Lecture 5-3: Screens, Comparison, Notifications: Practising Restraint
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Letters Across the Distance
- Lecture 1-2: What Online Can and Cannot Do
- Lecture 1-3: Depth and Limits of Online Relationships
- Lecture 1-4: Mapping My Online Places
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Online Place
- Lecture 2-1: Purpose, Size and Rhythm
- Lecture 2-2: Welcome and Hosting
- Lecture 2-3: Sharing the Word Online
- Lecture 2-4: Writing a First-Gathering Plan
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Gathering Plan
- Lecture 3-1: Honesty in What We Share
- Lecture 3-2: Video, Short Posts and Social Media: Uses and Limits
- Lecture 3-3: Comments, Quarrels and Criticism
- Lecture 3-4: Checking a Post Before I Send It
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Write and Check a Short Post
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Online
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Recording and Consent
- Lecture 4-3: Harassment, Harmful Content, Unsafe Contact
- Lecture 4-4: Our Safety Agreement
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Find the Gaps in a Safety Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: The Digital Divide and Access
- Lecture 5-2: Balance with Gathering in Person
- Lecture 5-3: Screens, Comparison, Notifications: Practising Restraint
- Lecture 5-4: Who Is Missing, and My Own Rest
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Find Who Is Missing; Plan My Rest
A person who builds up others online gives a lot of attention to other people's needs. That is good. It also creates a danger that is less often named: the tools through which we serve are built to keep our attention, and a person with a good reason to stay close to them can find it very hard to step away.
This lecture is about restraint. It is not a lecture against screens, and it does not claim to diagnose anyone. It makes a few general observations about what online life does to attention, comparison and rest. It looks at one temptation that is particular to people who lead or teach, which is the hunger for approval. And it offers practices of restraint that are simple, kind to the reader, and drawn from long Christian habits of rest and attention.
One caution must come first. Restraint is not a contest of denial. The aim is not to prove who can do without the most. The aim is to be present, to rest and to remain useful to others for a long time.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Describe, in general terms and without diagnosing anyone, how comparison, notifications and the sense of time affect people who spend long hours online.
- Name the temptation of a leader or teacher to seek approval from reactions, and explain how it differs from caring about people.
- Describe at least four practices of restraint and explain why each is meant to be adjusted to the person.
- Explain the principle of Sabbath rest (a regular time set apart for rest) and why traditions keep it differently.
- Say when a person should ask a pastor or a qualified professional for help, and who should move toward that person.
He said to them, “You come apart into a deserted place, and rest awhile.” For there were many coming and going, and they had no leisure so much as to eat." — Mark 6:31
World English Bible
It is vain for you to rise up early, to stay up late, eating the bread of toil; for he gives sleep to his loved ones." — Psalm 127:2
WEB
For am I now seeking the favor of men, or of God? Or am I striving to please men? For if I were still pleasing men, I wouldn’t be a servant of Christ." — Galatians 1:10
WEB
Jesus' invitation to rest is spoken to disciples who had been busy with serving. The psalm says that anxious toil is empty, and that rest is a gift. Paul's question to the Galatians concerns the person whom a servant of Christ is trying to please. All three are read here as principles. They do not say that anyone should leave work undone, nor that a certain number of hours is right.
1. What this lecture claims, and what it does not
It claims that the tools we use to serve others are not neutral about our attention, and that a person who serves through them needs to choose how and when to use them. It does not claim that screens are evil, that every heavy user has a problem, or that there is a measured amount of use that is right for everyone. A nurse, a farmer and a student will all have different days.
It also does not diagnose. Some people find they cannot put a device down, feel anxious without it or feel worse after using it. Whether this is a habit, a sorrow, a pressure of work or something that needs professional care is not for a lecture, or a friend, to say. What a lecture can do is describe what many people notice and suggest ways to be gentle with themselves.
2. Three things many people notice
Comparison. Online, other people's lives arrive as selected moments: the best photograph, the news of the success, the happiest week. A person who looks at these all day can slowly feel that their own ordinary life is smaller, slower or less blessed than it should be. A leader may see other groups growing, other teachers praised, other people's gatherings full, and quietly feel they are failing. The comparison is not fair: it sets a whole life against someone else's highlight. Many people know this and still feel it. Knowing does not switch it off. What helps is looking less often, and remembering that you are called to the people in front of you and not to the picture of someone else's work.
Notifications. A signal that arrives at any moment trains a person to be interrupted. After a time, even in silence, the person may feel a small pull to check. The tools are built so that each signal feels as if it is asking for something right now. Most of what they ask for can wait until the evening, and the few things that cannot wait are usually things a person would have been told about by phone.
The sense of time. Hours online do not feel like hours. A person may sit down for ten minutes and find that an evening has gone. Afterwards the feeling is often not rest but a kind of blur. This is not a sign of weakness. It is what happens when a stream has no natural end. A book has a last page; a conversation across a table has a goodbye. A feed has neither.
None of these three is a sin. Together they make it easy to live a day that was not chosen. The practices below are ways of choosing it back.
3. The leader's particular temptation: the hunger for approval
A person who shares teaching, prayer or encouragement online will be answered by reactions. A few people say thank you. Some mark that they like it. Some do not respond at all. Some, now and then, object.
There is nothing wrong with being glad when something helps someone. The danger lies elsewhere: a person may begin to measure the day's work by the reactions, and then to shape the work to win them. A teacher chooses the safer sentence. A leader avoids a hard truth. A person returns again and again, in the hour before sleep, to see who has responded. The call to serve people quietly changes into a need to be liked by them.
Paul's question in Galatians 1:10, whether he seeks the favour of people or of God, is not a rebuke to a poor man. It was written by a man who knew that serving is easily mixed with wanting to be seen to serve. Jesus says the same about giving and praying in Matthew 6. These passages do not forbid gladness at encouragement. They ask one honest question: For whom am I doing this?
Here are three signs, offered not as a test but as things to notice in yourself.
- You feel flat or irritated when there is no response, out of proportion to what happened.
- You change what you would say to what is likely to be liked.
- You check for responses when you are with people who are in front of you and need you.
If you notice one, you have not failed. You have noticed. The usual remedy is small: look less often, tell a trusted person, and serve one person who will never know.
4. Practices of restraint
Here are some practices that many people have found useful. None is a rule. A reader should take what fits and leave the rest.
Set hours. Choose the times when you will be available to the group, and say what they are. A reply within a day is generous for most people. Tell the group so that nobody takes silence for rejection.
Turn off most notifications. Keep the ones that matter (a call from a family member, a message from the person you are caring for). Turn off the rest. Check the others at the times you chose.
Give the device a place. Many people find it helps to keep the device out of the bedroom, or at least out of reach during meals and at night. This is a practical matter and not a moral one.
Have an ending. Decide in advance how long a session will last, and use a timer if that helps. Closing the day with something that has a natural end, such as a book, a walk, a meal or a prayer, can help the mind come back.
Fast from a thing for a time. A fast is a chosen period of going without something. Some Christians keep a regular period without a particular tool or without the whole group of tools. For some it is a day, for some it is a morning. It is held lightly, as a gift to oneself and not a feat.
Be fully where you are. When a child, a friend or a visitor is in front of you, they come first. The best thing a leader of an online group can show the group is a person who is plainly present to the people near them.
Two cautions go with these practices. First, they are to be adjusted to your life. A parent with a sick child, a person who cares for others through the night, or a person whose work needs a device all day cannot keep the same rules as a retired person. The question is not "what is the perfect rule?" but "what is a kind and honest pattern for me?" Second, do not shame yourself or others for failing. If you leave the phone on one night, nothing is lost. If a friend cannot manage the rule you find easy, nothing is wrong with them. Restraint is a way of looking after yourself so that you can look after others. It is not a contest.
5. Rest, and Sabbath as a principle
The Bible does not leave rest to chance. In the Ten Commandments, the people are told to remember the Sabbath day and keep it holy (Exodus 20:8), and to leave off work on the seventh day, so that the people, their household and even their animals may rest (Exodus 20:10). Jesus, who was busy beyond most people's imagining, went away to a quiet place and told his disciples to do the same.
Traditions keep rest differently
This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians differ about how the Sabbath commandment applies today. Some keep Sunday as a day of rest and worship, and see it as the fulfilment of the Sabbath in the resurrection. Some keep the seventh day, Saturday. Some hold that the commandment is fulfilled in Christ and that no day is specially required, while still holding that rest is a gift to be kept. Orthodox and Catholic traditions keep the Lord's Day with worship and rest, and the Church's calendar also gives fasts and feasts that shape the weeks. This course does not settle the question.
What it requires is smaller: that rest is received as a gift and not an enemy, that a leader of others cannot give what they do not themselves have, and that nobody should be made to feel guilty for resting.
If you wish to read more on rest, the Jewish teacher Abraham Joshua Heschel wrote a short and well-known book on the Sabbath, The Sabbath, in which he calls it a "palace in time". The idea there is that rest is not an interruption of life but a place in it. You need not agree with all of it to learn from it.
6. Family and the people who are present
An online ministry can quietly take attention from the nearest people. A husband or wife, a child, a parent or a housemate may be in the next room, hearing the leader be warm to strangers and distracted at home. This is a common and sad pattern, and it is not limited to people in ministry.
A simple test helps. Ask: If the people nearest to me were asked how much of my attention they get, what would they say? If the answer is painful, it does not mean that the ministry should be dropped. It means that it must be shaped so that the nearest people are not paying for it.
Often a conversation is enough. Tell the household when you will be on a call, and when you will be off. Ask them what they need. Offer them the same warmth you would give a stranger.
7. When to ask for help
Sometimes the tools are not the main thing. A person may find that, whatever they try, they cannot rest, or that they feel low most of the time, or that their use of the screen has come between them and the people they love, or that they cannot stop even though they want to. This may have many causes, and a lecture cannot name them.
What a lecture can say is this: it is right to ask for help, and it is not a failure. The person to ask first may be a pastor, a priest or a trusted friend in the community. If the difficulty seems to be more than a habit, a qualified professional may help, such as a doctor or a counsellor. If someone speaks of harming themselves, or if you are worried for their safety, this is not a matter for a group chat or a video meeting. Move toward a person: a pastor, a qualified professional or the local emergency number if there is danger now. This lecture is not medical advice and does not replace care. Heavy screen use, loneliness, depression, addiction and crisis are studied more fully in PT720E, PT721E and PT725E.
And if you are the person who notices a friend withdrawing, do not wait to be asked. A short, private message such as "I have been thinking of you. May I call?" is often the beginning of help.
8. Two modern voices
Two modern writers are useful here, not because they agree with this lecture in every way but because they have thought carefully about the subject. Sherry Turkle, a researcher of technology and human relations, has argued that constant connection can thin out our ability to be fully present to the person in front of us. Cal Newport, a computer scientist, has argued for a deliberate and selective use of tools, in which a person decides what is worth their attention instead of letting the tools decide. Neither was writing as a Christian pastor. Readers should weigh them as they would any thoughtful writer.
Diagram 1. Three pulls, three practices
핵심 요약
- Screens used for service still shape attention. Many people notice comparison, an urge to check notifications and a loss of the sense of time.
- This lecture does not diagnose anyone and does not claim a right number of hours.
- A leader or teacher may come to measure the day by reactions. The honest question is: for whom am I doing this?
- Practices of restraint include set hours, fewer notifications, a place for the device, a chosen ending and a fast held lightly.
- Rest is a gift. Traditions keep it differently; the common point is that no one should be shamed for resting.
- Restraint is not a contest. Ask for help from a pastor or a professional, and move toward a person when someone is in danger.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three common pulls | Comparison, notifications, and a lost sense of time. |
| The leader's question | For whom am I doing this? |
| Practices of restraint | Set hours, fewer notifications, a place for the device, a chosen ending, a light fast, being present. |
| When to ask for help | When rest will not come or use harms relationships; a pastor first, a professional if needed. Danger goes to a person. |
One sentence to remember Restraint is not a contest of denial; it is how a servant of others stays rested, present and useful.
This week's action Choose one practice from the list and try it for one week, adjusting it to your life, and tell one trusted person what you chose.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the three pulls (comparison, notifications, the sense of time) do you notice most? Answer for yourself and not for others.
- How would you tell the difference between being glad that something helped and needing it to be liked?
- Why does the lecture say that restraint must be adjusted to a person's life?
- How would you respond to someone who says, "I deleted everything for a month, so I am more spiritual than you"?
- What does your household or your nearest person receive from your attention at the end of the day?
- How might a group help a leader rest without making the leader feel replaced?