Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
Think of a woman who has sat in the same pew, or stood in the same place at the back, for thirty years. She has been to every festival. She knows the hymns, the order of the service and the names of three generations of the parish. If you asked her whether she believes, she would say yes at once and a little sharply. And if you asked her in a quiet moment, away from others, whether anything has changed in her faith in ten years, she might look at the floor and say, "Not really. I do not know why."
This lecture is about adults like her. They have been in the church a long time. They are not lost, they are not angry, and they have not left. They are stuck, or they feel they are. The people around them often do not notice, because such members are reliable and quiet. The companion who does notice faces a temptation: to offer a new programme, a new book, a new group, as if the trouble were a shortage of material.
The argument of this lecture is simple to say and hard to live. A long-time member who feels stuck is seldom helped by one more programme. Such a member is helped by a person who will walk the dry stretch beside them, ask honest questions and not hurry to fix. The lecture also asks you not to assume that stuck means failing. Many of the great traditions of the church speak of dry seasons as part of a road, not as a sign that the road is wrong.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Describe three different things a member might mean by "I feel stuck".
- Explain why a new programme is seldom the right first response, and what a companion can offer instead.
- Name four questions a companion can ask a long-time member without blaming them.
- Distinguish a dry season from a sign that the person needs a pastor or a professional, and say when to pass on.
- Explain how the same approach looks in a liturgical community and in a free-church one.
But I have this against you, that you left your first love." — Revelation 2:4
World English Bible
God, you are my God. I will earnestly seek you. My soul thirsts for you. My flesh longs for you, in a dry and weary land, where there is no water. So I have seen you in the sanctuary, watching your power and your glory. Because your loving kindness is better than life, my lips shall praise you." — Psalms 63:1-3
WEB
But he was angry, and would not go in. Therefore his father came out, and begged him. But he answered his father, ‘Behold, these many years I have served you, and I never disobeyed a commandment of yours, but you never gave me a goat, that I might celebrate with my friends. But when this, your son, came, who has devoured your living with prostitutes, you killed the fattened calf for him.’ “He said to him, ‘Son, you are always with me, and all that is mine is yours. But it was appropriate to celebrate and be glad, for this, your brother, was dead, and is alive again. He was lost, and is found.’”" — Luke 15:28-32
WEB
The first verse is spoken to a church that was busy and faithful in many ways, and still had lost something. The psalm is the voice of a person who longs for God in a dry place and says so without shame. The third passage shows an son who has been in the house all along and still stands outside the feast. Together they say that long service and inner distance can live in the same person, and that the Father goes out to meet both kinds of child.
1. What "stuck" can mean
Adults use the word "stuck" for very different things, and a companion who treats them as one will answer the wrong question. Here are three, drawn from what companions commonly hear. The list is not complete.
Flatness. Nothing is wrong. Prayer feels like saying words into a room. The sermon is familiar. The person still comes and still gives, but the warmth that was once there is not. This is the experience that the old writers of the church sometimes called dryness.
Repetition. The person has done the same things for years: the same class, the same rota, the same kind of Bible reading. They have not been challenged in a long time, and they feel the lack. They are not unhappy so much as unused.
A hidden question. Behind the word "stuck" sits something specific that the person has not said. A grief that was never given time. A doubt that seemed too late in life to raise. A disappointment with God, or with the church, or with a leader. The person has put a lid on it, and the lid is what feels like flatness.
(An invented example.) Grace has led a women's prayer circle for twenty years. She tells a friend that she has "run out of road". The friend asks what she means. After some silence, Grace says that her husband died four years ago, that everyone expected her to be strong because she was a leader, and that she has not prayed for him once. The word "stuck" was covering a grief.
The first task of a companion, then, is not to treat the word. It is to find out which of these, or what else, is meant. That takes time, and it takes a question asked in a way that does not make the person feel they are in trouble.
2. Why a new programme is seldom the first answer
A church that notices stuck members often does the natural thing. It starts something: a new course on prayer, a fresh study, a retreat, a small group with a bright title. These can be good. They are not always wrong. But as a first response they carry three risks.
First, they answer a question that may not have been asked. If the real matter is an unspoken grief, a course on prayer methods will leave the grief where it is, and the person may feel more of a failure because the course did not help.
Second, they can say, without meaning to, that the person is a problem to be fixed. A long-time member who is sent to a programme for people who are struggling may hear, "You are behind." Shame is a poor road back to love.
Third, they keep the leader in the place of the one who knows. The programme comes from outside, and the person receives it. An adult who has decided for herself throughout her life may quietly stop deciding for herself here, or may quietly decline, and the programme counts one more person who "did not engage".
None of this means a programme is never useful. A person who says, "I would like to learn to pray with Scripture, and I do not know how," has asked a question a programme can answer. The point is the order. First listen to the question the person actually has. Then, if a programme fits that question, offer it as one possible help and leave the person free to say no.
3. The dry road is an old road
The psalm for this lecture was written by someone who longed for God "in a dry and weary land, where there is no water". It is not the song of a person whose faith has failed. It is the song of a person whose faith is so alive that its absence hurts. The same psalm goes on to remember the sanctuary, and to say that the soul "stays close" to God even in the dark.
Many traditions have long said something like this. In some Orthodox and Catholic writing, there are periods in which prayer seems to give nothing back, and a wise guide tells the person to keep faith with the habit and not to read the dryness as a verdict. In some Pentecostal and evangelical settings, a season of low feeling is met with the advice to wait, to keep serving and to stay with the community until it passes. The vocabulary differs. The shared point is that the feeling of distance is not by itself proof of distance.
This course does not claim that every dry period is of this kind. There are other causes. A person may be exhausted, or ill, or unhappy in a way that deserves care of its own. There are also seasons when Scripture speaks to the church as it speaks to Ephesus: you have lost something, and it is time to remember where you were. The companion's task is not to decide which. It is to stay near while the person finds out.
4. The elder son
The story of the two sons in Luke 15 is usually taught for its younger son, the one who leaves and returns. The elder son is easy to pass over. He has worked in the field for years. He did not leave. And at the sound of the music he cannot go in.
Notice what the story does and does not say. The elder son is angry, and he says why: he has served for many years and has not been given even a goat. The father does not scold him. The father goes out to him, as he went out to the younger son, and begs him. The father does not answer the complaint with a lecture on gratitude. He says, "Son, you are always with me, and all that is mine is yours." He restates the relationship before he restates the rule.
A companion can learn two things from this. First, a faithful member can carry resentment or weariness that is real, and it deserves to be heard and not argued away. The elder son's complaint is a fair one by the standard of what he knows. Second, the right movement is outward. The father leaves the feast, goes to where the son stands and speaks to him. The companion who walks beside a stuck member does the same: goes to where the person is, and does not wait for them to arrive in the right mood.
The story leaves the son's answer open. We are not told whether he went in. That matters. The companion does not control the outcome either.
5. Four questions that do not blame
A conversation with a long-time member should not feel like an interview. Here are four questions that companions often find useful. They can be asked over a meal or a walk, and not all in one sitting.
- "What has your faith been like lately?" This is open. It does not assume a problem. The answer may be "fine", and that is a real answer.
- "When did you last feel close to God, or feel that something was alive?" This asks for a memory, not a fault. It often brings back a season, a person or an event that tells the companion what matters to the person.
- "Is there something you have been carrying that you have not had a place to say?" This invites the hidden question without demanding it.
- "What would you like, if you could ask for anything in this part of your life?" This returns the decision to the adult. The answer may be small and surprising: to be asked to do something new, to be let off something old, to sit in silence, to learn to read a Psalm.
Notice what these questions share. They do not tell the person what is wrong. They do not offer an answer. They leave room.
6. What to do and what not to do
Stay for more than one conversation. A single meeting rarely finds the answer. A person who has been stuck for years will not be moved in an hour. A companion who says, "I will be here," and means it, offers something no programme can.
Do not blame the person, and do not blame the church. "You should pray more" and "this church has failed you" are both quick verdicts. Neither is yet known.
Do not compare. "There are people who would give anything to have your years in church" shames and does not help.
Offer small and real invitations. Sometimes what unsticks a person is a very small change: a new kind of task, a chance to teach what they know, a request to accompany a newcomer. Offer it as an invitation, leave the person free, and take a refusal quietly.
Know your limits. Persistent flatness can be a sign of low mood or depression. A person who speaks of hopelessness, of not wanting to go on, or of being unable to cope may need a doctor or a counsellor, and a pastor as well. The companion's part is to notice, to stay and to pass on. Do not diagnose. If someone speaks of harming themselves or is in immediate danger, call the local emergency number and stay with them until help comes. Do not promise secrecy that safety forbids. Rules on what must be reported differ by country and by role, so follow your community's written policy and local law.
7. The same road in two kinds of community
In a liturgical parish, the setting often already contains resources: a confessor or spiritual father or mother, a prayer rule, the daily office, a season such as Lent that gives dryness a name and a shape. A companion can work with these. A person who feels stuck may be helped by being invited to go to confession, to take up a modest rule, or to attend one weekday service, as a way of keeping faith with the habit while the feeling is absent. The risk is that the structure can hide the problem, and a person can attend every service for years without anyone asking how they are.
In a free-church or Pentecostal assembly, the setting often has warmth, testimony and a strong expectation of present experience. A person who feels flat may feel they are failing at what everyone else seems to have. The companion's work is to say, gently and in private, that many faithful people pass through such seasons, and that the community's warmth is no measure of any one person's faith on a given Sunday. The risk is that a stuck member learns to perform the expected enthusiasm and tells no one the truth.
In a very small church with one helper, the answer is the same and costs little: a regular cup of tea with a person who is not in a hurry. Nothing more is needed to begin.
8. Where other courses take over
If the stuck member's question is how to teach or lead, the courses on teaching and on leadership take it up. If the hidden question is a deep hurt from the church, lecture 5-2 follows. If the person is drawn to a fuller life of prayer, a later course on is the place. This lecture asks only for the first step: to see the person, ask without blaming, and stay.
Diagram 1. Three meanings of "stuck" and what a companion does first
In short
- "Stuck" can mean flatness, repetition or a hidden question; a companion finds out which before answering.
- A new programme is seldom the right first response, because it may answer a question nobody asked and can suggest the person is a problem to be fixed.
- Dryness is an old and widely recognised road, and the feeling of distance is not by itself proof of distance.
- The father in Luke 15 goes out to the elder son and restates the relationship before the rule.
- Ask without blaming, stay for more than one conversation, and offer small invitations that may be refused.
- Notice persistent hopelessness, stay, and pass on to a pastor or professional; call the emergency number for immediate danger.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three meanings of "stuck" | Flatness, repetition, or a hidden question under the word. |
| Why not a programme first? | It may answer an unasked question and can say "you are a problem to fix". |
| What the elder son shows | A faithful member may carry real resentment; the father goes out to him and restates the relationship. |
| When to pass on | Hopelessness, thoughts of self-harm or deep low mood: a pastor and a professional; emergency number for danger. |
One sentence to remember A long-time member who feels stuck needs a person who will stay and ask, before any programme is offered.
This week's action Think of one long-time member who is quiet. Invite them for tea or a walk, and ask only the first question: "What has your faith been like lately?"
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Of the three meanings of "stuck" (flatness, repetition, a hidden question), which do you think is most often missed in your community? Why?
- When your community notices that someone is stuck, what does it usually do? What does the person probably hear in that action?
- In the story of the elder son, the father goes out to him. What would "going out" look like in your setting for a long-time member who has withdrawn inwardly?
- Which of the four questions would be hardest for you to ask? Which would be hardest for a person to answer? Why?
- What resources in your own tradition (a confessor, a rule of prayer, a testimony time, a pastor) could help a stuck member, and what are the risks of each?
- When does "dry" stop being a season of faith and become a reason to ask for help from a doctor or a counsellor? Who in your area could you pass on to?