Lecture 7-5: Where Faithful Preachers Disagree, and What to Do About It
목차 54
- Lecture 1-1: Four Definitions of Expository Preaching, Compared
- Lecture 1-2: A Genealogy — Gaps and Recoveries, Not One Unbroken Line
- Lecture 1-3: Expository, Topical, and Textual Preaching — Honest Boundaries
- Lecture 1-4: This Course's Own Method — A Map, Not a New Topic
- Lecture 2-1: Inerrancy and Pulpit Authority
- Lecture 2-2: The Sufficiency of Scripture
- Lecture 2-3: Perspicuity — the Clarity of Scripture
- Lecture 2-4: Inspiration and Dual Authorship
- Lecture 3-1: Illumination — How the Spirit Opens a Fixed Text
- Lecture 3-2: The False Dichotomy of Spirit and Preparation
- Lecture 3-3: The Congregation as an Interpreting Community
- Lecture 3-4: The Preacher's Praying Life as Preparation
- Lecture 4-1: Criteria for Setting a Preaching Unit's Boundaries
- Lecture 4-2: The History of Chapter and Verse Divisions
- Lecture 4-3: Basic Textual Criticism for the Pulpit
- Lecture 4-4: Deciding How Long a Preaching Unit Should Be
- Lecture 4-5: Placing the Text in Redemptive History
- Lecture 5-1: Repetition, Inclusio, and Chiasm as Structural Signals
- Lecture 5-2: Metaphor and Extended Image as Theological Argument
- Lecture 5-3: Irony, Hyperbole, and Deliberate Omission
- Lecture 5-4: Letting a Text's Form Shape a Sermon's Form
- Lecture 6-1: Biblical Theology and Systematic Theology — Two Disciplines, One Text
- Lecture 6-2: Theme-Tracing as a Method — The Temple from Eden to the New Jerusalem
- Lecture 6-3: Finding a Text's Own Theological Center
- Lecture 6-4: The Analogy of Faith — Legitimate Use and Real Danger
- Lecture 7-1: Geerhardus Vos and the Redemptive-Historical Shape of Revelation
- Lecture 7-2: Edmund Clowney and Principles for Preaching Christ from the Old Testament
- Lecture 7-3: Sidney Greidanus and the Seven Ways to Christ
- Lecture 7-4: The Exemplary Tradition, Its Critics, and the Dutch Controversy
- Lecture 7-5: Where Faithful Preachers Disagree, and What to Do About It
- Lecture 8-1: Preaching Hebrew Narrative — A Worked Case from Judges 4
- Lecture 8-2: Preaching Law and Covenant — A Worked Case from Deuteronomy
- Lecture 8-3: Preaching Psalms and Wisdom — A Worked Case from Psalm 137 and Proverbs
- Lecture 8-4: Preaching Prophecy and Apocalyptic — A Worked Case from Amos
- Lecture 8-5: Preaching Gospel Narrative and Parable — A Worked Case from Luke 15
- Lecture 9-1: Why a Text's Own Purpose Already Calls for a Response
- Lecture 9-2: From Original Intent to a Contemporary Situation, Faithfully
- Lecture 9-3: A Working Set of Application Categories
- Lecture 9-4: Idols of the Heart, and the Limits of Christian Freedom
- Lecture 9-5: Three Ways Application Fails — Moralism, Vagueness, and Guilt-Manipulation
- Lecture 10-1: What a Secular Age Actually Names
- Lecture 10-2: Contextualization — Its Principle and Its Real Limits
- Lecture 10-3: Reading the Actual Congregation in Front of You
- Lecture 10-4: Naming a Culture's Governing Story and Offering a Better Account
- Lecture 11-1: Continuous Exposition and the Lectionary's Own Discipline
- Lecture 11-2: Designing a Whole-Book Series — Pacing, Breaks, and Holding Attention
- Lecture 11-3: Annual Sermon Planning — Balance Across a Preaching Year
- Lecture 11-4: Preaching at Festivals, Sacraments or Ordinances, Weddings, and Funerals
- Lecture 12-1: The Preacher's Body — An Incarnational Theology of Delivery
- Lecture 12-2: Voice, Platform, and the Manuscript Question
- Lecture 12-3: Feedback, Evaluation, and Iron Sharpening Iron
- Lecture 12-4: Borrowed Words — The Ethics of Sermon Preparation
- Lecture 12-5: Finishing Well — Burnout, Sustainability, and a Capstone Statement
Every lecture in this chapter has been building toward this one. Vos stated the claim, Clowney gave it a discipline, Greidanus named its routes and its tests, and the last lecture stated the older exemplary tradition fairly, along with substantive objections raised against the redemptive-historical tradition from within careful, orthodox preaching itself. This closing lecture does not resolve the disagreement. It states it plainly, names who holds which position and why, and gives you something more useful than a verdict: a way to preach responsibly while the disagreement stands.
이 15분으로 얻는 것
- State plainly, without resolving it, where confessionally Reformed preaching and a range of other faithful traditions diverge on this question, and why.
- Explain how a lectionary structure changes what a single sermon needs to accomplish on its own.
- Identify what is genuinely at stake in the disagreement (what each side is protecting) rather than treating it as a matter of preference.
- State a working, personally examined position on this question that you can defend, including honestly naming what your own position risks getting wrong.
and was there until the death of Herod; that it might be fulfilled which was spoken by the Lord through the prophet, saying, "Out of Egypt I called my son.
Matthew 2:15 (World English Bible)
1. This is a point where readers will not agree
Reformed and confessionally Reformed preachers — standing in the tradition this chapter has traced through Vos, Clowney, and Greidanus, and the church-historical side of the Dutch controversy examined in the last lecture — tend strongly toward treating redemptive-historical, Christ-centered preaching as normative: not merely one legitimate option among several, but the standard a sound sermon on any biblical text, Old or New Testament, should meet. Many seminaries and denominations within this stream train preachers explicitly against exemplary preaching as a default mode, precisely because of the moralism risk lecture 7-4 stated.
Other evangelical preachers, Pentecostal and charismatic traditions, and a great many Catholic and Orthodox preachers — a substantial share of this course's own readership — preach Old Testament figures and events more directly, as this chapter's last lecture described, without treating every single sermon as incomplete unless it reaches an explicit Christological turn. This is often not a rejection of Christ-centered faith or of the New Testament's own claim that the Old Testament points to Christ; it frequently reflects, instead, a different structure of preaching altogether — many of these traditions preach within a lectionary, a fixed cycle of assigned readings tied to the church's liturgical calendar, in which the Christ-connection is already supplied by the as a whole (the church year's movement through Advent, Christmas, Lent, Easter, and Pentecost; the pairing of an Old Testament reading with a Gospel reading and an epistle in the same service; the creed recited, the eucharist celebrated, in the same liturgical act) rather than needing to be supplied, freshly, inside each individual sermon considered as a stand-alone unit.
This is not a minor procedural difference. A preacher working from a lectionary is not preaching one isolated text into a vacuum; the text arrives already embedded in a service whose other elements are doing theological work a free-preaching tradition expects the sermon alone to do. Judging a lectionary sermon by the standard "did this sermon, by itself, reach Christ" can therefore misjudge what that sermon was ever attempting, or needed, to do.
This course does not resolve which approach is correct, and readers should not expect it to. Both positions are held by careful, orthodox, textually serious preachers who have thought hard about what preaching Scripture faithfully requires. A student trained in this course may go on to serve in either kind of setting, or something between them, and should be equipped to preach responsibly in either — which is this lecture's actual task.
2. What each side is protecting, stated without a verdict
It clarifies the disagreement to ask, of each side, not "who is right" but "what is each position trying to protect, and is that concern legitimate on its own terms." The redemptive-historical tradition is protecting the New Testament's own repeated insistence that it, itself, reads the Old Testament as pointing to Christ — this chapter's own texts have shown Jesus doing this in Luke 24:27, in John 3:14-15, and Matthew's Gospel doing it explicitly in Matthew 2:15, this lecture's own text, where Hosea 11:1's original statement about Israel's exodus from Egypt is read by Matthew as also, at a further and fuller level, fulfilled in the infant Jesus's own return from Egypt. A tradition that never lets an individual sermon make that same kind of move risks losing a form of reading Scripture the New Testament itself repeatedly performs.
The exemplary and lectionary-preaching traditions are protecting something equally real: that Scripture also, undeniably, commends direct moral and spiritual imitation of its figures (Hebrews 11 again), that a rule requiring every single sermon to reach an explicit Christological turn can become formulaic and can force connections a text does not actually support (lecture 7-4's own critique), and that a sermon's task within a liturgical service is not identical to its task when it is the only Christ-centered element the congregation will encounter that week. Neither concern is illegitimate. They are, in a genuine sense, both correct about what they are protecting, and the disagreement is over how to weigh those two legitimate concerns against each other when they pull toward different homiletical practices — which is exactly the kind of disagreement that does not resolve by one side simply being shown to be mistaken.
3. Matthew 2:15 as a case that tests both positions honestly
This lecture's text is a genuinely hard case for a course trying to be fair to both sides, and stating that plainly is more useful than smoothing it over. Hosea 11:1, the text Matthew quotes, reads in its own original context as a backward-looking statement about God's past deliverance of the nation Israel from Egyptian slavery in the exodus — "when Israel was a child, then I loved him, and called my son out of Egypt" — not, on the surface, a forward-looking prediction about a future individual. Matthew's application of this verse to the infant Jesus's flight into and return from Egypt is a striking, and to some readers surprising, extension of the text's original sense.
A redemptive-historical preacher points to exactly this text as strong support for the whole method this chapter has traced: this is not a preacher-invented , discovered by resemblance; it is the New Testament's own inspired author making the connection explicitly, which settles, at least for this passage, that Israel's story and Jesus's story belong to a single redemptive-historical pattern in which Jesus recapitulates and fulfills what Israel as a nation was called, and failed, to be. A critic of unrestrained , meanwhile, can point to the same text as a caution: Matthew's move here is more theologically bold and less textually obvious than the bronze serpent's typology from lecture 7-3, and a preacher without Matthew's own apostolic authority who tried to make an equally bold move on a different, less clearly warranted text would be taking real interpretive risk. Both observations are true at once, and this course states both rather than choosing between them.
4. A working position, held responsibly
You are not required to leave this chapter without any position — only without this course telling you what it must be. A working position, stated honestly, includes naming its own risk. If you preach toward the redemptive-historical tradition's normative claim, your risk, named plainly by lecture 7-4, is forcing a connection Greidanus's own criteria would not actually support, and producing a predictable sermon shape a congregation learns to anticipate rather than hear afresh. If you preach in the exemplary or lectionary tradition, your risk is the moralism this chapter's own redemptive-historical critique named: a sermon whose central claim could be given by any moral teacher of any religion, contributing nothing that specifically required the Christian gospel to be true.
A responsible preacher in either tradition can reduce, though not eliminate, their own tradition's characteristic risk. A redemptive-historical preacher can apply Greidanus's own test criteria honestly, including to a text where the honest answer is that no clean warranted route to Christ exists, and can preach with variety of route (Greidanus named seven) rather than one repeated formula. An exemplary preacher can name explicitly, even briefly, what makes a call to imitate David's courage a Christian exhortation rather than a generic one — grace that precedes and enables the imitation asked for, or an acknowledgment that the same David whose courage is commended also, later, badly failed, which the New Testament's own larger story addresses rather than leaves as bare moral instruction. Neither discipline requires abandoning the tradition you preach within; each requires practicing it self-critically, aware of its own besetting risk.
핵심 요약
- The lecture does not resolve the disagreement. Reformed preachers in the tradition of Vos, Clowney and Greidanus tend to treat Christ-centered preaching as the norm for every text.
- Other evangelical, Pentecostal and charismatic preachers, and many Catholic and Orthodox preachers, preach Old Testament figures more directly. Many use a lectionary, where the liturgy as a whole supplies the Christ-connection.
- Each side protects something real. One protects the New Testament's own reading of the Old Testament as pointing to Christ. The other protects imitation of Scripture's figures and guards against formulaic or forced connections.
- Matthew 2:15 tests both. Matthew reads Hosea 11:1 as fulfilled in Jesus, which supports the method. But its boldness is a caution for a preacher without Matthew's apostolic authority.
- A responsible preacher holds a position and names its risk. The risk is a forced connection on one side, and moralism on the other.
Topic: Where faithful preachers disagree about Christ-centered preaching from the Old Testament, and how to preach responsibly while the disagreement stands.
Remember: Both positions are held by careful, orthodox preachers. A lectionary changes what a single sermon must accomplish on its own.
Caution: The course states plainly that it does not say which approach is correct. Judging a lectionary sermon by "did it reach Christ by itself" may misjudge its task.
One line to carry into ministry: Practice your own tradition self-critically. Apply real tests to any claimed link to Christ, or name what makes a call to imitation Christian.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- State, in one paragraph, why this course refuses to declare one side of this debate correct. Do you find that refusal appropriate for a seminary course, or evasive? Defend your answer.
- Explain how preaching within a lectionary changes what a single sermon needs to accomplish, compared to a tradition of free, sermon-by-sermon topic and text selection.
- In Matthew 2:15, Hosea's original statement about Israel's own exodus is applied by Matthew to the infant Jesus. State one way this supports the redemptive-historical tradition's method, and one way it should make a redemptive-historical preacher cautious about applying the same kind of move elsewhere.
- State your own current working position on this chapter's debate, and name honestly the specific risk your own position carries, as this lecture described for both sides. What practice could you adopt to guard against that risk in your own preaching?