FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT709E Youth Ministry Foundations: Walking Beside Young People

Lecture 6-4: Looking Back Without Counting Heads

Contents 31
PT709E Youth Ministry Foundations: Walking Beside Young People
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Companions, Not Projects
  1. Introduction: Companions, Not Projects
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Place of Youth Ministry
  1. Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
  2. Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
  4. Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Young People's World
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
  2. Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
  3. Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
  4. Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The Adult Who Stays
  1. Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
  2. Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
  3. Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
  4. Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Gatherings, Groups and Trips
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
  2. Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
  3. Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
  4. Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Living the Faith
  1. Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
  3. Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
  4. Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Walking With Families and Moving On
  1. Lecture 6-1: Working With Parents
  2. Lecture 6-2: Transitions and Leaving
  3. Lecture 6-3: Caring for the Team
  4. Lecture 6-4: Looking Back Without Counting Heads
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Review on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

At the end of the year the pastor of a small church asks the youth leader for a report for the annual meeting. The leader writes: "Average attendance, nine. Four new, three left. One camp." It is accurate. The pastor reads it and feels uneasy, and cannot say why. Then he asks a different question: "Tell me about the ones who left." The leader pauses and says, "One moved away, and I wrote to him. One I think we hurt, and I have been meaning to call her. The third I honestly do not know." The second report is not in the first. (an invented example)

This lecture is about how a youth ministry looks back. Looking back is a habit every serious work needs. Without it, we repeat our mistakes, we lose what we learnt, and we mistake being busy for being faithful. But there is a poor way of looking back and a good one. The poor way counts. The good way asks of each young person: were they welcomed, were they safe, did an adult know them, were they heard? It uses numbers where they help, always to find a name, and it ends with a small number of changes, not a long list of resolutions.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Name four questions that a review should ask of each young person.
  • Explain what counting can and cannot tell a youth ministry, and how a count can lead to a name.
  • Describe ways of hearing young people that respect their age and freedom.
  • Describe a review that includes parents and the team, and says what to do with a concern that arises.
  • Explain why a review should end in at most three changes.

Which of you men, if you had one hundred sheep, and lost one of them, wouldn’t leave the ninety-nine in the wilderness, and go after the one that was lost, until he found it? When he has found it, he carries it on his shoulders, rejoicing. When he comes home, he calls together his friends and his neighbors, saying to them, ‘Rejoice with me, for I have found my sheep which was lost!’ I tell you that even so there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents, than over ninety-nine righteous people who need no repentance." — Luke 15:4-7

World English Bible

Be careful that you don’t do your charitable giving before men, to be seen by them, or else you have no reward from your Father who is in heaven. Therefore when you do merciful deeds, don’t sound a trumpet before yourself, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, that they may get glory from men. Most certainly I tell you, they have received their reward. But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does, so that your merciful deeds may be in secret, then your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly." — Matthew 6:1-4

WEB

In Luke, a shepherd knows he has lost one among a hundred. In Matthew, Jesus warns against doing good in order to be seen. The passages meet in this lecture at a modest point: a good review looks for the one who is missing, and it is not a performance for an audience.

1. Why look back at all

A youth ministry that never reviews itself runs on habit. Habit has virtues: it gives young people something they can rely on. But habit does not notice when a room has become unwelcoming, when a trusted leader has quietly stopped coming, or when an evening that worked for eight young people no longer works for fifteen. A review is a regular time when the adults sit down and ask what is actually happening.

A review also has a spiritual side, which is easy to miss. It is a way of paying attention to the persons God has put in our care. In Luke 15 the shepherd knows what is lost because he knows what he had. Careful attention comes before any rescue.

A review is not an inspection, and it is not an occasion for blame. Its mood is the mood of people who care about the same young people and want to do it a little better.

2. The four questions

The core of the review is four questions asked about each young person, or, in a larger group, about each young person the adults can speak to. They echo the central claim of the course.

  1. Was the young person welcomed? Did someone greet them by name? Did a newcomer find a place at a table, in a game, in a group? Did they feel they were wanted, or just allowed?
  2. Was the young person safe? Was every adult who worked with them following the written policy? Were there any near misses, any worries, any matters passed on? Did the young person feel physically and emotionally safe? Was anyone left out, mocked or pressed?
  3. Was the young person linked to an adult? Is there at least one adult beyond their parents who knows their name, their interests and something of their life, and whom they would recognise as a friend? Not every young person will have a close bond with an adult in the group, and not every young person wants one. But every young person should have someone who would notice if they stopped coming.
  4. Was the young person heard? Did anyone ask them what they think, what they want, what they find hard? Did the programme change in any way because of something a young person said?

A fifth question belongs to the whole ministry and not to any one young person: were the parents informed? Did they know what was happening, who was in charge and how to reach us? Did any parent raise a concern, and was it answered?

Notice that none of the five questions asks "did we reach the target" or "did they grow in faith". A youth worker cannot measure the second and should not pretend to. What a youth worker can do is to see whether the conditions in which faith might grow, welcome, safety, a trusted adult and a voice, were present.

3. What counting is for

Counting is not forbidden. Some leaders, hearing "do not count heads", conclude that they must not count at all. That would be a mistake. A count is a small piece of information, and sometimes an important one. It can tell you that attendance has halved, or that a group has doubled, or that of twelve young people only two are girls, or that nobody over fifteen has come this term. These are facts worth knowing.

The rule is simple: a number is a question, not an answer. "Attendance halved" is a question: who is missing, and why? "Only two girls" is a question: what might be keeping the others away? A count that does not lead to a name has not yet done its work.

The shepherd in Luke 15 counts. He knows there should be a hundred sheep. But counting is not where he stops. The count tells him one is missing, and he goes after that one. The point of the number was the animal. This should not be pushed too far. The parable is about God's seeking of the lost, and not about how to keep an attendance register. But it does show something about the relation between number and person: the number serves the one.

Three habits keep a count honest.

  • Count in order to ask. After each figure, add a question: who, and why?
  • Count over time, not on one evening. A single night is weather; a term is climate.
  • Never use numbers to compare yourself with another community. Different places have different sizes, ages, countries and resources. A small group in a village may be doing a larger work than a large group in a city.

Matthew 6:1-4 is not a ban on records. It speaks about doing good to be seen, and warns about a certain kind of reward. For a youth ministry, the warning is quiet but real: the temptation to measure ourselves by the figures we can show an annual meeting, a funder, a visiting bishop or another congregation. The question to put to our own review is: whom is this for? If it is for the young people, it will look for names. If it is for our reputation, it will look for totals.

4. Hearing the young people

The fourth question asks whether the young person was heard, and a review that does not ask the young people themselves is missing its best source. This must be done with care, because young people vary in how free they feel to speak, and because adults can easily hear only what they hope to hear.

Several approaches are used. None is perfect. Use whichever fits your community, and say plainly what you will do with what you hear.

  • A conversation, one to one, in a known and open place, within the habits of lecture 3-2. Ask open questions: "What do you like about Friday evenings? What do you wish was different? Who do you talk to when you come?" Do not argue. Do not defend. Write down only what you will use, and only what the young person would not mind seeing.
  • A short anonymous form, in plain language, with free space for words. Some young people say more when no name is attached. For a young person whose reading or writing is difficult, offer another way.
  • A group conversation. Some young people speak freely in a small circle of friends, and some do not speak at all. In any group conversation, ask for what the group thinks, not for who said what, and make it easy to pass.
  • Hearing through a trusted young person. Some groups have a few older young people who know the others. They can be asked what they notice, with the understanding that they are not being asked to report on friends.

Two cautions. First, a young person who says something that raises a safety concern is not a source for the review; the concern goes to the person responsible, as the policy says. Do not discuss it in a review meeting. Second, do not ask a young person for a verdict on a named adult. If a young person wants to say something about a leader, they need a trusted route, a named person, and an assurance that they will be taken seriously. A review form is not that route.

You may not hear what you expected. A young person may say that a favourite game is boring, that the teaching is too long, or that the group is cliquish. These remarks are a gift, even when they sting.

5. Hearing parents and the team

Parents can be heard through the channels of lecture 6-1: a short note at the end of a term asking two questions, "What has been good for your child?" and "What would you like us to know or do differently?", or a word at the door. Many parents will have little to say, and a few will have a great deal. Receive both with the same patience.

The team can be heard in the meeting described in lecture 6-3, with the same "how are we?" question. Ask also: what did we find hard this year? What did we do well? What did we avoid?

In both cases the same rule applies as with the young people: say what you will do with the answers. People answer honestly when they believe it will make a difference.

6. Running the review

A review can be small. A pastor, a youth leader and a parent can do it in an hour. A large parish may have a committee. These steps work for both.

  1. Gather what you have. Attendance by name (kept as the written policy allows), notes on trips, the "how are we?" of the team, anything parents or young people said. Do not invent a long form.
  2. Go through the four questions for the young people you can speak of. Take each young person in turn. For a group of two or three, this is a short list. For a group of forty, begin with those who are new, those who have stopped and those about whom someone is concerned.
  3. Add the parents' question for the whole group.
  4. Notice patterns. Not "Daniel was quiet", but "three of the younger boys were quiet in small groups". Patterns point to changes.
  5. Handle concerns correctly. If the review brings up a worry about a young person's safety, or about an adult's conduct, stop. The matter goes to the person responsible under the written policy, and does not continue in the review meeting. A review is not an investigation.
  6. Choose at most three changes. This is the discipline that most reviews lack and most need.

7. Why at most three

A review that ends with fourteen resolutions will probably produce none. The adults are volunteers with other lives. Each change costs time, attention and conversation. Three is a number a small team can hold in its head.

Choose the changes by asking three questions. What would make the biggest difference to a young person who is not yet welcomed, safe, linked or heard? What can we do with the people and time we have? What will we do first? Each change should be specific enough to know whether it happened: "Greet every newcomer at the door by name, with a named person on duty each week", and not "improve welcome". Write them down, name who will do each, and put a date on the next look.

A change may be to stop something. A programme that nobody enjoys, a trip too large for the team, a rota that wears out the same two people. Stopping is a change, and often the wisest.

8. Telling the congregation

At some point the review is shared with the wider community. Share it in words as well as figures. "This year, nine young people came regularly; four were new, and each of the four was welcomed by a named adult. Three left. One of them moved, and we have stayed in touch; with two we are still wondering what we could have done differently." That is more honest than a graph, and it leads the congregation to pray and to care, and not just to approve.

Do not name young people in public reports without the consent of the young person and a parent, and avoid details that could identify a young person to those who know them. A story told with the names removed is usually enough.

9. In two kinds of community

In a liturgical community, the review may fit into the existing rhythm: the end of the confirmation year, the parish council, a report to the priest or the bishop's delegate. The risk is that a report is a form to complete, and the four questions are lost under official categories. Use the form for what it asks, and keep the four questions for yourselves.

In a small free-church assembly, the review may be a conversation over a meal. The risk is that it is too informal to leave any trace. Write the three changes on a single sheet and put it where the leaders will see it.


Diagram 1. The four questions, the one question, and the three changes

A Review That Looks for Names Four questions for each young person, one for the whole group, three changes at most Welcomed? Greeted by name, given a place, wanted Safe? Policy followed, nobody left out or pressed Linked? An adult who would notice if they stopped coming Heard? Asked what they think; something changed because of it And for the whole group: were the parents informed? Did they know who is in charge, how to reach us, and was any concern answered? A number is a question Attendance halved: who is missing? Only two girls: what keeps the others away? Count to ask, and ask to find a name. A worry about safety Stop the review. It goes to the person responsible under the written policy. A review is not an investigation. At most three changes: specific, named, dated What helps most? What can we do with the people and time we have? What first? One may be to stop something.

In short

  • A review asks four questions of each young person: welcomed, safe, linked to an adult, and heard; and one of the whole group: were the parents informed?
  • A number is a question, not an answer; count in order to ask who and why, and keep going until you reach a name.
  • Hear young people in ways that suit their age, by conversation, a short anonymous form or a small group, and say what you will do with what you hear.
  • A concern about safety or about an adult's conduct stops the review and goes to the person responsible under the written policy.
  • End with at most three changes, each specific, named and dated; stopping something can be one of them.
  • Report to the congregation in words as well as figures, and without naming young people.
Front Back
Four questions for each young person Welcomed, safe, linked to an adult, heard.
What counting is for A number is a question: it should lead to who and why, and then to a name.
A safety worry arises in a review Stop; it goes to the person responsible under the written policy.
How many changes? At most three, each specific, named and dated.

One sentence to remember Count if it helps you find a name, and end with three changes you can check.

This week's action Take the four questions and answer them, in a few words each, for one young person you know, without writing the name down.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • How does your youth ministry describe its year now: in figures, in stories, or in names? What does that suggest about what it values?
  • Think of the last number your community reported about its young people. What question should have followed it?
  • For a young person you know well (without naming them here), how would you answer each of the four questions?
  • How could the young people in your community be heard in a way that suits their age and does not put any one of them on the spot?
  • How would you handle a review meeting in which someone begins to describe a worry about an adult's conduct?
  • What would be the three changes for your own group this year, written in a way you could check?
  • Matthew 6:1-4 warns about doing good to be seen. Whom does your community's report on its youth ministry serve?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.