Lecture 19-3: Elizabeth's Settlement and the Idea of a Middle Way
Contents 85
- Lecture 1-1: The Avignon Papacy and the "Babylonian Captivity"
- Lecture 1-2: The Western (Papal) Schism, 1378-1417
- Lecture 1-3: Conciliarism and the Council of Constance
- Lecture 1-4: Popular Piety on the Eve of Reform
- Lecture 2-1: John Wycliffe and Dominion by Grace
- Lecture 2-2: The Lollards and the Wycliffite English Bible
- Lecture 2-3: Jan Hus at Prague
- Lecture 2-4: The Council of Constance and the Execution of Hus
- Lecture 3-1: Ad Fontes — The Renaissance Recovery of Languages and Its Christian Turn
- Lecture 3-2: Northern Christian Humanism as a Reform Movement — Reuchlin and Colet
- Lecture 3-3: Erasmus's Greek New Testament — Scholarship, Limits, and Consequences
- Lecture 3-4: Erasmus and the Reformation — Alliance and Rupture
- Lecture 4-1: The Printing Press and the Speed of an Idea
- Lecture 4-2: Cities, Guilds, and Universities as Carriers of Reform
- Lecture 4-3: The Holy Roman Empire and the Grievances of the German Nation
- Lecture 4-4: Europe Around 1500 — A Different Moment, Not a Destined One
- Lecture 5-1: An Unremarkable Beginning
- Lecture 5-2: The Vow at Stotternheim and Entry into the Cloister
- Lecture 5-3: Anfechtung and the Mentor Who Could Not Follow Where It Led
- Lecture 5-4: The Tower Experience, and What Luther's Memory May Have Compressed
- Lecture 6-1: What an Indulgence Actually Was
- Lecture 6-2: The Money Behind the Sermon — Albrecht, the Fuggers, and Rome
- Lecture 6-3: Reading the Theses Themselves
- Lecture 6-4: Heidelberg, 1518 — A Theology of the Cross
- Lecture 7-1: Leipzig and the Turn Toward 1520
- Lecture 7-2: Augsburg, 1518 — The First Interrogation
- Lecture 7-3: To the Christian Nobility and the Three Walls
- Lecture 7-4: The Babylonian Captivity and The Freedom of a Christian
- Lecture 8-1: Justification by Faith, Stated Precisely
- Lecture 8-2: The Scriptural Case — Romans, Galatians, and Abraham
- Lecture 8-3: Law and Gospel
- Lecture 8-4: The September Testament and the Word "Allein"
- Lecture 9-1: Karlstadt's Wittenberg and Luther's Return
- Lecture 9-2: The Zwickau Prophets and the Challenge of Spiritualism
- Lecture 9-3: The Invocavit Sermons and the Limits of Force
- Lecture 9-4: Adiaphora — Things Indifferent
- Lecture 10-1: The Twelve Articles of the Peasants
- Lecture 10-2: Thomas Müntzer and the Battle of Frankenhausen
- Lecture 10-3: Luther's Two 1525 Writings on the War
- Lecture 10-4: The Two Kingdoms Doctrine
- Lecture 11-1: The Diets of Speyer and the Protestation
- Lecture 11-2: The Augsburg Confession
- Lecture 11-3: The Schmalkaldic League and Its Defeat at Mühlberg
- Lecture 11-4: The Peace of Augsburg (1555)
- Lecture 12-1: Zwingli's Arrival in Zurich and the Rule of Worship
- Lecture 12-2: Zwingli's Formation — Humanist, Chaplain, Not a Monk
- Lecture 12-3: Sausages and Disputations — Authority Shifts to the Council
- Lecture 12-4: Rebuilding Zurich's Worship
- Lecture 13-1: Stating the Dispute — Real Presence Against Memorial Sign
- Lecture 13-2: The Exegetical Machinery — Communicatio Idiomatum and "The Flesh Profits Nothing"
- Lecture 13-3: The Marburg Colloquy — Fourteen Articles and One That Was Not
- Lecture 13-4: What Settled Out — Two Traditions, and Zwingli's Wars Ahead
- Lecture 14-1: The Swiss Brethren and the First Rebaptisms
- Lecture 14-2: A Capital Crime — Zurich, Rome, and the Drowning of Felix Manz
- Lecture 14-3: The Schleitheim Confession — A Church Fully Separated
- Lecture 14-4: Münster, Menno Simons, and a Movement's Two Faces
- Lecture 15-1: Calvin's Conversion and the First Institutes
- Lecture 15-2: French Evangelicalism and the Affair of the Placards
- Lecture 15-3: The Institutes Across Its Editions, 1536-1559
- Lecture 15-4: Calvin as Commentator and Preacher
- Lecture 16-1: Geneva Twice — Expulsion, Strasbourg, and Return
- Lecture 16-2: The Ecclesiastical Ordinances and the Consistory
- Lecture 16-3: Predestination — Calvin's Pastoral Doctrine and Beza's System
- Lecture 16-4: Michael Servetus and the Geneva Academy
- Lecture 17-1: Why the Genevan Model Traveled
- Lecture 17-2: The Huguenots — Organizing Under Persecution
- Lecture 17-3: The Dutch Reformation and Its Two Confessions
- Lecture 17-4: John Knox and Scottish Presbyterianism
- Lecture 18-1: The King's Great Matter
- Lecture 18-2: Royal Supremacy and the Dissolution of the Monasteries
- Lecture 18-3: Underground Currents — Lollardy and Tyndale's New Testament
- Lecture 18-4: The Six Articles — A Reformed Government, an Unreformed Creed
- Lecture 19-1: Edward's Prayer Book, Twice Revised
- Lecture 19-2: Mary's Restoration and the Smithfield Fires
- Lecture 19-3: Elizabeth's Settlement and the Idea of a Middle Way
- Lecture 19-4: Vestments, and a Reformation Left Unfinished
- Lecture 20-1: Reform Before Luther — Cisneros and the Oratory of Divine Love
- Lecture 20-2: New Orders as Reform Vehicles — Capuchins, Theatines, Ursulines
- Lecture 20-3: The Council of Trent
- Lecture 20-4: Ignatius of Loyola and the Society of Jesus
Elizabeth I came to the throne in November 1558, twenty-five years old, having survived her half-sister's reign under real suspicion of Protestant sympathy and real personal danger — she had spent time imprisoned in the Tower during Mary's reign, on suspicion (never proven) of involvement in a rebellion against Mary's Spanish marriage. What Elizabeth actually believed, theologically, in private, is one of the harder questions in Tudor religious history, and this lecture will not pretend to answer it with more confidence than the evidence supports. What she built as a matter of public policy within the first year of her reign is much better documented, and it is the subject of this lecture: a settlement designed, deliberately, not to state the fullest, clearest Protestant doctrine England's Reformed exiles wanted, but to construct a single national church wide enough that most of Mary's conforming Catholic subjects and most of Edward's surviving Protestants could, with some discomfort, worship inside the same building under the same liturgy.
Two Acts of Parliament in 1559 did the legal work. The Act of Supremacy made Elizabeth "Supreme Governor" of the Church of England — not "Supreme Head," the title Henry had claimed and Mary had abolished — a change in wording this lecture takes seriously rather than treating as decoration. The Act of Uniformity required the use of a revised Book of Common Prayer (based on the 1552 book, with some conservative softening) in every parish, with penalties for nonattendance and for clergy who refused to use it. Twelve years later, the Thirty-Nine Articles (1571, a revision of Edward's Forty-Two) supplied the settlement's doctrinal statement — Reformed in substance, but worded, in places, to avoid forcing a decision on questions where English Protestants themselves disagreed. This chapter's fourth lecture will show what this settlement's critics thought was still missing. This lecture's task is to show what Elizabeth actually built, on its own terms, before that argument starts.
What these 17 minutes give you
- Explain what changed, and why it mattered, in the shift from "Supreme Head" to "Supreme Governor" between Henry's and Elizabeth's acts of supremacy.
- State what the Act of Uniformity actually required and enforced, and distinguish "the settlement tolerated private Catholic belief" from "the settlement tolerated public Catholic worship" — they are not the same claim.
- Describe Richard Hooker's "threefold authority" of Scripture, tradition and reason as a theological defense of the settlement, and explain what work each of the three is doing in his argument.
- Explain why "via media" is a defensible description of Elizabeth's settlement in some respects and a misleading one in others.
Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God." — Matthew 5:9
World English Bible
The saying is faithful and worthy of all acceptance, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners; of whom I am chief." — 1 Timothy 1:15
WEB
Matthew 5:9 was, and still is, the text most naturally reached for by defenders of Elizabeth's settlement, and this lecture uses it deliberately rather than only reporting its historical use: a church built to end forty years of English Christians burning and imprisoning each other over doctrine has some real claim to be doing peacemaking work, in a sense this beatitude can plausibly cover. But the pairing with 1 Timothy 1:15 is meant to keep that claim honest. Paul's confession that Christ came "to save sinners; of whom I am chief" is a statement of doctrinal content he refused to soften for the sake of anyone's comfort — the same letter goes on, a few verses later, to warn Timothy to "wage the good warfare" by holding to right doctrine (1 Timothy 1:18-19). A settlement built for breadth has to answer whether it is making peace in Matthew 5:9's sense or simply declining to say, as 1 Timothy 1:15 says, what it actually believes salvation requires. This chapter does not resolve that question for the reader; §4 returns to it directly.
1. "Supreme Governor," not "Supreme Head" — a change worth taking seriously
Henry's 1534 Act of Supremacy (Chapter 18) named the king "Supreme Head" of the Church of England, a title that put the monarch in a position analogous to the pope's within English Christendom — head of the church's body, not merely its chief civil officer. Elizabeth's 1559 act deliberately chose different language: "Supreme Governor." The change served an immediate political need — a woman claiming to be "head" of Christ's church sat badly with some in a culture that would not have accepted a female bishop, and Elizabeth's own Protestant advisers, not only her Catholic opponents, raised the objection. But the change also did real theological work that outlasted the immediate occasion: "governor" describes civil oversight and administrative authority over the church's temporal affairs, while leaving the claim to spiritual headship — a title most English Protestants, following continental Reformed thinking, were content to reserve for — unclaimed by the crown. It is a small change in one word, and this course's habit throughout has been to notice exactly this kind of small change (Chapter 8's allein in Luther's Romans 3:28, this chapter's own first lecture on 1549 versus 1552) because small changes in official language are frequently where a settlement's real theological commitments are legible.
2. What the Act of Uniformity actually required
The Act of Uniformity required every parish in England to use the revised 1559 Prayer Book and no other service, and required every subject to attend that service on Sundays and holy days or pay a fine. It did not require anyone to state a private belief, take a doctrinal oath, or affirm the Thirty-Nine Articles as a condition of ordinary church attendance — a genuine and significant difference from Mary's heresy laws, which had prosecuted private conviction directly. This distinction matters and should not be blurred in either direction. It is true that Elizabeth's settlement, in its first decades, allowed a great many quietly Catholic English subjects to attend the required services (sometimes called "church papists" by contemporaries) while privately holding to the old faith, in a way Mary's regime had made impossible for convinced Protestants. It is equally true that the settlement did not tolerate public Catholic worship, the Mass, or allegiance to papal authority over the English church, and that the penalties for recusancy (refusing to attend the required services at all) escalated significantly later in Elizabeth's reign, especially after the 1570 papal bull excommunicating her and after several plots against her life implicated Catholic conspirators. "Elizabeth's England tolerated Catholics" and "Elizabeth's England tolerated Catholicism" are different claims, and only a qualified version of the first one is defensible for this period.
3. Richard Hooker's threefold authority: a theological defense written after the fact
The settlement's classic theological defense came later, from Richard Hooker, whose Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical (published across the 1590s, decades after the 1559 acts) argued against Puritan critics — the next lecture's subject — that a church's practice need not be governed by Scripture alone in every particular. Hooker's structure runs, in rough summary: Scripture is the supreme and sufficient authority for what is necessary to salvation, full stop, no rival claim there. But Scripture does not, and was never intended to, specify every detail of church government, ceremony and order; for those matters, the church may draw additionally on the tradition of the church's own accumulated practice and on reason — the God-given faculty by which human beings judge what is fitting, orderly and edifying in circumstances Scripture itself does not address. Where a Puritan critic read Zwingli's rule from Chapter 12 — whatever Scripture does not command should be removed from worship — as the only defensible starting point, Hooker was working from something closer to Luther's more permissive principle in Chapter 9: whatever Scripture does not forbid may, if reason and tradition commend it, be retained.
Tradition and reason
This is a point where readers will not agree. A Reformed reader shaped by Zwingli's or Calvin's regulative instinct will likely hear Hooker's "tradition and reason" as an opening for exactly the kind of unscriptural accretion the Reformation existed to strip away — the same objection this chapter's next lecture will show the Puritans making directly and specifically, about vestments. A reader more sympathetic to Anglican, Catholic or Orthodox accounts of tradition's proper role will likely hear Hooker as simply correct that Scripture was never meant to function as a complete manual for church order, and that treating it as one produces exactly the kind of scrupulous, contentious church life the Vestments Controversy will illustrate. Hooker's own argument deserves to be read, not only summarized from either side's objection to it — see §5.
4. "Via media": a fair description of some things, a misleading one for others
Elizabeth's settlement a via media, a middle way, is accurate for what it was built to do institutionally: hold one national church together across a doctrinal spread that, on the continent, had already split into separate Lutheran, Reformed, Anabaptist and Catholic churches unable to share a communion table. It is a much less accurate description of the Thirty-Nine Articles' actual doctrinal content, which — on by faith, on (Article XVII, cautiously worded but genuinely Reformed in substance), on the rejection of and of papal authority — sits recognizably within the Reformed Protestant family this course has been tracing since Zwingli, not at some theological midpoint between Geneva and Rome. The "middle way" is a description of the settlement's comprehension strategy — how wide a range of belief and practice it tried to hold inside one church's boundary — not of where its own confessional center of gravity actually sat. Readers who have heard "via media" used to suggest Anglicanism as doctrinally halfway between Protestant and Catholic positions should hold that claim loosely against what the Articles themselves actually say.
5. Going to the Sources
Read Book I of Richard Hooker's Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity (widely available in modern critical editions and searchable online; Book I is the general statement of his method before he turns to specific Puritan objections in later books), particularly his treatment of the relationship between the "law of reason" and the authority of Scripture. Reading Hooker's own careful qualifications — he does not claim reason or tradition can override or add to Scripture on matters necessary to salvation — is the only way to judge fairly whether the Puritan objection in the next lecture is answering the argument Hooker actually made or a simpler version of it.
In short
- Elizabeth's 1559 Act of Supremacy made her "Supreme Governor," not "Supreme Head." Governor claims civil oversight and leaves spiritual headship, which most English Protestants reserved for Christ, unclaimed.
- The Act of Uniformity required every parish to use the revised Prayer Book and every subject to attend. It did not require a doctrinal oath or police private belief.
- The settlement tolerated Catholics who conformed, but not public Catholic worship. Penalties for recusancy (refusing to attend) rose later, after the 1570 papal bull and plots against her.
- Richard Hooker defended the settlement in the 1590s. Scripture is supreme for what is necessary to salvation, while tradition and reason guide matters Scripture leaves open.
- Readers disagree on Hooker. Reformed readers may see an opening for unscriptural additions. Anglican, Catholic and Orthodox readers may see him as right about tradition.
- "Via media" fits the settlement's wide strategy for holding one church together. It fits the Thirty-Nine Articles poorly, since their content is Reformed in substance.
Topic: This lecture explains Elizabeth's 1559 settlement, its legal terms, Hooker's defence of it, and whether "via media" (middle way) describes it fairly.
Remember: The settlement was wide in who it held inside one church, but the Thirty-Nine Articles were Reformed in doctrine, not halfway between Geneva and Rome.
Caution: "Elizabeth tolerated Catholics" and "Elizabeth tolerated Catholicism" are different claims. Only a qualified form of the first is defensible.
One line to carry into ministry: Ask of any broad church both questions: what does it require people to do, and what does it officially teach?
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The lecture distinguishes "tolerating Catholics" from "tolerating Catholicism" under Elizabeth's settlement. Is that a distinction with a real moral difference, or is it a way of making a fairly narrow religious freedom sound more generous than it was?
- Hooker argues that Scripture is sufficient for salvation but was never meant to specify every detail of church order, and that tradition and reason properly fill that remaining space. State, in your own words, the strongest version of the Reformed objection to this — not a caricature of it — before deciding whether you find Hooker's answer adequate.
- The lecture argues that "via media" fairly describes the settlement's comprehension strategy but not its doctrinal content. Can a national church's real character be judged more by what it requires everyone to do (attend one liturgy) or by what it officially teaches (the Articles)? What would change about how you'd answer that question if you were a conforming Catholic in 1560, versus a convinced Puritan in 1570?