FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT716E Church Staff and People Care: Calling, Hiring, Appraisal and Care of Ministers

Lecture 1-2: Pastors, Staff and Volunteers: Roles and Understandings

Contents 31
PT716E Church Staff and People Care: Calling, Hiring, Appraisal and Care of Ministers
Chapter 0 · Introduction: People Before Positions
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: People Before Positions
Chapter 1 · Week 1: People and Calling
  1. Lecture 1-1: Persons, Not Resources
  2. Lecture 1-2: Pastors, Staff and Volunteers: Roles and Understandings
  3. Lecture 1-3: Partners in Scripture: Delegating, Sending and Supporting
  4. Lecture 1-4: Who Has Authority Over Whom
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Role Map
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Hiring and Welcome
  1. Lecture 2-1: Start With the Need: A Job Description
  2. Lecture 2-2: Searching, Asking and Checking
  3. Lecture 2-3: Offer, Pay and Written Understanding
  4. Lecture 2-4: Welcome and the First Year
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Job Description and Interview Questions
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Working Together and Appraisal
  1. Lecture 3-1: Supervision and Everyday Feedback
  2. Lecture 3-2: Appraisal That Is Fair and Caring
  3. Lecture 3-3: Training, Growth and Mentoring
  4. Lecture 3-4: Fairness and Voice: Staff Who Find It Hard to Speak
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Appraisal Conversation
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Caring for Ministers
  1. Lecture 4-1: Pay, Leave, Sabbath and Sabbatical
  2. Lecture 4-2: Reading the Signs of Exhaustion
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Minister's Household
  4. Lecture 4-4: Friends, Mentors and Support
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Care Plan
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Hard Times
  1. Lecture 5-1: Conflict and Authority Among Staff
  2. Lecture 5-2: Misconduct and Fair Correction
  3. Lecture 5-3: Leaving: Resignation, Dismissal and Reduction
  4. Lecture 5-4: After a Departure
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing a Hard Conversation
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Sustaining the Work of Many
  1. Lecture 6-1: Volunteers and Lay Partners
  2. Lecture 6-2: Different Sizes, Different Traditions
  3. Lecture 6-3: Handing On: Succession, Interim and Retirement
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Yearly Rhythm of People Care
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page People Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

21 min

People who work among a community do not all stand in the same place. One is ordained and recognised by a wider church. One is hired to run the office. One is employed half-time as youth worker. One is a pastor who also teaches in a school to pay his bills. One leads the children's class every Sunday and has never been paid. One comes in from outside, once a week, to keep the building safe. If the community treats all of them the same way, some will be wronged. If it never says clearly how they differ, everyone will be confused.

This lecture sorts out the common kinds of role and shows why a short written description of each role, and of what has been promised, protects everyone. It does not tell you which kind of role your community should have. It tells you how to say plainly what each one is.

This lecture is not legal or employment advice. A person's legal status (employee, clergy, volunteer, contractor, or something else) depends on the country, region and year, and the same title can mean different things in different places. Do not decide a person's status from this lecture. Check locally and ask a qualified person.

What these 21 minutes give you

  • Name six common kinds of role in a community and say how they differ.
  • Explain why the word used for a role may not match the legal or practical reality, and why that must be checked locally.
  • List the parts of a short written description of a role.
  • Explain why paid work should not be passed off as volunteering.
  • Describe how a minister with a second job can be treated fairly and openly.

He gave some to be apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, shepherds and teachers;" — Ephesians 4:11

World English Bible

for the perfecting of the saints, to the work of serving, to the building up of the body of Christ;" — Ephesians 4:12

WEB

For even as we have many members in one body, and all the members don’t have the same function," — Romans 12:4

WEB

Let the elders who rule well be counted worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in the word and in teaching." — 1 Timothy 5:17

WEB

The New Testament shows many kinds of service, not all the same. Paul does not rank a person's worth by the function. He does say that functions differ, and that those who labour deserve honour. Naming the differences clearly is not unspiritual. It is part of honouring them.

1. Six kinds of role

The names differ from place to place, but most communities have some of these six kinds of role. Read each as a description of a common pattern, not a rule.

1. The ordained or recognised minister. A person whom a wider church or the community has set apart for a ministry: priest, pastor, minister, with a charge, or another title. The tradition has its own rules about who may hold such an office, how a person is called, who oversees them and how they may be removed. Those rules belong to that tradition's own order, and this course does not decide them.

2. The paid staff member. A person hired to do defined work for the community and paid for it: an administrator, a youth worker, a musician, a caretaker, a bookkeeper. The role may be full-time or part-time.

3. The part-time or bi-vocational minister. A person who serves as a minister and also has another paid job: a pastor who teaches school, or a priest who farms. This is very common in the world and is not a lesser arrangement. Section "The minister with a second job" returns to it.

4. The volunteer leader. A person who gives time without pay and carries real responsibility: a small group leader, a children's coordinator, a member of a committee, a treasurer who gives the hours free.

5. The outside contractor or supplier. A person or firm engaged for a task, paid for the result, and not under the community's day-to-day direction: a builder, an accountant, a trainer for a weekend, an electrician.

6. The sent or seconded worker. A person placed by a mission agency, a diocese, a denomination or another body, who may be paid by that body and not by the local community, and who answers to both.

A single person can fit more than one: a retired teacher who is a volunteer leader and also a paid caretaker. This is where confusion starts.

2. Why the label may not match the facts

Communities usually choose a word and then act as though the word settles everything. "He is a minister, not an employee." "She is only a volunteer." "They are contractors." Yet the facts of the arrangement may point elsewhere.

Consider three questions that apply almost everywhere, though their legal weight differs:

  • Who decides what the person does each day, and when?
  • Is the person paid regularly, or only for results or expenses?
  • Could the person freely do the same work for someone else?

If the community tells the person what to do, when to do it and where, and pays regularly, then in some places the law treats the person as an employee whatever the community calls them. In other places it does not. In some countries a minister is treated by the law as an office-holder who is not an employee; in others the same person is an employee for some purposes and not others. You cannot know which from the title.

This matters for fairness, not only for law. A person called a "volunteer" who is in fact told to work set hours, and who depends on a small payment to live, may be in an unfair position that the word hides. A person called an "employee" who is also a minister may be caught between two sets of rules and have neither protected. A community that wants to treat people justly should first find out, locally, what each arrangement is. The aim is not to take sides. It is to avoid hiding behind a word.

3. Why a written description helps

Imagine two small agreements in the same church.

(an invented example) At Grace Haven, an elderly pastor named Obadiah serves the congregation. Nothing is written down. He is paid what the treasurer remembers. He lives in the church's house. When the board changes, a new treasurer asks what he is owed and nobody can say. When Obadiah is ill, nobody is sure whether the congregation should pay for a substitute. When he is seventy-four, nobody knows whether or when he should retire, because it was never discussed.

At Lakeside Chapel, in the same town, a youth worker named Priya has a single page. It says what the role is, to whom she reports, what she is paid and how often, how many days of leave she has, that her first three months are a trial period for both sides, and how either side can end the arrangement with notice. Priya and the chairman signed it, and each has a copy. The page does not stop disagreement. It means that when there is disagreement, the two can look at the same sheet.

Writing things down is not distrust. It is the opposite: it is an act of care for the person who is weaker in the arrangement, and for a successor who was not there when the promise was made. A spoken promise made in warmth is easily forgotten, or remembered differently, when the warmth is gone.

4. What a short role description contains

It need not be long. One page is enough. These are the usual parts:

  1. The purpose of the role, in one or two sentences.
  2. Main duties, five or six, in plain words, and what is not expected.
  3. To whom the person reports, and who, besides that person, they can go to if there is a problem.
  4. Pay or support: what, how often, and how it is decided. If it is unpaid, say so, and say what expenses are covered. Give the figures in the written document, not here: this course names no amounts.
  5. Time: the expected hours or days, rest days and leave.
  6. How it begins and ends: any trial period, how long a notice either side gives, how the agreement is reviewed. What the law requires differs by country; check locally.
  7. Care and safety: any checks for work with children or vulnerable adults, and the community's safeguarding rules.
  8. Date, and the names of those who agreed.

The document is a plain statement of the understanding. It does not replace the law, a contract that the law requires, or the rules of the tradition. In many places a written contract is required by law for an employee, and a community should find out locally. In some it is not. The page can still be written.

5. Do not pass off paid work as volunteering

One of the commonest unfair arrangements is the unpaid job that is called service. A community needs someone to run the office for twenty hours a week. It cannot or will not pay. It asks a member to "volunteer", and says the work is a ministry. The member agrees out of love.

A volunteer is a person who gives time freely, can stop without penalty, and has no expectation of pay. That is a beautiful thing, and a community should be glad of it. But if the work is steady, the hours are fixed, the person cannot easily stop because the community depends on them, and they have in fact come to rely on a small payment, then the label "volunteer" no longer describes the arrangement.

This is not a call to pay everyone. A small community may be unable to pay for anything. It is a call to be honest, in three ways:

  • Say what is asked. "We ask you for three hours a week for a year."
  • Leave the person free to stop. "You can stop at any time and we will thank you."
  • Do not let a gift become a debt. If a community finds that its work depends on one unpaid person doing a large share of it, it should ask whether it has a job disguised as a favour, and look for fair ways to share or fund it.

Where a volunteer is paid something, even a small amount, the legal and tax position may change. This is another reason to check locally.

6. The minister with a second job

In many parts of the world, a pastor cannot live on what the community can pay. He or she teaches, farms, drives, trades or runs a shop. This is not a failure of . Paul's own trade is a well-known example.

(an invented example) Pastor Iman leads a small congregation in a river town. The congregation gives him a modest amount each month. He also repairs boats three days a week. For years it was never discussed. Some members felt he was "not really giving himself to the church", and he felt unseen. After a conversation, the board and Iman wrote a short page. It said that the congregation expected him on Sundays and two weekday afternoons, that he would be free of boat work for funerals and emergencies, that the congregation would review its support each year, and that the arrangement was honourable and open.

Fairness for a minister with a second job means three things: the arrangement is open (everyone knows it), agreed (the hours the church may expect are stated), and reviewed (the community looks again each year at what it can give, and does not assume the second job will always cover the gap). The community should also not use the second job as a reason to ask for the time of a full-time minister.

7. How this looks in different settings

In a house church or a tiny congregation, there may be one leader and no staff. The sixth kind of role may not exist at all, and the first may be a gift from a wider network. A one-page note between the leader and two or three members is enough.

In a large congregation, there may be dozens of roles and a danger of treating all as one kind. A table that lists each role, its type and its supervisor is a useful tool, and lecture 1-5 uses it.

In a parish that belongs to a diocese or a synod, the minister may be appointed and paid through the wider body, with the local community providing a house or expenses. Then the written understanding must say who is responsible for what: the local council or the wider body. Both should be named.

In a mission agency or a non-profit, there are often staff, volunteers, seconded workers and consultants in the same office. The agency should keep one place where each person's type of role and the understanding with them is kept, and make sure each person knows it.

8. One warning

Do not use this lecture to put people in boxes in order to treat them as less. The point of naming roles is to see each person clearly and to make promises that can be kept. A full-time pastor and a part-time cleaner are both members of the body, and both are owed truth and fairness.


Diagram 1. Six kinds of role and what to write down

Six Kinds of Role The word does not settle the facts: check locally, then write it down 1. Ordained or recognised Set apart by a tradition Its own order governs 2. Paid staff Hired for defined work Full-time or part-time 3. Minister with a second job Open, agreed, reviewed Not a lesser calling 4. Volunteer leader Gives time freely Free to stop 5. Outside contractor Paid for a task or result Not directed day to day 6. Sent or seconded worker Placed by a wider body Answers to two parties One page for each role Purpose. Main duties and what is not expected. Who the person reports to and who else can hear a concern. Pay or support, how decided. Time and leave. How it begins, is reviewed and ends. Safety checks if children or vulnerable adults. Date and names of those who agreed. Not legal advice. A person's legal status depends on country, region and year. Check locally and ask a qualified person before deciding what any arrangement is.

Diagram 2. Label and fact: three questions

Question Why it matters
Who decides what the person does each day, and when? Direction and control can matter for fairness and sometimes for law
Is the person paid regularly, or only for results or expenses? Regular payment can change how an arrangement is seen
Could the person freely do the same work for someone else? Freedom to work elsewhere is one sign of independence

These questions open a conversation. They do not decide anyone's status. Check locally.


In short

  • Common roles: ordained minister, paid staff, minister with a second job, volunteer leader, outside contractor, and sent or seconded worker.
  • The label does not settle the facts or the legal status; these differ by country and year, so check locally.
  • A one-page written description of each role, signed by both sides, protects the weaker party and the successor.
  • A volunteer gives freely and may stop freely; do not pass off steady paid work as volunteering.
  • A minister with a second job is honourable; the arrangement should be open, agreed and reviewed.
  • This is not legal advice; ask a qualified person where you live.
Front Back
Six kinds of role Ordained or recognised minister; paid staff; minister with a second job; volunteer leader; outside contractor; sent or seconded worker.
Why write a description It is an act of care: both sides look at the same page, and a successor can see what was promised.
Volunteer test Does the person give freely, ask no pay, and remain free to stop? If not, the label may hide a job.
Fair second job Open to all, agreed in hours the church may expect, and reviewed each year.

One sentence to remember A name for a role is not the same as the facts of the role, and a promise not written down is easily forgotten.

This week's action Pick one role in your community and write its one-page description in plain words. Ask the person in it to read and correct it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the six kinds of role exist in your community? Is there one that exists but has never been named?
  • Is anyone in your community called a volunteer who works regular hours and depends on a small payment? How might that be made more honest?
  • Does any promise made to a worker exist only in memory? What would it take to put it on one page?
  • If your pastor or leader has a second job, is it open and agreed? What does the community expect, and has it ever said so?
  • In your tradition, who holds the final say on a minister's status: the local community, a wider body, or both? What follows for the written understanding?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.