Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
- Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
- Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
- Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
- Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
- Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
- Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
- Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
- Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
- Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
- Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
- Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
- Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
- Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
- Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
- Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
- Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
- Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
A woman tells a deacon that her doctor has suggested a kind of help for the heaviness she has carried for a long time, and that she is afraid it means she has failed as a believer. A man tells his small-group leader that a visitor at church told him he should stop taking what his doctor prescribed and trust God instead. A father says, "We have prayed for months and nothing has changed. Does God not hear us, or have we been doing it wrong?" Each of them is asking, in a different way, how prayer and treatment belong together.
This lecture gives the answer the course holds to in every week: prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. They are not rivals. A person may need both, and a leader's task is to make room for both.
This lecture, and this course, is not medical or psychological advice, not diagnosis and not treatment. It does not say what kind of help any person needs, it names no medicine and no method, and it does not replace professional care. A leader must never advise anyone to stop taking, or to change, a medicine. Any change belongs to the doctor or other professional who prescribed it and who knows the person.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Explain, in your own words, why prayer does not replace treatment and treatment does not replace faith.
- Name two or three places in Scripture where prayer and practical remedy sit side by side.
- Say what a leader does, and what a leader never does, when a person mentions a medicine or a professional.
- Respond kindly to a person who says they were told to stop treatment, without giving medical advice.
- Explain why Scripture must never be used as a weapon against a person who is struggling.
Jesus answered them, “Those who are healthy have no need for a physician, but those who are sick do." — Luke 5:31
World English Bible
Go, and tell Hezekiah, ‘Thus says Yahweh, the God of David your father, “I have heard your prayer. I have seen your tears. Behold, I will add fifteen years to your life." — Isaiah 38:5
WEB
Now Isaiah had said, “Let them take a cake of figs, and lay it for a poultice on the boil, and he shall recover.”" — Isaiah 38:21
WEB
Be no longer a drinker of water only, but use a little wine for your stomach’s sake and your frequent infirmities." — 1 Timothy 5:23
WEB
Luke, the beloved physician, and Demas greet you." — Colossians 4:14
WEB
came to him, and bound up his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. He set him on his own animal, and brought him to an inn, and took care of him." — Luke 10:34
WEB
On the next day, when he departed, he took out two denarii, and gave them to the host, and said to him, ‘Take care of him. Whatever you spend beyond that, I will repay you when I return.’" — Luke 10:35
WEB
He heals the broken in heart, and binds up their wounds." — Psalm 147:3
WEB
In nothing be anxious, but in everything, by prayer and petition with thanksgiving, let your requests be made known to God." — Philippians 4:6
WEB
And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and your thoughts in Christ Jesus." — Philippians 4:7
WEB
He won’t break a bruised reed. He won’t quench a smoking flax, until he leads justice to victory." — Matthew 12:20
WEB
Scripture does not set prayer against practical care. Jesus says that the sick need a physician (Luke 5:31). King Hezekiah prays and is heard, and a poultice is laid on his boil in the same chapter (Isaiah 38:5, 38:21). Paul gives his younger colleague simple advice for his stomach and his frequent illnesses (1 Timothy 5:23), and he calls Luke "the beloved physician" in a greeting (Colossians 4:14). In Jesus' story the Samaritan binds the wounds, takes the man to an inn and pays for his care (Luke 10:34-35). The psalm says that God heals the broken in heart and binds up their wounds (Psalm 147:3). Paul asks that requests be made known to God in prayer, and promises God's peace (Philippians 4:6-7). None of these verses is a medical instruction. They show that Scripture does not set the two against each other.
A plain statement first
Before anything else, three sentences.
- This course does not tell anyone what treatment they need, and a leader must not do so either.
- A leader never advises a person to stop or to change a medicine. That decision belongs to the person's prescriber or treating professional.
- This course does not replace professional care, and a leader who offers prayer and company is not offering a substitute for it.
The rest of the lecture explains why these three sentences are not cold, and why they sit easily beside a warm and faithful pastoral life.
Two false choices
Many people have been taught, without anyone saying it plainly, that they must choose.
"Pray, do not treat." This choice says that to go to a doctor, a counsellor or a clinic is to doubt God. If prayer were strong enough, the thinking goes, no other help would be needed. This choice comes from love of God and from a real belief that God can heal. But it makes the person's faith into a test that they might fail. A person who is still struggling after prayer is then told, or leads themselves to believe, that the failure is theirs.
"Treat, do not pray." This choice says that since a doctor or a counsellor is now involved, the church has nothing more to give. It comes from respect for professionals and from fear of overstepping. But it leaves the person without the things a church is for: prayer, the Scriptures, the sacraments in traditions that hold them, company, a place to belong, and the questions of meaning that no clinic is set up to answer.
The truth is neither. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. A person may need a doctor and a pastor, a counsellor and a prayer partner, a family meal and a clinic appointment. They are different gifts that do different work.
What Scripture shows
We should be careful not to ask Scripture to settle questions of medicine. It does not. But its pictures show something steady: God's people pray and use what is at hand, and the Bible does not see a contradiction.
Hezekiah (Isaiah 38). The king is gravely ill. He prays, and God says, "I have heard your prayer. I have seen your tears" (Isaiah 38:5). Then, later in the same chapter, "Now Isaiah had said, 'Let them take a cake of figs, and lay it for a poultice on the boil, and he shall recover'" (Isaiah 38:21). The same story gives us a prayer heard and a plain remedy applied. The story does not tell us that one of these did the work and the other did not. It does not tell us how to treat any condition, and nothing in this course should be read as treating Hezekiah's remedy as a model. It shows only that the text sees no conflict.
Paul and Timothy (1 Timothy 5:23). Paul writes, "Be no longer a drinker of water only, but use a little wine for your stomach's sake and your frequent infirmities." An apostle gives a young leader a practical suggestion for his health. He does not tell him to pray harder instead. (This verse is not advice about food or drink for anyone today. It is a picture of a leader's body being taken seriously.)
Luke the physician (Colossians 4:14). Among Paul's companions is Luke, "the beloved physician." He is greeted with affection in the same letter that speaks of prayer and ministry. The early church had a doctor among its helpers and called him beloved.
The Samaritan (Luke 10). In Jesus' story, the traveller who stops does what a neighbour does: he binds the wounds, sets the man on his own animal, brings him to an inn, and pays for his care (Luke 10:34-35). He does not stop at a kind word. He stays involved and he connects the man to a place where he can be looked after. That is, in a small way, the pattern of this course.
Jesus on need. "Those who are healthy have no need for a physician, but those who are sick do" (Luke 5:31). Jesus was speaking about sinners and those who need him, but he used an ordinary truth to do it: the sick need a physician. He did not mock that truth.
God who binds up. "He heals the broken in heart, and binds up their wounds" (Psalm 147:3). God's care is described in the language of a healer. A leader who believes this can also hold that God works through the hands of doctors, nurses, counsellors and other professionals. Many traditions say so plainly.
Prayer and peace. Paul asks that requests be made known to God "by prayer and petition with thanksgiving," and promises that the peace of God will guard hearts and thoughts (Philippians 4:6-7). Many people take comfort from these verses, and they should not be taken away. But they are not a promise that a struggle will end on a timetable, and they are never to be used to say, "If you prayed properly you would not need help." A verse is a gift to be offered, not a weapon.
Traditions speak differently about healing, about anointing and about the way God acts through ordinary means. This course does not take up those differences here. Lecture 3-3 deals with how spiritual and medical explanations relate. On the point of this lecture, the traditions that we know of agree on one thing: the sick should seek help, and prayer is not a reason to refuse it.
Treatment does not replace faith
The other half matters equally. A person who has found a good doctor or counsellor has not thereby lost the need for the church. What a church can give, no clinic is set up to give:
- Company. A person who is struggling is often alone. The church can sit with them (Ecclesiastes 4:9-10 says that two are better than one).
- Prayer, if the person wants it, and the Scriptures read slowly.
- Meaning and hope. Questions such as "Is this my fault?", "Where is God in this?" and "Will I be welcome again?" are spiritual and personal. A professional may listen to them, but the church has its own words.
- A place to belong. A seat at the meal, a part in the life of the community, a way to be useful again when the person is ready.
- The sacraments or practices of the tradition, where the person wants them.
The leader should not make the person feel that going to a doctor has put them outside the church's care. On the contrary: it is a good moment for the church to say, "We are glad you went. We are still here."
What a leader does, and does not do
A leader does:
- Say, if it is true and the person seems to need to hear it, that seeking professional help is not a lack of faith. One sentence is enough.
- Ask, "What would help you most from us?" and offer prayer, company or practical help, as the person chooses.
- Keep in touch during treatment, without questioning.
- Pray with the person if they want it, and not push prayer on anyone who does not.
- Encourage the person to keep in touch with their doctor or other professional, and to tell them about their concerns.
A leader does not:
- Advise anyone to stop, start, skip or change a medicine, or to take less or more.
- Say or imply that a medicine, a clinic or a counsellor shows weak faith.
- Say or imply that prayer should be enough.
- Promise that prayer will cure the person, or give a date.
- Ask what a person takes or why, as a way of judging it.
- Name or recommend any product, programme or method.
If a person asks the leader's opinion about a medicine, the plain answer is: "I am not able to advise on that. Your doctor is the right person to ask. I will gladly pray with you and help you get to the appointment, if that would be useful."
When someone says they were told to stop
This happens. A visitor, a relative or a well-meaning friend says, "You do not need that. God can do it." A person who is hurting and wants to be faithful may feel pulled in two directions.
(an invented example) Hillcrest Fellowship is a congregation of about sixty adults. A member, Danjuma, comes to the , Rosalind, after a Sunday service, and says: "A man at the back told me that if I trusted God I would not need my tablets. I want to trust God. I am not sure what to do."
Rosalind could say one of two wrong things. She could say, "He is right, God can heal you," and so repeat the first mistake. Or she could say, "Ignore him, he is a fool," which is unkind, and leaves Danjuma without any sense of how to go forward. She does neither. She says:
"Thank you for telling me. I am glad you want to trust God, and I do not think that taking what your doctor gave you is a lack of trust. I cannot tell you about your treatment. That is for your doctor, and I would ask you to speak to the doctor before you change anything. I would be glad to pray with you right now, and I would be glad to go with you to the appointment if that would help."
This answer has four parts, and each is worth keeping: thanks, reassurance on faith, an honest limit, and an offer. Rosalind has not given medical advice. She has not criticised the visitor in front of Danjuma. She has kept the door open, and she has pointed him to the person who can answer his question.
If the person has already stopped or changed something, the leader still gives no advice about it. The same kindness applies: "I am glad you told me. I think your doctor needs to know. Would you like me to help you call?" If the person seems unwell or in danger, the leader does not wait. Lecture 4-2 says more about connecting, and the course on crisis, suicide and trauma response covers danger.
When prayer seems unanswered
The father in the opening said, "We have prayed for months and nothing has changed." A leader should not argue with a person's experience, and should not defend God with an explanation. The Psalms already make room for this, and so does lecture 3-4. For now, three things are true and kind to say.
- Prayer is not a failed test. A person who has prayed faithfully and is still struggling has not failed.
- God is not absent because the struggle remains. Many people of deep faith have struggled for long periods.
- Other help may be part of how God answers. A leader can say this gently and without pressure, and leave the decision with the person and their family.
Scripture is never a weapon
Several sentences are sometimes said to people in distress, and they do harm even when kindly meant:
- "If you had faith, you would not feel like this."
- "Real Christians do not get anxious."
- "You are not trusting God."
- "You need to repent."
- "The Bible says not to worry, so stop."
Each of these uses Scripture, or the tone of Scripture, to put a person in the wrong. A struggling person already feels unworthy, and these sentences add to the weight. A leader who hears such a sentence in the community can say, privately and kindly, "I think that may hurt more than it helps. Let us not use the Bible that way." (This is how Jesus handled the question in John 9, as lecture 1-2 said.) A leader who has said one of them may simply say, "I am sorry. I said that badly." No one is beyond being forgiven for a careless sentence.
A difference of setting
(an invented example) Saint Aldric's Parish has a part-time priest and a volunteer lay team, and the nearest clinic is two hours away by bus. The team cannot offer a clinic, and it would be wrong to pretend to. What it can do is help a person find out how to reach one, pray with them, go with them if they ask, and keep the parish door open. A leader in a place like this does not need to be a professional. The leader needs to know that connecting is a form of love.
(an invented example) Northgate Community Church is a large congregation with several staff, a visiting care team and many members who are doctors, nurses and counsellors. The risk here is different: that the church treats a struggle as something to pass along to its own members who are professionals, and forgets to stay beside the person. Many professionals in the congregation do not wish to be "the church's doctor", and some rules of their work forbid it. The pastor learns to ask a professional member only what they are glad to offer, and not to assume.
What a leader takes from this lecture
- Prayer does not replace treatment; treatment does not replace faith.
- A leader never advises anyone to stop or change a medicine. That belongs to the prescriber or treating professional.
- Scripture shows prayer and practical care side by side, without conflict.
- What a church adds is company, prayer, meaning and belonging, which a clinic is not set up to give.
- A good answer has four parts: thanks, reassurance, an honest limit, and an offer.
- Scripture is never used as a weapon, and a careless sentence can be repaired.
1-1. Prayer and treatment: two hands, one person
1-2. A good answer has four parts
In short
- Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith; a person may need both.
- A leader never advises anyone to stop or change a medicine; that belongs to the prescriber or treating professional.
- Scripture shows prayer and practical care side by side, as in Hezekiah, Timothy and the Samaritan, without conflict.
- A church adds company, prayer, meaning and belonging, which a clinic is not set up to give.
- A good reply to "I was told to stop" has four parts: thanks, reassurance, an honest limit and an offer.
- Scripture is never used as a weapon, and this course does not replace professional care.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The central pair | Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. |
| Medicine | A leader never advises anyone to stop or change it; that belongs to the prescriber or treating professional. |
| The four-part answer | Thanks, reassurance that seeking help is not a lack of faith, an honest limit, and an offer of company or prayer. |
| Scripture as a weapon | Sentences such as "if you had faith, you would not feel this" put a struggling person in the wrong and must not be used. |
One sentence to remember Pray, and make room for treatment; a leader never says stop, and always says "we are still here".
This week's action Write, in your own words, a four-part reply to a member who says they were told to stop what their doctor gave them, and say it aloud once to a trusted colleague.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the two false choices, "pray, do not treat" or "treat, do not pray", have you heard in your community? What was good in it, and what did it cost?
- Hezekiah prays, and a remedy is applied in the same chapter. Why does it matter that the text sees no conflict?
- What would you say to a member who tells you that a visitor told them to stop what their doctor gave them? Write the four parts in your own words.
- What can a church give a person that no clinic is set up to give? Which of these does your community give well?
- Why is "if you had faith, you would not feel like this" a use of Scripture as a weapon? What could be said instead?