Lecture 5-1: The Digital Divide and Access
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Letters Across the Distance
- Lecture 1-2: What Online Can and Cannot Do
- Lecture 1-3: Depth and Limits of Online Relationships
- Lecture 1-4: Mapping My Online Places
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Online Place
- Lecture 2-1: Purpose, Size and Rhythm
- Lecture 2-2: Welcome and Hosting
- Lecture 2-3: Sharing the Word Online
- Lecture 2-4: Writing a First-Gathering Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Gathering Plan
- Lecture 3-1: Honesty in What We Share
- Lecture 3-2: Video, Short Posts and Social Media: Uses and Limits
- Lecture 3-3: Comments, Quarrels and Criticism
- Lecture 3-4: Checking a Post Before I Send It
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Write and Check a Short Post
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Online
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Recording and Consent
- Lecture 4-3: Harassment, Harmful Content, Unsafe Contact
- Lecture 4-4: Our Safety Agreement
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Find the Gaps in a Safety Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: The Digital Divide and Access
- Lecture 5-2: Balance with Gathering in Person
- Lecture 5-3: Screens, Comparison, Notifications: Practising Restraint
- Lecture 5-4: Who Is Missing, and My Own Rest
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Find Who Is Missing; Plan My Rest
Every online gathering has an invisible guest list. It is made of the people who can join. The people who cannot join are not on it, and because they are not in the room, nobody sees them missing. A leader can run a warm, well-attended meeting for a year and never notice that three people from the congregation, the street or the family stopped being part of it on the day it moved to a screen.
This lecture is about those people. It asks who is left out, why, and what a leader can do. Its answer is practical and short: offer the same gathering through more than one door, and do not treat the people who use the other doors as a smaller kind of member.
This is the fifth week of the course, and the central claim returns here in a plain form. A screen can open a door. A door that opens for some people and stays shut for others is not yet serving the building up of people. It is serving the people who were already well placed.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Name at least six different reasons a person may not be able to join an online gathering, and explain why "no device" is only one of them.
- Describe a set of alternative doors into the same gathering and say what each one gives and what it costs.
- Explain why a leader asks people about access instead of guessing.
- Explain the standard of this course: nothing essential is said only in the online room.
- Explain why some people must not be pressed to turn on a camera or to explain why they stay hidden.
Four people came, carrying a paralytic to him. When they could not come near to him for the crowd, they removed the roof where he was. When they had broken it up, they let down the mat that the paralytic was lying on." — Mark 2:3-4
World English Bible
That servant came, and told his lord these things. Then the master of the house, being angry, said to his servant, ‘Go out quickly into the streets and lanes of the city, and bring in the poor, maimed, blind, and lame.’" — Luke 14:21
WEB
No, much rather, those members of the body which seem to be weaker are necessary. Those parts of the body which we think to be less honorable, on those we bestow more abundant honor; and our unpresentable parts have more abundant propriety; whereas our presentable parts have no such need. But God composed the body together, giving more abundant honor to the inferior part, that there should be no division in the body, but that the members should have the same care for one another." — 1 Corinthians 12:22-25
WEB
Three passages, read here as principles and not as rules about technology. In Mark, four friends carry a man who cannot come by himself, and when the way is blocked they find another way in. In Luke, a host sends his servant out to bring in people who were not on the first list. In First Corinthians, Paul says that the members of the body that seem weaker are needed, and that the body is made so that no part is left without care.
1. The guest list nobody can see
In a building, you can see who is missing. A chair is empty. An elderly member who always sat by the door is not there. Someone may say, "Where is Joseph this week?"
Online, an absence looks different. A name does not appear on a screen. There is no empty chair. And when a leader invites "everyone", the word means "everyone I can think of who has what I have". The result is a quiet sorting. People with a good connection, a private room, a working device and the habit of using them are in. The others are out, and they are often the people the church used to care for most.
That is the first thing to accept: a gathering that is easy for you may be impossible for someone you love. It is not an accusation. It is an observation about how easy it is to build for ourselves.
2. Many reasons, not one
Many people speak of "the digital divide" as if it meant only that some people have no internet. That is one reason. There are many more, and each one needs a different answer.
- No device, or a shared one. A family may have one phone for four people. A person may have a device only at the workplace.
- No connection, or a weak one. In some places a connection is slow, costs money by the amount used, or works only at certain hours.
- Cost. A device, a connection and the credit to use them cost money that some households need for food.
- Age and unfamiliarity. An older person may never have used these tools. Fear of pressing the wrong button and breaking something is real, and it is often hidden behind the words "I don't need it".
- Disability. A person who cannot see well, cannot hear well, cannot hold a device or cannot sit for an hour may find a video meeting closed. Some people tire quickly. Some people need the words written down.
- Language. A gathering may be in a language that a person understands in a room, where they can watch faces and gestures, but not through a thin sound and a small picture.
- Technology anxiety. Some people are not unable; they are afraid, or they have been embarrassed once and will not try again.
- Time. Shift workers, carers and people in other time zones may never be free at the hour that suits the leader.
- Safety and privacy. Some people must not be seen or heard. A person living with someone who controls them, a person whose faith is not tolerated at home or at work, or a person whose location must stay hidden may have a good device and still cannot join. They may not be able to say why.
- Preference and conscience. A few people have decided, for reasons of faith or family, to use these tools little or not at all. That is their right, and it is not a problem to be solved.
Read the list again and notice that it is not a list of people who are "behind". Several of these are people with good reasons. A leader who treats the whole list as a lack of effort has misread it.
3. Ask, do not guess
A leader cannot answer these needs from imagination. The only reliable way to find out is to ask, and to ask in a way that does not shame.
Compare two sentences.
- "Is anyone having trouble getting online?" Asked in front of the group, this invites silence. Nobody wants to be the one.
- "I am planning the next few weeks. I want to make sure everyone can take part. If anything about the time, the tool or the place makes it hard, tell me, or tell a friend who can tell me. I will not mention your name to the group." Said privately or in a message to each person, this makes it safe to answer.
Two more habits help. First, notice absence as information. When someone stops coming, the first thought should be "something may be in the way", not "they lost interest". Second, ask more than once. Circumstances change. A person who could join in spring may not be able to in winter.
4. Several doors into one gathering
The practical answer is not to make a second, lesser gathering for the people who cannot join. It is to open more than one door into the same one. A door is a way of taking part. Here is a set of doors, from the most connected to the least. A group does not need all of them. It needs enough of them that the people it actually has can come in.
| Door | What it gives | What it costs or risks |
|---|---|---|
| Live video | Faces, tone, the feeling of being together | Needs a device, a good connection and a quiet place |
| Voice only, by an ordinary telephone call | Hearing and speaking, with no screen and no new skill | The leader must keep track of who is speaking; no faces |
| A written summary after the meeting | Lets a person catch up or take part later | Must be written with care; must not expose what others shared in confidence |
| Captions, a written text of what was read, a shared document | Lets people who cannot hear well, or who read better than they listen, follow | Takes preparation; a person must be asked to do it |
| A printed pack, posted or handed over | Reaches people with no connection | Slower; someone must print and deliver |
| A visit, or a phone call from a named person | Keeps the relationship alive for those who cannot join at all | Takes time and people; needs the person's agreement |
| Quiet contact | A short message, a card, a prayer promised | Small, but often what a person remembers |
Notice what this table does not say. It does not say that video is the best door. For a person who is hard of hearing, a text may be better. For a person with no screen, a plain call may be better than anything else. The right door is the one this person can use.
5. The standard: nothing essential only in the room
This course asks for one rule that is easy to say and demanding to keep.
Nothing essential is said only in the online room.
If a decision is made, if a date is changed, if a prayer need is shared (with permission), if a lesson is given, then those who were not in the room must be able to learn of it by another door within a reasonable time. A group that ignores this slowly divides into two groups: those who know, and those who find out late or never.
This rule also protects the leader. A leader who carries the whole group in their head is a risk to the group, because everything depends on one person. When the leader is ill or travelling, the habit of writing things down is what keeps the group alive.
A careful word about summaries. A written summary of a gathering is a useful door, and it is also a risk. What a person shares in the group stays in the group (lecture 4-2). A summary should record the lesson, the questions raised, the decisions and the next date. It should not record who said what about their private life. When in doubt, leave it out, or ask.
6. People who must stay hidden
One group needs special care. Some people take part only if they are not seen, not named or not asked to explain.
A leader should keep a simple, firm habit: never press a person to turn on a camera or to say why they will not. Make it normal for cameras to be off. Allow people to join by a name that is not their full name where the group's safety rules allow it. Do not announce who is present. If a person says they can only join at certain hours, or only by voice, accept it without questions.
There is a reason for this restraint beyond courtesy. The person who asks "why won't you show your face?" may be speaking to someone for whom the honest answer is dangerous. The leader does not need to know. The leader needs only to make the door usable.
At the same time, the safety rules of lecture 4-1 still hold. If the group includes children or young people, hidden participation by an unknown adult is not acceptable. The group must always know that every adult present is known to a responsible person. The care here is for adults who have a good reason and who are known to someone trustworthy.
7. An invented case
(An invented example.) A small group of eleven meets weekly by video. The leader, Tomas, is pleased. Attendance is steady. Then, one evening, the group's oldest member, Mrs. Anders, sends a short message: "I miss you all." She had stopped joining two months ago. Tomas had assumed she was busy.
When he telephones her, he learns the real situation. She never had trouble with the meeting itself. Her tablet had stopped updating, and when she pressed the button to join, a message appeared that she did not understand. She was too embarrassed to ask. She had also stopped reading the messages because the print was small.
Tomas does three things. He agrees with her a standing weekly telephone call at the same hour as the group, with him holding the phone near the speaker for her. He asks a younger member to call her once beforehand each week. And he begins to send the written summary in large print by post to two members who have no screen. Nobody in the group has to do more than a small part. Mrs. Anders is back.
The case teaches three things. The absence was information. The fix was not a new tool but a new door. And the people who walked through it were a small chain of ordinary members, as in the story of the four friends in Mark who carried a man and, when the crowd blocked them, found another way in.
8. What this lecture does not ask
It does not ask a small group to give every possible door. It does not ask a leader to buy equipment. It does not claim that every person who stays away is being kept away by a barrier; some are simply busy, and some have chosen. It asks the leader to look, to ask, and to open the doors that cost little.
It also does not claim that the digital divide can be closed by good will. Some of the causes are poverty and distance, which a small group cannot fix. What a small group can do is make sure that, inside its own care, nobody is left behind only because the group chose a tool that suited itself.
Diagram 1. One gathering, many doors
핵심 요약
- A gathering has an invisible guest list: the people who can join. Those who cannot join leave no empty chair and are easy to miss.
- Reasons for not joining are many: device, connection, cost, age, disability, language, anxiety, time, safety and conscience.
- A leader asks privately and more than once, and treats an absence as information, not as a lack of interest.
- Open several doors into one gathering instead of building a smaller one for those who cannot join.
- Standard: nothing essential is said only in the online room. A summary must not expose what others shared in confidence.
- Never press a person to show a camera or to explain why they stay hidden.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The invisible guest list | The people who can join. Those who cannot leave no empty chair, so a leader must ask. |
| Reasons for not joining | Device, connection, cost, age, disability, language, anxiety, time, safety and conscience. |
| The standard | Nothing essential is said only in the online room. |
| The leader's habit with the hidden | Do not press for a camera or an explanation; make the door usable. |
One sentence to remember Open more than one door into the same gathering, and never treat the people who use the other doors as a smaller kind of member.
This week's action Write down, without names, three kinds of people your gathering might be missing, and one cheap door you could open for each.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a gathering you take part in or lead. Who would not be on its invisible guest list? Answer in kinds of people, not names.
- Which of the reasons listed in this lecture had you not thought of before?
- Why is "Is anyone having trouble getting online?" a weaker question than a private message to each person?
- A leader says, "Making all these doors is too much work for a group of eight." What would you say to her?
- The rule "nothing essential is said only in the online room" has a cost. What would a group give up, and what would it gain?
- How can a leader respect a person who stays hidden without ignoring the safety rules for children and young people?