Lecture 3-2: Appraisal That Is Fair and Caring
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Persons, Not Resources
- Lecture 1-2: Pastors, Staff and Volunteers: Roles and Understandings
- Lecture 1-3: Partners in Scripture: Delegating, Sending and Supporting
- Lecture 1-4: Who Has Authority Over Whom
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Role Map
- Lecture 2-1: Start With the Need: A Job Description
- Lecture 2-2: Searching, Asking and Checking
- Lecture 2-3: Offer, Pay and Written Understanding
- Lecture 2-4: Welcome and the First Year
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Job Description and Interview Questions
- Lecture 3-1: Supervision and Everyday Feedback
- Lecture 3-2: Appraisal That Is Fair and Caring
- Lecture 3-3: Training, Growth and Mentoring
- Lecture 3-4: Fairness and Voice: Staff Who Find It Hard to Speak
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Appraisal Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: Pay, Leave, Sabbath and Sabbatical
- Lecture 4-2: Reading the Signs of Exhaustion
- Lecture 4-3: The Minister's Household
- Lecture 4-4: Friends, Mentors and Support
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Care Plan
- Lecture 5-1: Conflict and Authority Among Staff
- Lecture 5-2: Misconduct and Fair Correction
- Lecture 5-3: Leaving: Resignation, Dismissal and Reduction
- Lecture 5-4: After a Departure
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing a Hard Conversation
An appraisal is a planned conversation, with some written record, in which a worker and the people responsible for their work look together at a period of service: what was asked, what was done, what helped, what hindered, and what comes next. The word frightens many people. In some communities it has never been done and the idea seems to be an insult to a "called" person. In others it is done badly, as a ritual of criticism, or as the first step of an exit. Both experiences make people afraid of the word.
This lecture argues that a fair appraisal is a form of care. It tells a person where they stand, so that nothing is hidden and nothing is saved up. It also protects the community from drift and the worker from rumour. But it has to be done in a way that honours the person. A process without love becomes a tribunal; love without a process becomes silence, and silence is where unfairness grows.
This lecture is general teaching and not legal or employment advice. What is required, permitted or forbidden in appraisal, records and the ending of a role differs by country, region and year, and a minister's legal status differs too. Check locally and consult a qualified person.
What these 24 minutes give you
- State the purpose of an appraisal and distinguish it from a review of a ministry and from a disciplinary process.
- Describe what makes an appraisal fair: criteria known beforehand, self-assessment, other voices, a written record and a right to reply.
- Plan and run an appraisal conversation in a sequence that begins with thanks and ends with agreed next steps.
- Describe fairly the different views on appraising a senior pastor, and say what this course requires whichever is held.
- Recognise when an appraisal is being misused as a pretext for dismissal.
Don’t judge, so that you won’t be judged." — Matthew 7:1
World English Bible
For with whatever judgment you judge, you will be judged; and with whatever measure you measure, it will be measured to you." — Matthew 7:2
WEB
Why do you see the speck that is in your brother’s eye, but don’t consider the beam that is in your own eye?" — Matthew 7:3
WEB
Or how will you tell your brother, ‘Let me remove the speck from your eye;’ and behold, the beam is in your own eye?" — Matthew 7:4
WEB
You hypocrite! First remove the beam out of your own eye, and then you can see clearly to remove the speck out of your brother’s eye." — Matthew 7:5
WEB
Faithful are the wounds of a friend; although the kisses of an enemy are profuse." — Proverbs 27:6
WEB
Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance." — Proverbs 27:17
WEB
Matthew 7 is often used to forbid any assessment at all. Read through to verse 5, it is a warning about how we judge: with a plank in our own eye, with a measure we would not want used on ourselves, and with contempt. It ends by saying that after the beam is out, we can "see clearly" to help. So it does not forbid helping a brother or sister; it forbids doing it without self-examination. Proverbs 27:6 says that a true friend may hurt you faithfully, and verse 17 describes people sharpening one another. Put together, they ask for an honest word from someone who first looks at themselves and who is for the other person.
What an appraisal is for
An appraisal has one main purpose and a few supporting ones.
The main purpose is to help the worker and the community see the work clearly and decide together how to serve better. It is a conversation about service, not a verdict on a soul.
Supporting purposes are to say thanks aloud; to check that the role still fits what the community needs and what the worker can carry; to name training or support that is missing; to look at pay, hours and rest honestly; and to agree on a few goals for the next period. Some communities also use it to confirm that the person should continue; if so, say so openly, in advance.
An appraisal is not the same as three other things.
- It is not a review of a ministry. A community looks at its youth work, its food programme or its yearly plan to learn what happened and why. That belongs to the strategic planning course, and it should be done without singling out the person who led it. A person's appraisal looks at their service, including the ministry they led, but a weak ministry is rarely only one person's fault.
- It is not a disciplinary process. Discipline is for serious breaches and follows a different, more formal path (lecture 5-2). If a supervisor treats every appraisal as the start of a case, nobody will speak freely in one.
- It is not a popularity poll. The person who is liked by many may still have unresolved problems; the person who is difficult may be doing the hard task nobody else will.
Criteria known beforehand
The first rule of fairness is simple: nobody should be judged by a standard they were never given. Before an appraisal, the worker should already have:
- a written description of the role (lecture 1-2 and lecture 2-1),
- the goals, if any, that were agreed at the last appraisal or at the start,
- the questions that will be asked and who will be asked,
- the purpose: whether this is for support and growth only, or whether it also bears on continuing in the role,
- the date, the people present and how long it will take.
An appraisal that surprises the worker with new standards, new questions or an unannounced panel is not an appraisal. It is an ambush. If your community has never given a written role description, begin there; an appraisal without one is guesswork.
Self-assessment and other voices
A good appraisal starts with the worker's own account. A short written self-assessment, prepared a week or two before, can ask:
- What do I think has gone well? Where did I serve best?
- What was hard? What did I leave undone, and why?
- What did I learn? What support did I lack?
- What do I want for the next year? What do I need from others?
Self-assessment shows what the person sees. It also shows that the community respects their judgement. Many people are harder on themselves than any supervisor would be, and a self-assessment gives the supervisor a chance to say, truthfully, "you are asking too much of yourself".
Other voices help check what one person sees. These may include colleagues, volunteers, those the worker serves, and, where it fits, a few members. But collecting other voices can be done badly. Four cautions:
- Ask people who have actually worked with the person, and ask for specific observations, not general feelings.
- Do not use anonymous complaints as if they were facts. A comment may be shared, without a name, as one view, but a serious charge needs a fair route in which the person can answer it (lecture 5-2).
- Tell the worker, beforehand, who will be asked and what will be asked.
- Keep what people say private to those who need to know. Do not pass round who said what.
Be careful not to count the loudest voice as the majority. A person who is hard to work with may have more critics, and a person who protects the weak may have fewer friends. Read the comments with judgement and with the role description in hand.
Running the conversation
Plan a time and a place that are quiet and private, with enough time that nobody is hurried. Where the worker is more junior or in a weaker position, consider a second person on the appraising side, so that no one is alone with the power, and let the worker bring a trusted colleague or friend if the community's rules allow it. A plain order for the conversation:
- Begin with thanks and with the purpose. Say what the meeting is for and what it is not for.
- Listen first. Let the worker go through their self-assessment. Ask questions. Do not interrupt to correct.
- Share what you have seen and heard, using facts, effect and request (lecture 3-1). Give real strengths as many details as real concerns.
- Look together at the causes. What in the role, the workload, the team or the structure made things harder? A weak result often has a cause that is not the person's character.
- Agree on a few goals. Two to four are better than ten. Say who will do what, and what support the community will give. A goal that gives only a duty and no support is unfair.
- Look at the conditions. Pay, leave, hours, rest, housing and training are part of the conversation (lecture 4-1 returns to rest). If a promise to the worker was not kept, say so and set it right.
- Close with the written record and the right to reply. Say what will be written. Give the worker a copy. Allow them to add their own comments or to disagree in writing.
- End kindly. Thank them again. Offer a short prayer if both are comfortable, and do not use it as a seal on what has been said.
Everything said should be something the worker has a fair chance to respond to. If a serious matter is raised for the first time in an appraisal, stop and say that it needs a proper process, not a quick answer.
Written record
Write a short, factual record: the date, who was present, the main points, the goals and the support agreed. Avoid labels ("lazy", "difficult"). Avoid guesses about motives. Share the draft with the worker, correct any mistakes of fact, and keep the record safely, available only to those who need it. How long records are kept, who has a right to see them, and what must not be kept differ by country; check locally. Never keep a hidden second file.
Appraising a person and reviewing a ministry
When a community has had a hard year, the temptation is to find the person to blame. Resist it. A ministry is shaped by many things: the aim, the money, the room, the volunteers, the neighbourhood and the time given. A review of a ministry should ask what happened and why (the strategic planning course covers this). An appraisal of a person should ask about their service within those conditions. Keep the two separate. If a ministry failed because the community gave a worker no help, that is the community's lesson, not the worker's fault.
Volunteers
Volunteers deserve appraisal too, in a lighter form. A volunteer is not a cheap worker. A yearly conversation, perhaps over a meal, can ask: What is it like to do this? What would help? Is this still right for you? Would you like to change, rest or stop? A volunteer should be free to say "I am tired" or "I want to do something else" and be thanked. Do not use a volunteer appraisal to fill a hole in the staff list with unpaid labour. Lecture 6-1 returns to volunteers.
Appraising the senior pastor or leader
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that a minister called to an office answers to God and to the church's order, and that a formal appraisal by those they lead turns the pastor into an employee and invites control by the loudest members. Some hold that elders, a board or an oversight body should appraise the senior minister regularly, because no one is above accountability and because the pastor is the person with the most power and the least check. Others hold that the wider congregation should have a voice, through a questionnaire or a meeting, since the congregation is the one served. Each view has a real worry behind it: that the office is not made smaller, that power is not left unchecked, and that the voice of those served is not ignored.
This course asks less than any of them. Whichever view your tradition holds, there should be an appraisal or an equivalent conversation that exists, is known in advance, has a stated purpose, is fair, and does not condemn the person. It may be carried out by a bishop's delegate, by elders, by a board committee, or by a trusted outside minister. The senior leader should not be the only person who decides how, or whether, they are appraised. A leader who refuses any form of accountability is a risk, and so is a congregation that uses an appraisal to settle old arguments.
In a very small community, where the pastor is the only leader, the appraisal might be a yearly conversation with two trusted members and, if possible, a minister from a neighbouring church. In a church linked to a wider body, the oversight body may have its own process; use it and make it known.
Appraisal must not become a pretext
Here is the sharpest warning in this lecture. An appraisal can be turned into a weapon. It happens when the decision to remove someone has already been made, in private, and the appraisal is then staged to give a reason. It happens when criticisms are gathered over months and never mentioned until a meeting where they all arrive at once. It happens when a new set of criteria appears after the fact. It happens when "restructuring" or "a change of vision" is the language used and the real cause is a personal quarrel.
Signs of a pretext: the worker was never told of problems; no support was offered; the criteria changed; the people asked were chosen because they were known critics; the worker was not given the record or a chance to reply; or a decision appears to have been taken before the meeting. If you see these signs in your own community, stop and ask what you are doing. If a person must leave a role, lecture 5-3 explains how to do it honestly. Do not dress a dismissal in spiritual words.
And if what comes to light in an appraisal is suspicion of abuse, sexual misconduct or financial wrongdoing, it leaves the appraisal at once. Follow the proper authority and any legal reporting duty, which differs by country (check locally). Protect the harmed first. Never settle it by asking for a quiet resignation.
How this looks in communities of different sizes
A house church with one volunteer leader. No forms are needed. A yearly walk or meal with a trusted , asking "How is it for you? What do you need? What should we do differently?" is an appraisal in the best sense. Write three lines of what was said.
A congregation with several paid staff. A simple form, a self-assessment, a meeting with the supervisor and a second person, and a record shared with the worker. The senior pastor is appraised by elders or a committee, not by the staff they supervise alone.
A parish or diocese. There may be a bishop's visit, a review by an office, or a regular conversation with a dean. Use it, and keep the parish's own conversation as well; the two do not compete.
A mission agency or non-profit. Staff are often appraised by a line manager far away. Make sure the worker has a second contact, that language and culture are respected, and that the worker's family and living conditions are asked about, not only results.
A pointer, in one sentence: how a community reviews its ministries and sets annual plans belongs to the strategic planning course, and the rules for belong to the church order and law course.
4-1. A fair appraisal in order
4-2. Self-assessment questions
| Question | Why it is asked |
|---|---|
| What has gone well, and where did I serve best? | Starts with strength and shows what the worker values |
| What was hard, and what did I leave undone? | Gives the worker the first word on difficulty |
| What support did I lack? | Looks for causes in the community as well as the person |
| What do I need and want for the next period? | Turns the conversation toward the future |
In short
- A fair appraisal is a planned conversation about service that helps worker and community see the work clearly; it is care, not a verdict.
- It is not a ministry review, not a disciplinary process and not a popularity poll.
- Fairness needs criteria known beforehand, a self-assessment, carefully gathered other voices, a short factual record and a right to reply.
- A senior leader should not be the only person deciding how, or whether, they are appraised; the form differs by tradition.
- An appraisal is misused when the outcome was decided in advance or concerns were hidden until the meeting.
- Suspicion of abuse or wrongdoing leaves the appraisal at once and follows the proper authority.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Purpose of an appraisal | To help worker and community see the work clearly and serve better; it is not a verdict on a person. |
| What must be known beforehand | The role description, the purpose, the questions, who will be asked and the date. |
| Matthew 7:1-5 read in full | Examine yourself first; then you can see clearly to help, not to condemn. |
| A sign of a pretext | The decision was taken before the meeting, or problems were never raised with the worker. |
One sentence to remember An appraisal is fair when the person was told the standard, heard the concern and could answer.
This week's action Write down who appraises each paid or volunteer leader in your community, and whether they have been told the criteria. Note one gap.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Have you ever been appraised, formally or not? What made it fair or unfair?
- Matthew 7:1-5 is often used to forbid any assessment. What does reading through to verse 5 add?
- In your tradition, who appraises the senior leader, and is it known in advance? State another view fairly.
- What would a role description in your community need to say before anyone could be fairly appraised against it?
- What are the signs, in your own experience, that a meeting is a pretext and not a conversation?