Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
Most conflicts in a community are not solved in a meeting, but many are made worse in one. People arrive with feelings that have been growing for weeks. The room is too small, the agenda is too long, two people speak for half an hour, and the person who is most afraid says nothing. Then someone calls for a vote, and the community goes home divided on a question that was never really heard.
This lecture is about how to run a meeting in which a conflict is faced. It is practical, and it is meant to be used. It covers the agenda, the time, the rules for speaking, the order of speaking, the difference between facts and feelings, the record, and the decision not to decide too soon. It also raises a question on which communities differ: how much of a conflict should be discussed in front of everyone, and how much should be settled first among a few.
This lecture does not teach the one-to-one conversation between two people. That belongs to the course Lay Leadership (LM401E). It does not teach conflict inside a small ministry team, which belongs to Building a Ministry Team (LM403E). Here we are concerned with the meeting of a committee, a council or a congregation.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Prepare an agenda and a time plan for a meeting in which a conflict will be discussed.
- Set ground rules and an order of speaking that give quiet people a fair chance.
- Explain why facts are heard before feelings, and why both are heard.
- Keep a record that can be checked by those who were there, and explain why a decision is sometimes not made at the first meeting.
- State fairly two views on how openly a conflict should be discussed, and say what protection this course requires.
The apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter." — Acts 15:6
World English Bible
All the multitude kept silence, and they listened to Barnabas and Paul reporting what signs and wonders God had done among the nations through them." — Acts 15:12
WEB
for God is not a God of confusion, but of peace. As in all the assemblies of the saints," — 1 Corinthians 14:33
WEB
So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19
WEB
The meeting in Acts 15 is not a model that every community must copy. It shows a kind of meeting: leaders gathered for a defined question, the room quiet enough for reports to be heard, and the weight of what had happened among the nations laid before them. Paul and James speak of the same thing in different words. God is not a God of confusion, and a person who wants to be heard must first be willing to hear.
1. Decide what the meeting is for
Before you write an agenda, write one sentence: At the end of this meeting, what will be different?
A meeting about a conflict can have one of only a few purposes, and mixing them is the first cause of failure.
- To hear. Everyone with a stake says what they see. No decision is made.
- To understand. The facts are laid out and agreed, as far as they can be.
- To explore. Possible ways forward are named and weighed. No decision is made.
- To decide. A choice is made by the road the community's rules provide.
A first meeting about a heated question is nearly always for hearing, and sometimes for understanding. It is rarely for deciding. If you call a meeting "to settle the matter" before anyone has been heard, people hear a threat. Say the purpose in the invitation and again at the start of the meeting. "Tonight we will listen. We will not vote."
2. The agenda and the clock
A written agenda, sent beforehand, is a courtesy and a protection. It tells people what will be raised, so that nobody is surprised. It also tells the person who wants to raise something else that there is a place and a time for it.
A good agenda for a difficult meeting has a short list of items, and time beside each one. In many groups, two hours is about the longest that people can work well on a hard matter. If the question is large, plan a second meeting rather than a longer one.
Allow for three things that a typical agenda forgets:
- A break. Ten minutes in the middle lets people breathe, speak to one another and calm down. A person who is about to say something they will regret is often saved by a cup of tea.
- A time at the end for what was agreed. Never end on the last speaker. End by reading back what was settled and what was not.
- A clear place for people who need to leave. If the meeting must end at nine, say so at the start and keep to it. A meeting that continues past its time rewards the people with the most stamina, who are often not the people with the most to say.
3. The room
Small things matter. A room that is too hot, too cold or too crowded raises tempers. People who sit in a row facing a table at the front are in a different frame of mind from people who sit in a circle. Think about who sits next to whom. If two people are known to be in disagreement, you need not seat them together, and you need not seat them as far apart as possible; either arrangement says something. Seat them where they can see one another without a table or a person between them, or in the middle of the group, depending on what you know of them.
If some will join by telephone or on a screen, say at the start how they will be called on, and call on them. Someone who is on a screen is often forgotten for an hour.
4. Ground rules
Ground rules are a few simple agreements, made at the start, that make speaking safer. They should be few: four or five. They should be said aloud and, where possible, agreed by the room. A leader who has written them on a card and reads them out as a command will be obeyed for ten minutes.
A short set that works in many communities:
- One person speaks at a time. We do not interrupt.
- We speak for ourselves. "I am worried that..." and not "Everybody thinks that..."
- We talk about the matter, not about the character of a person. If a name is used, it is to say what was done, not what sort of person the other is.
- What is said here stays here, except what we agree to report. A group should agree beforehand what will be recorded and told to others, and who may be told. Where a person fears for their safety, see lecture 5-4: the rule that "what is said here stays here" never covers a harm.
- Anyone may ask for a pause. A break, a silence or a moment to pray may be asked for by any person in the room.
Two notes. The word "respect" is often used in ground rules and seldom defined. Better to name the behaviour: no raised voices, no ridicule, no private conversations while another person is speaking. And ground rules apply to the chair too. If the leader interrupts, the rules mean nothing.
5. The order of speaking
In an open discussion the people who speak first and longest are not necessarily those who know most or care most. They are often those who are least afraid. The people who are most deeply affected are sometimes the quietest: the elderly person who has sat in the same seat for forty years, the new member who does not yet know if she may speak, the young person who has been told that his generation is the problem.
Several simple methods help.
- A round. Go round the circle, each person speaking briefly, with the right to pass. A round at the start gives everyone a voice before the first long speech sets the tone.
- A list. Take names for speaking in the order they are raised. The chair holds the list, not the loudest voice.
- Small groups. For a large meeting, break into groups of three to five for ten minutes and ask each to bring back one thing. Quiet people often speak in a small group who would never speak in a hall.
- Written questions. Allow people to write a question or a concern and hand it in. This lets a person who fears being identified, or who is slow in a second language, take part. The chair reads them out without naming the writer.
Many in the room will not be native speakers of the language in which the meeting is held. Speak slowly. Avoid sayings. Say the main point twice, in different words. Invite someone to say it in their own language if that would help, and allow the time for it.
6. Facts before feelings, and both
A common piece of advice is "keep emotion out of it". It is bad advice. Feeling is information. A person who is angry about a proposed change is telling you that something they treasure is threatened.
A better rule is the order in which things are heard. Facts first, so that everyone is standing on the same ground. Then meaning, so that everyone knows what the facts mean to the people involved.
For example, when a conflict is about a decision to sell a small building, the facts might include the cost of repairs, the number of people using it, the offer that has been made, and what the community's written rules say about a sale. These are put on a page, agreed as far as possible, and corrected where they are wrong. Only then does the room ask, "What does this building mean to you?" The two questions are different, and the answers to the second do not alter the answers to the first. If they are mixed, people argue over facts when they are really arguing over meaning, and nobody feels heard.
If a fact is disputed and nobody in the room can settle it, record it as disputed and name who will find out. Do not allow the meeting to be taken over by a quarrel about a number.
A chair can do three things to help. Ask for the source ("Where does that figure come from?"), without suspicion. Ask the speaker to separate what they saw from what they think it means ("What did you see? What do you take it to mean?"). Reflect back what has been said ("What I heard is that..."), and ask if it was right.
7. The record and the check
A conflict meeting needs a record, kept by someone other than the chair. It need not be long. It should note who was present, what was discussed, what was agreed, what was not, and who will do what by when. It should not contain the names attached to opinions, unless the people agreed.
Do two things with the record. Read back what was agreed at the end of the meeting, so that anyone who disagrees with the summary can say so at once. Send the record to those present within a few days, and invite corrections. A record that is checked by those who were there is hard to dispute later. A record that is circulated three weeks afterward, and is the only version, becomes a weapon.
Where a matter involves personal details of someone who is not present, those details do not go into a record that many will read.
8. Not deciding too soon
Almost every leader feels pressure to decide quickly. The silence is uncomfortable. The matter has gone on for months. A vote could finish it.
Resist this when the conflict is fresh, for three reasons.
- A decision made before people have been heard is not accepted as just. Even those who win may feel uneasy. Those who lose will say, truly, that they were not listened to.
- A hurried decision on an adaptive question (lecture 1-2) often solves the wrong problem.
- Some changes cannot be undone. Lecture 3-2 set out the difference between reversible and irreversible steps. A decision that cannot be reversed deserves more time.
Delay has its own cost, and this too is real: people lose confidence, rumours grow, and good people leave. So the answer is not "never decide". It is to decide when the matter has been heard and the road is clear, and to say in the meantime when the decision will be made. A date for the next step is the antidote to the fear that nothing will happen.
At the end of a first meeting, a leader can say, "We have not decided anything tonight. We have listened. In two weeks we will meet again, and we will look at three ways forward. Between now and then, the secretary will send you what we heard. If you think we have got something wrong, write to her by Friday."
9. Small meetings and large
A meeting of five people, where each knows the others, can work almost without rules. The risk is that the rules are never said, and the quietest person has no way to object. A meeting of two hundred is almost the opposite: rules are needed, and only a few will speak. For the large meeting, much of the work must be done before it. Hold smaller meetings, listening sessions and written consultations first (lecture 2-2). Bring to the large meeting a clear proposal, the facts and the road by which it will be decided, and let the large meeting do what it alone can do: hear, vote if the rules provide for it, and give or withhold consent.
A leader who is a party to the conflict should not chair. Lecture 5-1 explained why. Ask a person who is not a party, or an outside person (lecture 5-3), to lead.
10. Open discussion or private resolution?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some communities hold that a conflict that touches the whole body should be discussed by the whole body. They point to the way Acts 15 places the question before the apostles, the elders and "all the multitude", and to a long tradition of congregations that make decisions in assembly. They fear that matters settled quietly by a few will produce suspicion, and that a body that is not allowed to speak will not own what is decided. For them, openness is part of justice.
Other communities hold that a conflict should be settled first among as few people as possible. They point to passages that call for private approach before public (taught in PT705E), to the harm that is done when a quarrel is aired before people who cannot help and may be hurt, and to the way a public meeting can reward the confident speaker and expose the vulnerable. For them, privacy is part of mercy.
Both are speaking of real goods. Some polities build one or the other into their rules, for example by having a bishop or a small council settle a matter, and others by requiring a vote of all members. A leader follows the community's written constitution first.
What this course requires is less than either position demands, and it applies to both. Protect people from exposure they did not choose. And do not hide from the body what the body must decide. If the whole body will have to decide a matter, it must be told enough to decide. If a matter concerns the private life, health, family or past of a person, that person's details are not shared in a meeting, whichever tradition the community follows. The test is simple: Who is helped and who is exposed by the number of people who know this?
11. When someone is afraid
One last thing for the person running the meeting. Watch for the person who stops speaking when a certain other person enters, who will not sit near them, who asks to leave early or who says, "I would rather not be in the room." It may be shyness. It may be something else. If a person says they are afraid of another person in the room, stop. Do not ask them to explain in front of the group, and do not ask them to "work it out" with the other person. Speak to them privately after the meeting, listen, and ask whether they are safe now. If what you hear sounds like harm, the matter has left the territory of this lecture and entered that of lecture 5-4.
Diagram 1. The shape of a meeting about a conflict
핵심 요약
- Decide the purpose of the meeting before writing the agenda: to hear, to understand, to explore or to decide. A first meeting about a heated question is rarely for deciding.
- Send an agenda beforehand, set a time for each item, allow a break, and end by reading back what was agreed and what was not.
- Keep to a few ground rules, said aloud: one speaker at a time, speak for yourself, speak about the matter and not the person's character.
- Hear facts first, so everyone stands on the same ground, then hear what the facts mean to people. Feeling is information.
- Keep a record, checked by those present. Do not decide before people have been heard, but say when the decision will be made.
- Protect people from exposure they did not choose, and do not hide from the body what it must decide.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four purposes of a meeting | To hear, to understand, to explore, to decide. Say which one in the invitation. |
| Order of hearing | Facts first, so that all stand on the same ground; then what the facts mean to people. |
| The record | Kept by someone other than the chair, read back at the end, sent within days, open to correction. |
| Open or private? | Protect people from exposure they did not choose; do not hide from the body what it must decide. |
One sentence to remember A meeting about a conflict is for hearing before it is for deciding, and it always ends with what was agreed read back.
This week's action Write a one-sentence purpose, five ground rules and an order of speaking for the next difficult meeting you may have to chair or attend.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a meeting about a disagreement that went badly. Without naming anyone, what was its purpose, and was that purpose ever said?
- Which of the four purposes (to hear, to understand, to explore, to decide) do you most often skip to? Why?
- Who is usually silent in the meetings you know? What would help them speak?
- Why does the lecture say that feeling is information? Do you agree?
- Describe in your own words the difference between a matter that is private and a matter that is hidden. In your own community's rules, who decides which is which?