Lecture 6-4: Welcome and Discipline
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: God's Time, the Church's Time
- Lecture 1-2: How the Church Year Grew
- Lecture 1-3: Churches That Keep the Year and Churches That Do Not
- Lecture 1-4: The Shape of the Year
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Read a Year
- Lecture 2-1: Advent, Christmas and Epiphany
- Lecture 2-2: Lent and Holy Week
- Lecture 2-3: Easter and Pentecost
- Lecture 2-4: Ordinary Time and Days Your Country Keeps
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Shape One Season in a Service
- Lecture 3-1: Season and Word
- Lecture 3-2: Children and All Ages Together
- Lecture 3-3: Making Room at Home
- Lecture 3-4: When the Season Hurts
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, One Small Practice
- Lecture 4-1: What a Sacrament Is
- Lecture 4-2: The Supper: What Happens
- Lecture 4-3: Word and Table
- Lecture 4-4: Who Presides
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Table of Understandings
- Lecture 5-1: Who Comes to the Table
- Lecture 5-2: Bread, Cup and Body: Access and Health
- Lecture 5-3: Sick, Elderly and Housebound
- Lecture 5-4: Worthiness, Self-Examination and Online Communion
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, A Welcome Note and an Access Check
Every community that welcomes people also has to answer a harder question: what happens when something goes wrong between a member and the community, or between members? Many traditions have some form of discipline: a warning, a period of being kept from the table, a removal from membership. Many have used it well. Many have misused it. Some have used it to silence people who asked awkward questions, to protect a leader, or to shame a person in front of a congregation.
This lecture asks what a caring and fair approach looks like. It is not a legal guide and it does not set rules; communities decide their own rules, and local law applies. It gives a minimum that every tradition can hold: the aim is restoration, the process is known and fair, privacy is kept, and the person who has been harmed is protected first. It looks at how this meets the table, and it uses invented cases.
The principle of the week applies here as much as to the water: baptism is the beginning of growing inside one community. Discipline, at its best, is part of that growing and not the end of it.
이 19분으로 얻는 것
- State the five minimum marks of a fair and caring process: restoration, a known process, privacy, no public shaming and victims first.
- Explain why Matthew 18 is not a rule for cases of abuse or danger.
- Describe how different traditions understand keeping a person from the table or from membership, in their own words.
- Name three ways discipline has been misused and three ways to guard against them.
- Say what your community's process is, who decides, and how a person returns.
If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother. But if he doesn’t listen, take one or two more with you, that at the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the assembly. If he refuses to hear the assembly also, let him be to you as a Gentile or a tax collector." — Matthew 18:15-17
World English Bible
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1
WEB
Matthew 18 describes a pattern for a conflict between members: a private word first, then a small group, then the assembly. Galatians 6:1 sets the tone: restoration "in a spirit of gentleness", with a warning to the one who restores. Both are about a brother or sister, and both aim at getting that person back.
1. What the two passages are for
Take Matthew 18 first. It begins with a person who has been wronged. The first step is small: go and speak, "between you and him alone". The aim is stated: "you have gained back your brother." Only if this fails are one or two others brought; only after that, "the assembly". The last sentence is hard, and communities have read it in different ways. Some read it as a decision to end membership. Some read it as a way of treating a person with the openness that Jesus himself showed to tax collectors and Gentiles, who were the people he went on eating with and . Both readings are held by communities that take the passage seriously.
Notice what the passage does not say. It does not say how to handle a case where one person has harmed another severely, or where there is a difference of power (a leader and a member, an adult and a child). It does not say that a person who was abused must first confront the person who did it. It does not say that a community may decide things in secret and tell no one. A passage about a quarrel between members cannot be stretched into a method for abuse.
Galatians 6:1 sets the tone. The verse says to restore such a one "in a spirit of gentleness", and adds, "looking to yourself". Two things are present. The aim is restoration, and the person doing the restoring is warned that they are not above the temptation. A community that disciplines in pride has already lost the verse.
2. How traditions understand it
Communities differ on how this works. Each can be described in its own words.
- Penance and reconciliation. In the Catholic tradition, a person who has seriously sinned is invited to confession and reconciliation. In some cases, a person may be kept from communion for a time, and in grave and public cases, the church has rules about excommunication; these are decided by the bishop or other proper authority, and are meant to bring the person back. The Orthodox churches also have a long practice of a time of repentance, sometimes with a period of not receiving communion, guided by a priest and bishop.
- The call of the elders. Many Reformed, Presbyterian and some other communities appoint elders to oversee the life of the community. They may visit, warn and, in rare cases, suspend a person from the table or from membership, with set steps and an appeal.
- The congregation as a whole. Many Baptist and independent communities place the decision in the congregation, sometimes through a meeting of members. Many Anabaptist communities have a practice of that includes a formal separation, with a strong stress on return.
- Counsel and prayer. Lutheran, Anglican and Methodist communities often rely on pastoral conversation, the priest or minister, and a bishop or superintendent for serious cases.
- Little formal discipline. Some communities (including many Quaker meetings, many charismatic and house churches) have little formal discipline, and rely on talk, elders and shared life.
The details differ widely, and a short description cannot be complete. What matters for this lecture is that each has an aim (restoration, protection, holiness, peace) and each can be done well or badly.
3. Five marks of a fair and caring process
This is a point where readers will not agree about many things: who decides, how public a step should be, whether a person may be kept from the table, and for what. This course does not decide those. It asks only for a minimum that every tradition can accept.
- The aim is restoration. The first question is not "What does this person deserve?" but "How can this person come back, and be safe, and keep others safe?"
- A known and fair process. The steps are written down and told in advance, in plain words. The person is told what is said about them and may answer. The same steps apply to everyone, leaders included. In a small community, where the leader is the person concerned, an outside person (a bishop, an from another place, a trusted neighbour) is asked.
- Privacy. Only those who need to know are told. Reasons for a decision are not made public, and names are not read out. If something has to be said to the community, it is said as little and as kindly as possible.
- No public shaming. A person is not made to stand up and confess before others, is not named in a notice and is not discussed in the community's chat group. Children are never made to be present at or to carry news of such matters.
- Victims first. The person who has been harmed is protected before anything else. They are not asked to meet or forgive the one who harmed them, are not told to "just forgive", and are not expected to attend the same table as that person if they do not wish to. If abuse or danger is suspected, do not investigate. Tell a responsible person or body, such as your community's safeguarding person, the proper authority and, where required by local law, the proper public body. If there is danger now, call the local emergency number. A community is not the place to decide guilt in a matter of crime.
These five marks are a minimum, not a recipe. A community may do more. It may not do less and still claim to be caring.
4. The table and discipline
Many traditions hold that a person who is under discipline may be kept from the table for a time. Some say it with great seriousness; some do not hold it at all. A few points apply either way.
- The table is never a weapon. It is not used to punish, to control or to settle a quarrel. If it is withheld, it is for the sake of the person and the community, and it is meant to be given back.
- A person who is kept from the table is not forgotten. Someone visits, prays and says plainly what would allow the person to return. A review date is set. Withholding without end is not discipline; it is exile.
- The person is told privately. They are not turned away in front of others. A quiet word before the service, or a letter, is better than a refusal at the front.
- People who cannot come for other reasons are not mistaken for people under discipline. A person who does not come to the table because of illness, a recovery programme, a fear of the cup or a conflict with another person is not under discipline. Do not guess.
- A victim is never kept from the table because of the victim's anger. A person who has been wronged, and who cannot bear to share the table with the person who wronged them, may need another time, another place or a separate arrangement. Offer it; do not ask the person to explain.
5. How discipline is misused
Three ways are common.
- To silence. A member asks a question, raises a concern about money, or reports a worry about a leader. The next thing they hear is that they are "divisive". Guard against this by having a clear path for concerns, a person outside the leader's circle to hear them and the same process for every member.
- To protect. A person with power is protected; a person without power is moved. Guard against this by asking, "Who gains if this stays quiet?" and by involving someone from outside.
- To shame. The story is told, the name is told, and the person is marked for life. Guard against this by keeping to the five marks above.
Spiritual abuse can look like discipline. If a person says they are being controlled by threats of exclusion, judgement or God's anger, if a leader says nothing may be questioned, or if a person is told that their private conscience does not matter, take it seriously. Do not diagnose or condemn. Listen, and take it to a responsible person or body.
6. Two short invented cases
(An invented example.) Two members of a small church fall out over a loan. One feels cheated; the other says it was a gift. The leader asks the first to speak with the second privately; they do, and with the help of a third person agree to a short written note. Both go on coming to the table. Nothing is announced. This is Matthew 18 working as it should: small, private, and with no more people than needed.
(An invented example.) A teenage girl tells her youth leader that an older man in the church has been touching her. The leader does not say "Go and speak to him alone." The leader does not ask the girl to describe it, and does not question the man. The leader tells her it was right to speak, says that someone responsible will be told, and then tells the community's safeguarding person at once, as the written rules require. If there is danger now, the local emergency number is called. The church's process for membership and the table comes later, and only after the proper authorities have acted. Matthew 18 is not the instrument for this.
(For the wider work of caring for people in conflict and trouble in a community, see PT713E.)
Diagram 1. The shape of a fair and caring process
핵심 요약
- Matthew 18 and Galatians 6:1 aim at restoration; Galatians adds a warning that the restorer is also tempted.
- Matthew 18 is for conflict between members, not for abuse or danger; abuse is reported, not investigated, and a victim is never asked to confront.
- Five marks of a fair process: restoration, a known process, privacy, no public shaming, victims first.
- The table is never a weapon; withholding it is meant for restoration and is reviewed, with a way back.
- Discipline can be misused to silence, to protect or to shame; guard with clear paths, outside help and the same rules for everyone.
- Say what your community's process is, who decides and how a person returns.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five marks of a fair process | Restoration as the aim; a known and fair process; privacy; no public shaming; victims first. |
| Matthew 18 and abuse | Matthew 18 is for quarrels between members; abuse is reported to a responsible person or body, never settled privately. |
| The table and discipline | Never a weapon; if withheld, told privately, reviewed, and given back. |
| Three misuses | To silence, to protect, to shame. |
One sentence to remember Discipline that does not aim at restoration, fairness and a way back has stopped being discipline.
This week's action Find out whether your community has a written process for concerns and a named safeguarding person, and read both.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What is your community's process when a member has done something serious, or when two members are in conflict? Who decides, and is it written down?
- How would your community protect a person who has been harmed, and how would it avoid asking that person to confront the one who harmed them?
- Which of the three misuses (to silence, to protect, to shame) is hardest to guard against in a small community, and why?
- If a person were kept from the table for a time, what would a quiet and fair way of telling them look like?
- What could your community do so that a person who made a serious mistake can find a way back?