Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
Some adults who do not come to church any more have not drifted. They have been hurt there. A leader spoke to them in a way they cannot forget. A trusted friend broke a confidence. A decision about their family was made without them. A person with authority used it to press, to frighten or to silence. Some left in a single week. Others stayed for years and left slowly, and nobody asked why.
This lecture is about walking beside such a person. It is one of the hardest tasks in the course, because the companion usually belongs to the same church that did the harm, or to one that looks like it. The companion is therefore not a neutral party, and the person can see that. The lecture does not ask you to settle what happened. It asks for a posture: listen first, do not defend the institution at once, do not hurry a return, and pass on to people who can help with what is beyond you.
Hurt in a church can run from careless words to a serious misuse of authority. This lecture gives no detail of abuse, and it does not teach how to investigate. It teaches how to be a safe person for the first conversations, and when to hand the matter to someone else.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Name several kinds of hurt that adults carry from church life, from the careless to the serious.
- Explain why defending the church too early closes the conversation.
- Describe what a companion can offer in the first conversations, and what a companion should not promise.
- Explain why a return to the community must not be hurried, and what a person may need instead.
- State when and to whom to pass on, including when to call an emergency number.
For it was not an enemy who insulted me, then I could have endured it. Neither was it he who hated me who raised himself up against me, then I would have hidden myself from him. But it was you, a man like me, my companion, and my familiar friend. We took sweet fellowship together. We walked in God’s house with company." — Psalms 55:12-14
World English Bible
The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to heal the broken hearted, to proclaim release to the captives, recovering of sight to the blind, to deliver those who are crushed," — Luke 4:18
WEB
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalms 34:18
WEB
The first passage is the cry of a person hurt by a close friend with whom he once walked into God's house. It shows that the Bible knows this kind of pain and does not tell the sufferer to be quiet. The verse from Luke gives the direction of Jesus' own work: toward the broken hearted and the crushed. The psalm closes the lecture with a promise that God is near to such people, which does not depend on whether the church has been.
1. What the hurt can be
People say "I was hurt by the church", and the sentence covers a wide range. A companion who hears it should not decide too fast how serious it is, up or down.
- Careless words. A remark about a person's divorce, weight, job, child or doubts, made in passing and never forgotten.
- Being overlooked. Years of service without thanks, or being passed over for a role with no explanation.
- A broken confidence. Something told in trust that was repeated, or used in a sermon or a prayer request.
- A rejection. Being told that a person, a marriage, a question or a past does not belong.
- Pressure and control. A leader who demanded obedience in private choices, who isolated a person from family or friends, who used shame to keep someone in line, or who punished questions. Lecture 2-4 described the signs.
- A serious wrong. Abuse of authority, or of a person, by someone in the community.
The last two are the most serious, and a companion who meets either should not carry it alone. This lecture says only what the companion does in the first hour. It does not ask you to describe or to weigh what was done.
(An invented example.) Daniel sat in the back row for eleven years. Last spring, his eldest son was refused a place in the youth group because the family "did not give enough." Nobody said it to Daniel. He heard it from his son. He has not come since. When a member visits and asks gently why, he says only, "I am busy." The word "busy" covers a good deal.
2. Listen first
The most important thing a companion can do is the plainest: listen. This is not a technique to learn here. The course on listening skills, LM205E, teaches it in depth. The points that matter for this lecture are four.
Let the person tell it at their own pace. Some people will say everything in the first meeting. Others will say a sentence and stop. Both are fine. Do not ask for the full story. A person who is made to repeat it to prove it happened is hurt again.
Believe what the person says about how it felt. You may not know what was said or done. You do not need to. "That sounds painful" does not accuse anyone. It receives a person.
Resist the urge to explain the other side. "I am sure she did not mean it" and "he has had a hard year" may be true, and they are not for the first conversation. They tell the hurt person that the listener is on the other side.
Be willing to stay in the discomfort. The person may be angry at the church, at God or at you. Anger is not an attack to be corrected. It is often what the hurt looks like when it speaks.
3. Do not defend the institution at once
A companion who belongs to the church feels the pull to defend it. The church is also the companion's own family, and the account of its failing is hard to hear. There are good reasons for the pull. Most churches are not harmful, most leaders mean well, and hurt often comes from weakness more than from malice. These things may be true.
Yet to say them first is almost always a mistake. A person who has just said, "I was treated badly by someone in authority," and hears in reply, "But our church has done so much good," hears a closed door. The person concludes that the church will always put itself first. That belief is what the companion is trying to loosen.
The better order is: hear, believe the pain, and say, if it is true, "I am sorry that happened." That sentence does not accept every detail. It does not condemn anyone. It says that the pain is seen. Whether the church is to blame can be looked at later and by the right people. If a matter needs to be looked at, the companion does not do it alone. It is passed to someone responsible, in line with the community's written policy.
One thing a companion should not do is to say "the church is not the people" or "God is not like that" as a way to end the conversation. These may be sincerely believed, and a person who was harmed by someone speaking for God may not be ready to hear them. They may be heard as another claim to speak for God.
4. What not to promise
A hurt person may say, "Promise you will not tell anyone." The wish is understandable, and it is dangerous to grant in full. If what you are told shows that the person or someone else is in danger, or that a child or a vulnerable adult is being harmed, you cannot keep it secret, and you should not say you will.
A better reply is honest and gentle: "I will listen to you, and I will not repeat what you tell me to people who do not need to know. If I hear something that means someone could be hurt, I will tell you first, and I will have to tell the right person." This is the kind of confidence the course describes in lecture 2-3. It is not secrecy as a tool. It is care with a limit that protects people.
Rules about what must be reported, to whom and by whom differ between countries, denominations and roles. Some clergy are bound by a seal or a strict rule of confidence. Some must report certain things to the civil authorities. Do not guess. Know your community's written policy, and know who is the responsible person to ask. If your community has no written policy, ask your pastor or bishop to prepare one.
Do not promise that a wrong will be put right. You may not have the power. Promise what you can: that you will listen, that you will tell the right person if it is needed, and that you will not disappear.
5. Do not hurry a return
A well-meaning church often wants the person back. A companion may feel it too. "We miss you" is kind. "Come back on Sunday and see how it feels" can be a pressure.
Several things may be true of someone who has been hurt in a church:
- The building, the music, a smell, or a particular person may bring the hurt back in the body.
- The person may have found another place of worship, or none, and may be well there.
- The person may need a long time away before deciding anything.
- The person may never return to this church and still be a follower of Christ.
A companion's job is not to restore attendance. It is to walk beside the person, in whatever way the person allows. Sometimes that means meeting outside the church building. Sometimes it means praying together briefly, or not praying at all if the person does not wish it. Sometimes it means only a message a few weeks later that says, "I was thinking of you."
If the person does decide to return, or to try another community, the companion can help with small and gentle steps: an agreed seat near the door, a friend to sit with, permission to leave early. The decision stays the person's.
6. Counselling and other help
Some hurt is beyond what a companion can carry. A person who describes a long period of fear, of flashbacks, of being unable to sleep or work, of feeling worthless, or of thoughts of ending their life, needs more than a friend. The companion is not a counsellor, a doctor or a lawyer, and should not try to be.
The ethic is the same as in the rest of the course: notice, stay, and pass on. Notice that the matter is beyond you. Stay with the person while help is arranged. Pass on to a pastor or other responsible person, and to a counsellor, doctor or other professional who is trained for it. If your community knows trusted professionals, offer their names. If it does not, ask a pastor to help find some. Offering to go with the person to a first appointment is a real kindness.
If a person is in immediate danger, or says they intend to harm themselves or someone else, call the local emergency number and stay with them until help arrives. Do not leave them alone. Do not promise secrecy.
Be careful also about recommending that a hurt person talk to the leader who caused the hurt, or "make peace" with them, as a first step. It may be right in time. It may be unsafe or deeply unfair to ask it too soon. If the person is moved toward reconciliation, it should be on their terms and with a safe third person present, not by pressure from the community.
7. The same posture in different communities
In a liturgical parish, the presence of a clear structure of authority can make the hurt sharper (a priest or a bishop spoke in God's name) and the route of complaint longer. A companion can help a person learn what the community's procedure is, and who outside the parish can be approached, without promising any result. Sacramental life may be a source of comfort or a source of pain, and a person may avoid the sacraments for a while. A companion does not press.
In a free-church or Pentecostal assembly, the leader may be the founder and the highest voice, and there may be no one above them to turn to. A companion may need to help the person find someone outside the assembly: a trusted pastor of another church, a regional leader, or a professional. In a very small community, the person who hurt may sit two rows away, and a companion may need to protect the person's privacy more strictly.
In every community, the companion who listens well is already giving something that the institution failed to give. That is not disloyalty to the church. It may be the most faithful thing the church can do in that moment.
8. Where other courses take over
The skill of listening is taught in LM205E. Counselling and trauma care belong to professionals and to courses in . Preparing a community's policy on safeguarding is a task for its leaders. This lecture asks that the companion know the limits and use the help that exists.
Diagram 1. Notice, stay, pass on: the first conversations with a hurt person
In short
- Hurt in church ranges from careless words to serious wrongs; a companion does not decide too fast how serious it is.
- Listen first, believe how it felt, and say "I am sorry that happened" before any defence of the church.
- Do not promise secrecy that safety forbids; say honestly what you will keep and what you must tell.
- Do not hurry a return; the person may need a long time, another place, or never to return to this church.
- A companion notices, stays and passes on to a pastor and a professional; call the emergency number for immediate danger.
- Duties to report differ by country and role; know your community's written policy.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| First response to hurt | Listen, believe how it felt, and say you are sorry it happened. |
| Why not defend the church first? | It sounds like a closed door and confirms that the church puts itself first. |
| What not to promise | Absolute secrecy, or that a wrong will be put right. |
| Notice, stay, pass on | Notice it is beyond you, stay with the person, and pass on to a pastor and a professional. |
One sentence to remember Before a hurt person can hear anything about the church, they must first be heard.
This week's action Find out your community's written policy on confidence and safeguarding, and write down the name and number of the person you would pass a serious matter to.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of the range from careless words to a serious wrong. Where in that range does your community tend to underestimate hurt?
- Why does "I am sure she did not mean it" close a conversation, even if it is true? What could you say instead?
- What is your community's written policy on confidence and on reporting? If you do not know, whom could you ask this week?
- If a hurt person says, "Promise you will not tell anyone", what would you say? Write the sentence in your own words.
- What would a gentle, unpressured message to a person who has stayed away look like? What would make it feel like pressure?
- Who are the trusted counsellors, doctors or other professionals in your area to whom you could pass someone on? What stops you from knowing their names?