FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT709E Youth Ministry Foundations: Walking Beside Young People

Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences

Contents 31
PT709E Youth Ministry Foundations: Walking Beside Young People
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Companions, Not Projects
  1. Introduction: Companions, Not Projects
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Place of Youth Ministry
  1. Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
  2. Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
  4. Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Young People's World
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
  2. Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
  3. Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
  4. Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The Adult Who Stays
  1. Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
  2. Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
  3. Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
  4. Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Gatherings, Groups and Trips
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
  2. Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
  3. Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
  4. Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Living the Faith
  1. Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
  3. Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
  4. Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Walking With Families and Moving On
  1. Lecture 6-1: Working With Parents
  2. Lecture 6-2: Transitions and Leaving
  3. Lecture 6-3: Caring for the Team
  4. Lecture 6-4: Looking Back Without Counting Heads
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Review on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

21 min

A volunteer called Grace, in her fifties, is paired with a sixteen-year-old called Kofi. She is a retired teacher from a farming family. He grew up in a city, loves music she has never heard, and speaks quickly in a mix of two languages. After three meetings she has a quiet thought: "We have nothing in common." That thought is honest and common. It can also be the start of a mistake, if she concludes that the pairing is a failure. (An invented example.)

Every mentoring relationship crosses some distance. Even two people of the same age, family and congregation differ in temperament and history. Most pairings cross more: age, gender, culture, money, ability, health, and the amount of faith each person holds or doubts. This lecture is about doing it well. It asks the adult to be humble (the young person knows things you do not), curious (ask before assuming), steady (do not take over) and honest (apologise when you are wrong).

It is about the adult's posture more than the adult's technique. And it includes the young adult leaders who are close in age, and the young person who simply does not warm to you.

What these 21 minutes give you

  • Name the main kinds of difference that run through a mentoring pairing, and say why none of them is a problem in itself.
  • Describe what it means to learn from a young person and why this is not a trick of technique.
  • Explain the difference between walking beside a young person and rescuing them.
  • Say how to apologise to a young person well, and why it strengthens trust.
  • Describe the special gifts and risks of young adult leaders as mentors.
  • Say what to do when a young person does not warm to you.

Peter opened his mouth and said, “Truly I perceive that God doesn’t show favoritism;" — Acts 10:34

World English Bible

but in every nation he who fears him and works righteousness is acceptable to him." — Acts 10:35

WEB

There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." — Galatians 3:28

WEB

For perhaps he was therefore separated from you for a while, that you would have him forever," — Philemon 1:15

WEB

no longer as a slave, but more than a slave, a beloved brother, especially to me, but how much rather to you, both in the flesh and in the Lord." — Philemon 1:16

WEB

Peter says it after a surprise: he did not know that God's welcome reached so far. Paul's letter asks a Christian to see a person who had been counted as property in a new way, as a brother. In both, a difference is not removed, but it stops being the whole truth about the person.

1. The differences that run through a pairing

The following differences matter most in many communities. Your list will vary.

  • Age. An adult of fifty and a young person of fifteen live in different cultural moments, and often in different expectations of authority and politeness.
  • Gender. Young people may be more at ease with an adult of the same gender or of another. Communities hold different customs about this, and lecture 3-2 explains the safety habits that apply whatever the pairing is.
  • Culture and language. Home customs on eye contact, on respect for elders, on how to disagree, on food, on touch and on what is private differ widely. A young person may live in two cultures, school and home, and move between them every day.
  • Money and class. A leader may not notice that a trip, a phone, a uniform or a meal out costs more than a family can easily find. A young person may feel shame and say nothing.
  • Ability and health. Some young people have a learning difference, a physical disability, a long illness, or a mind that works in a different way. They are not a problem to be fixed. They are part of the ordinary picture of the community.
  • Faith background. One young person comes from a devout home, another from a home with no religion, a third from a mixed marriage. One has deep doubts. One has never had any. The adult's own tradition may be different from theirs.

None of these differences is a fault. Paul says in Galatians 3:28 that in Christ the old divisions do not decide who belongs. This does not mean that differences vanish or that they are unimportant. It means that none of them marks off someone as outside. Peter’s words in Acts 10:34 come from a man who had to be shown that his assumptions were too narrow.

2. Humility: the young person knows things you do not

The first posture is the plainest. The young person is the expert on being this young person. They know their school, their friends, their music, their fears and their family in a way you do not and cannot. An adult who forgets this tends to talk too much.

(An invented example.) Grace decides to ask Kofi to teach her. At the next meeting she says: "I'd like to hear a song you really like, and why. I may not like it, but I would like to understand what it does for you." Kofi is surprised. He picks a piece and explains how it was made, and which line makes him stop. Grace does not claim to share his taste. She asks what the words mean. She finds, to her surprise, that he is moved by the same sort of thing that moves her in a hymn: a feeling that someone else has put a hard thing into words.

Notice what Grace did not do. She did not pretend to like the music. She did not imitate his speech. She did not turn it at once into a lesson. She treated him as a person with something to give, and that is a kind of respect that cannot be faked for long. This is not a trick to win trust. It is the truth: many young people do know things the adult does not, and an adult who is learning is a more honest companion than one who is only teaching.

Learning from a young person is also a protection. A mentor who always talks from above will sooner or later say something that hurts. A mentor who asks, "What is it like at your school?" hears the answer that corrects the guess.

3. Do not rescue

A caring adult often feels the urge to rescue: to pay, to phone, to arrange, to speak to the teacher or the parent or the employer on the young person's behalf. Sometimes help of this kind is exactly right, and in matters of safety the adult must act. But as a habit, rescue has costs.

It says to the young person, "You cannot do this." It builds a dependence that the adult may not be able to keep up. It can hide from the adult the fact that the young person has strengths. And it can cross boundaries: money given to a family, a place to stay, a job arranged, all belong to a community's policy and to the parents, not to a private act of kindness.

Walking beside is different. It asks: "What do you want to do? What have you tried? What would help?" It lets the young person take the next step, and it stays near in case the step is hard. When a young person truly cannot manage, the adult tells the responsible person and the parents or guardians, and the community decides together what help is fitting. This is the same posture as the last lecture: notice, stay, pass on.

There is a reverse mistake too: to hold back help for the sake of principle. If a young person is hungry, cold or in danger, the adult does not wait for a lesson to be learned. The test is whether the help is open, agreed with the right people, and aimed at the young person's strength.

4. Apology

Every adult who works with young people will, sooner or later, get something wrong. You forget a promise. You say something thoughtless about a young person's friend. You assume a young person's background and are mistaken. You lose your temper at the end of a long day.

The honest response is a plain apology, made soon and in private, or in public if the fault was public. It has four parts:

  1. Name what you did. ("I spoke sharply to you in front of the others.")
  2. Do not excuse it. ("I was tired, but that is not a reason.")
  3. Say you are sorry. ("I am sorry.")
  4. Say what you will do. ("Next time I will wait and talk to you after.")

Do not ask the young person to forgive you at once. Do not turn it around ("I am sorry if you were hurt"), and do not ask them to apologise in return. If the matter was serious, tell the person responsible too.

Some adults fear that apologising will lose them respect. Often the opposite happens. A young person who hears an adult say "I was wrong" learns that an adult can be wrong and still be trusted. For a young person who has seen few adults take responsibility, this may be a rare sight. It also teaches, without a sermon, what repentance looks like.

5. Young adult leaders as mentors

Many youth ministries depend on young adults: students, those starting work, the recently married, the nineteen-year-old who still lives at home. They bring real gifts. They remember what it is like to be fifteen. They speak the young person's idiom. A young person may find it easier to talk to someone close in age than to an adult of fifty.

The same closeness brings risks, and it is respectful to name them.

  • Blurred roles. A young adult leader may be a friend of the older teenagers, a classmate of a sibling, or a former member of the same group. It is hard to be a friend and a leader. The leader has a duty that the friend does not.
  • Less distance. Boundaries on messages, meetings and gifts matter more, not less, when the age gap is small. The habits of lecture 3-2 apply in full. Young adult leaders need to hear this kindly and before something goes wrong, not afterwards.
  • Their own growth. A young adult leader is still growing in faith, in judgement and in life. They should not be asked to carry what an experienced adult carries. Set them beside an older adult, who supports them and to whom they can turn. Lecture 5-2 returns to young leaders in the group.
  • Strong feelings. Admiration, attraction and rivalry can arise in any pairing, more easily when ages are close. The right response is not shame but openness: speak to the person responsible early, and change the arrangement if it helps.

A community that uses young adult leaders well gives them training, a mentor of their own, a clear role, and an honest word about their limits. A community that uses them badly leaves them alone with fifteen-year-olds and calls it trust.

6. The young person who does not warm to you

Not every pairing works. A young person may be polite and distant, or may say little for months, or may never come back. Some adults take this as a verdict on their worth. It is not.

There are many possible reasons. Perhaps the young person has been let down by adults and is slow to trust. Perhaps your manner is wrong for them, too loud or too quiet. Perhaps they would simply do better with someone of another age, gender, background or temperament. Perhaps they are busy with things unrelated to you. You cannot tell which, and often they could not tell you.

Three responses are better than the alternatives.

  • Stay open and do not press. Greet them by name, offer without insisting, and let the door stand open.
  • Widen the circle. Tell the person responsible, who may be able to bring another adult into the young person's life. This is not rejection; it is making sure they are known by more than one person.
  • Do not take it as a personal injury. Your work is to be available. A young person who finds another trusted adult has not gone wrong, and neither have you. If the other adult is in the same community, you have both done well.

7. In a large parish and in a small church

(An invented example.) In a large parish with a confirmation programme, candidates are matched with sponsors by the parish office. Some matches are poor. The wise parish says at the beginning: "If it does not suit, tell the coordinator, and we will change it with no blame." The young person then has a way out that costs nothing.

(An invented example.) In a small church with one teenager, Mei, there is no choice of mentor. Two adults take turns. Mei finds one easy to talk to and the other awkward. They do not mind. They both know that between them there is someone she can speak to. The church also lets Mei know that she can name an adult from outside, a relative or a teacher, whom she trusts and whom the church is glad to include.


Diagram 1. Across the distance: four postures and the traps beside them

Mentoring Across Differences A difference is never the whole truth about a person The posture The trap beside it Humble The young person is the expert on being them. Talking from above Guessing, lecturing, pretending to know. Curious Ask before assuming; let them teach you. Imitating Faking taste or speech to seem close. Steady Walk beside; the next step is theirs. Rescuing Taking over; money, rooms, errands in secret. Honest Name it, own it, say sorry, say what changes. Defending "I am sorry if you were hurt." If it does not warm: stay open, do not press, widen the circle. A young person who finds another trusted adult has not gone wrong, and neither have you.

In short

  • Differences of age, gender, culture, money, ability and faith background run through every pairing; none puts a young person outside, because a difference is never the whole truth about them.
  • Be humble and curious: the young person is the expert on being them, and an adult who learns is a more honest companion.
  • Walk beside, do not rescue: help that takes over teaches dependence, while safety matters go to the responsible person and the parents.
  • A good apology names the fault, makes no excuse, says sorry and says what will change.
  • Young adult leaders bring closeness and risk; they need the same boundaries, training and an older adult beside them.
  • If a young person does not warm to you, stay open, do not press and widen the circle of adults.
Front Back
Why learn from a young person? They are the expert on being themselves, and an adult who learns is more honest than one who only teaches.
Rescuing or walking beside? Walking beside lets the young person take the next step; rescue takes over and hides their strengths.
Four parts of an apology Name the fault; make no excuse; say you are sorry; say what will change.
Young adult leaders They bring closeness and gifts, and need the same boundaries, training and an older adult beside them.

One sentence to remember A difference between you and a young person is where learning begins, not a reason to stand apart.

This week's action Ask one young person to tell you about something they like that you do not know, and listen for five minutes without comparing it to your own youth.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which differences do you notice most when you picture the young people you serve? Which have you never thought about?
  • When did you last learn something from a young person? What did you ask that made it possible?
  • Think of a time you wanted to rescue someone. What would "walking beside" have looked like instead?
  • Write the four parts of an apology for a small fault you might make this month. Say it aloud once.
  • If a young adult leader in your community were asked to explain the boundaries of lecture 3-2 to a new volunteer, would they know them? Who would train and support them?
  • A young person has stopped coming to your meetings but is still friendly. What would be a kind, no-pressure way to keep the door open?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.