Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
- Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
- Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
- Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
- Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
- Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
- Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
- Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
- Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
- Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
- Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
- Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
- Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
- Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
After a Sunday gathering, a fourteen-year-old called Lucia lingers by the stacking chairs. She says, looking at the floor, "Can I tell you something? Only if you swear you won't tell anyone." The helper beside her, Peter, has been trusted with a good deal in his time. He knows that the next ten seconds matter more than the next ten minutes. (An invented example.)
This lecture is about those ten seconds and what follows them. It teaches a posture with three verbs: notice, stay, pass on. You notice that something important is being said or hinted. You stay: you listen, calmly, and you do not run away or take over. You pass on: you tell the person who is responsible and, where right, point towards the professional help that you are not.
Three things are not taught here. The skills of listening in general belong to LM205E. The signs that a young person is struggling, and how a troubled heart shows itself, belong to PT706E. And the lecture gives no methods, no details and no advice on diagnosis, law or medicine. It does not say what to do about a particular harm, because that depends on your community's written policy and on your country's law. What it gives is the order of the first steps, which holds almost everywhere.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Explain why a youth worker asks more than they advise, and give an example of an open question.
- Say why a promise of secrecy should not be given, and what to say instead.
- Describe the order of the first steps when a young person tells you something hard: stay calm, listen, tell the person responsible, point to professional help.
- Say when to call the local emergency number at once.
- State what a youth worker is not, and explain why that is a relief and not a failure.
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
World English Bible
So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19
WEB
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
The first two verses are about the order of hearing and speaking. The third is about the burden. It says "bear one another’s", which means that nobody carries it alone, and that is the reason for passing on.
1. Ask more than you advise
When a young person brings something hard, the adult's first urge is usually to help by saying something: advice, comfort, a Bible verse, a story from their own youth. Sometimes these are right. But Proverbs 18:13 warns about answering before hearing, and James adds that the right order is "swift to hear, slow to speak."
There is a practical reason as well as a moral one. A young person who has just said something hard is watching your face. If you answer at once, they may think: "I was not really heard," or "this is easy for them," or "I should not have said it." A young person who has been listened to for two minutes without interruption may feel something different: that there is room.
Some questions help.
- "Do you want to tell me more?"
- "What was that like for you?"
- "What would help right now?"
- "Is there anything you want me to do, or do you just want me to listen?"
Questions that do not help are those that sound like an inquiry: "Why did you let that happen?", "What were you thinking?", "Are you sure?" They put the young person on trial. Even a well-meant "Are you sure?" can teach a young person that it is not safe to say it again. Compare "What happened next?", which asks the young person to carry on without weighing what they have said.
Be careful also with questions that lead. Do not suggest what may have happened or who may have done it. Let the young person use their own words. Do not press for detail. You are not an investigator, and detail you draw out can be a burden to the young person and, in some situations, can make later steps harder for the professionals who must take them.
2. Do not promise secrecy
The most important sentence in this lecture is a short one. Do not promise to keep a secret.
Here is the strongest case for promising. Young people are right to be afraid that an adult will betray them. If an adult says, "I cannot promise anything," the young person may close up and say nothing. A promise of secrecy might win the very trust that makes the young person speak. And some adults may feel that breaking a confidence will destroy a relationship that has taken years to build.
The strongest case is real, and the course takes it seriously. But a promise of secrecy before you know what you will hear is a promise you may not be able to keep. If the young person tells you about harm to themselves or to someone else, you may be required, by your community's policy, by the law of your country, or by conscience, to tell someone. Breaking such a promise is much worse than never making it. And a promise of secrecy can make the adult a keeper of a harm that is still going on.
What can you say instead? Something like:
"I am glad you told me. I want to listen. I cannot promise to keep everything secret, because if it is something that affects your safety, I will have to tell someone whose job it is to help. If that happens, I will tell you who and why, and I will not leave you alone with it."
This is honest. It does not threaten. Many young people accept it, and those who do not will still know where they stand. If a young person says they will not speak without a promise, do not give it. Say gently that the door stays open, and tell the person responsible that a young person wanted to say something and was afraid.
Duties about reporting differ by country, by profession and by role. In some places certain people must report certain things by law. In others there is no such duty, or the duty falls on particular roles. Your community's written policy should say what is expected of you. If it does not, ask the person responsible before you need to know.
3. The first steps, in order
When a young person tells you something hard, the following order holds in most places. It is a sequence of four steps, and it asks little of you.
1. Stay calm. Your face and voice matter. If you look shocked, the young person may stop. Breathe. Keep your voice low and slow. If you are upset, you can say: "That sounds very hard. I am listening."
2. Listen, and believe that something is being said. Let the young person speak in their own words. Do not question, do not promise, do not blame. Do not say "I am sure it was not meant that way" or "nobody would do that." Say "Thank you for telling me." Say "It was not your fault" only when you can say it honestly, and where a young person is blaming themselves, it often can be said.
3. Tell the person responsible, soon. Your community should name this person: a safeguarding lead, a pastor, a priest, the youth coordinator. Tell them the same day, in private. Write down what was said, as nearly in the young person's own words as you can, with the date and time, and keep the note somewhere secure, as your policy says. Do not discuss it with other helpers, with friends or on social media. Do not contact the people the young person has named. That is for the responsible person and, where right, the professionals.
4. Point towards professional help. Depending on what was said, the help may come from a doctor, a counsellor, a social worker, a helpline, the police or another service. You do not need to decide which. The person responsible, or your policy, will say. What you can do is stay a friendly adult while the professionals do their part, and tell the young person truthfully what is happening next.
Each step has its mistake. At step 1 the mistake is to panic; at step 2 to interrogate or to promise; at step 3 to wait, to handle it alone, or to gossip; at step 4 to try to be the professional. The remedy for each is the same: remember what you are.
4. When there is immediate danger
If a young person is in danger now, or is about to harm themselves or someone else, call the local emergency number at once. Do not wait for the responsible person first. Stay with the young person if it is safe to do so, speak calmly, and tell the emergency service what you see and where you are. Afterwards, tell the responsible person, the parents or guardians as your policy says, and write down what happened.
The emergency number differs from country to country. Learn yours now, and write it on the sheet that hangs by the telephone or the first-aid box in the room where you meet. A gathering that has no such sheet is not ready.
This lecture gives no methods, no signs to look for and no advice about particular harms. That is deliberate. Some things should be dealt with by people who have the training, and a handbook for volunteers is the wrong place for detail. If you are uncertain whether something is serious, treat it as serious and ask the person responsible. It is better to tell too soon than too late.
5. What a youth worker is not
Peter, standing by the chairs, is not Lucia's parent, counsellor, doctor, lawyer, police officer or rescuer. He is an adult she trusted enough to speak to. The aim of this lecture is to make that enough. Many helpers carry a hidden belief that if they are not able to solve the problem, they have failed. The ethic of this course is different: you are asked to notice, to stay and to pass on, and that is already a great deal.
This is also a relief. It means you do not have to know what to say, to find the right verse or to repair what is broken. It means that you may say, "I do not know what to do, but I will find someone who does, and I will stay with you." That sentence is complete.
Two cautions. The first is to look after yourself. Hearing something hard can leave a helper shaken. Tell the person responsible how you are; ask for someone to talk to; do not carry it alone, and do not break the young person's privacy in doing so (you can speak about your own feelings without repeating the details). The second is to look after the young person's dignity. Do not treat them from now on as fragile or as a case. Greet them as before. Remember them as the person they were before they spoke.
6. In a parish and in a small assembly
(An invented example.) In a parish with a priest, a safeguarding officer and a parish council, the order is clear: the helper tells the safeguarding officer, who knows the diocesan procedure. The risk is that the helper tells the priest informally and nobody records it. The remedy is a standing instruction: whoever hears, tells the named person, and the note is written the same day.
(An invented example.) In a small assembly of forty people, the pastor is also a friend of the family concerned. The community may be tempted to handle it "in the family of faith." The remedy here is to say plainly beforehand that some matters go outside the community to those trained to help, and to name an outside contact in advance, such as a trusted professional or a national child-protection helpline, so that nobody has to look for one in a crisis. Where there is no such person, ask a nearby denomination or a local service.
Diagram 1. What to say, what to do, and who to tell
In short
- Ask more than you advise: hear the whole account first, use open questions, and do not question as an investigator or lead the young person.
- Do not promise secrecy; say you will listen, cannot promise to keep everything quiet, and will tell the young person who and why.
- The first steps, in order: stay calm, listen, tell the responsible person the same day, and point towards professional help.
- In immediate danger, call the local emergency number first; duties to report differ by country and by role.
- A youth worker is not a counsellor, doctor, lawyer or rescuer: the task is to notice, stay and pass on.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why ask more than advise? | An early answer can tell the young person they were not heard; listening makes room for the whole account. |
| What to say about secrets | "I cannot promise secrecy. If it affects your safety I must tell someone, and I will tell you who and why." |
| The first steps in order | Stay calm; listen; tell the responsible person the same day; point towards professional help. |
| Immediate danger | Call the local emergency number first, stay if safe, and tell the responsible person afterwards. |
One sentence to remember Notice, stay and pass on: you are not asked to solve it, only to be the adult who did not turn away and did not carry it alone.
This week's action Write on one card the name of your responsible person, your local emergency number and your outside helpline, and keep the card where you keep your keys.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- When did an adult listen to you for a long time without hurrying to answer? What did it feel like, and what did that adult not do?
- Write three open questions that you could use with a young person. Then write one that sounds like an inquiry. What is the difference in how each lands?
- State the case for promising secrecy as fairly as you can. Then say why this course asks you not to promise. Which reason weighs most with you?
- Who is the responsible person in your community? If you do not know, how could you find out this week?
- Do you know the local emergency number and the outside helpline your community uses? Where is it written?
- Why might a helper hold back from "passing on"? What would you say to a colleague who feels they are betraying a young person by telling?