Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
A change is not only done. It is also said. People learn that something is coming from the words that reach them, from the order in which those words arrive, and from the words that never come. In many congregations, more of a change is decided by what people hear than by what is voted.
Speaking about change is not a skill of persuasion in this course. It is a matter of truthfulness, and of respect for people who will live with the result. This lecture teaches five habits: say why, say what will be lost, ask for questions, say it more than once, and meet rumour with plain facts. It also teaches the limits of speaking, because some things concerning persons and their private lives are not told, even when people ask.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- State the reason for a change in a few plain sentences, including what will be lost.
- Plan how a proposal is told, to whom, in what order and how often.
- Explain how a rumour starts in a community and what a leader can do to answer it.
- Distinguish a matter that must be told from a matter that is properly kept private.
- Explain what it means to speak the truth in love, and name two ways the phrase is misused.
but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15
World English Bible
A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1
WEB
For lack of wood a fire goes out. Without gossip, a quarrel dies down." — Proverbs 26:20
WEB
Paul writes of a body that grows when its members speak truth in love. The Proverbs describe how words calm or inflame, and how talk behind backs feeds a quarrel. We use these verses as guidance about the manner of speaking. They do not tell a community what to decide.
1. What people hear first
When a leader says "we are thinking of changing the time of the service", something is said and something is heard. What is said is a time. What is heard may be: they have already decided; they did not ask me; my mother cannot come at that time; this is the beginning of the end of our community.
A leader cannot control what is heard. A leader can, however, shape what is said, and can make sure that people hear it from the right person, at the right time, in the right order. Most of the damage in a change comes not from the change but from people hearing, from someone other than the leader, that something is about to happen.
2. Habit one: say why
Begin with the reason, not the plan. People can follow a plan only if they know what it is for. If you begin with the plan, they will argue with the plan, because they have not been told what it answers.
A good reason is short and honest. It names the problem, says how the community knows it is a problem, and says why this change is proposed in answer. Three or four sentences are enough. If the leader cannot say it in that space, the leader may not yet have understood it. That is worth discovering before speaking to the community, and not after.
Two cautions.
- Do not give a reason that is not the real one. If the real reason is that the building is too costly to heat, do not say it is for the sake of fellowship. People discover the real reason, and then they doubt the others.
- Do not give a reason to which no answer is allowed. "God is leading us" may be sincerely meant. As an argument, it ends the conversation, and those who disagree are made to appear to oppose God. Say what you have seen, what you have prayed about, what Scripture or the community's standard says, and let others test it. Lecture 1-4 gave the questions to ask before proposing; speak from those.
3. Habit two: say what will be lost
This is the habit that leaders most often leave out, and it is the one that people most want to hear. Lecture 2-1 taught that behind a refusal there is often a loss. If the leader speaks of the gain and is silent about the loss, people feel unseen: they do not know what this costs me, or they know and do not care.
So name it. "The early gathering has been the home of this community's quiet prayer for many years. If we join the two gatherings, that quiet will change, and some of you will miss it. We know that." The sentence costs the leader nothing, and it tells the listener that someone has noticed.
Do not name the loss in order to take it away. Naming is not bargaining. The aim is to say what is true. A leader may add what will be done to honour the loss, such as keeping a short time of quiet prayer within the new order. But the first word is acknowledgement, not remedy.
4. Habit three: ask for questions, and mean it
An announcement is not a conversation. If the leader says "any questions?" and then closes the meeting after twenty seconds, people notice that the question was a gesture.
To ask for questions in a way that works:
- Say when and where. Not "my door is open" but "on these two evenings, in this room, at these times, and in writing to this address."
- Make a way for the quiet. Some people will not speak in a room. Offer small groups, a written form, a person other than the leader who will listen and report. An anonymous form helps some people; it also invites unfair accusations, so a leader should read such forms with care and answer the question, not the tone.
- Say what will be done with questions. Will answers be written? Will they be shared? By when?
- Answer, or say you do not know. "I do not know yet; I will find out by the next meeting" is a good answer. A leader who invents an answer to fill a pause will be caught.
- Do not argue with the asker. A question that sounds hostile is often an anxious one. Answer what it asks.
Listening of the kind described in lecture 2-2 is for deciding what to do. Asking for questions here is for helping people understand what has been decided or proposed. Both are needed, and they are not the same.
5. Habit four: say it more than once
A leader who has spoken to the council five times often forgets that the congregation has heard it once. People do not take in a hard message the first time. Some were not present. Some were thinking of something else. Some heard only the part that frightened them.
So say it again, in more than one form: from the front on a Sunday, in a written letter, in the bulletin, in small meetings, in a conversation after the service. Say it with the same reason and the same words, so that nobody can say the story changed. If the plan changes, say that it changed and why.
Do not take repetition for pressure. Repeating the same facts is respect. Repeating the demand until people give in is another thing.
6. Habit five: meet rumour with plain facts
Every community has an unofficial network. It is the set of conversations in car parks, kitchens and telephone calls by which news moves, and where much of what people believe about a change is formed. The network is not wicked. It is how people make sense of things that matter to them.
A rumour grows where there is a gap. If people do not know what the leaders are planning, they will fill the gap, usually with the worst version, because anxiety prefers the worst. The cure for rumour is not scolding. The cure is a reliable place where facts are given: the same source, regularly, even when there is little to say. "There is nothing new this month; here is where things stand" is a useful sentence.
When a rumour is already running:
- Find out what is actually being said. Ask a few trusted people. Do not guess.
- Answer the rumour with the facts that you may share, briefly and without anger. Do not name who started it, and do not hunt for the source.
- Say what you cannot yet say, and when you will be able to.
- Go to the people directly affected before they hear it from the network.
Proverbs 26:20 says that without gossip a quarrel dies down. A leader should be slow to blame the gossip and quick to ask what gap it is filling. For the handling of communication in a wider crisis, see and Leadership (PT702E).
7. The limits of telling
Truthfulness does not mean telling everything. A leader may be asked about things that must not be told.
Some matters about persons are private. The health, finances, family difficulties or private failings of a named person are not the community's business unless the community's own rules say they must be. A staff member's contract, a person's illness, a matter of discipline or of safety that is being handled under a written procedure: these are not told in a congregational letter to satisfy curiosity. The leader should say so plainly: "That is a private matter, and I cannot speak about it."
A limit is not a lie. A leader may decline to speak. A leader may not say something false. "I cannot tell you" is honest. "There is nothing to tell", when there is, is not. People forgive a limit that is stated. They do not forgive a falsehood that is found out.
Do not use privacy as a cover. There is a difference between a person's private life and a decision that affects the whole community. Money, property and the way a decision is made are not private in the same way. Where the community's rules require that members be told, tell them. Where a matter touches the safety of a child or an adult at risk, privacy is not the leading question: the road is in lectures 4-4 and 5-4, and it is not hidden.
8. Speaking the truth in love
Paul's phrase in Ephesians 4:15 is often used, and often misused.
The first misuse: truth without love. "I am only being honest." A hard word is chosen for its force and not for its listener. Truth said in order to wound is not what Paul commends. Proverbs 15:1 observes that a harsh word stirs anger. If the aim is for the community to grow, anger is rarely the way.
The second misuse: love without truth. "I did not want to upset anyone, so I said nothing", or "I said it so softly that nobody understood." A kindness that leaves people unaware of what is coming is not love. It postpones the pain and adds a feeling of betrayal.
The phrase says both. It asks the leader to say what is true, and to say it in a way that shows the listener is cared for. That is hard, and no formula does it. But a few questions help. Is this true? Is it necessary to say? Is this the right time? Am I the right person? Will the listener hear a person who cares, or a person who is protecting himself or herself?
(An invented example.) A leader must tell a group of volunteers that a weekday programme they have run for twelve years will end at the close of the year, because there are no longer enough people to lead it. The leader could send an email. Instead, the leader meets the volunteers first, in person, before it is told to anyone else. The leader says the reason, says that it is a loss, thanks them by name for specific things, and answers questions. Some are angry. The leader does not defend the decision loudly. The leader says, "I know. I would be angry too," and stays in the room. A week later, the matter is told to the whole congregation, and the volunteers have heard it from the person whose task it was.
9. A short plan for telling
Before a change is spoken of, write down answers to these questions.
- Who must hear first? Those most affected, and those whose office means they should not be surprised.
- In what order will others hear? The order is a message in itself.
- Who will say it? The person people trust and the person whose task it is, not always the same.
- What are the reason, the loss and the next step? In three or four sentences.
- Where and when may people ask? Dates, places, ways to ask in writing.
- What will be said again, and when?
- What can be told, and what cannot? Decide this before you are asked.
Diagram 1. The five habits and the telling plan
Diagram 2. Truth in love: two ways to miss
| Misuse | What it sounds like | What goes wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Truth without love | "I am only being honest." | The listener is wounded and stops hearing |
| Love without truth | "I did not want to upset anyone." | The listener is left unprepared and feels betrayed later |
핵심 요약
- People learn of a change from what they hear, in what order, and from whom. Most damage comes when they hear it from someone other than the leader.
- Say the real reason briefly, say what will be lost, ask for questions in a way the quiet can use, and say it more than once.
- Rumour grows in a gap. The remedy is a reliable place for facts, not scolding.
- A leader may decline to speak of a private matter, but may not say something false.
- Speaking the truth in love means both: truth without love wounds, and love without truth leaves people unprepared.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five habits | Say why; name the loss; ask for questions; say it more than once; meet rumour with plain facts. |
| Why a rumour grows | Where there is a gap in what people are told, anxiety fills it with the worst. |
| A limit and a lie | "I cannot speak of that" is honest; "there is nothing to tell", when there is, is not. |
| Two misuses of "truth in love" | Truth without love; love without truth. |
One sentence to remember A change is not only done; it is said, and the way it is said decides whether people can bear it.
This week's action Write, in four sentences, the reason for a change you know of, including what will be lost, and read it aloud once.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Recall a change you heard about in a way that made you feel unseen. What was said, who said it, and what was missing?
- Why is it hard to name a loss out loud in front of the people who will bear it? What does a leader fear?
- What gap in your community does rumour usually fill? What would a reliable place for facts look like there?
- Where does the line fall between a private matter and a matter the community must be told? Who in your community decides?
- Which is your habit, truth without love or love without truth? What would a small correction look like?