Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
- Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
- Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
- Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
- Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
- Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
- Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
- Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
- Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
- Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
- Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
- Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
- Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
- Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
- Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
- Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
- Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
- Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
- Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
- Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
- Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
- Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
- Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
- Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics
The first five weeks asked what is right at the bedside: at the start of life, at the edge of death, in the middle of treatment. This week steps back from the bed and looks at the room, the building and the street outside. Medical care is not only a matter between a patient and a clinician. Someone has to pay for it, build the clinic, train the nurse, bring the medicine and decide who is seen first. Whether a person receives care at all often depends on where they live, what they own and who they know.
This lecture asks how Christians think about justice (giving each person what is owed to them, and putting right what is wrong) when the question is health care. It uses very general terms. It gives no figures, names no country, and prescribes no policy. Its aim is to give you a way of seeing: to notice who is at the bedside and who is not, and to ask what Scripture and the traditions say to a church that finds itself near that question.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain in general terms why medical resources are limited and why that raises a question of justice.
- Summarise what Luke 4:18-19, Matthew 25:35-36 and James 2:15-16 say, and separate what the text says from a tradition's reading and from our own judgement.
- Describe, as each would put it, the emphasis of Catholic social teaching and of Protestant social-gospel and related streams on the poor and on care.
- Explain, with its strongest argument and its weak point, each of two ways of thinking about fair sharing of limited care.
- Describe the calling and the burden of those who work in health care, and say why a congregation should not blame them.
The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to heal the broken hearted, to proclaim release to the captives, recovering of sight to the blind, to deliver those who are crushed, — Luke 4:18
World English Bible
and to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord.” — Luke 4:19
WEB
for I was hungry, and you gave me food to eat. I was thirsty, and you gave me drink. I was a stranger, and you took me in. — Matthew 25:35
WEB
I was naked, and you clothed me. I was sick, and you visited me. I was in prison, and you came to me.” — Matthew 25:36
WEB
And if a brother or sister is naked and in lack of daily food, — James 2:15
WEB
and one of you tells them, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled”; and yet you didn’t give them the things the body needs, what good is it? — James 2:16
WEB
In Luke 4 Jesus reads from the prophet Isaiah in the synagogue at Nazareth and applies the words to his own work. The passage joins good news for the poor with healing for the broken-hearted and sight for the blind. In Matthew 25 the speaker is the king in a story about judgement; the sick, the hungry and the stranger are those whom the king calls his own. James writes to a community and asks what a kind word is worth if the body's need goes unmet.
None of these texts speaks of hospitals, insurance, waiting lists or drugs. They speak of people in need and of the community's response. What they mean for the sharing of modern medicine is a question of reading and judgement, and the lecture marks that difference as it goes.
1. Care is limited
Every society has limits. There are only so many clinics, so many trained nurses and doctors, so much medicine, so many hours in a day. In some places the limit is hard and near: a village may be a long journey from any clinic. In other places the limit is hidden behind waiting lists, forms and cost. In every place, choices are being made about who is seen and when, even when nobody calls them choices.
New technology changes the picture in two ways. It can make care possible that was never possible before, and that is a real good. It can also make the possible more expensive, so that the distance between those who can reach it and those who cannot grows. We cannot say here which of these happens in your country. We can say that the question "who receives care?" does not go away when technology advances. It becomes sharper.
2. What the three texts say
Begin with the plain words.
In Luke 4:18-19, Jesus names a set of people: the poor, the captives, the blind, those who are crushed. The "good news" is announced first to them. Healing of the body and release from bondage stand in one list with preaching. Many readers see this as a picture of the kind of kingdom Jesus announces, one in which those at the edge are the first to be reached. Some readers take the words mostly as a spiritual promise, and others take them mostly as a social one. Many take them as both. The text itself does not settle how the two are to be balanced.
In Matthew 25:35-36 the king names six needs, and one of them is sickness: "I was sick, and you visited me." The picture is of ordinary acts of care, done to the least important, and counted as done to the king. Notice what the text asks: hunger, thirst, welcome, clothing, a visit. It is a list of things a community can do with its own hands. It does not describe a system.
In James 2:15-16 the writer describes a failure that is easy to commit: to say a kind word and do nothing about the body's need. The writer's point is that faith which stops at the kind word is empty. The text does not say how large the need is or how it is to be met; it says that it matters and that words are not enough.
Taken together, these texts say that care for the body's need, and for the weak above all, is close to the heart of what Jesus asks of those who follow him. That much the texts say. What they do not say is how a modern country should organise its clinics, who should pay, or how scarce treatment is to be shared. When we move to those questions we are no longer reading; we are judging, and honest Christians judge differently.
3. How two streams speak of the poor and of care
Different traditions have drawn on these texts in different ways. We give two, as each would describe itself, and we do not rank them. Others, in the Orthodox, Anabaptist, Pentecostal and Evangelical families, have their own ways of speaking of mercy, and what is said here is only a sample.
Catholic social teaching is the name for a body of church teaching, developed over more than a century in letters from popes and bishops, on how a society should be ordered. It stresses the dignity of every person, the common good (the conditions in which every member of a community can flourish) and what it calls a preferential option for the poor, meaning that the needs of the poorest should have a special weight in the community's decisions. In this teaching, care for health is generally understood as something owed to a person because of that person's dignity. Catholic hospitals and orders of religious sisters and brothers have a long history of caring for the sick, and many of them have understood this work as a form of the gospel.
The social gospel and related Protestant streams grew out of a conviction that the church should work for justice in society as well as for the conversion of individuals. In its classical form it called Christians to attend to the conditions of working people, of the sick, of children and of the poor, and to treat the ordering of a society as a matter of faith. Not every Protestant stream agrees with this movement. Some stress personal mercy and the work of the congregation over political change; others stress that the first task of the church is to preach and to make disciples. Yet many Protestants of all kinds have founded hospitals, clinics and mission health work, and many have understood these as the fruit of faith.
You may read both descriptions and recognise your own tradition in neither. That is normal. The point is that all of them hold, in their own words, that the sick and the poor are a first concern of the church.
4. Two ways of thinking about sharing
When care is limited, communities ask how it should be shared. Here we set out two broad ways of thinking about this, as a student of the question would describe them. These are not Christian positions as such. Christians hold each of them, and some hold a mixture.
This is a point where readers will not agree. One way of thinking begins with equal claim. Each person, because they are made in God's image, has an equal claim on the community's care, and a rich person's life is no more valuable than a poor person's. So, this view holds, access should not depend on wealth; the community should make sure that the basic care it can provide reaches everyone, and the weakest first. Its strongest argument is that it takes the Bible's concern for the poor seriously and puts it into the structure of the system. Its weak point is that "equal claim" does not by itself say what to do when a community cannot afford everything. Someone must still decide which care is basic and which is not, and the people who bear the cost of that decision are often the most vulnerable.
The other way of thinking begins with responsibility and freedom. Families, communities and charities have the first duty to care for their own, and a system that gives the whole task to a distant authority can weaken both generosity and the bonds of a community. So, this view holds, care should be provided as far as possible by local giving, by the market under fair rules and by voluntary effort, with help for those who cannot provide for themselves. Its strongest argument is that it values the personal and local nature of mercy, which is also the nature of the texts we have read. Its weak point is that where the poor are many and local giving is thin, voluntary effort may not reach those who most need it, and the poorest may be left behind.
Each view contains something the other needs: the first reminds us that care for the weak cannot be left to chance, and the second that mercy is personal before it is administrative. This course does not require you to choose either. It requires that you can state each in a form its holder would accept, and name its weak point.
5. The conditional: if new technology widens a gap
We have said that we cannot tell you what happens in your country. We can describe a possibility, and the lecture asks you to hold it as a question and not a prediction. If a new technology brings real benefit, and if it is expensive, then it may first reach those who can pay. If that happens, a new gap may open between those who can use the technology and those who cannot, and the gap may in time become a gap in health and in length of life. The church would then have a new form of an old question: whom do the benefits of technology reach, and whom do they pass by?
Some will answer that the cost of new technology generally falls with time and that all benefit in the end. Others will answer that the gap between first and last is itself a harm, and that some never receive. Both can point to cases from history in general terms. Neither can say what will happen to a particular technology. What a congregation can do is to keep the question alive. When someone speaks of a new treatment, one question to ask is not only "is it good?" but "who will be able to have it?"
6. The calling and the burden of those who work in health care
A word about the people who stand between limited care and the person who needs it. Nurses, doctors, aides, midwives, pharmacists, community health workers, cleaners, chaplains and hospital managers work in places where the demand is larger than what can be given. They may have to say that a bed is full or a medicine has run out. They may carry the weight of a decision they did not make. Many of them are people of faith, and many see their work as a .
A congregation can easily blame them. A family that waited a long time may say the staff did not care. A member may say the hospital is unjust. Sometimes there is a real wrong, and it should be named to those who can put it right. Yet very often the one who is told is a person who is tired, who also wished things were otherwise, and who may be the least able to change the system. This course asks the church to treat health workers as fellow members of the body, to pray for them, to listen when they speak of the strain, and to avoid turning them into villains.
7. What this lecture does not do
It does not tell you which health system is best, or which treatments a state should pay for, or whether any particular law is just. These questions turn on facts about your own country, and on judgements about which honest Christians differ. What it offers is a set of questions you can take to those debates: who is at the bedside, who is not, whom do the texts put first, and what do I owe to the one outside the door?
Diagram 1. From the text to the clinic: where reading ends and judgement begins
In short
- Care is always limited, and new technology makes the question of who receives it sharper.
- Luke 4, Matthew 25 and James 2 put the poor and the sick near the centre of the church's concern, but do not say how a modern system should be built.
- Catholic social teaching and Protestant social-gospel and other streams each describe care for the poor as part of the gospel, in different language.
- Equal claim and responsibility-and-freedom are two ways of thinking about sharing, each with a strength and a weak point.
- If new technology reaches only those who can pay, a gap may widen; the church keeps asking who is left out.
- Health workers carry real burdens, and the church does not blame them.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the three texts say | Good news and healing for the poor; the sick are the king's own; kind words without meeting the body's need are empty. |
| Equal claim | Every person has an equal claim on care; its weak point is deciding what counts as basic when a community cannot afford all. |
| Responsibility and freedom | Mercy is local and personal; its weak point is that giving may not reach the poorest. |
| The question for any new technology | Who will be able to have it, and who will be left outside? |
One sentence to remember Care is a question of justice as well as of the bedside, and the church keeps asking who is outside the door.
This week's action Write down one question about fair access to care that you could ask in your own community, without blaming anyone.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What do Luke 4:18-19, Matthew 25:35-36 and James 2:15-16 say directly, and what do they leave open about how a modern society should share medical care?
- State the "equal claim" way of thinking about sharing in a way its holder would accept. Then state its weak point. Do the same for "responsibility and freedom".
- Which of the two descriptions of Catholic social teaching and of the Protestant social-gospel streams is nearest to the way your own tradition speaks of the poor and the sick? How does your tradition differ from both?
- If a new technology were costly at first, which questions would you want your congregation to ask before praising it or doubting it?
- How can a congregation speak with and about health workers without blaming them?