Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
A church that used to meet in a hall now has a weekly adult study on a video call. A retired teacher, who lives on a hill two hours from the church by bus, has not missed a session in a year. A young mother joins from her kitchen with a baby on her knee, camera off. A man who works nights joins in the car park outside his factory. One older member of the congregation has never been on the call, because he has no computer and his telephone line is poor, and nobody has thought to ask what happened to him.
All of these are true at once in many places, and they show the two sides of this subject. Online learning can reach people who could not come. It can also leave out people who cannot connect, and it carries risks of privacy and of thin relationship that a meeting in a room does not. This lecture asks what online and blended learning can and cannot do for adult discipleship, how to protect the people in it, and why it should serve presence and not replace it.
A later course in this programme covers online discipleship in depth. This lecture gives the basics that a person who leads adults needs now, whatever the tools are. Tools change; the questions below stay.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Name what online learning can do well for adult groups and what it does poorly.
- Describe how to protect the privacy of people in an online or recorded session.
- Explain how to include adults who have no device, no connection or little skill.
- Say what "blended" learning means and why it should not replace presence.
- Name three practical habits for leading an online session that keeps people as people.
Let us consider how to provoke one another to love and good works, not forsaking our own assembling together, as the custom of some is, but exhorting one another; and so much the more, as you see the Day approaching." — Hebrews 10:24-25
World English Bible
For I long to see you, that I may impart to you some spiritual gift, to the end that you may be established; that is, that I with you may be encouraged in you, each of us by the other’s faith, both yours and mine." — Romans 1:11-12
WEB
Two notes about gathering. The first speaks of an assembling that stirs love and good works, and warns against dropping it. The second is from Paul, who longs to see people in person and says why: so that each may be encouraged by the other's faith. Paul wrote letters, which were a kind of distance learning, and he also wanted to be present. Both can be true.
1. A word about the tools
This lecture does not name any product, platform or application. They change quickly, and the lesson does not depend on which one a community uses. It speaks of three things in general terms: a live online meeting (people in different places, at the same time), a recorded or shared resource (a video, an audio file, a written study that people use when they like), and blended learning (some of both, together with meeting in person).
2. What online learning can do well
Be fair to it. There are real gains, and a leader who denies them is not serving the people who have found them.
It reaches people who could not come. A person who is ill, a carer who cannot leave a relative, a shift worker, someone in another town or country, a person whose health makes travel hard, a member who has moved away: for these, an online session may be the only way to take part.
It gives time. A recorded talk or a written study can be used at a different hour. An adult who has only twenty minutes at midnight can do something with that.
It can lower some barriers. A shy person may find it easier to type a question than to speak it in a room. A person who fears a crowd may be able to take part from a quiet place. A group can include a speaker from far away.
It can keep a thread. Between meetings, a short message or a shared reading can keep a group in touch.
3. What it does poorly
Be fair here too.
It thins presence. On a screen we see faces, but not the whole person. Small signs of distress, of weariness, of welcome are harder to see. Silence is hard to read. A pause that would be companionable in a room may feel like a broken connection.
It is tiring in its own way. Many people find a long session on a screen draining. Short sessions, a break and a camera off option help.
It favours the confident and the connected. The person with a good device, a fast connection, a quiet room and skill with the tools finds it easy. Others do not.
It makes some things harder to do together. Sharing bread, laying on hands, anointing, receiving the , praying with a hand on a shoulder: these are things for which the Christian traditions generally want bodies in a room. What a given community permits at a distance differs, and this lecture does not decide it. The communities themselves, through their own teaching and their pastors, decide what can be done online and what cannot.
It can slide into watching. A recorded talk is easy to watch and easy to forget. The adult who learns by watching alone does not have the benefit of a question, a friend, or a person who notices.
4. Privacy: who can see, who can keep
An online session raises questions that a room does not.
Who is in the session? In a room, you can see who is present. Online, a person may be listening off-screen: a relative, a colleague, a stranger who found the link. Share a link only with those you intend, and say at the start who is present and whether anyone is listening who has not been named.
Is it recorded? Recording is easy and its effects are lasting. A recording of an adult speaking of a doubt or a hardship can be kept and shared far beyond the group. Decide before the session whether to record. If you do, tell everyone clearly at the start, give them a way to leave or turn off their camera and microphone, and do not record small-group conversations or any session in which people speak personally. Delete recordings according to a stated rule.
Where do the messages go? A group chat can carry personal information. A prayer request sent to forty people is no longer a private matter. Say what the group chat is for, and what belongs elsewhere.
Who holds the list? Names, addresses and telephone numbers of adults are personal data. Keep them where only those who need them can see them. Data protection law differs from country to country, and some places treat information about a person's religion as especially sensitive. This lecture does not give a legal rule. Follow your community's written policy and local law, and ask the person responsible in your community if you are unsure.
Who are the children and the vulnerable adults? If a session includes anyone who is a minor or who may be vulnerable, the community's safeguarding policy applies online as it does in a room. Do not meet one adult or one child alone through a private online channel unless the policy allows it.
5. Who is left out
Return to the member with no computer. Every online plan has someone on the other side of it. Ask who they are.
People without a device or a connection. This may be a matter of money, of place, or of the infrastructure where they live. Do not assume that "everyone has a phone." Some have a phone that cannot run the application. Some have a shared device, and a household in which others will hear. Some have data they must ration.
People who are not used to the tools. Many adults, especially but not only older ones, find the tools confusing, or are afraid of breaking something. They may say nothing and simply drop away.
People who need a different form. A person who is blind or deaf, a person with a condition that makes screens difficult, a person who reads slowly: the form of the session may shut them out.
What can be done? Here are some ways that do not need money.
- Offer a plain way in. A telephone number to call in by voice, a posted printed study, a visit.
- Pair people. Ask a member who is at ease with the tools to help another, in person if possible.
- Teach without shaming. Offer a short practice time before a session, as a normal feature.
- Keep an offline way. If a group meets online, make sure there is also a way to take part without a screen: a printed copy, a call, a visit.
- Ask. "Is this form of meeting working for you? What would make it easier?"
In some places, a community may not be able to do any of this. A small church with no technical help, no money and one leader should not feel it has failed. The best online habit for such a church may be to do very little of it and to keep meeting in person.
6. Blended learning, and why presence is not replaced
"Blended" means that some of the learning happens online and some in person. A group might meet in a room every second week, with a short study and a message group between. A catechist might send a reading by telephone message and meet the adult once a month. The blend can fit a busy life better than either alone.
The key question is what the blend is for. Presence is the aim; the online part serves it. The reasons are those in the two verses above. The author of Hebrews speaks of an assembling that stirs people to love and good works. Paul wants to see the Roman Christians, so that he and they may be encouraged "each of us by the other's faith." Neither speaks of a technology, and neither suggests that a message is as good as a meeting. At the same time, both texts were carried by a means of distance: Paul's was a letter. A letter carried his words, and he did not therefore stop wanting to see the people.
A plain test for any online practice: does it bring people closer to each other and to the faith, or does it stand in place of that? A weekly video call that leaves people more connected passes. A stream that people watch alone, and that replaces the visit they would otherwise have made, may not.
Some communities hold that certain acts of the church, such as the sacraments, require the bodily gathering. Others are more open to what can be shared at a distance. This lecture does not decide the matter; it asks the person who leads to follow the community's teaching and to be honest with adults about what an online session is and is not.
7. Three habits for an online session
If your community uses online meetings, these three habits keep people as people.
Begin by arriving. The first five minutes are for greeting, not for content. Give each person a moment to say hello. Silence at the start of a screen call is harder than silence in a room, so fill it with warmth.
Make it short and give a break. A session of an hour on a screen is long. Forty minutes, with a pause, is often better. Give permission to turn off the camera.
Keep a way to reach the person afterwards. If someone looked low or said something hard, follow up the same day by a call or a message. Do not leave a worrying silence for a week.
Diagram 1. What online learning serves, and what it should not replace
In short
- Online learning can reach the ill, the carer, the shift worker and the far away, and can give time and a quiet way to speak; it thins presence, tires, favours the connected and cannot carry what needs bodies.
- Decide before a session whether it is recorded, say so at the start, and keep names, contacts and group messages where only those who need them can see them.
- Follow your community's written policy and local law on personal data and safeguarding; this lecture gives no legal rule.
- Ask who is left out (no device, no connection, no skill, a different need) and keep a plain way in that needs no screen.
- Blended learning serves presence; test any online practice by asking whether it brings people closer or stands in place of that.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What online does well | Reaches those who cannot come, gives time, lowers some barriers, keeps a thread. |
| What it does poorly | Thins presence, tires, favours the connected, cannot carry what needs bodies. |
| Privacy basics | Say who is present; decide about recording and say so; protect names and messages; follow policy and local law. |
| The test of any online practice | Does it bring people closer to each other and to the faith, or stand in place of that? |
One sentence to remember Let the screen serve the gathering, and do not forget the person who is not on it.
This week's action Find out how one adult who is not online takes part in your community's learning, and ask them what would make it easier.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Who in your community has been helped by online learning? Who has dropped away because of it? How do you know?
- Which of the limits of online learning (thin presence, tiredness, favouring the connected, things that need bodies, slipping into watching) do you see most clearly where you are?
- If your community records sessions, who knows about it? What would a person who spoke a hardship in a recorded session need to be told?
- Think of a member who is not online. What is the plain way in that your community offers? What else could it offer?
- What does your tradition teach about which acts of worship need a bodily gathering? How does that shape what you do online?
- Using the test (does it bring people closer or stand in place of that?), how would you judge one online practice in your community?