  • "Nothing you did caused this."
  • "It is all right to be tired. It is all right to be angry sometimes."
  • "You do not have to tell me anything."
  • "Would you like me to pray with you, or would you prefer not?"

Words that do not help, however kindly meant: "God never gives more than you can bear", "at least it is not worse", "you must be so strong", "have you thought about what you might have done?", "everything happens for a reason", "if you just had more faith". The last one in particular is a weapon, and Scripture is never used as one.

Company without fixing. The best thing a carer may have is somebody who will sit in the kitchen and drink tea and ask nothing. In Job 2:13 the friends sit without a word. Later they speak, and they spoil it (see Proverbs 18:13 on giving an answer before hearing). But the sitting is good.

Rest. A carer who never rests wears down. A leader can organise, with the carer's agreement, a regular time when someone else is with the person so the carer may go to the market, to a service, to sleep or to a friend. A carer who does not want to leave should be gently asked what would make leaving possible.

Their own help. The carer is a person too. A carer who is exhausted, anxious or low may need to see their own doctor or counsellor, and a leader can say so without suggesting that the carer is failing. "You have given a great deal for a long time. It would be wise to look after yourself too. Would it help if I came with you to see someone?" Many communities have groups for families who care for someone, run by churches, clinics or neighbours. A leader finds out in advance what is available locally and keeps a list: check locally.

6. When the household and the person disagree

Sometimes a family believes a person needs help, and the person says no. Sometimes the person wants help, and the family does not. Sometimes the family disagree among themselves about whether to pray, to see a doctor, to see an or to do nothing.

A leader's place is not to take a side or to force a decision. The principle is the same as in lecture 4-2: the aim is help that fits this person, and an adult has the right to decide, while the leader stays beside everyone. In practice:

  • The leader listens to each person separately and does not repeat what one has said to another.
  • The leader says, calmly, that both prayer and proper care are good, and that the leader is not the one to decide about care. Lecture 1-3 set out the principle: prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith.
  • The leader never advises a family, or the person, to stop, start or change any medicine or treatment. Those decisions belong to the prescriber and the treating professional.
  • The leader does not pressure the person through the family, and does not pressure the family through the person.
  • The leader keeps the door open. A person who says no today may say yes later, and is more likely to if the church was kind.

If the leader believes that someone is in danger now, this is not a matter for balance. The leader acts for safety, by staying with the person and the local emergency services. The course on crisis, suicide and trauma response teaches this properly. A leader should not carry such a moment alone, and should make sure someone else knows.

7. When there are children in the household

Children notice more than adults expect. A child may see that a parent is changed and may not be told why. Silence tends to leave a child to make up a reason, and the reason is often "it is my fault". Honest, simple words help: "Mummy is not well. It is not because of anything you did. The doctors are helping. You are loved. You can ask me anything." A leader does not have to be the one who says this, but a leader can encourage the adults and can make sure the child has a safe adult to talk to.

Children should not be used to carry messages between adults, to keep secrets about a parent, or to take the place of an adult carer for long periods. If a leader is worried that a child is not safe or is not being cared for, the course on safe church and child protection sets out what a community must do. The duties to report differ by country, region and role, and a leader checks locally in advance.

A leader should also think about brothers and sisters of a struggling young person, who are sometimes overlooked. A quiet word, a place to go, and being asked how they are can matter a great deal.

8. Different households, different shapes

Households are not all one shape. A leader should not assume a married couple with children.

(an invented example) St Brendan's Parish is a large congregation of several hundred, with a small team of lay visitors. One visitor, Paulo, learns that a man in the parish lives alone and has an adult sister three hours away who phones every day. Paulo visits the man, with permission, and also rings the sister once a week for five minutes, with the man's agreement, simply to ask how she is. The sister later says she had felt that nobody in the church knew she existed.

(an invented example) In a mission team abroad, a member's husband is back home and his mother is ill. The team leader, Rosalind, notices that the member is quiet on calls and has stopped joining the team meal. She does not ask what is wrong. She asks if she may sit with her for ten minutes on Friday. The team also arranges for the member to speak with someone back home who is not part of the team.

In a house church, the family may be most of the group. In an immigrant congregation, the family that cares for someone may be spread over several countries, and the church may be the only family nearby. In a large congregation there may be a care team, and the temptation is to leave the family to it. In each place the same three steps hold: notice the household, stay beside it, connect it to help of its own.

9. What a leader does not do

  • A leader does not blame a family or search for what it did wrong.
  • A leader does not tell a family what the person "has" or what it will mean.
  • A leader does not become the family's channel for information about the person against the person's wishes.
  • A leader does not advise on medicines, doses or treatments.
  • A leader does not promise that prayer will make everything well, or that the trouble will pass by a certain time.
  • A leader does not ask a family to keep going alone.

10. What a leader takes from this lecture

  1. Families and carers are among the people the church forgets. They carry worry, tiredness, guilt, anger, grief and shame.
  2. Do not blame the household, and do not treat it as the person's spokesperson.
  3. The person's own wishes matter. A leader can listen to a family without sharing what the person has said, and never promises absolute secrecy (check locally).
  4. Specific, small, asked-for help is better than a general offer, and a carer needs rest and help of their own.
  5. When people disagree, the leader takes no side, advises nothing about treatment, and acts for safety if anyone is in danger.
  6. Children need honest, simple words and a safe adult; the course on safe church and child protection covers concerns about a child.

Diagram 1. The household around a struggling person

A household around a struggling person Carers carry something too. Notice them, stay beside them, connect them. What a household may carry Worry, tiredness, fear, guilt, anger, grief, isolation and shame. Two mistakes about families To blame the household. To forget the household. Both leave someone out. The way between The family has needs of its own. The person has a voice. Ask both, kindly. The leader's three verbs for a household Notice who is carrying. Stay beside them with small, specific, asked-for help. Connect them to help of their own. Never promise absolute secrecy. Never advise on medicine or treatment. Check locally.

Diagram 2. What helps a carer, and what does not

What helps a carer, and what does not Small, specific and asked for, not slogans What helps "How are you? I mean you." "I can bring a meal on Tuesday." Company without fixing. Rest, and help of their own. What does not help "If you just had more faith." "God never gives more than you can bear." Looking for what the family did wrong. If anyone is in danger now This is not a matter for balance. Stay with the person and call the local emergency services. The course on crisis, suicide and trauma response teaches this properly.

In short

  • Families and carers carry worry, tiredness, fear, guilt, anger, grief, shame and isolation; none of these shows weak love or weak faith.
  • A leader does not blame a household and does not treat it as the person's spokesperson; the person's own wishes are asked and respected.
  • A leader may listen to a family without sharing anything the person has said, and never promises absolute secrecy; the rules differ by country and role, so check locally.
  • Specific, small, asked-for help, honest words and rest help a carer; slogans and scripture used as a weapon do not.
  • When a family and a person disagree, the leader takes no side, never advises on medicine or treatment, keeps the door open, and acts for safety where there is danger.
  • Children need honest, simple words and a safe adult; concerns about a child go to the safe church and child protection principles.
  • This course is not medical or psychological advice and does not replace professional care.
Front Back
Who is a carer Anyone who gives time, attention or worry day after day to a person who is struggling, paid or not.
Two mistakes about families To blame the household, or to forget it; both leave someone out.
Confidentiality with a family Listen without sharing what the person told you; never promise absolute secrecy; check locally.
What helps a carer Specific offers, plain kind words, company without fixing, rest, and help of their own.

One sentence to remember The people around a struggling person are carrying something too, and a leader asks them how they are.

This week's action Think of one household you know of (no names written down) and plan one small, specific offer you could make, and a plain sentence for asking how the carer is.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of the households around you without naming any. Whom has your community asked "how are you?" and whom has it only asked "how is he?" or "how is she?"
  • Why might a family reach for blame, and why might a leader allow it without meaning to? What is one sentence that gently refuses it?
  • In your setting, what would a specific offer look like (a meal, a lift, two hours of company)? What would make it easy for a carer to say no?
  • What do you say when a family asks you to "make" a person see a doctor or come to a meeting? How is that different from refusing to care?
  • Harbour Lane Fellowship, St Brendan's Parish and the mission team are very different. Which is closest to your setting, and what is the first small change that would help its carers?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.