Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
A church of about sixty adults has three people who could lead something. The pastor asks, "Should we start a class, a small group or a mentoring scheme?" The question sounds practical. It hides a more important one: what does this adult need, and which form of company can give it?
Most churches use three forms of walking beside adults: one to one, the small group and the class. Each does some things well and some things badly. None is the best form. A church that has only one form will find that it serves the adults who fit that form and loses the rest.
This lecture sets the three forms side by side, shows how to choose between them, and shows how they can be combined, in a large church and in a small one. It does not teach how to lead a group (the small-group course, LM201E, does that) or how to teach (the course How to Teach, LM402E, does that). It asks the earlier question: which form, for whom, and why.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Describe what one-to-one companionship, the small group and the class each do well and do badly.
- Choose a form by starting from the adult's need and the church's size, and not from the programme already on offer.
- Give an example of two forms combined for one adult.
- Explain how a church with one helper and no budget can still offer more than one form.
He went up into the mountain, and called to himself those whom he wanted, and they went to him. He appointed twelve, that they might be with him, and that he might send them out to preach, and to have authority to heal sicknesses and to cast out demons:" — Mark 3:13-15
World English Bible
Every day, in the temple and at home, they never stopped teaching and preaching Jesus, the Christ." — Acts 5:42
WEB
Behold, two of them were going that very day to a village named Emmaus, which was sixty stadia from Jerusalem. They talked with each other about all of these things which had happened. While they talked and questioned together, Jesus himself came near, and went with them. But their eyes were kept from recognizing him." — Luke 24:13-16
WEB
Beginning from Moses and from all the prophets, he explained to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself. They drew near to the village, where they were going, and he acted like he would go further. They urged him, saying, “Stay with us, for it is almost evening, and the day is almost over.” He went in to stay with them. When he had sat down at the table with them, he took the bread and gave thanks. Breaking it, he gave to them. Their eyes were opened, and they recognized him, and he vanished out of their sight." — Luke 24:27-31
WEB
Mark 3 shows a group formed so that people might "be with him." Acts 5 shows teaching in two places, the public temple and private homes. Luke 24 shows two people walking together, and a third who joins them.
1. Three forms, three kinds of space
Think of the three forms as three kinds of space.
One to one is a space for two. One adult meets one companion, often at a regular time, to talk about faith and life. It may be called mentoring, spiritual direction, discipling, pastoral conversation, godparenting or accompanying, depending on the tradition. The names carry different meanings, but the shape is the same: two people and a road.
The small group is a space for a handful, usually between four and twelve, who meet regularly. It may be a house group, a cell, a fellowship, a Bible circle or a prayer group. The shape is a circle of people who know one another's names and, over time, some of one another's lives.
The class is a space for many, who gather to be taught something. It may be a baptism class, a confirmation class, a class, an enquirers' course or an adult Sunday school. The shape is a leader at the front, a body of material, and learners who come with different amounts of knowledge.
Each space makes some things easy and others hard.
2. What one to one does well, and what it does badly
Done well. A one-to-one companionship can fit one person's real question and pace. A man who cannot speak about his father's death in a group of ten can say a sentence about it to one person he trusts. A woman whose English is limited can slow down. An adult who has been hurt by a group can try one relationship first. The form also lets a companion notice small changes in a person's life over months.
Done badly. It depends on one person's character and time. If the companion is weary, the road stops. If the companion is careless, no one else sees. If the companion has too much influence, there is no one to say so. A pair can become closed, and it is the form in which dependence and control are most likely to grow, as lectures 2-3 and 2-4 explain. It is also expensive in people: one companion can walk beside only a few adults at once.
3. What the small group does well, and what it does badly
Done well. A small group lets an adult find that others have the same questions, and that faith is carried by a community and not alone. It teaches listening, patience and mutual care by practice. It spreads the work: no single person has to be everything. Mark 3:14 says Jesus appointed twelve "that they might be with him." The group is a place of being with, not only of learning about.
Done badly. A group can be dominated by one voice. It can be shallow if it avoids what is hard, or harsh if it presses people to say more than they wish. A group moves at the speed of its slowest or loudest member, and an adult whose need is private may sit through months of talk that does not touch it. A group can also turn into a closed circle that is warm inside and cold to anyone arriving later.
4. What the class does well, and what it does badly
Done well. A class can pass on a body of teaching to many people at once, with a plan and a clear beginning and end. For an adult who wants to know what the church believes, or who is preparing for baptism or confirmation, a class gives a map of the ground. It is efficient where the need is shared. It also gives a church one place where its teaching can be seen and checked.
Done badly. A class tends to speak to the average adult and miss the actual one. Questions that come from a real life may not fit the lesson. Some adults are afraid of the front of a room because of old experiences of school. A class can make faith look like information, and an adult who finishes the course may feel finished. This is the danger of treating as a programme, and the whole course argues against it.
5. Choosing: start from the adult, then look at the church
Many churches choose a form because it is the one they already run. A better order has two steps.
Step one: ask what the adult needs. The questions below are not a test. They are a way of attending.
- Does this adult need a body of teaching, such as what the church believes, how to read the Bible or what happens in baptism? A class often fits.
- Does this adult need to find others who share the road, or to practise listening and speaking? A small group often fits.
- Does this adult carry something private or heavy, such as grief, doubt, shame or a hard decision? One-to-one company often fits, and some of these matters call for a pastor or a qualified helper, as lecture 2-3 explains.
- Does this adult learn better by reading, by talking, by doing, by listening? Do they read easily? Do they have a free evening? Do they have a shift pattern, a child to care for, a long journey?
Step two: ask what the church can honestly offer. A church of twenty cannot run a large class series. A church with one helper cannot give ten adults one-to-one company. A church with a small budget may not hire a trainer. Be honest. A form offered badly is worse than a simpler form offered well.
Then put the two together. If the need is for private company and the church has only one helper, the helper might walk beside two adults and not ten. If the need is for teaching and the church has a hall, a class may serve. If the need is for belonging, a meal and a circle of chairs may do more than a syllabus.
6. Combining the forms
Most adults are best served by more than one form at once. A few patterns are common.
A class with a companion. An adult joins an enquirers' class, and one member of the church agrees to meet with the adult once between sessions to hear questions that did not fit the class. Many churches with a formal catechumenate do something like this, often through a sponsor.
A group with a pairing. Within a small group, two members agree to pray for one another and to speak between meetings. The group provides the circle, and the pairing provides the private space.
One to one that opens into a group. An adult starts with a single companion because they cannot yet enter a room of strangers. As the companionship grows, the companion invites the adult to join a group, at a pace the adult chooses. The companion does not push, and the adult can stay as long as they wish in the first form.
A group that sends people to a class. The group finds that several members have the same question, for example how to read a hard book of the Bible, and agrees to join a short class together.
Combining carries its own caution. The more forms a person is in, the more people hold some part of their story. Let the adult choose what is shared among them, and do not let the three leaders talk about the adult without the adult's knowledge. The same adult should not be pulled to every meeting the church offers; a path that uses up an adult's week has stopped being a help.
7. Small churches and large
In a large church, the danger is that forms multiply while no one watches the whole of one adult's road. The remedy is a named person, a pastor, a coordinator or a team, whose task is to look at the pattern, to ask "What is happening for this person?" and to make sure that no adult falls between the groups. Many adults in a large church can be in a class and yet be known by no one.
In a small church, or a house church, the danger is the opposite. There may be one form only, or none, and the same two or three people carry everything. The remedy is to be clear and modest. One person can honestly walk beside two adults. A single evening a month can be a class if it has a plan. A shared meal can be a group. The church does not need to copy a large church's structure. It needs to be clear about which form it is offering to whom.
In a liturgical community, the forms may be marked by the church year and by rites: a period of enquiry, a time of preparation, a sponsor who stands beside the adult. The shapes are often already there. The task is to make sure that the persons who fill the roles are really beside the adults and not merely present at the rite.
In a free church or an assembly, the forms are often freer, and may depend on the gifts and time of certain people. The task is to make sure that the free forms have an end or a review, so that no group or pairing continues out of habit after it has stopped helping.
In both, the church should be able to say: "Here is what we offer, here is what we do not, and here is who can say what an adult is doing next."
8. The walk to Emmaus as a picture of company
Luke 24:13-35 gives a picture of one form of company, which may be useful to hold beside the three forms above. Two people were walking, talking and sad. Jesus came near and went with them. They did not recognise him. He did not begin with a lecture. He asked them a question, they told him their story at length, and only then did he open the Scriptures to them. Later, when they urged him to stay, he stayed, and it was at table that they knew him.
Notice what a companion may take from this, without pressing the story too far. The company came alongside, at the speed of the walkers. It began with a question and listening. The teaching came after the story had been told. It was given on the road, in the middle of an ordinary journey. And it ended at a meal, in a house, where a guest was invited to stay.
The story is not a rule. It cannot show how every companionship should go, and the Lord's own knowledge and authority were not like ours. But it shows a pattern that suits any of the three forms. A class that begins with the learners' questions, a group that listens before it teaches, and a one-to-one companion who sits and asks are all drawn from the same road.
9. Where the other courses come in
When you have chosen a form, you will need skills for it. The technique of leading a small group is taught in the small-group course (LM201E). The technique of teaching, with a class or a person, is taught in How to Teach (LM402E). This lecture does not repeat either one. Its job is to help you ask, before you begin, which form is right and whether your church can offer it honestly.
Diagram 1. Three forms, what each gives, and where each strains
In short
- One to one, the small group and the class are three different spaces; each does some things well and some badly, and none is best.
- One to one fits private matters and one person's pace but rests on one companion and can foster dependence.
- A small group shows an adult that others share the road, but one voice can dominate it or it can close to newcomers.
- A class passes on teaching to many but speaks to the average adult and can make faith look like information.
- Choose by asking first what the adult needs and then what the church can honestly offer; combine forms, without overloading the adult.
- Large churches need someone who watches the whole pattern; small churches need to be clear and modest about what they offer.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Choosing a form | Start from the adult's need, then ask what the church can honestly offer; do not start from the programme already running. |
| One to one: gift and strain | Fits private matters and one person's pace; rests on one person and can grow into dependence. |
| Small group: gift and strain | Shows that others share the road; one voice may dominate or the circle may close. |
| Class: gift and strain | Passes on teaching to many; speaks to the average adult and can make faith look like information. |
One sentence to remember No form of company is best; the right one is the one that fits this adult and that the church can honestly offer.
This week's action Write on a private page the forms your church actually offers, and for each, one adult it fits well and one it does not reach.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the three forms has your community used most? Which adults has it served well, and which adults has it quietly lost?
- Think of a time when you were in one of the three forms. What did it give you? What did it strain?
- What does your community offer an adult who is carrying something private and heavy? Is the answer a form, a person or nothing?
- If your church has one helper and no budget, which form would you offer first, and what would you say clearly about what you cannot offer?
- In the Emmaus story, the teaching came after the story had been told. In your classes and groups, does teaching come before the story or after?
- How can a church make sure an adult is not pulled into every meeting it runs?