Lecture 10-3: Luther's Two 1525 Writings on the War
Contents 85
- Lecture 1-1: The Avignon Papacy and the "Babylonian Captivity"
- Lecture 1-2: The Western (Papal) Schism, 1378-1417
- Lecture 1-3: Conciliarism and the Council of Constance
- Lecture 1-4: Popular Piety on the Eve of Reform
- Lecture 2-1: John Wycliffe and Dominion by Grace
- Lecture 2-2: The Lollards and the Wycliffite English Bible
- Lecture 2-3: Jan Hus at Prague
- Lecture 2-4: The Council of Constance and the Execution of Hus
- Lecture 3-1: Ad Fontes — The Renaissance Recovery of Languages and Its Christian Turn
- Lecture 3-2: Northern Christian Humanism as a Reform Movement — Reuchlin and Colet
- Lecture 3-3: Erasmus's Greek New Testament — Scholarship, Limits, and Consequences
- Lecture 3-4: Erasmus and the Reformation — Alliance and Rupture
- Lecture 4-1: The Printing Press and the Speed of an Idea
- Lecture 4-2: Cities, Guilds, and Universities as Carriers of Reform
- Lecture 4-3: The Holy Roman Empire and the Grievances of the German Nation
- Lecture 4-4: Europe Around 1500 — A Different Moment, Not a Destined One
- Lecture 5-1: An Unremarkable Beginning
- Lecture 5-2: The Vow at Stotternheim and Entry into the Cloister
- Lecture 5-3: Anfechtung and the Mentor Who Could Not Follow Where It Led
- Lecture 5-4: The Tower Experience, and What Luther's Memory May Have Compressed
- Lecture 6-1: What an Indulgence Actually Was
- Lecture 6-2: The Money Behind the Sermon — Albrecht, the Fuggers, and Rome
- Lecture 6-3: Reading the Theses Themselves
- Lecture 6-4: Heidelberg, 1518 — A Theology of the Cross
- Lecture 7-1: Leipzig and the Turn Toward 1520
- Lecture 7-2: Augsburg, 1518 — The First Interrogation
- Lecture 7-3: To the Christian Nobility and the Three Walls
- Lecture 7-4: The Babylonian Captivity and The Freedom of a Christian
- Lecture 8-1: Justification by Faith, Stated Precisely
- Lecture 8-2: The Scriptural Case — Romans, Galatians, and Abraham
- Lecture 8-3: Law and Gospel
- Lecture 8-4: The September Testament and the Word "Allein"
- Lecture 9-1: Karlstadt's Wittenberg and Luther's Return
- Lecture 9-2: The Zwickau Prophets and the Challenge of Spiritualism
- Lecture 9-3: The Invocavit Sermons and the Limits of Force
- Lecture 9-4: Adiaphora — Things Indifferent
- Lecture 10-1: The Twelve Articles of the Peasants
- Lecture 10-2: Thomas Müntzer and the Battle of Frankenhausen
- Lecture 10-3: Luther's Two 1525 Writings on the War
- Lecture 10-4: The Two Kingdoms Doctrine
- Lecture 11-1: The Diets of Speyer and the Protestation
- Lecture 11-2: The Augsburg Confession
- Lecture 11-3: The Schmalkaldic League and Its Defeat at Mühlberg
- Lecture 11-4: The Peace of Augsburg (1555)
- Lecture 12-1: Zwingli's Arrival in Zurich and the Rule of Worship
- Lecture 12-2: Zwingli's Formation — Humanist, Chaplain, Not a Monk
- Lecture 12-3: Sausages and Disputations — Authority Shifts to the Council
- Lecture 12-4: Rebuilding Zurich's Worship
- Lecture 13-1: Stating the Dispute — Real Presence Against Memorial Sign
- Lecture 13-2: The Exegetical Machinery — Communicatio Idiomatum and "The Flesh Profits Nothing"
- Lecture 13-3: The Marburg Colloquy — Fourteen Articles and One That Was Not
- Lecture 13-4: What Settled Out — Two Traditions, and Zwingli's Wars Ahead
- Lecture 14-1: The Swiss Brethren and the First Rebaptisms
- Lecture 14-2: A Capital Crime — Zurich, Rome, and the Drowning of Felix Manz
- Lecture 14-3: The Schleitheim Confession — A Church Fully Separated
- Lecture 14-4: Münster, Menno Simons, and a Movement's Two Faces
- Lecture 15-1: Calvin's Conversion and the First Institutes
- Lecture 15-2: French Evangelicalism and the Affair of the Placards
- Lecture 15-3: The Institutes Across Its Editions, 1536-1559
- Lecture 15-4: Calvin as Commentator and Preacher
- Lecture 16-1: Geneva Twice — Expulsion, Strasbourg, and Return
- Lecture 16-2: The Ecclesiastical Ordinances and the Consistory
- Lecture 16-3: Predestination — Calvin's Pastoral Doctrine and Beza's System
- Lecture 16-4: Michael Servetus and the Geneva Academy
- Lecture 17-1: Why the Genevan Model Traveled
- Lecture 17-2: The Huguenots — Organizing Under Persecution
- Lecture 17-3: The Dutch Reformation and Its Two Confessions
- Lecture 17-4: John Knox and Scottish Presbyterianism
- Lecture 18-1: The King's Great Matter
- Lecture 18-2: Royal Supremacy and the Dissolution of the Monasteries
- Lecture 18-3: Underground Currents — Lollardy and Tyndale's New Testament
- Lecture 18-4: The Six Articles — A Reformed Government, an Unreformed Creed
- Lecture 19-1: Edward's Prayer Book, Twice Revised
- Lecture 19-2: Mary's Restoration and the Smithfield Fires
- Lecture 19-3: Elizabeth's Settlement and the Idea of a Middle Way
- Lecture 19-4: Vestments, and a Reformation Left Unfinished
- Lecture 20-1: Reform Before Luther — Cisneros and the Oratory of Divine Love
- Lecture 20-2: New Orders as Reform Vehicles — Capuchins, Theatines, Ursulines
- Lecture 20-3: The Council of Trent
- Lecture 20-4: Ignatius of Loyola and the Society of Jesus
Luther wrote two documents about the Peasants' War in 1525, and the gap between them is the single most argued-over turn in his career among readers across every tradition this course serves. The first, Admonition to Peace, a Reply to the Twelve Articles of the Peasants in Swabia, was written in April 1525, before the war's worst violence, and it is genuinely even-handed: Luther rebukes the princes at length for the oppression that provoked the peasants' grievances, tells them plainly that they have brought this on themselves, and only then turns to warn the peasants that taking up the sword, whatever their grievances, cannot be justified by the gospel. The second, Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants, followed only weeks later, after Luther had received reports (some exaggerated, some accurate) of spreading violence, monasteries burned, and nobles killed — and it drops the even-handedness almost entirely, urging the princes to "smite, slay, and stab" the rebels without mercy, framing the peasants' revolt as a satanic betrayal of both gospel and civil order that any lord had not merely the right but the Christian duty to crush.
This lecture states plainly what needs to be said: the historical judgment, shared across Lutheran, Reformed, Catholic, and secular historians alike, is that the second tract did lasting damage to Luther's standing among the common people whose earlier grievances Luther had, mere weeks before, taken seriously in print. That judgment is not this course's invention, and it is not limited to Luther's critics — many historians and theologians sympathetic to Luther's larger project reach the same conclusion about this specific document. At the same time, a real defense exists and deserves to be stated in its strongest form, not dismissed as mere apologetics: Luther wrote the second tract believing, on the information he had, that organized violence was actively spreading and might overturn civil order entirely, and his stated theological reasons for opposing revolutionary violence — reasons this lecture will trace to Romans 13 — were consistent, not invented after the fact to excuse a change of heart.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Summarize the content and tone of *Admonition to Peace* and explain specifically how it addresses the princes' own responsibility before it addresses the peasants.
- Summarize the content and tone of *Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants* and identify at least two specific ways its argument and register differ from the first tract.
- State the historical judgment that the second tract damaged Luther's reputation among common people, and name at least one specific piece of evidence or reasoning historians use to support that judgment.
- State the strongest available defense of Luther's shift between the two tracts, and evaluate for yourself whether it answers the criticism or only explains it.
Isn't this the fast that I have chosen: to release the bonds of wickedness, to undo the bands of the yoke, and to let the oppressed go free, and that you break every yoke? Isn't it to distribute your bread to the hungry, and that you bring the poor who are cast out to your house? When you see the naked, that you cover him; and that you not hide yourself from your own flesh?" — Isaiah 58:6-7
World English Bible
Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God. Therefore he who resists the authority, withstands the ordinance of God; and those who withstand will receive to themselves judgment... for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn't bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." — Romans 13:1-2, 4
WEB
This is close to the register of Admonition to Peace's opening address to the princes: a direct charge that oppression of the poor is itself a serious sin, stated in language a reader could easily mistake for a defense of the peasants rather than a rebuke of both sides. Luther's April tract genuinely occupies this register for its first half, and it is worth reading Isaiah 58 alongside it to see how far Luther was, at that point, willing to go in holding the powerful responsible before he turned, in the same document, to warn the powerless against seizing justice by force.
Romans 13 is the text underneath both of Luther's 1525 tracts, and underneath the doctrine of the two kingdoms Lecture 10-4 will draw out at length. Luther's argument, consistent across both documents even as their tone diverges sharply, is that civil authority bears a real, divinely instituted sword, and that private individuals — including sincerely wronged ones — have no standing under this text to seize that sword for themselves. What changes between April and May 1525 is not this underlying argument but Luther's judgment about how urgently and how forcefully it needed to be pressed, given what he believed was happening on the ground.
1. Admonition to Peace: an even-handed document, read in full
Admonition to Peace, published in April 1525 as a direct response to the Twelve Articles, opens by addressing the princes and lords, not the peasants, and Luther does not soften what he says to them. He tells them bluntly that they, not any preacher of "the new gospel," bear primary responsibility for the unrest: their oppressive, arbitrary rule over the peasants has provoked what is happening, and unless they change course, worse is coming, whatever Luther himself does or does not say. He goes through several of the Twelve Articles individually — the demand to elect one's own pastor, the complaint against the death tax, the request to reduce excessive dues — and grants that several of them are just, or at least arguable on their merits, urging the lords to negotiate rather than dismiss the peasants' whole document as sedition.
Having said that, Luther turns to the peasants and states his objection plainly: whatever the justice of specific grievances, taking up the sword to force their remedy cannot be defended from the gospel, because the gospel does not license private individuals to seize the authority Romans 13 reserves for civil rulers. He specifically challenges the peasants' own appeal to Christian freedom (Article 3's language) and to Scripture generally, arguing they have confused a spiritual freedom — freedom from sin's condemnation, freedom of conscience before God — with a license to overturn a social order Scripture never promised to abolish. This is a serious theological argument, not a dismissal, and Admonition to Peace closes urging both sides toward negotiated settlement rather than toward force. Read on its own, without knowing what followed, the tract is a genuinely balanced document: sharp toward the powerful, firm but respectful toward the powerless, and hopeful that reasoned argument could still avert the worst.
2. Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes: what changed, and what did not
Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants, written only weeks later as reports reached Luther of monasteries and castles burned, nobles killed, and organized peasant armies (including forces associated with Müntzer, Lecture 10-2's subject) moving through Thuringia, is a document in a different register almost from its first paragraph. Luther no longer addresses the peasants' grievances at all; the tract assumes their revolt has already crossed from grievance into rebellion, theft, and murder, categories he treats as settling the moral question regardless of what provoked them. His language toward the rebels is deliberately harsh — he calls on the princes to "smite, slay, and stab" without hesitation, arguing that a rebel has already forfeited any claim to mercy by taking up arms against divinely ordained authority, and that a prince who fails to act decisively is failing his own God-given duty to wield the sword against evildoers (again, the Romans 13 logic, now applied without qualification in the rebels' direction).
Two changes between the tracts deserve to be named specifically, because "Luther got harsher" understates what happened. First, the earlier tract's extensive engagement with the Twelve Articles' specific merits disappears entirely; the second tract treats the revolt as a undifferentiated mass to be suppressed, not a document of grievances some of which Luther had, weeks earlier, called just. Second, the earlier tract's call for negotiation is replaced by an explicit call for overwhelming, unhesitating force, applied before rather than after other options are exhausted — Luther argues, in effect, that the moment for negotiation has passed and that hesitation now itself risks greater bloodshed by letting rebellion spread further.
3. The historical judgment, and the strongest defense
The judgment that this second tract damaged Luther's standing among ordinary people for the rest of his life is not a modern imposition on the sources; it is documented in Luther's own lifetime. Contemporary reports describe Luther being jeered and even physically threatened on visits to towns where peasants had suffered under the suppression his tract had urged, and Luther himself, in later writings, acknowledged the tract's harsh reception without ever fully retracting its substance. Roland Bainton's widely read biography Here I Stand states the criticism directly: whatever Luther's stated reasons, the tract's language went beyond what the moment required and cost him credibility as a friend of the common man that he had built across the previous eight years this course has traced. This is not a fringe reading; versions of it appear across Lutheran, Reformed, and secular historical accounts alike.
The strongest defense available does not deny the tract's harshness; it contests whether harshness, in that specific moment, was actually wrong rather than merely unattractive. Defenders, including some modern Luther scholars who take his apocalyptic urgency seriously as a lens on his whole career (Heiko Oberman's work on Luther's sense of living "between God and the Devil" is often cited here), argue that Luther, working from the information reaching him in May 1525 — organized armed bands, burned property, killed nobles, and Müntzer's own explicitly revolutionary preaching circulating in the same territories — reasonably believed that civil order itself, and with it any possibility of continued, peaceful reform, was at genuine risk of collapsing entirely. On this reading, Luther's error, if it was one, was tactical and rhetorical (choosing language that foreclosed any acknowledgment of the peasants' still-legitimate grievances) rather than a betrayal of a settled conviction he had held all along; Romans 13's argument against private violence is present in both tracts, unchanged.
Was the second tract right?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some readers, including some within Lutheran tradition itself, defend the harsh 1525 pamphlet as a necessary, if regrettable, stand against a real and spreading chaos that threatened to discredit reform entirely and hand every opponent of the gospel a vivid excuse to call it seditious. Other readers, including many historians broadly sympathetic to Luther's larger achievement, judge Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes a serious pastoral and moral failure — a document that abandoned, in the space of a few weeks and without acknowledgment, people whose grievances Luther himself had called largely just, and that a genuinely fairer middle course (continued negotiation pressure on the princes, sharper but still qualified language toward the rebels, explicit acknowledgment that the war's causes remained real even as its methods were condemned) remained available and was not taken. This course does not resolve the disagreement for you; it asks you to state clearly which reading you find more persuasive, and why, rather than avoiding the question.
5. Going to the Sources
- Read Admonition to Peace and Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants together, back to back — both are collected in Luther's Works, American Edition, vol. 46 (Fortress Press), and shorter excerpts of both circulate widely in Reformation sourcebooks. Reading them in sequence, as this lecture does, is the point; reading only the second without the first badly distorts Luther's overall position.
- Roland Bainton's Here I Stand (any edition), chapter 21 ("The Reformer as Prophet and Pastor" or the equivalent section covering 1525 in your edition's table of contents), gives a widely respected one-volume account of the episode and its aftermath for Luther's reputation.
In short
- In April 1525 Admonition to Peace rebuked the princes at length, granted that several of the Twelve Articles were just, and urged negotiation. It also warned that the gospel cannot justify taking the sword.
- Weeks later, after reports of burned monasteries and killed nobles, Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants urged princes to "smite, slay, and stab". It ignored the grievances and dropped negotiation.
- Romans 13 underlies both tracts. Civil authority bears the sword, and private persons may not seize it. What changed was Luther's judgment of urgency and tone.
- Historians across traditions judge the second tract damaged Luther's standing with common people. Bainton says its language went beyond what the moment required.
- Defenders, citing Heiko Oberman's work, say Luther reasonably feared civil order would collapse. Critics say a fairer middle course was available. The course asks readers to decide and explain why.
Topic: This lecture compares Luther's two 1525 writings on the Peasants' War, the judgment that the second harmed him, and the strongest defense of his shift.
Remember: The two tracts share the Romans 13 argument against private violence, but they differ sharply in tone and in how they treat the peasants' grievances and negotiation.
Caution: Read the first tract with the second. The lecture does not claim Luther's stated reasons were invented, and it does not resolve whether the defense answers the criticism or only explains it.
One line to carry into ministry: In a crisis, keep holding the powerful to account while you oppose violence, and do not let alarm drop your concern for the wronged.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- *Admonition to Peace* rebukes the princes at length before turning to the peasants. Does that structure change how the tract's ultimate warning against peasant violence should be read, compared to reading the warning in isolation?
- This lecture names a "strongest defense" of the second tract based on what Luther reasonably believed was happening in May 1525. Does a defense based on reasonable belief at the time answer the moral criticism, or only explain why Luther might not have known better?
- The lecture proposes that "a fairer middle course" — continued pressure on the princes alongside sharper but still qualified language toward the rebels — remained available in May 1525. Try to draft, in a few sentences, what such a document might actually have said. Does the exercise make the criticism of Luther's actual tract stronger or weaker?