Lecture 3-3: Elections, Terms and Conflicts of Interest
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why a Church Needs Order
- Lecture 1-2: Offices and Meetings in the New Testament
- Lecture 1-3: Authority as Service, and Its Misuse
- Lecture 1-4: Checks and Balances in a Fallen World
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, A Decision Map of Your Church
- Lecture 2-1: Oversight From Above: Episcopal Structures
- Lecture 2-2: Governing Together: Presbyterian and Connexional Structures
- Lecture 2-3: Self-Governing Congregations: Congregational and Independent Structures
- Lecture 2-4: Comparing Structures: Strengths, Weaknesses and Common Minimums
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Three Churches
- Lecture 3-1: Principles of Meetings
- Lecture 3-2: Constitutions, By-laws and Resolutions
- Lecture 3-3: Elections, Terms and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 3-4: Records and Minutes
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Mock Meeting
- Lecture 4-1: Church and State: Two Spheres
- Lecture 4-2: Legal Status, Property and Contracts
- Lecture 4-3: People Who Work and People Who Serve
- Lecture 4-4: Insurance, Records and Knowing When to Ask
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check-Locally List
- Lecture 5-1: Protecting Children and Vulnerable People
- Lecture 5-2: Personal Data, Photographs and Confidentiality
- Lecture 5-3: Openness, Conflicts of Interest and Raising Concerns
- Lecture 5-4: Responding When a Concern Is Raised
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Safeguarding and Openness Check
Offices in a church are filled in many ways. A bishop is chosen by one process, an elder by another, a deacon by a third, a trustee by a fourth. Some are elected by the members. Some are appointed by a wider body. Some are called by a committee, chosen by lot, nominated by the pastor, or inherited from a founder. A church that has never asked how its offices are filled may find that the answer is: "whoever was there first".
This lecture asks how a church can fill its offices fairly, how long people should hold them, what to do when a leader's own interests stand close to a decision, and how an office is left and handed on. It does not teach one system of election. Different traditions choose their leaders differently, and each has serious reasons. The lecture asks what any fair way of choosing has in common.
This is not legal advice. Some places set legal rules for who may be an officer of a church that is a legal body, for how long, and for what must be declared. These differ by country, region and year, and this lecture names none of them. Where a point may be one of those it says "check locally". A real case needs your church's own rules and a qualified person.
이 26분으로 얻는 것
- Describe the marks of a fair election or appointment, whichever way a church chooses its leaders.
- Explain why terms, rotation and a pause between terms protect both the church and the leader.
- Define a conflict of interest, and describe what a leader should do when one arises.
- Explain the risks of one person holding several offices, or of related persons holding the offices that check one another.
- Describe a fair way for an office-holder to resign, be replaced and hand over.
Therefore select from among you, brothers, seven men of good report, full of the Holy Spirit and of wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business." — Acts 6:3
World English Bible
These words pleased the whole multitude. They chose Stephen, a man full of faith and of the Holy Spirit, Philip, Prochorus, Nicanor, Timon, Parmenas, and Nicolaus, a proselyte of Antioch;" — Acts 6:5
WEB
Moreover you shall provide out of all the people able men, such as fear God: men of truth, hating unjust gain; and place such over them, to be rulers of thousands, rulers of hundreds, rulers of fifties, and rulers of tens." — Exodus 18:21
WEB
You shall not pervert justice. You shall not show partiality. You shall not take a bribe, for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise, and perverts the words of the righteous." — Deuteronomy 16:19
WEB
I command you in the sight of God, and Christ Jesus, and the chosen angels, that you observe these things without prejudice, doing nothing by partiality." — 1 Timothy 5:21
WEB
Two passages show how leaders were chosen. In Acts 6 the apostles describe the qualities and the whole community selects, and then the apostles appoint; the people and the leaders both have a part. In Exodus 18 the qualities are named, truth and a hatred of unjust gain, and the structure is a ladder of rulers of different sizes. Two passages show what a fair judge must avoid. A bribe blinds, and so does partiality. We do not say Acts 6 or Exodus 18 prescribes your method. We say that both begin with character, and both are concerned that the person holding the office be free of the pull of gain and favour.
1. Three questions every church must answer
Whatever its structure, a church needs a written answer to three questions about each office:
- Who may hold it? What does the person have to be, to have done, or to believe?
- Who chooses? The members, a council, a wider body, a bishop, a committee, the pastor, a lot, or some combination?
- For how long, and how does it end?
A church that can answer all three, in writing, for each of its offices, is already ahead of many. The answers differ between traditions. In an episcopal church, the choice of a bishop may involve clergy, lay representatives, neighbouring bishops and a wider body, in a process set by the church's own law. In a presbyterian-type church, elders are often elected by the congregation and then ordained by the council. In a connexional church, a minister may be appointed by a wider body to a local church for a period. In a congregational church, the members call a pastor and elect their deacons. In an independent church, a founder may appoint a board that then chooses the founder's successor. Each of these can be done fairly. Each can also be done badly. We turn to the marks of fairness.
2. The marks of a fair choice
A fair way of filling an office, in any structure, has these marks.
The qualifications are known beforehand. The church says in advance what it is looking for: character, gifts, time, faith, any requirement the tradition sets. The apostles in Acts 6 name what they want before the people choose. The New Testament lists of qualifications (we met them in lecture 1-2) are about character first. A vague standard allows the favoured candidate to be described as suitable.
The process is open to those who have a right to take part. The persons entitled to propose, to vote or to advise know that they are, and know when. A choice made in a corner by three people, when the rules gave the choice to the members, is a fault even if the person chosen is excellent.
More than one candidate or more than one view can be heard. Where the rules allow, nominations come from more than one source. Where the structure gives the choice to one person, such as a bishop appointing a priest to a parish, the fairness lies in the consultation: those who know the parish and the candidate can be heard before the decision.
Nomination is separate from counting. The person who nominates, or who has a favourite, is not the one who counts the votes. In a small church this may mean asking two members who are not candidates to count. The principle is that the result can be trusted.
The count is honest and the result is recorded. The number for and against, the number of abstentions and who was present are written in the minutes. This is not distrust. It is the record that prevents, three years later, a quarrel about who was actually elected.
A way to question the result exists. A candidate or a member who believes the rules were broken can say so, to a named person or body, and be heard. If the only person who can hear a complaint about an is the person who was elected, the complaint is empty.
The conscience of the person chosen is respected. A person is not elected to an office he or she has not accepted. And a person who accepts an office is told plainly what is expected, before the vote and not after.
3. Terms, rotation and rest
Most people who hold an office in a church hold it for love of the church. Some hold it for a very long time. Is that good?
There are serious views here, and this lecture does not settle them. Some hold that long service gives experience, memory and steadiness, and that to remove a faithful after two terms is waste. Some hold that an office is a that does not expire. Some hold that long unbroken service by the same few people hardens into ownership, that fresh eyes see what the old ones no longer do, and that to rotate offices honours the many gifts of the body. All of these views can be held by thoughtful Christians, and traditions differ. Some give a term of a few years, renewable once or twice, followed by a rest. Some elect for a single term. Some appoint to an office for life. Some leave the matter to the person's conscience and the church's judgement.
What is common is this. A term, whatever its length, is a promise that the church will look again. It is a point at which the church asks whether the person still serves well, whether they wish to continue, and whether others should be given the chance. Without any such point, the only way to end a long service is a quarrel. A fixed term protects the faithful office-holder from being forced out in anger, and it protects the church from an office-holder who will not leave.
The same reasoning applies to a break between terms. A pause, even of a year, lets the office-holder rest and lets the church find out whether the work can be done by others. It also tests whether the church has become dependent on one person. A church that cannot imagine its treasurer or its clerk or its leader being replaced has already been captured by that person's role, however good the person.
Check your own rules. Your tradition may set the term, or it may leave it to you. If nothing is written, it is wise to write a term and a way to renew it.
4. Relatives and other close ties
(An invented example.) In the Calder Mills church, the board has five members. The treasurer is Mrs. Anna Fenwick. The person who checks the accounts each year is her brother. The chair of the board is her husband. The board chose them one by one over the years, each time because the person was trusted, and nobody ever considered the three together. Nothing wrong has been done. But if something were wrong, the persons who would find it are the persons who would be most unwilling to say so.
This is a conflict of interest: a situation in which a person's duty to the church stands next to a personal interest, a family tie or a loyalty that could, or could seem to, influence their judgement. A conflict of interest is not a sin. It is a condition. Every community has them. A small church where everyone is related to everyone has more than it can avoid. The question is not whether they exist but what is done about them.
Common kinds include:
- Family ties between the persons who make a decision and the persons who are affected by it, or between the persons who do a task and the persons who check it.
- Money: a leader or a leader's relative or business who would be paid, or would profit, from a decision of the church, such as a contract for repairs, a rent, a loan or a purchase.
- Employment: a person who sits in judgement on the pay or conduct of someone who is also that person's superior or employer elsewhere.
- Close friendship or enmity with someone whose conduct is being considered.
- Several roles in one person, for example the person who signs the cheques, records them and checks them.
The common rule across traditions is simple. Declare the interest openly; do not take part in the decision; let the record show that you left the room. Often this is all that is needed. For a larger matter, the church should ask that the decision be made by those with no interest, and that an outside price or opinion be sought. The key point is that it is declared before the discussion, not found out afterwards.
A church should also have a short written rule that says who must declare, to whom, and how it is recorded. A conflict that is hidden is more dangerous than a conflict that is named. And the church should not make the declaring person feel shamed. Honesty must be easier than concealment, or concealment will win.
Where a church is a legal body, the law of your place may have its own rules about declaring interests and about payments to officers or their relatives. Check locally, and ask a qualified person before a large decision. Matters of church money practice belong to the church finance course.
5. One person, many offices
In a small church it is natural that the same few people hold many roles. The pastor is also the chair. The treasurer is also the secretary. The founder is also the owner of the building. Often there is no other way. But the more offices are held by one person, the less any of them is checked, since the checking offices are held by the same hand.
Three safeguards fit nearly any church:
- Separate the offices that check one another. The person who spends is not the person who approves the spending. The person who keeps the records is not the person whose conduct they record. If a small church cannot separate them inside, it can ask someone from outside the circle to do the checking.
- Limit the number of offices one person may hold, and write the limit.
- Notice when two related persons hold offices that check one another, and fix it, not as an accusation but as a simple structural repair.
None of this means that a person who holds several offices is dishonest. It means that the church is wise enough not to depend on any one person's perfect honesty. That is the thought behind the whole of lecture 1-4.
6. Resigning, succeeding and handing over
Offices end. The person resigns, falls ill, moves, dies, completes a term or is removed through a fair process (a matter we meet in Week 6). A church that has not thought about the ending finds itself in a crisis at the worst moment.
A sound pattern, in any tradition, has these parts.
Resignation in writing. Even a short note, addressed to the right person or body, with a date. It avoids the later quarrel about whether the person had left.
A clear rule for filling the gap. Who acts in the meantime? Who chooses the successor? How soon? The answer should be in the documents, so that no one has to invent it under pressure.
A handover. The outgoing person hands over the records, the keys, the passwords and the bank signatures, and tells the successor what is in progress. A church that discovers, a year later, that the only copy of its records was on a former secretary's home computer has paid a high price for a missing handover. (Lecture 6-4 returns to leaving well.)
A fair parting. A person who has served the church should be thanked, and the thanks should be real. A person who leaves in conflict should still receive a fair hearing, according to the church's own rules. Where the departure is for reasons of concern about conduct, the fair procedure of Week 6 applies, and where it concerns a crime or the safety of a person, the matter goes beyond the church.
7. An invented case
(An invented example.) At Riverside Chapel, an independent church, the trustees are the pastor, his sister, her husband, and two older members. The church needs to replace its roof and the cheapest quote is from a roofing company owned by the sister's husband. The two older members feel uneasy but do not like to say so.
At the meeting, the young secretary, Mr. Tomas Ilunga, who joined last year, says, "I think we should declare an interest, and ask for a second quote." The pastor is at first offended; he says the family has served for thirty years. The older member Mrs. Chioma Eze says, "Nobody is saying the family is dishonest. We are saying the church should be able to show the members that it chose fairly."
The chair asks the brother-in-law to say whether he has an interest. He does, and he declares it. He and his wife leave the room for the discussion. The church asks for two other quotes. In the end the family's company still wins the contract, on a fair price, and the minutes record the declaration, the departure, the other quotes and the vote.
Nothing in this account is dramatic. A man was not accused. A relative of the pastor kept a contract that he deserved. But the church can show, to any member and to anyone who ever asks, that the decision was made openly, and the family can show that it was not given a favour. That is what the procedure is for. It protects the honest as much as it constrains the others.
In an episcopal setting, the same matter might be handled by a rule that parish contracts above a certain amount be approved by a diocesan office. In a presbyterian setting the council might send it to a finance committee of persons with no tie. In a congregational setting, a members' meeting might decide. The shape is different. The principle is the same.
Diagram 1. What to do when you have an interest
핵심 요약
- Every office needs a written answer to three questions: who may hold it, who chooses, and for how long it lasts.
- A fair choice has known qualifications, an open process, more than one view heard, nomination kept apart from counting, an honest recorded count, and a way to question the result.
- A term, of whatever length, is a promise that the church will look again. It protects the faithful leader and the church alike.
- A conflict of interest is a condition, not a sin. The rule across traditions is to declare it early, step back from the decision, and let the record show it.
- The offices that check one another should not sit in one hand or in close relatives. If a small church cannot separate them, it asks someone from outside.
- An office ends well with a written resignation, a rule for filling the gap, a real handover, and a fair parting.
- Rules for officers, payments to them and declarations differ by place. Check locally.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three questions per office | Who may hold it? Who chooses? For how long, and how does it end? |
| Marks of a fair choice | Known qualifications; open process; views heard; nomination apart from counting; honest record; a way to question. |
| Conflict of interest | A condition, not a sin. Declare early, step back, and record it. |
| Ending an office | Written resignation, a rule for the gap, a handover of records, keys and passwords, a fair parting. |
One sentence to remember A term is a promise to look again, and a declared interest is a kindness to everyone, including the one who declares it.
This week's action For each office in your church, write who may hold it, who chooses and the term. Mark any pair of offices held by one person or by close relatives where one office checks the other.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- For each office in your church, can you answer in writing the three questions: who may hold it, who chooses, and for how long? Which answer is missing?
- Give the best case for long service in an office and the best case for fixed terms. Which is harder for you to state fairly?
- In the Calder Mills example, nothing wrong had been done. Why was it still wise for the church to separate the treasurer, the checker and the chair?
- Why is it a better habit to declare an interest before the discussion than to explain it afterwards? What would make declaring easier in your church?
- A long-serving leader says: "If you ask me to step down after four years, you are saying you do not trust me." How would you answer kindly, without questioning the leader's character?