FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT716E Church Staff and People Care: Calling, Hiring, Appraisal and Care of Ministers

Lecture 5-1: Conflict and Authority Among Staff

Contents 31
PT716E Church Staff and People Care: Calling, Hiring, Appraisal and Care of Ministers
Chapter 0 · Introduction: People Before Positions
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: People Before Positions
Chapter 1 · Week 1: People and Calling
  1. Lecture 1-1: Persons, Not Resources
  2. Lecture 1-2: Pastors, Staff and Volunteers: Roles and Understandings
  3. Lecture 1-3: Partners in Scripture: Delegating, Sending and Supporting
  4. Lecture 1-4: Who Has Authority Over Whom
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Role Map
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Hiring and Welcome
  1. Lecture 2-1: Start With the Need: A Job Description
  2. Lecture 2-2: Searching, Asking and Checking
  3. Lecture 2-3: Offer, Pay and Written Understanding
  4. Lecture 2-4: Welcome and the First Year
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Job Description and Interview Questions
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Working Together and Appraisal
  1. Lecture 3-1: Supervision and Everyday Feedback
  2. Lecture 3-2: Appraisal That Is Fair and Caring
  3. Lecture 3-3: Training, Growth and Mentoring
  4. Lecture 3-4: Fairness and Voice: Staff Who Find It Hard to Speak
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Appraisal Conversation
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Caring for Ministers
  1. Lecture 4-1: Pay, Leave, Sabbath and Sabbatical
  2. Lecture 4-2: Reading the Signs of Exhaustion
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Minister's Household
  4. Lecture 4-4: Friends, Mentors and Support
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Care Plan
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Hard Times
  1. Lecture 5-1: Conflict and Authority Among Staff
  2. Lecture 5-2: Misconduct and Fair Correction
  3. Lecture 5-3: Leaving: Resignation, Dismissal and Reduction
  4. Lecture 5-4: After a Departure
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing a Hard Conversation
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Sustaining the Work of Many
  1. Lecture 6-1: Volunteers and Lay Partners
  2. Lecture 6-2: Different Sizes, Different Traditions
  3. Lecture 6-3: Handing On: Succession, Interim and Retirement
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Yearly Rhythm of People Care
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page People Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Where people work together for long enough, they will disagree. Two colleagues want the same room. A supervisor and an assistant read the same task in different ways. A board member and a pastor remember a promise differently. None of this proves that someone is wicked or that the community has failed. It shows that people with different gifts, habits and fears are sharing a work.

This lecture begins Week 5, "Hard Times", with the commonest hard thing: conflict among the people who work together, paid or unpaid. It asks two questions. First, what is this conflict really about? Very often it is not about the thing people are shouting about, but about who has the right to decide. Second, what is a fair first step? Jesus gives a pattern in Matthew 18, and it is a good one, but it was not given for every kind of trouble, and it must not be used as a weapon.

The central claim of the course returns here. Staff and ministers are called persons and members of the body. When they quarrel, the community may not treat them as machines that have jammed. Neither may it treat "love" as a reason to avoid a fair process, or a process as a reason to stop caring.

A note on limits. This is not legal or employment advice. Rules about how an employer must treat staff, how complaints must be handled and what records must be kept differ by country, region and year, and a minister's legal status (employee, clergy, volunteer, contractor) differs too. Check locally, and consult a qualified person when a matter is serious.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Separate fact from interpretation in a description of a conflict between colleagues.
  • Recognise unclear authority as a common root of conflict, and name the three common lines of conflict: between colleagues, between supervisor and staff, between staff and board.
  • Explain the pattern of Matthew 18:15-17 and say where it does not apply.
  • Describe when and how an outside helper can be asked to join.

If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother." — Matthew 18:15

World English Bible

But if he doesn’t listen, take one or two more with you, that at the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established." — Matthew 18:16

WEB

If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the assembly. If he refuses to hear the assembly also, let him be to you as a Gentile or a tax collector." — Matthew 18:17

WEB

He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13

WEB

So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19

WEB

Then the contention grew so sharp that they separated from each other. Barnabas took Mark with him, and sailed away to Cyprus," — Acts 15:39

WEB

Matthew 18 gives the order of a first approach: alone, then with one or two others, then before the assembly. Proverbs and James say what must come before any of it: listening. Acts 15 shows two workers who served the same Lord and could not agree about a colleague. Scripture does not hide that sharp disagreement happened among the first workers. It does not tell us that either of them stopped being a servant of Christ.

What the quarrel is usually about

(an invented example) At Greenfield Chapel, the office secretary, Mrs Adaeze, and the youth worker, Daniel, are not speaking. The visible cause is a printer. Daniel says the secretary refuses to print his weekly sheet. Mrs Adaeze says Daniel hands her work at the last minute and treats her as his servant. Each is partly right. Under the printer sits a question nobody has answered: who decides whose work comes first, and who may ask whom for what? The pastor has never written it down. Each of them has made up an answer, and the two answers do not match.

This is the first lesson. Many conflicts among staff are not clashes of character. They are the result of unclear authority and unclear roles. When two people cannot say who decides, they will each decide, and they will each feel the other has overstepped. A written description of each role and a clear line of reporting (lecture 1-2 and lecture 1-4) are not paperwork. They prevent a good share of such quarrels before they start.

Not every conflict is about roles. Some are about money, about credit, about a change that one person welcomed and another feared, about a past wound, or about plain tiredness (lecture 4-2). Some are about real wrong. The first task is to find out which kind this is, and for that you need to separate what happened from what people think it means.

Fact and interpretation

Most quarrels are fought on the field of interpretation, while the facts hide underneath. Compare two sentences:

  • Interpretation: "Daniel is lazy and disrespects the office."
  • Fact: "The youth sheet reached the office at four o'clock on Friday on each of the last three weeks, and the printing is done on Friday at noon."

The first sentence cannot be answered except by an argument. The second can be checked, discussed and fixed. A good helper in any conflict does one simple thing again and again: "What did you see or hear? And what did you make of it?" The two parts are both important. The meaning a person draws from a fact is real to them, and it may be right. But it is a separate matter from the fact, and a conversation that mixes them will go round in circles.

Here is a small before-and-after.

Before: "You never tell me anything. You are trying to push me out."

After: "Twice this month I learnt about a change in the programme from a member, not from you. When that happens I feel left out, and I begin to think you do not want my help. Can we agree how I will hear about changes?"

The second version names facts (twice, from a member), says what the speaker made of it (left out), admits it is an interpretation ("I begin to think"), and asks for something that can be done. It does not guarantee a good answer. It does give the other person something to answer.

Proverbs 18:13 is blunt: to answer before you have heard is folly and shame. In a conflict the most useful thing a leader can often do is to let each person say, without interruption, what happened and what it meant to them, and to repeat it back until that person says, "Yes, that is what I mean."

Three lines along which conflicts run

Between colleagues of equal standing. Two associate pastors, two office staff, two volunteer leaders. The danger here is that nobody has the authority to settle it, so it drags on. Colleagues should be expected to try to settle most things between themselves. But they should also know, in advance, whom they may go to when they cannot.

Between a supervisor and a person supervised. Here power is uneven, and everyone needs to remember it. A staff member who speaks plainly to a supervisor risks more than the supervisor does. A supervisor who is quarrelling with a staff member holds a power the other lacks: the power to appraise, to assign work, to recommend dismissal. A supervisor must therefore be especially careful not to let a personal quarrel quietly turn into a case against the person. Ephesians 6:9 and Colossians 4:1 remind those with authority that they too have a Master, and that their power is held under him.

Between staff and the board or the congregation. Staff may feel a board interferes in daily matters; a board may feel staff are not accountable. Here the cause is again usually unclear authority: which matters belong to the board, which to the senior minister, which to staff? One clear sentence for each, written down and approved, saves many meetings.

When the quarrel involves the senior pastor, staff members often have no one to go to. That is a serious weakness. A community should decide, before it is needed, whom a staff member may approach if the difficulty is with the senior leader (an , a board chair, a bishop's representative, a respected outsider). Lecture 3-4 returned to this.

Matthew 18, used rightly

Matthew 18:15-17 is the best-known pattern for a sin of one believer against another. Its steps are: go alone; if that fails, go with one or two others; if that fails, bring it to the assembly. The pattern teaches several wise things. Start small and private. Speak to the person, not about them. Do not go to the crowd first. Add witnesses to protect both sides, and only slowly widen the circle.

For ordinary conflicts among colleagues, the first step is the most valuable and the most skipped. Many people will tell five others before they tell the one person who could do something about it. A community that takes the first step seriously will have fewer large fires.

But the pattern has limits, and honest teachers say so.

  1. It was given for a brother or sister who sins against you. Many staff conflicts are not sins at all, but differences of view or style. The pattern still helps in spirit, but a person has not "sinned" because they disagree with you about the printer.
  2. It is not for safety matters. If the trouble is abuse, sexual misconduct, violence, threats, or theft and fraud, a private word "between you and him alone" is the wrong first step. It can put the harmed person at risk, warn the wrongdoer, and delay the proper authority. The next lecture sets out the separate path. Nobody should be told that Matthew 18 requires them to confront alone a person who has harmed them or who holds power over them.
  3. It must not be used to demand silence. "You must go to him privately first" is sometimes said to stop a person from raising a concern with the board or with an outside body. That turns a gentle pattern into a gate. Where there is a real imbalance of power, a person may need a supporter alongside them from the start, or a safe way to raise the matter that does not begin with a face-to-face meeting.
  4. The last step is not a formula for dismissal. What "tell it to the assembly" and "let him be to you as a Gentile or a tax collector" mean, and who may act on them, are questions for each tradition's own order and are discussed in the church order and law course. This course says only that an employment decision must not be dressed up as a , nor the other way round (lecture 5-2).

Bringing in an outside helper

Sometimes two people cannot find a way through, and the people around them are too close to be fair. Then a helper from outside the quarrel is a mercy, not a defeat.

An outside helper might be a respected elder from another congregation, a person from the regional body, a trained mediator, or a mature friend of both who has no stake in the result. The helper's task is not to decide who is right but to make a safe place to speak, keep to the facts, and help the two find a next step they can both keep. Before the first meeting, agree on three things: that the helper's role is to help and not to judge; who will hear what is said (a short summary agreed by both is better than silence or a full report); and what happens if no agreement comes.

A small community may have no helper nearby. It can ask a neighbouring congregation, a regional body, a retired minister or an agency's care office. Cost, distance and language are real limits; try to find someone who understands the people involved. If no helper can be found, two respected and fair people from the community who are not part of the dispute can serve, provided both sides accept them.

Watch for one danger. A helper chosen by one side and only trusted by that side is no helper. The other will conclude the outcome is decided, and will be right.

For the work of change and conflict in general (how a community moves through a long disagreement, how to read patterns of anger, how to hold meetings), see the change-and-conflict course. This lecture covers only what is specific to the people who work together.

Paul and Barnabas: a conflict that is not hidden

Acts 15:36-39 is a short and honest passage. Paul wished to revisit the places where they had preached. Barnabas wished to take Mark. Paul did not think it good to take someone who had withdrawn from the work earlier. The dispute was sharp enough that the two separated. Barnabas went one way with Mark, Paul another with Silas.

There is no villain in the account. Both men had reasons: Barnabas, a care for a young worker who had failed; Paul, a concern for the reliability of the team. The text does not say who was right. Years later Paul wrote that Mark was useful to him for service (2 Timothy 4:11). We do not know what was said between them in the meantime, and we should not make up a story of reconciliation that the text does not give. What we can say is that a hard disagreement did not end the ministry of either, that the work went on in two places, and that, in the end, the relationship with Mark was repaired in some way.

The passage helps in three modest ways. It tells us that godly workers can disagree about people. It tells us that sometimes the right outcome is to work apart for a time. And it warns us against two lazy readings: that a good community never has such disputes, and that parting is always failure.

The same situation in communities of different shapes

A house church with one unpaid leader and two helpers. Conflicts are between friends and neighbours, and the leader may also be the host, the employer of one helper and the friend of another. The danger is that all roles are tangled, so a disagreement about the Sunday meal becomes a disagreement about whether a person is still welcome. A short spoken understanding ("who decides what, and who do we ask if the three of us cannot agree?"), perhaps with a trusted older friend from another group as the person to turn to, is realistic and enough.

A large congregation with a personnel committee. There are written lines and a committee, and the danger is the opposite: a quarrel that should be met face to face is sent to a committee at once. A committee should usually be the second step, not the first. Staff should know how a concern reaches it and what protection they have.

A parish linked to a diocese, or a congregation in a connexion. The regional office can act as a helper and as a place of appeal. Staff and clergy should know its role in advance. A regional body that is also the one who appoints or dismisses is not a neutral helper, and that should be stated openly.

A mission agency or non-profit board. Staff may be spread across countries and languages; a conflict may be made worse by distance and by writing instead of speaking. A call or a visit, with an interpreter if needed, is worth the cost. A staff care contact who is not in the line of authority is of great value.

A short guide for the person who is in the quarrel

  1. Write down, for yourself only, what you saw and heard, and separately what you made of it.
  2. Ask whether the quarrel is about a role or a decision nobody has settled.
  3. Choose a time, a private place and a plain opening sentence. Begin with what you want to understand.
  4. Listen to the end. Say back what you heard.
  5. Ask for one thing that can be done and that can be checked.
  6. If it does not work, or if you fear for your safety or your position, tell the person to whom you report, or the person your community has named for such matters, and ask for a helper.
  7. If a matter involves harm to a person, money, or a child or vulnerable adult, do not go to the person alone. Go straight to the proper authority (lecture 5-2).

4-1. Reading a conflict: what is it about, and what is the first step?

Reading a Conflict Among Staff First ask what it is about, then choose the step Step 1. Separate what happened from what it means "What did you see or hear?" then "What did you make of it?" Step 2. Ask: is the root an unclear role or an undecided question? Who decides? Who may ask whom for what? Write the answer down. Ordinary disagreement 1. Speak alone, listen first 2. Add one or two others 3. Ask an outside helper Spirit of Matthew 18, widening slowly Harm, abuse, danger, money wrongdoing Do NOT confront alone. Protect the harmed person first. Go to the proper authority. Reporting duties differ: check locally A helper from outside the quarrel Accepted by both sides. Makes a safe place; does not pick a winner. Not legal or employment advice. Rules differ by country and by a minister's legal status. Check locally and consult a qualified person.

4-2. Fact and interpretation

What a person says Fact or interpretation? A way to turn it into something workable
"He is always late." Interpretation ("always") "On four of the last six Mondays the meeting began late."
"She does not respect me." Interpretation "In last week's meeting she spoke over me twice, and I felt unrespected."
"The board is against us." Interpretation "The board changed the budget twice without telling us."
"The sheet reached the office on Friday at four." Fact Check it, then discuss what should be done.

In short

  • Many conflicts among staff are caused by unclear roles and unclear authority, not by bad character; write down who decides what.
  • Separate what happened from what it means: facts can be checked, interpretations can only be argued over.
  • Conflicts run between colleagues, between supervisor and staff, and between staff and board; power is uneven in the last two.
  • Matthew 18:15-17 teaches starting small and private, but it is not for safety matters and must not demand silence.
  • An outside helper makes a safe place and does not pick a winner; both sides must accept the helper.
  • Paul and Barnabas show that godly workers can disagree sharply and work apart without ending their service.
Front Back
The root of many staff quarrels Unclear roles and authority: nobody has said who decides, so each person decides.
Fact and interpretation Ask "what did you see or hear?" and then "what did you make of it?"; keep the two apart.
Where Matthew 18 does not apply Safety matters such as abuse, violence, theft or fraud, and any case where it would be used to enforce silence.
An outside helper Accepted by both sides; makes a safe place to speak; does not decide who is right.

One sentence to remember Before asking who is wrong, ask what happened and who was supposed to decide.

This week's action Pick one working relationship in your community and write, in two sentences each, who decides what and whom each person goes to if they cannot agree.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a quarrel you have known in a team or a community (without naming people). Was its root a person, a role, or an undecided question about who decides?
  • Where in your community could a staff member take a concern about the senior leader? Is that route known, and is it safe to use?
  • Why might Matthew 18:15 be a good first step in one case and a harmful one in another? What distinguishes them?
  • Who in your area could serve as an outside helper? What would make both sides accept them?
  • Acts 15:36-39 shows a sharp disagreement that ended in two teams. When might parting be the wisest outcome, and what would be needed to do it well?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.