Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
A group of adults seldom believes the same thing in the same way. In a class for adults there may be a woman who came because a friend asked her and who does not yet know what she thinks. There may be a man who was raised in the faith, no longer sure of it and too proud to say so. There may be a husband whose wife is the believer, and who comes to keep her company. There may be a member of another Christian tradition who has moved to town and is looking for a home, or who is simply visiting for a season. There may be someone of another faith who is a neighbour, a relative or a colleague, and who has been invited to a meal or an evening.
This lecture is about being with such adults without pressing them, and without pretending that the community believes nothing in particular. The argument is that welcome and honesty belong together. A community that welcomes without saying what it believes is not telling the truth about itself. A community that states what it believes without welcome is not showing what the belief is for. The companion's task is to hold both, with respect for the adult's own mind.
This lecture does not argue for any theory of how Christians should relate to other faiths. Traditions disagree on that, and the course does not settle it. It asks for a posture that nearly all of them can share: kindness, clarity and patience.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Describe five kinds of adults who may be in the room with differing beliefs.
- Explain why welcome without pressure and honesty about the community's beliefs belong together.
- Say what a companion can do to make a seeker, a doubter or a visitor feel at home without forcing a decision.
- Describe how to speak of the community's faith in a clear and humble way when asked.
- Name the limits of a companion's role when a mixed household or a conflict of belief becomes painful.
Paul stood in the middle of the Areopagus, and said, “You men of Athens, I perceive that you are very religious in all things. For as I passed along, and observed the objects of your worship, I found also an altar with this inscription: ‘TO AN UNKNOWN GOD.’ What therefore you worship in ignorance, this I announce to you." — Acts 17:22-23
World English Bible
Now when they heard of the resurrection of the dead, some mocked; but others said, “We want to hear you again concerning this.” Thus Paul went out from among them. But certain men joined with him, and believed, among whom also was Dionysius the Areopagite, and a woman named Damaris, and others with them." — Acts 17:32-34
WEB
But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear: having a good conscience; that, while you are spoken against as evildoers, they may be disappointed who curse your good way of life in Christ." — 1 Peter 3:15-16
WEB
Walk in wisdom toward those who are outside, redeeming the time. Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." — Colossians 4:5-6
WEB
In Athens, Paul begins from what the listeners already honour, speaks plainly about what he believes, and meets three responses: some mock, some wish to hear more, some believe. He does not force a result. The letter of Peter asks for readiness to explain hope "with humility and fear", and Colossians asks for speech that is gracious and fitted to the person. Together the passages describe clarity without pressure, and respect without silence.
1. Who is in the room
It helps to name the people, so that the companion does not lump them together. The five below are not a complete list, and one adult can be in more than one.
The seeker. Someone who is curious or searching and has not decided. A seeker may come because of a bereavement, a change of life, a friendship, a book or a question. A seeker may not know how to join in and may fear making a mistake in a service or a prayer.
The doubter. Someone who has believed, in some way, and now is unsure. Lecture 3-3 looked at doubt in detail. In a mixed group the doubter is often quiet, since saying "I am not sure" in front of the faithful costs something.
The spouse or relative of another faith or none. A husband, wife or parent who comes to the church because of family. This person may attend for years without being asked what they think. They may be happy, or they may feel they are a guest at an event that does not belong to them.
The member of another Christian tradition. A Catholic in an evangelical class, a Pentecostal in an Orthodox parish, an evangelical in a Lutheran fellowship. The differences may be in the Bible, the sacraments, authority, worship or the saints. The person is often a fellow believer, and sometimes feels unsure whether they are treated as one.
The neighbour of another faith. A person who comes to a meal, a funeral, a wedding, or an open evening and may or may not return. This person may be deeply devout in another tradition and is not a project.
(An invented example.) In a parish evening class for adults, six people sit round a table. Joan is returning to church after twenty years. Mehmet's wife, who is a member, brought him for the first week and he has come since because he enjoys the discussion. Olu was raised in an independent Pentecostal church and has recently joined the parish with his family. Teresa has said she is "not sure about God, but sure about this room". Each of these four hears the same words differently. The leader who forgets this will end up speaking to one person.
2. Welcome without pressure
Welcome of newcomers belongs to the course LM207E. For this lecture, the question is narrower: what does welcome look like when beliefs differ?
Treat the person as a person before treating them as a prospect. An adult can tell at once whether they are being listened to or being worked on. The message "we want you to become one of us" may be true, and it is not the first thing to say. The first thing is that the person is wanted for who they are, now, in the room.
Ask and listen about their story. "What brought you here?" and "What was your experience of church or faith, if any?" are good questions, asked in a relaxed way and not as an examination. Accept the answer, including "I am not sure". Do not correct it.
Let people take part at their own level. Some people will join the prayers, some will sit quietly, some will not say "Amen". In many traditions, certain acts, such as receiving communion, are for members of the community only, or for baptised Christians only. A companion should explain what the community's practice is, kindly and in advance, so that a guest is neither embarrassed nor offended. "In our parish, communion is for baptised Christians. You are welcome to come forward for a blessing, or to stay in your seat." Such a sentence respects both the practice and the person. Where the community's practice is wider or narrower, say what it is.
Do not count heads. An adult who is being watched for signs of conversion will feel it. is not a conversion rate. The companion who sets out to "win" a particular person has already turned a friend into a target. Lecture 6-3 returns to the danger of counting.
Respect the adult's decision. If a person decides not to come back, or to stay at the edge, or to explore another community, that is theirs to decide. A farewell that is warm may be remembered for years.
3. Be clear about what the community believes
Respect for the person does not mean silence about the faith. A community that hides its beliefs from guests treats them as unable to cope with the truth. A person should be able to ask, "What do you believe?" and receive a plain answer.
What counts as a plain answer depends on the community. A parish may point to a creed and a , an assembly to a statement of faith, a house church to a short list of what it holds central. The companion should know what the community teaches, and should not invent or soften it. If the companion does not know, the honest reply is, "I will ask our pastor and tell you."
Here are some habits that make clarity kind.
- Speak for the community when you speak for it, and for yourself when you speak for yourself. "Our church teaches..." and "I find that..." are different sentences.
- Do not caricature another faith or another Christian tradition. If you describe their belief, describe it in a way a member of that tradition would recognise. If you do not know it well, say so and ask.
- Do not pretend to agree. If asked whether you think all religions say the same thing, and you do not, say gently what you think. The same respect that listens also speaks.
- Do not use a person's silence as consent. A spouse who sits through years of services has not thereby agreed to anything.
- Say what you do not know. "I do not have a good answer to that" is a good answer.
The passage in 1 Peter asks for readiness to give "an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear." The weight falls on two things. The question comes from the other person. And the manner is humble. It is not a licence to push an argument on someone who has not asked.
4. What Paul does in Athens, and what he does not
Acts 17 is a case that has been read in many ways. This lecture takes only a few features of it that most traditions can accept.
Paul begins from what he sees: the city is full of objects of worship, and he has noticed an altar to an unknown god. He does not begin by insulting. He starts where the listeners are. He then says plainly what he believes about God, creation, repentance and the resurrection. He does not leave out the hard part: some of his hearers mock when they hear of the resurrection.
The result is mixed. Some mock. Some say, "We want to hear you again." A few join him. The narrative does not hide the mocking, and it does not suggest that Paul changed his message to avoid it. It also does not suggest that he followed anyone home to press them.
Three points follow for a companion. First, begin with something true that you can honestly share with the other person, a shared concern, a question, a value. Second, say what you believe without apology and without a threat. Third, accept the range of responses. Not everyone who hears will believe. Some will say, "Tell me more." The companion's faithfulness does not depend on the proportion.
Traditions differ on how to speak of other faiths and on whether and how to invite people to convert. Some stress proclamation and a clear invitation. Some stress dialogue, presence and friendship, and trust God with the outcome. Some stress both. This course does not decide among them. It asks that in every case the person is treated with honour, the community's belief is stated honestly, and nobody is manipulated.
5. The mixed household
One of the hardest settings for a companion is a marriage or family in which one person is a believer and another is not, or in which the two belong to different traditions. The believer may long to share their faith and feel lonely without it. The other may feel unspoken pressure, or be fully content.
The companion is not a marriage counsellor. But some simple things can be said.
- Listen to the believer without urging them to push. A spouse who is pressed to believe may come to resent the faith. Patience, kindness and an honest life are slow and are often what is asked.
- Do not pray in a way that makes the other spouse a case. A prayer request that names an unbelieving husband in front of the group may feel to him like exposure.
- Welcome the other spouse as a person. Invite them to a meal, to a social event, to a task that suits them. If they take part, good. If not, keep the door open.
- Notice when the situation is more than a difference of belief. If a person says that they are afraid at home, controlled, or forbidden to attend church or to speak to friends, that is not a disagreement about faith. It is a matter for a pastor and a professional. For immediate danger, call the local emergency number. Duties to report differ by country and role.
Where a marriage is troubled, a pastor and a trained counsellor are the right persons. The companion's part is to notice, to stay and to pass on.
6. The same posture in different communities
In a liturgical community, the structure gives the guest a clear place: the welcome at the door, the printed order of service, the distinction between receiving a blessing and receiving communion. The risk is a sense of closed doors. A companion can explain the service in advance and sit beside a guest who is lost.
In a free-church or Pentecostal assembly, a guest may be greeted warmly and invited to the front, and may feel exposed. A companion can protect the guest from being singled out for prayer or testimony before they wish. The risk is a warmth so strong that it feels like pressure.
In a very small community, everyone knows who the guest is. A kind and plain word, "You are welcome here, whatever you believe, and please ask me anything", is a good beginning, and it costs nothing.
7. Where other courses take over
The welcome of newcomers is taught in LM207E. Teaching about other faiths and the theology of religions is a matter for courses in doctrine and mission. The listening skills that help in these conversations are taught in LM205E. This lecture offers the posture in one phrase: welcome and honesty together.
Diagram 1. Welcome and honesty held together
In short
- A group contains seekers, doubters, spouses of other faiths or none, members of other Christian traditions and neighbours of other faiths.
- Welcome and honesty belong together: the person is wanted now, and the community's beliefs are stated plainly.
- Explain the community's practices in advance, such as who receives communion, so that no guest is embarrassed.
- Speak for the community when you speak for it, do not caricature other traditions, and say what you do not know.
- Paul in Athens begins where the listeners are, speaks plainly, and accepts a mixed response.
- In a mixed household do not press the other spouse; if fear or control appears, pass on to a pastor and a professional.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Welcome with honesty | The person is wanted now and the community says plainly what it believes. |
| Explaining practice | Tell guests in advance, kindly, who may receive communion and what the options are. |
| What Paul shows in Athens | Begin where listeners are, say what you believe, accept a mixed response. |
| A mixed household | Do not press the other spouse; notice fear or control and pass on. |
One sentence to remember Welcome a person as a person, say plainly what you believe, and leave the decision to them.
This week's action Write one plain sentence about what your community believes and one about how it welcomes a guest who does not share it. Test both on a friend.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the five kinds of adults is most often in your group? Which is least noticed?
- How does your community explain its practices (for example communion, prayer, baptism) to a guest in advance? What is missing?
- Write one plain sentence about what your community believes. Would a guest understand it?
- When have you felt pressure to believe or to join something? What did it do to your trust in the person?
- How does your tradition speak about people of other faiths and other Christian traditions? Can you state it in a way a member of that group would recognise?
- If a believing spouse asks for help because their partner is not a believer, what would you say, and when would you pass the matter on?