Lecture 5-4: After a Departure
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Persons, Not Resources
- Lecture 1-2: Pastors, Staff and Volunteers: Roles and Understandings
- Lecture 1-3: Partners in Scripture: Delegating, Sending and Supporting
- Lecture 1-4: Who Has Authority Over Whom
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Role Map
- Lecture 2-1: Start With the Need: A Job Description
- Lecture 2-2: Searching, Asking and Checking
- Lecture 2-3: Offer, Pay and Written Understanding
- Lecture 2-4: Welcome and the First Year
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Job Description and Interview Questions
- Lecture 3-1: Supervision and Everyday Feedback
- Lecture 3-2: Appraisal That Is Fair and Caring
- Lecture 3-3: Training, Growth and Mentoring
- Lecture 3-4: Fairness and Voice: Staff Who Find It Hard to Speak
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Appraisal Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: Pay, Leave, Sabbath and Sabbatical
- Lecture 4-2: Reading the Signs of Exhaustion
- Lecture 4-3: The Minister's Household
- Lecture 4-4: Friends, Mentors and Support
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Care Plan
- Lecture 5-1: Conflict and Authority Among Staff
- Lecture 5-2: Misconduct and Fair Correction
- Lecture 5-3: Leaving: Resignation, Dismissal and Reduction
- Lecture 5-4: After a Departure
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing a Hard Conversation
The papers are signed and the keys are handed over. The farewell has been held, or has not. And then the harder season begins. A congregation is left with a gap and with feelings it has not named. The person who left is somewhere else, perhaps hurt, perhaps relieved, perhaps both. The staff who stay are tired. The work must go on. The weeks after a departure shape whether a community heals or carries the wound for years.
This lecture is about those weeks. It looks at references and the questions of other communities, at the congregation's grief and its gossip, at the interim time before a new person comes, at boundaries between the one who left and the people who stay, at the person who left, and at the possibility of reconciliation. It does not promise that all hurts mend. It asks what a community can do so that, whatever the cause of the departure, the aftermath is honest, careful and kind.
A note on limits. This is not legal, employment-law or tax advice. What may be said in a reference, what a former employer may disclose, what a departing worker may take or must return, and what continuing duties exist after an ending differ by country, region and year, and by a minister's legal status. Check locally, and consult a qualified person. Mental-health and crisis matters belong to those courses; clergy discipline and the restoration of ministers belong to the church order and law course.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Describe how to give an honest, fair reference and when a safety matter overrides it.
- Name the ways a congregation grieves after a departure and how leaders can help without feeding gossip.
- Explain what an interim period asks of the community and of any interim leader.
- State sensible boundaries between a former worker and the community, and what care the person who left may still be owed.
- Describe what reconciliation can and cannot mean, especially where harm was done.
If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18
World English Bible
so that on the contrary you should rather forgive him and comfort him, lest by any means such a one should be swallowed up with his excessive sorrow." — 2 Corinthians 2:7
WEB
Therefore I beg you to confirm your love toward him." — 2 Corinthians 2:8
WEB
If therefore you are offering your gift at the altar, and there remember that your brother has anything against you," — Matthew 5:23
WEB
leave your gift there before the altar, and go your way. First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift." — Matthew 5:24
WEB
He who covers an offense promotes love; but he who repeats a matter separates best friends." — Proverbs 17:9
WEB
They all wept a lot, and fell on Paul’s neck and kissed him," — Acts 20:37
WEB
Romans 12:18 is honest about limits: "if it is possible, as much as it is up to you". Peace is sought, and it is not always in one party's power. Paul's counsel in 2 Corinthians 2 is about a person who had been disciplined and was now at risk of being crushed by sorrow; he asks the community to forgive, comfort and confirm love. We do not know the details of that case, and we should not use it as a pattern for every departure; but it shows that a community's duty does not end when a hard decision has been made. Matthew 5:23-24 puts reconciliation before worship. Proverbs 17:9 says that covering an offence in love and repeating it as gossip lead in opposite directions. Acts 20:37 shows that a farewell can be full of tears, and that weeping is not a failure.
References and the questions of other communities
Soon after a departure, a letter or a call may come from another church, agency or employer: "We are thinking of appointing this person. What can you tell us?" Few moments test a community's honesty and kindness more.
Three duties pull against each other. A duty to the former worker: not to damage their future out of hurt or relief, not to repeat gossip, and to speak only what is true and relevant. A duty to the enquirer and to those the enquirer serves: not to mislead them by a glowing but empty reference, especially where children or vulnerable people would be in the person's care. A duty to the truth: neither to exaggerate good nor to hide bad. (Ephesians 4:25 asks for truth among members of one another.)
A few practical rules help.
- Decide beforehand who answers references, and have it be one or two people, not whoever picks up the phone. They should have the facts and the community's agreed approach.
- Speak of the work, with facts. "She led the youth programme for four years. She was strong in teaching and in her care for individual young people. The community found that the administration and the reporting were not at the level the role needed." That is fair, specific and checkable.
- Say what you cannot say. "I am not able to comment on that" is honest. Do not invent a reason for silence, and do not hint at a bad thing you will not state.
- Where there was an agreed form of words at departure, keep to it (see lecture 5-3). If you have agreed with the worker what will be said, do not add to it in a private chat.
- Check locally what a reference may include, what the law allows a former employer to say, and what a worker may see.
- If the departure involved a safety matter, the duty to inform the proper authority and, through them, those responsible for the next appointment may outweigh a mutual agreement of silence. A promise "not to say anything" cannot lawfully or morally cover the abuse of a child or the theft of trust money. Ask a qualified person what must be said and to whom, and say it.
(an invented example) A small agency, Stonebridge Trust, receives a call about a former field worker, Pieter, who left after a long and painful dispute with a regional director. The dispute was about management style and not about safety. The caller asks: "Would you employ him again?" The agency's contact replies: "I can tell you that he worked for us for six years, that he was gifted in training local leaders, and that he and one of our directors had a serious disagreement about how decisions were made. That was the reason he left. I'd suggest you also ask him about it directly." That answer is honest about difficulty, fair to Pieter and does not gossip.
The congregation's grief and gossip
When a minister or a loved worker leaves, members grieve, even when they agree with the decision. They may feel loss, anger, guilt ("could I have helped?"), fear, relief, or a confused mixture. Some will take sides. Some will leave the community in sympathy with the one who went; others will be angry that anyone left. Children and young people who were close to the worker may be especially hurt; they should be told simply and truthfully, and given someone to talk to.
Gossip grows when two things are true: people feel something big has happened, and they have been told too little. Proverbs 17:9 puts it sharply: the one who repeats a matter separates friends. What can leaders do?
- Give the agreed true account, briefly, and not more. Then be willing to say, "That is what I can say."
- Name the loss. "This is sad for many of us, and it is right to be sad." A community that is allowed to grieve openly may need less whispering.
- Provide a place for feelings that is not a place for the case. A prayer evening, a meeting after a service, a listening group led by someone trusted who was not involved. The purpose is to hold sorrow, not to retry the decision.
- Ask for restraint, kindly. "Please do not discuss reasons in messages or on social media; it hurts people on every side." Ask leaders and staff to model it. Do not threaten.
- Answer questions that have an answer. "What happens to the youth group?" "Who will preach?" Practical facts reduce speculation.
- Watch for the harmed. If the departure concerns a safety matter, there may be members who were hurt or who know someone who was. Make sure that they have care and a way to speak safely. Do not let a wish to move on silence them.
In a small house church, grief is intimate and every member knows every story. The leaders cannot hide behind formality; the best help may be a shared meal, honesty about what hurts, and a clear agreement on what is not to be repeated. In a large congregation, most members may never have known the worker; the need is for a short, clear word and for the small groups closest to the person to be cared for. In a parish linked to a diocese, the regional office may send a visitor or issue a statement; the local community still needs a way to be heard. In an agency, supporters and donors may be the ones asking. Give them the same true, limited account, and check locally on what may be disclosed.
The interim: neither a vacuum nor a rush
After a departure there is a gap. It may be a few weeks for a part-time helper or many months for a senior minister. A community often swings between two errors. It rushes to fill the post, to relieve the pain, and appoints a person who is not right. Or it drifts and leaves tasks undone, work unclear and the remaining staff exhausted.
A good interim has these marks.
Someone is clearly in charge for now. A named person holds the decisions, and the community knows who. An interim leader may come from within or from outside; some traditions provide for a trained interim minister, and some do not. Whatever the form, say plainly what the interim person may and may not decide. An interim should not be made to feel that they are only there to keep a seat warm, nor should they use the time to remake the community alone.
A time to look back and ahead. The community may ask, before it calls or hires: What did this role do? What has changed? What did we learn from the ending? Lecture 2-1 (a job description that starts with the need) and the strategic planning course are the guides here. The time should not be used to reopen the departure as a trial.
Care of the staff who remain. They carry the extra work and the strain (lecture 4-2). Reduce what can be reduced. Say thank you. Make rest possible.
Honest handover of the work. Files, accounts, passwords, contacts and promises made on the community's behalf. A handover note written by the departing worker, where the parting was good enough for that, is a gift; where it was not, a colleague must reconstruct what is needed. Safeguarding records and financial records must be complete and secure.
Not too long, and not rushed. There is no number that fits all communities, and this course gives none. Ask honestly whether the community is ready, and whether the pain is still too raw to choose well.
Boundaries after leaving
A person who has left a role is still a person with a history in the community, and sometimes still a member. Boundaries protect everyone.
For the one who left. Do not use the new distance to gather support against those who remain, to undermine the successor, or to carry on the old role informally. Do not turn up at gatherings in the old way, take calls from members seeking your counsel on community matters, or keep access to accounts, rooms or records. Where this is hard, that is natural; it is also a reason for a clear agreement. A former pastor who stays in the community can be a gift or a burden. Many traditions advise a time of distance and, often, a move to another congregation, so that the successor can lead. Decide this with honesty and, if possible, in writing, before it becomes a problem. (Lecture 6-3 will look at succession and retirement.)
For the community. Do not ask the departed to carry on as unpaid adviser. Do not use them as a scapegoat for every later difficulty. Do not exclude a family from the community because of the worker's departure. If the person was dismissed for conduct, what they may do in the community, and with whom, may be limited for safety reasons, and this should be set by those who hold the duty and explained to the extent that is needed, without gossip.
For the successor. The successor needs to know, in plain terms, what happened that bears on the role, and what is unfinished. They need not inherit the old quarrel. The previous worker's friends and critics will both be watching.
The person who left
The one who left is the person most easily forgotten. They may have lost income, housing and friends in one blow. They may feel shame whether or not they were at fault. They may be angry at the community, at themselves, or at God. Their family, too, has lost a home and a community (lecture 4-3).
What can a community do? Not everything; there are limits of money, distance and, sometimes, of safety. But some things are possible.
- A kind contact, not a clinging one. A short note, a visit by one or two trusted people, an offer of help with moving. Not a crowd; not a demand to talk.
- A fair reference and an honest word to those who ask.
- Honouring what was good. If a worker gave years, say so, even if the ending was painful. The thanks need not wait for an easy farewell.
- Pointing to help. A pastor or friend from outside the quarrel, a peer group of ministers, a counsellor. If there are signs of serious distress, point to qualified help at once; and if the person is in danger, to the local emergency number. The mental-health and crisis courses cover this. Do not diagnose.
- Attention to the family. Children especially may have no say and little understanding.
If the departure followed a safety matter, care for the person who left must never be allowed to override care for those who were harmed, and contact should be arranged with the guidance of those who hold the safeguarding duty. A person can be treated with dignity without being given access to the people or the place that were put at risk.
Reconciliation: what it can and cannot be
Many hope that a painful parting will end in reconciliation. Sometimes it does. Romans 12:18 speaks wisely: peace "if it is possible, as much as it is up to you". Matthew 5:23-24 puts reconciliation ahead of worship. And 2 Corinthians 2:7-8 shows an apostle asking a community to forgive and comfort someone who had been corrected.
It helps to distinguish several things that are all called reconciliation.
Forgiveness is a release of resentment and the refusal to take revenge. It can be offered by one person alone, and it does not depend on the other's response. It does not mean that nothing happened or that no consequence follows.
Reconciliation is the restoring of a relationship, and it takes two. It needs truth told, wrong acknowledged where there was wrong, and some change. It may be partial: two people may be able to greet each other, work on one task, or pray for each other, without being close friends.
Trust is rebuilt slowly, by kept promises. It cannot be demanded.
Safety has its own claims. Where one person harmed another, the harmed person must not be pressed to meet, forgive quickly or "put it behind them" for the sake of the community's peace. Forgiveness can be real, and still the person who did harm may not be allowed to return to a place of trust or access. Reconciliation of this kind can only proceed at the pace and on the terms of the one who was harmed, with proper support, and often with the guidance of those with experience.
In an ordinary dispute, without harm, a meeting after the first heat has passed can be healing. It might be a letter, a cup of tea, or a meeting with a trusted third person. The aim is not to decide who was right, but to say what each regrets, to hear what the other felt, and to agree how to speak of each other in future. The invitation should be free; neither side should be pushed. And sometimes the right thing is to wait for months or years, or to accept that the parting must stand, and to bless each other from a distance.
The case of Paul and Mark (lecture 5-1) is a reminder that a relationship broken in a sharp dispute can be mended in some way. We do not know how that happened, and we should not make it into a promise for every case. We can say that it is worth leaving the door open.
A short pattern for the weeks after
- Within days: care for the staff who stay; the agreed true account to the congregation; a named person in charge.
- Within weeks: a place for grief; practical handover; one person answers references; contact with the person who left.
- Within months: a look back at what was learned; a decision on the form of the interim; an honest conversation about boundaries; perhaps a letter or meeting towards reconciliation where it is safe and wanted.
- Always: truth without gossip; protection of those who were harmed; dignity for all.
4-1. The weeks after a departure
4-2. Answering a request for a reference
| Do | Do not |
|---|---|
| Name one or two people to answer, and give them the facts | Let whoever picks up the phone answer |
| Speak of the work, with facts | Speak of character, with adjectives |
| Say "I am not able to comment on that" if it is so | Hint at a bad thing you will not state |
| Keep to any agreed form of words | Add private remarks to what was agreed |
| Tell the proper authority of a safety matter, whatever was agreed | Promise silence about abuse or theft |
In short
- A reference is honest, specific and about the work; a safety matter overrides any promise of silence.
- A congregation grieves; leaders give a short true account, name the loss and ask for restraint without threats.
- An interim needs a named person in charge, a time to look back, honest handover and care for remaining staff.
- A former worker and a community need clear boundaries, so that the successor can lead and nobody is used as a scapegoat.
- The person who left, and their family, still deserve kindness, a fair reference and pointers to qualified help.
- Forgiveness, reconciliation, trust and safety are different; a harmed person is never pressed to reconcile.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A good reference | Facts about the work, one or two named answerers, an honest "I cannot comment", and a safety matter reported whatever was agreed. |
| Leaders and gossip | Give the true agreed account, name the loss, offer a place for grief, ask for restraint. |
| An interim | A named person in charge, a time to look back, an honest handover, care for the staff who stay. |
| Four different things | Forgiveness, reconciliation, trust and safety; the harmed are never pressed to reconcile. |
One sentence to remember The weeks after a departure decide whether a wound heals or is carried: tell the truth briefly, grieve openly, and keep every person safe.
This week's action Decide who in your community would answer a request for a reference, and write down in a few lines what they would say about the work of someone who left on good terms.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- If another church asked you today for a reference on someone who had left your community painfully, who would answer, and what would they say?
- When a loved worker leaves, how does your community grieve? What helps it to grieve without gossip?
- What would a good interim look like in your community? Who would be in charge, and what would they decide?
- What boundaries would you want between a former pastor and a successor? Who would explain them?
- How do forgiveness, reconciliation, trust and safety differ? Why must a harmed person never be pressed to reconcile?