Lecture 3-2: Constitutions, By-laws and Resolutions
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why a Church Needs Order
- Lecture 1-2: Offices and Meetings in the New Testament
- Lecture 1-3: Authority as Service, and Its Misuse
- Lecture 1-4: Checks and Balances in a Fallen World
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, A Decision Map of Your Church
- Lecture 2-1: Oversight From Above: Episcopal Structures
- Lecture 2-2: Governing Together: Presbyterian and Connexional Structures
- Lecture 2-3: Self-Governing Congregations: Congregational and Independent Structures
- Lecture 2-4: Comparing Structures: Strengths, Weaknesses and Common Minimums
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Three Churches
- Lecture 3-1: Principles of Meetings
- Lecture 3-2: Constitutions, By-laws and Resolutions
- Lecture 3-3: Elections, Terms and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 3-4: Records and Minutes
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Mock Meeting
- Lecture 4-1: Church and State: Two Spheres
- Lecture 4-2: Legal Status, Property and Contracts
- Lecture 4-3: People Who Work and People Who Serve
- Lecture 4-4: Insurance, Records and Knowing When to Ask
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check-Locally List
- Lecture 5-1: Protecting Children and Vulnerable People
- Lecture 5-2: Personal Data, Photographs and Confidentiality
- Lecture 5-3: Openness, Conflicts of Interest and Raising Concerns
- Lecture 5-4: Responding When a Concern Is Raised
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Safeguarding and Openness Check
Every church has rules. Some are written and some are only remembered. Some were made last year and some were made by people who died long ago. Some say what the church does, and some say what it once hoped to do. Most churches, when a hard question comes, discover that nobody is sure which rule applies, or whether the rule they remember is the rule that was actually made.
This lecture is about the documents of a church and the order among them. It does not teach what your documents must say. Those matters differ between traditions, and in many places the law has a say too. It teaches how to find, rank and use the documents your church has, what to do when you have none or an old one, and how to change them fairly.
As in the other lectures, this is not legal advice. It explains general principles. Whether a church must have a certain kind of document, how it must be adopted and whether it must be filed with an official body differ by country, region and year. Where a point may be one of those, the lecture says "check locally". A real case needs the church's own documents and a qualified person. The manuals that tell a church office how to run day to day belong to the church administration course, and the lecture will not enter them.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Describe the ladder of documents that most churches have, from Scripture and confession down to a single resolution.
- Explain what to do when a church has no written document, an old one, or one that differs from its practice.
- Distinguish a constitution (or articles), a by-law (or rule) and a resolution, and say what each is for.
- Describe a fair way to amend a document, and why the way a rule is changed matters as much as the change.
- Say where in your own church the higher and the lower documents are kept and who has the right to see them.
Let all things be done decently and in order." — 1 Corinthians 14:40
World English Bible
I left you in Crete for this reason, that you would set in order the things that were lacking, and appoint elders in every city, as I directed you;" — Titus 1:5
WEB
For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us, to lay no greater burden on you than these necessary things:" — Acts 15:28
WEB
it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus;" — Luke 1:3
WEB
Titus is told to set in order what was lacking. Luke tells us that he traced things accurately and wrote them in order. The Jerusalem letter shows a decision stated plainly, with the burden it places and the burden it does not. None of these is a rule about how to write a constitution. Together they say that the early church valued putting things in order, and writing them clearly, so that those who had not been in the room could know what had been decided.
1. Why a church has documents at all
Some Christians feel uneasy about written rules. They say that the Spirit leads the church, that love needs no paragraph, and that a church with a constitution has put trust in paper. The unease is not foolish. Rules can harden. A church can quote its by-laws and lose its mercy. A document can be used as a weapon by whoever knows it best.
But the unease has its own answer in the central claim of this course. Documents are not there to hold power. They are there to protect people who are not in the room: the new member, the member who is away, the one who will come ten years later, and the one who is afraid to ask. A rule that is written can be read by anyone. A rule that is only in the head of the oldest member can be changed, without anyone voting, to suit the oldest member.
So there are three honest reasons for writing things down. A written rule is known, so people may rely on it. It is the same for everyone, so it limits the favourite and the founder. And it is lasting, so that a church survives the departure of its leaders. These are the reasons the apostles' letters were written, rather than only told.
2. The ladder of documents
Most churches, in any tradition, can be understood as having a ladder of authority among their documents. The rungs differ in name. The order is the point: what is higher binds what is lower, and a lower document that contradicts a higher one is, in the church's own eyes, to be repaired.
1. Scripture and the confession or creed. At the top, for every Christian church, is Scripture. Many churches also hold a creed or a confession of faith that states how they read it. Some traditions hold the creeds of the early church; some hold later confessions; some hold none and say "Scripture alone". These differ, and this lecture does not decide among them. What matters for our purpose is that the church knows what its highest standard is and has said it in words.
2. The rules of a wider body, where there is one. A church that belongs to a diocese, a presbytery, a conference, a convention or an association is usually bound by that body's rules in some matters. These may be a book of order, a code of canons, a discipline or a simple statement of agreement. A local church that has joined such a body should know which of its decisions are its own and which belong, under the wider rules, to someone else. A church that belongs to no wider body has no such rung, and that is a fact to be named, not a lack to be hidden.
3. The church's constitution, articles or charter. This is the founding document of the particular church. It usually says the church's name and purpose, who its members are, who governs it and by what process, how property is held and how the document itself may be changed. In some places a church of a certain kind is required by law to have such a document, or finds it needed to hold property or open a bank account. Check locally. Where a legal body exists, the document may need to be in a certain form. A qualified person should look at that form; this course cannot.
4. By-laws, rules or regulations. These are the more detailed rules of procedure that sit beneath the constitution: how a members' meeting is called, how many make a quorum, how an is held, how committees are formed, who signs for money. They are easier to change than the constitution, and they must not contradict it.
5. Resolutions and minutes. A resolution is a decision of a particular meeting on a particular matter: to buy a piece of equipment, to open a second service, to appoint a committee. It is not a rule for ever. It is a record that on a certain day the proper body decided a certain thing, and it must fit within the documents above it.
A short way to remember the order is by who can change what. A resolution may be passed by a meeting. A by-law may be changed by the body the constitution names. A constitution may be changed only in the way the constitution itself provides, which is usually harder. Scripture is not changed by any vote, and a confession is changed, where a tradition allows it at all, only by that tradition's own process.
(An invented example.) The Grace Harbour church has a constitution that says the members elect five trustees. A resolution passed in the trustees' meeting in a hurried year says the pastor "will name two more." No one noticed that a resolution cannot change what the constitution says. When a member years later asks why the pastor names two of the seven, the church discovers that the practice has no basis in its constitution, and that the practice has been, for a decade, the real constitution. The right step is neither to conceal this nor to condemn anyone. It is to bring the practice and the document together in the open, by the process the constitution itself provides.
3. When you have no document
Many small churches, new churches and churches in places where there is little paper have no written constitution. They have a pastor, a few leaders and a custom. This is not a scandal. It is a condition that should be repaired, for the reasons already given.
A church in this position can begin simply. The leaders and, where possible, the members meet and write down, in plain words and not more than a page or two, the following matters:
- the name and purpose of the church;
- who may be a member and how someone ceases to be one;
- who makes decisions, who chooses leaders, and for how long;
- who handles money, and who checks it;
- how a concern may be raised, and to whom;
- how this page may be changed.
Then read it aloud to the members, let them ask questions, and keep it where anyone may see it. If the church is part of a wider body, tell the wider body and ask whether its own rules affect what you have written. If the church needs to hold property or enter contracts, check locally about what form the law expects, and ask a qualified person to read the page before you adopt it.
A short, honest page that people keep is worth more than a long document that nobody reads.
4. When your document is old
Some churches have the opposite problem: a document that was written long ago for another situation. It may name offices that no longer exist. It may require a meeting at an hour or in a form that nobody keeps. It may use words in a sense nobody uses now. It may assume a church of forty families in one village, and now there are three hundred members in four places.
The right step is not to ignore it, and not to quietly do what seems sensible. The document is the church's agreement with itself. If it is out of date, it should be amended by the process it names. In the meantime the church should write down, in a short note kept with the document, which parts the church knows no longer fit and what it is actually doing. Honesty about the gap is the first repair.
5. When your practice differs from your document
This is the most common situation of all. The constitution says the members elect the leaders; for twenty years the leaders have chosen their own successors. The by-laws say the accounts are reviewed each year; they have not been reviewed in six. The rules say two signatures; one person signs.
This is not always bad faith. Practice often drifts for good reasons, for example because the church was small, the founder was trusted, and the rule seemed a formality. But a gap between the paper and the practice is dangerous in two ways. It lets whoever benefits from the drift say "that is how we have always done it", and it leaves the church open to a sudden challenge from a member, a wider body, or an outside person who reads the document.
There are only two honest ways to close the gap. Either the church returns to the document, or the church changes the document by its proper process to match what it has found to be wise. What it must not do is leave the gap open and hope. Whichever way is taken, it is recorded.
6. What a constitution, a by-law and a resolution are for
Because the three words are often mixed, a short summary may help.
| Constitution or articles | By-law or rule | Resolution | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | The founding agreement of the church | The detailed rules of procedure under it | A decision on one matter at one time |
| Lasts | Until changed by the hard process | Until changed by the named body | Until it is carried out or replaced |
| Easy to change? | No, by design | Moderately | Yes |
| Typical contents | Name, purpose, members, who governs, how property is held, how to amend | Meetings, notice, quorum, elections, committees, signatures | Buy, sell, appoint, approve, thank |
| Who sees it? | Every member should | Every member should | Recorded in the minutes |
The names differ among traditions. Some churches call their founding document a charter, a book of order, a discipline or a , and their detailed rules canons, standing orders or regulations. Do not be misled by names. Ask what each document does, which is higher, and who may change it.
7. Amending a document fairly
The way a rule is changed protects everyone more than the rule does. If a constitution can be changed by a few people in an evening, it is not much of a constitution. If it can never be changed, it will be broken.
A fair process for changing a founding document usually has these marks, whatever the structure:
- A proposal in writing, with the exact words to be added, removed or replaced.
- Notice long enough before the meeting that the proper members can read it and, if they wish, send a view. Many churches give a longer notice for a change to the constitution than for ordinary business.
- A higher bar than an ordinary vote, for example a larger fraction, or a second meeting, or the approval of a wider body where one has authority over the matter.
- A record of the exact wording adopted, the date, the vote and who was present.
- A clean copy of the new document, dated, placed where members can see it, and the old one kept.
Some of these steps may be set by the law of your place. Others by your wider body's rules. Others by your own constitution. Check your own rules first, and then check locally if the document concerns property, a legal body or money held for others.
(An invented example.) A church wishes to lengthen the term of its trustees from two years to four. A member says it should not be done at a single evening meeting. The church's constitution says a change needs notice of thirty days and two-thirds of the members present. The church follows that. The change passes. A month later, a member who was away asks what was decided. The notice, the proposed words and the minutes are all in the same folder. The point is not that the change was right. The point is that the process was open, and the member can see what happened and, if she disagrees, can bring it to the next meeting by the proper route.
8. The same ladder in different shapes
In an episcopal church (invented diocese of Santa Verena), the parish's own rules may be few, because much is set by the diocese's canons and the bishop's directions. The ladder has a long upper part. The local task is to know which matters belong to the parish council and which to the diocese, and to keep a short local rule-book for the rest.
In a presbyterian or connexional church (invented Marlow Presbytery), a book of order sits above the local church's constitution and by-laws. A local church's rules may not contradict it. The local task is to know which part of the book of order is binding and which is guidance, and to bring any changes of its own to the regional body when required.
In a congregational or independent church (invented Hollis Road church), the church's own constitution is at the top of the written ladder, under Scripture and its statement of faith. There is no wider body that checks it. That is exactly why such a church should keep its document simple, clear, and read by its members. Without an outside body, the members are the check.
In a very small church with nothing written, the ladder is a page. That page is enough to begin.
In every case, the question that the reader must carry away is the same: where is the document, what does it say, who may see it, and does the church do what it says?
Diagram 1. The ladder of documents
핵심 요약
- Documents protect people who are not in the room: they are known, the same for everyone and lasting. They are not a way to hold power.
- The ladder runs from Scripture and confession, through the rules of any wider body, to the constitution, then by-laws, then resolutions. What is higher binds what is lower.
- A constitution is the founding agreement, a by-law the detailed rules under it, a resolution one decision at one time.
- With no document, begin with a page of plain words. With an old one, amend it by its own process. With a gap between paper and practice, return to the paper or change the paper, openly.
- A fair amendment has a written proposal, long notice, a higher bar than ordinary business, a record, and a clean dated copy.
- Whether a church must have certain documents, in what form, and where they must be filed differs by place. Check locally, and ask a qualified person.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The ladder | Scripture and confession; wider body's rules; constitution; by-laws; resolutions. Higher binds lower. |
| No document | Write a page: name and purpose, members, who decides, money, how to raise a concern, how to amend. Read it to the members. |
| Paper and practice differ | Return to the paper, or change the paper by its process. Do not leave the gap open. |
| Fair amendment | Written proposal, long notice, higher bar, record, clean dated copy. |
One sentence to remember A written rule is for the person who is not in the room.
This week's action Write the ladder of documents for your church on a page, mark where each one is kept, and mark any rung that is missing or out of date.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- List the documents your church has, from the highest to the lowest. Which rung is missing, and who would know where it is kept?
- Why does this course say a written rule protects the people who are not in the room? Give an example from a church you know, without naming anyone.
- A resolution passed years ago seems to contradict the constitution. What are the two honest ways of closing the gap, and why is leaving it open the worst choice?
- Why is the way a document is amended as important as what is changed? What marks make an amendment fair?
- A leader says: "We have no constitution; we are led by the Spirit." What would you say that honours both the leader's faith and the members' need to know the rules?