Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
- Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
- Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
- Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
- Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
- Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
- Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
- Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
- Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
- Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
- Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
- Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
- Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
- Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
- Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
- Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
- Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
- Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
- Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
- Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
- Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
- Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
- Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
- Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
- Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
- Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
- Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
- Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
Arius was a senior presbyter in Alexandria — an able preacher with a substantial following, including a number of consecrated virgins and, before long, several bishops. He was not a maverick. He believed he was defending the most basic thing Christians and Jews had always said about God: that God is one, unbegotten, without beginning, and utterly unlike anything he has made.
His argument ran like this. If the Son was begotten, then there was a point at which the begetting happened. If there was such a point, then the Son had a beginning. And whatever has a beginning is on the creature's side of the line between God and everything else — however exalted, however far above all other creatures, however genuinely the agent through whom the world was made.
The slogan his opponents quoted against him is his own: "There was when he was not."
This lecture is about why that sentence had to be rejected, why the rejection took a word that is not in the Bible and had been condemned once before, and why the fight then went on for another fifty-six years.
What these 20 minutes give you
- State Arius's position in its strongest form, including the concern about God's oneness that motivated it, and identify the biblical texts he relied on.
- Explain Athanasius's argument from salvation — that only the Creator can re-create — and why he held that the dispute could not be settled by compromise.
- Describe how and why the Council of Nicaea was convened, and what was political about it.
- Explain what *homoousios* asserted, why many perfectly orthodox bishops resisted it, and what the difference from *homoiousios* actually was.
In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." — John 1:1
World English Bible
The verse both sides quoted. Notice that it contains the whole problem in one sentence: the Word is with God, which distinguishes them, and the Word is God, which does not. Any account that makes either clause easy has lost something. That is why this took a century.
1. The strongest form of Arius's case
Take Arius seriously first. A course that presents him as obviously absurd cannot explain why so much of the church agreed with him for so long.
He was defending monotheism. For a Jew or a Christian in the ancient world, the single most important thing to say about God was that he is one, and that he is not a member of a class. Everything else either is God or is made. There is no third category. Arius's charge against his bishop was that talk of an eternally begotten Son was smuggling in a second God, and that this was exactly what the surrounding paganism would hear.
He had texts. Proverbs 8:22, read as the voice of Wisdom identified with the Son — "Yahweh possessed me in the beginning of his work" — where the Greek version could be read as created me. Colossians 1:15, "the firstborn of all creation". John 14:28, "the Father is greater than I". Mark 13:32, where the Son does not know the day or the hour. These are not marginal verses, and any orthodox reading has to account for all of them.
He had precedent. Subordinationism — treating the Son as genuinely divine but somehow less than the Father — was widespread and untroubling in the third century. Origen, the most influential theologian the Greek church had produced, used language that later readers found alarming. Arius could reasonably claim to be conservative.
And his Son is not a small figure. He is the first and greatest of all God's works, the one through whom everything else was made, worshipped by the church, existing before all ages. Arius is not saying Jesus is merely a good man. He is saying that Jesus stands on the created side of a line — the highest thing there, but on that side.
What was actually wrong with it is the line itself. If there is a boundary between God and creation, and the Son is on the creature's side, then Christians are worshipping a creature. That is idolatry by the church's own definition. Arius's position ends in either a worshipped creature or a demoted Christ, and the church could accept neither.
One caution. Modern scholarship has taken apart the tidy picture of two parties, "Arians" and "Nicenes", fighting for a century. Lewis Ayres and R. P. C. Hanson have shown that most bishops in the middle were neither, that "Arian" became a slur applied to people with little connection to Arius, and that the church genuinely did not know the answer in advance. Rowan Williams's study reconstructs Arius as a serious conservative theologian. Nobody in 320 was choosing between orthodoxy and heresy; they were trying to work out what could be said.
2. Athanasius: the argument that this was not about words
Athanasius was a young accompanying his bishop at Nicaea, and he spent the next forty-five years on this question. His decisive contribution is a single line of reasoning, and it is not philosophical but soteriological.
The human problem, as he states it in On the , is corruption and death — the creature falling back toward the nothing it was made from. What is needed is not improvement but re-creation. And here is the argument:
Only the one who made can re-make. A creature, however exalted, cannot restore creation to God, because a creature does not have that to give. If the Son is not God, then what happened in Christ is that God sent an intermediary to do something only God can do — and it did not get done.
Athanasius adds a second point that presses on the church's own practice. Christians worship Jesus, and pray to him, and are baptised into his name. If he is a creature, the church has been committing idolatry in its central act since the beginning. Either the worship stops or the Son is God, and nobody was proposing to stop the worship.
This is why Athanasius would not compromise, and why he was so hard to deal with. To him a negotiated middle position was not diplomacy but a proposal to have a Saviour who cannot save.
3. Nicaea, 325: what kind of meeting it was
The dispute spread through Egypt and beyond, and Constantine — who had just reunited the empire and wanted the church to hold it together, not divide it — summoned bishops from across the empire to Nicaea in Bithynia. Chapter 4 described the machinery: he convened it, paid for the travel, provided the venue, opened it, and afterwards enforced its decision by exile.
Some accurate detail, since this council is heavily mythologised.
Around three hundred bishops attended; the traditional figure of 318 is symbolic, matching the number of Abraham's servants in Genesis 14:14. Almost all were from the East; the West sent a handful, and the bishop of Rome sent representatives rather than attending. Constantine seems to have opened the council and taken part in the discussion, while Hosius of Cordoba, his ecclesiastical adviser, apparently chaired much of the business.
Two things Nicaea did not do, both of which are widely believed.
Two common myths
It did not decide the of Scripture. No ancient source says it did; lecture 3-3 gave the actual history.
It did not produce the creed most Christians recite. The said in churches today is the longer text associated with Constantinople in 381 — properly the Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed. The creed of 325 is shorter, ends abruptly after "and in the Holy Spirit", and has a set of anathemas attached, condemning by name those who say "there was when he was not".
4. Homoousios: the word, and why it frightened people
The council needed a form of words that Arius's supporters could not sign. They tried scriptural phrases and found that the Arian party could accept all of them with a straight face — "from God", "the ", "like the Father" all admit an Arian reading.
So they chose a word that could not be evaded: homoousios, "of the same being" — the Son is not merely like the Father, but is what the Father is.
Now notice three things about that choice, because they explain the next half-century.
The word is not in the Bible. For a church that had just spent a century insisting on apostolic sources against the Gnostics, adopting a non-scriptural term to define the faith was a genuine difficulty, and it was raised at the time.
The word had a bad history. Homoousios had been used by Paul of Samosata and had been condemned by a synod at Antioch in 268. Bishops who resisted it were not being obstructive; they were pointing out that the church had already rejected this word once.
And it could be misread. In some usages homoousios suggests two things sharing a common stuff, which sounds like two Gods made of the same material, or like the Father and Son being merely two names for one thing. Both were errors the East wanted to avoid.
So the council chose a word that was unscriptural, previously condemned, and ambiguous — because every alternative could be signed by people who meant the opposite. That is what it looks like when a church fences a mystery rather than explaining it. Homoousios does not tell you how the Son is God. It tells you which sentence you may not say.
5. The famous iota, and what the story gets wrong
The story everyone knows is that the whole controversy came down to one letter: homoousios, of the same being, against homoiousios, of like being — and that this shows either the church's precision or its absurdity, depending on who is telling it.
Correct the story, because it distorts the history.
Homoiousios was not Arius's position. Arius held the Son to be a creature; "of like being" is a much stronger claim than he would make. The homoiousian party appears in the 350s, a generation after Nicaea, and it was a moderate position — held by men who wanted to affirm the Son's real likeness to the Father in being while avoiding a word they thought dangerous.
And here is the part that matters. Athanasius himself came to treat them as allies. In his work on the councils he writes about the homoiousians as brothers who mean what the Nicenes mean and are quarrelling about a term. Most of them ended up on the Nicene side, and their leaders were instrumental in the settlement of 381.
So the iota is a real difference and it is not the difference between orthodoxy and heresy. It is the difference between two ways of saying nearly the same thing, in a period when the vocabulary had not yet been fixed — which is exactly what lecture 5-2 is about.
6. What the council actually did
Nicaea did not end the controversy. Within a few years the Arian party had recovered politically, and for most of the next half-century the empire's bishops leaned away from Nicaea, not toward it.
What Nicaea did was set a boundary and refuse to move it. It said: whatever the relation of the Son to the Father is, it is not the relation of a creature to its maker. That is a negative statement. It leaves the mystery entirely intact and rules out one road.
The creeds fence the mystery rather than explain it. Nicaea does not tell you how God can be one and the Son be God. It tells you that "there was when he was not" is not a sentence Christians may say — and it took a hundred and thirty years, five exiles and a great deal of politics to make that stick.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Question | Arius | Nicaea |
|---|---|---|
| Where does the Son stand? | On the created side — the first and highest of God's works | On God's side: begotten, not made |
| The driving concern | The oneness of God; no second divine being | Salvation; only the Creator can re-create a creature |
| Key texts | Proverbs 8:22, Colossians 1:15, John 14:28, Mark 13:32 | John 1:1, and the church's practice of worshipping Christ |
| Chosen term | The Son is unlike the Father in being | Homoousios — of the same being |
| The cost of the term | — | Unscriptural, condemned at Antioch in 268, and open to misreading |
| Frequently misstated | That his opponents differed by one letter | Homoiousios is a later moderate position, not Arius's |
5. Going to the Sources
- Athanasius, On the Incarnation — an evening's reading, and the clearest statement anywhere of why the divinity of the Son is a question about salvation.
- The Creed of Nicaea (325), with its anathemas — one page. Read the anathemas, which are usually omitted, and note that the council's decisive work is in what it forbids.
- The letters of Arius, and Alexander of Alexandria's letters against him — surviving fragments, and short. Arius arguing in his own words is a different experience from Arius summarised.
- Athanasius, On the Councils (De Synodis) 41 — where he treats the homoiousians as brothers who mean the right thing. The single best corrective to the two-party picture.
In short
- Arius, a respected Alexandrian presbyter, defended God's oneness. If the Son was begotten, the Son had a beginning and stands on the creature's side. His slogan was "There was when he was not."
- The lecture says this ends in a worshipped creature or a demoted Christ. Scholars such as Ayres and Hanson also show that most bishops were neither "Arian" nor "Nicene."
- Athanasius argued from salvation: only the one who made can re-make. If the Son were a creature, Christians would be worshipping a creature in their central act.
- Constantine summoned about three hundred bishops to Nicaea in 325. The council did not decide the canon and did not produce the creed recited today, which comes from 381.
- The council chose homoousios, "of the same being." It was unscriptural, once condemned and ambiguous, but could not be signed by Arius's supporters.
- Homoiousios, "of like being," was a later moderate position, and Athanasius treated its holders as allies. The creed fences a mystery rather than explaining it.
Topic: Why the church rejected Arius's view of the Son at Nicaea, and what the word homoousios did and did not claim.
Remember: Nicaea set a boundary and refused to move it: the Son's relation to the Father is not that of a creature to its maker. It did not explain how.
Caution: The controversy was not two tidy parties, and the one-letter difference was not the line between orthodoxy and heresy. Nicaea did not end the dispute.
One line to carry into ministry: State an opponent's case so that they would recognise it, then ask what the church already does in worship and what that implies.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- State Arius's case so that someone who held it would recognise it. What did you have to concede to do that, and was the concession costly?
- Athanasius argued from what the church already did — it worshipped Jesus — to what must therefore be true. Is that a sound way to argue? Where else does your tradition reason from practice to doctrine?
- Nicaea chose a word that was unscriptural and had been condemned. What justifies that, and what would justify it now?
- The council fenced the mystery rather than explaining it. Is that a failure of nerve or an act of honesty? What would an explanation have cost?