Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Table of Understandings
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: God's Time, the Church's Time
- Lecture 1-2: How the Church Year Grew
- Lecture 1-3: Churches That Keep the Year and Churches That Do Not
- Lecture 1-4: The Shape of the Year
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Read a Year
- Lecture 2-1: Advent, Christmas and Epiphany
- Lecture 2-2: Lent and Holy Week
- Lecture 2-3: Easter and Pentecost
- Lecture 2-4: Ordinary Time and Days Your Country Keeps
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Shape One Season in a Service
- Lecture 3-1: Season and Word
- Lecture 3-2: Children and All Ages Together
- Lecture 3-3: Making Room at Home
- Lecture 3-4: When the Season Hurts
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, One Small Practice
- Lecture 4-1: What a Sacrament Is
- Lecture 4-2: The Supper: What Happens
- Lecture 4-3: Word and Table
- Lecture 4-4: Who Presides
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Table of Understandings
- Lecture 5-1: Who Comes to the Table
- Lecture 5-2: Bread, Cup and Body: Access and Health
- Lecture 5-3: Sick, Elderly and Housebound
- Lecture 5-4: Worthiness, Self-Examination and Online Communion
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, A Welcome Note and an Access Check
This is the Practice Lab for week 4. Every week of this course ends in one, and every one asks you to do something and not only to agree with something.
Today's task is to write a table of understandings of the Supper. For each understanding you met in lecture 4-2, you will write, in its own words, what the bread and cup are, how Christ is with the people, and what verse that understanding leans on. Then you will say what your own community teaches and who decides. The test of each entry is this: would a person who holds that understanding read it and say, "Yes, that is how we say it"?
Nothing here asks you to judge a real teacher, a real church or a real person. You work with your own place, or with an invented class question, or with a partner. Nobody sees your page.
이 18분으로 얻는 것
- Complete a table that states five understandings of the Supper, each in terms its holders would accept.
- Notice where a short answer to a question about the Supper ranks one view over another, or describes a view unfairly.
- Say aloud, to a partner, one understanding in its own words, and hear it said back.
- Explain the privacy rules of this lab and keep them when you run it in a group.
Oh taste and see that Yahweh is good. Blessed is the man who takes refuge in him." — Psalm 34:8
World English Bible
The psalm asks us to "taste and see." Christians who come to the table from different traditions have been fed at the same command, and they say different things about what they taste. The aim of this lab is not to settle that. It is to learn to say what each community says, so that a visitor, a child or a new member who asks a question gets a fair and kind answer.
What the lab is for
When someone asks, "What do Christians believe about the bread and wine?", a quick answer is usually one-sided. It describes the speaker's own tradition as the plain one, and the others as additions or as losses. The person who asks goes away thinking that Christians are in two camps and that one of them is wrong.
A written table slows this down. It makes you write each understanding in the words its holders use, with the verse they point to, and with the reason they give. Writing it, you find where you do not know the words yet. That is a useful finding.
The three ways in
You can do this lab in any of three ways. Choose the one that fits you. None is a lesser version of the others.
1. In your own place. If you teach, lead a table, or answer questions about the Supper where you gather, use the five understandings and add your community's. Fill in what you are able to say fairly. Write "ask" where you do not know, and note whom to ask. If your community has a or a written statement, use its words for your own row.
2. The observer's way. If you do not teach or lead a table, or want to practise on something that is not yours, use the invented class question and draft answer printed below. Fill in the table, and mark where the draft answer is unfair. You are not judging a real teacher.
3. The partner's way. Sit with a trusted partner. Take turns. One of you chooses an understanding and says it in its own words, in about a minute, with the verse. The other says it back in their own words and asks, "Have I got that right?" Then swap. If you hold a different understanding from your partner, each of you says the other's. You do not have to say which one is yours.
Four promises of privacy
Say these before you begin, and say them again if you run this in a group.
- Nobody reads what you write. The form is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded.
- You may pass on any part, including the whole exercise.
- The leader fills in a sheet too.
If you record yourself saying an understanding aloud, only you watch or listen. Do not write the name of a real person, a real congregation or a real church leader on the form; use "my community" or "a Catholic parish" or "a Baptist church." If the exercise brings a harm to light, such as abuse, violence, or danger, stop the lab. Speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. If someone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
The invented class question, for the observer's way
An invented class question and a draft answer
(An invented example.) In an adult class in a small church, a visitor, Mira, asks: "I grew up in one church and now I am visiting another. They talk about the bread in a different way. Why can't Christians agree on what it is? Which is right?"
The teacher is kind and in a hurry. Here is the draft answer written for the class:
"Good question. The early church believed that the bread and wine become Christ's body and blood, and some churches still teach that, but I think it is a rather strange idea, and the Reformers saw it was not in Scripture. Others say it is a symbol only, which is simple and clear. Some say Christ is spiritually there. My own view is the one that fits the Bible best: when we eat the bread we remember what he did. The people who believe the bread changes are honestly mistaken, but they mean well. Jesus said 'Do this in memory of me,' and that is all we need. So the right answer is to keep it simple and do what he said. I would not worry about the rest, because the old arguments were mostly about words. If your old church told you something different, you do not need to think about it any more. You are with us now, and here we know what the Bible teaches. Come to the table with us on Sunday, and you will see that it is plain and honest."
The class is quiet. Mira says "thank you" and looks down at her notes. Another member of the class, who grew up in the same church as Mira, says nothing.
Read the draft with the lecture 4-2 in mind. Write down, in the table or on a spare line:
- Where does the draft rank one understanding above the others?
- Where does it describe a view in words its holders would not use?
- Where does it make a claim that sounds like "the Bible clearly says" about a point on which readers do not agree?
- What does it leave out that all traditions share?
- Write a better answer of three or four sentences for Mira. It should be kind, honest, short, and fair to each tradition.
How to do it
Five steps
Step 1. Gather what you need. Lecture 4-2, with its six understandings and its list of what all agree on. A pen and paper, or a blank page on a screen.
Step 2. Copy the form in section 4-1 below. One row for each of the five understandings, plus one for your own community. About twenty-five minutes, alone, in silence if you are in a group.
Step 3. Fill in each row. Write what the bread and the cup are, how Christ is with the people, and the verse or reason the holders give, in the words they would use. Mark the "Yes, we would say that" box only when you could read it to a person who holds the view without wincing.
Step 4. Write what all agree on, and your own row. Write three points of agreement. For your own community, write what it teaches and who decides, or write "ask" and whom you will ask.
Step 5. Say it aloud, or pass. If you have a partner, say one row in a minute, and hear it said back. If you are alone, you may say one row aloud to yourself, and ask whether it sounds fair.
What usually goes wrong
"I only know my own." That is a real result. Write "ask" in the other rows and the name of a person or a source you could ask. Do not fill the rows from guesses. A false description of another community is worse than an empty row.
"The honest answer is that one of them is right." You may hold that. This lab does not ask you to give it up. It asks you to write the other views in their own words first. A teacher who holds a view firmly and describes others fairly is the teacher people trust.
"The words feel like a compromise." They are not meant to be a blend. Each row should be sharp: it should say what the community says, even where that is different from the row beside it.
"I do not teach; this is not for me." Use the observer's way. Anyone may be asked at a family table, by a child or a neighbour, what Christians think about the Supper, and a fair answer is a kindness.
Leader's note, for running this in a group
Privacy comes first
State the privacy rules out loud, before anyone writes. Nobody will read the sheet. Nothing is marked. Anyone may pass. Say it even if you said it last week.
Fill in your own sheet with them. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination. Sit down and write.
Give a full twenty-five minutes. Do not fill the silence with comments.
Offer all three ways, equally. Do not ask anyone why they chose the observer's question. In a mixed room, you may have members of several traditions. Say plainly that no row is the "right" one and that nobody has to say which row is their own.
Do not ask: "Which understanding is correct?" Ask instead: "What was the strongest reason you heard for a view that is not your own?"
Asked the second way, people tell you what they have learned, and nobody's tradition is put on trial.
Stay with the work, not the person. A row that is unfair is something to fix, not a verdict on the writer. If a person in the room belongs to a tradition that is discussed, thank them for any correction they give, and let them say how their community says it.
Allow anyone to pass. Say it: "If you would rather not say anything, just pass." Then move on at once.
If something painful comes up. Sometimes this subject touches a real hurt: a person who was turned away from a table, or who was shamed at one, or who left a church. Do not rush on. Stay a moment. Afterwards, speak privately, and if what you hear is beyond you, help the person find a pastor, a priest or a safeguarding person. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number.
4-1. The form: A Table of Understandings
4-2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Stated the four privacy promises out loud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Offered all three ways (own place, observer, partner) equally | [ ] |
| Said that no row is the "right" one and nobody must say which is theirs | [ ] |
| Gave a full twenty-five minutes without filling the silence | [ ] |
| Did not ask which understanding is correct | [ ] |
| Did ask for the strongest reason heard for a view not their own | [ ] |
| Offered a genuine option to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Knew who to call if something painful came up | [ ] |
핵심 요약
- The test of a fair description is whether a person who holds the view would say, "Yes, that is how we say it."
- The table has five rows: Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, spiritual presence and memorial, with the verse or reason each gives, and a row for your own community.
- A quick answer often ranks one view above the others or describes another in words its holders would not use.
- Three ways in: your own place, the observer's invented class question, or a partner; none is lesser.
- Group rules: state privacy first, the leader writes too, ask for the strongest reason heard, never which view is correct.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The test of a fair description | Would a person who holds the view say, "Yes, that is how we say it"? |
| The three ways in | In your own place; the observer's invented class question; with a partner. |
| The four promises of privacy | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| The question to ask | Not "which is correct?" but "what was the strongest reason you heard for a view that is not your own?" |
One sentence to remember A fair answer about the Supper begins with what all agree on, and gives each tradition its own words.
This week's action Fill in the table on paper. Write "ask" in any row you cannot yet write fairly, and note the person or source you will ask.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What was the strongest reason you heard for a view that is not your own? Answer with the reason, not with the name of any real person or church.
- Which row was hardest to write fairly? What word or phrase did you not yet know?
- What did the draft answer to Mira get wrong, and what would you say to her instead?
- If you wish to say which row is closest to your own community, do so. If you would rather not, pass.
- How did it feel to say another community's view aloud and hear it said back? What did your partner's question make you notice?