Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Appraisal Conversation
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Persons, Not Resources
- Lecture 1-2: Pastors, Staff and Volunteers: Roles and Understandings
- Lecture 1-3: Partners in Scripture: Delegating, Sending and Supporting
- Lecture 1-4: Who Has Authority Over Whom
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Role Map
- Lecture 2-1: Start With the Need: A Job Description
- Lecture 2-2: Searching, Asking and Checking
- Lecture 2-3: Offer, Pay and Written Understanding
- Lecture 2-4: Welcome and the First Year
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Job Description and Interview Questions
- Lecture 3-1: Supervision and Everyday Feedback
- Lecture 3-2: Appraisal That Is Fair and Caring
- Lecture 3-3: Training, Growth and Mentoring
- Lecture 3-4: Fairness and Voice: Staff Who Find It Hard to Speak
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Appraisal Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: Pay, Leave, Sabbath and Sabbatical
- Lecture 4-2: Reading the Signs of Exhaustion
- Lecture 4-3: The Minister's Household
- Lecture 4-4: Friends, Mentors and Support
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Care Plan
- Lecture 5-1: Conflict and Authority Among Staff
- Lecture 5-2: Misconduct and Fair Correction
- Lecture 5-3: Leaving: Resignation, Dismissal and Reduction
- Lecture 5-4: After a Departure
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing a Hard Conversation
This is the third Practice Lab of the course. Its task is to prepare and practise one appraisal conversation: to say true things about a person's service, with care, and to hear a reply. Over this week you have seen how supervision works in small moments, what makes an appraisal fair, how training and mentoring help people grow, and how to make room for those who find it hard to speak. Today you put it into a conversation.
The task is single and small: prepare one appraisal conversation, and practise the opening and the hardest sentence. You do not need to hold a real appraisal in this lab, and you must not use the lab to prepare a case against a real person. The aim is to practise a way of speaking, not to settle anything.
This lab is general teaching and not legal or employment advice. What a community may record, say or decide about a worker differs by country, region and year, and a minister's legal status differs too. Check locally and consult a qualified person before you act on any real situation.
You can do this lab in three ways, and you only need one: in your own community, the observer's way, or the partner's way. All three use the same form.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Complete a one-page appraisal preparation sheet.
- Find, in a short invented appraisal record, condemnation, vagueness and unkept promises, and rewrite them fairly.
- Give and receive a short appraisal conversation in a way that begins with thanks, uses facts and effect, and ends with agreed next steps.
- Explain the privacy promises of this lab and keep them in a group.
but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15
World English Bible
A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1
WEB
Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29
WEB
Ephesians 4:15 joins two things that people often separate: truth and love. A conversation that has only truth wounds. A conversation that has only love may leave a person ignorant of what they need to know. Proverbs 15:1 reminds us that the manner of an answer changes what happens next. Ephesians 4:29 asks that our speech build up and give grace to those who hear. Keep these three in front of you while you work.
Four promises of privacy
Before anything else, these four promises hold for every lab in this course. Say them aloud if you are in a group.
- Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer to find.
- You may pass on any part. Leave a box empty. Say "pass". Nobody asks why.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. A leader who watches while others write turns a room into an examination.
If you record yourself in the partner exercise, only you watch it.
Never write the name of a real person, a real church or a real case on the form. Write "a youth worker", "my assistant", "the person I supervise". The aim is to practise a way of speaking, not to record who did what. Do not use this lab to prepare a case against someone.
A stop rule. If doing this lab brings to mind harm that you have seen or suffered (abuse, violence, theft, serious danger, being threatened by someone with power over you), stop the lab. This is more important than the lab. Speak soon to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number. Do not carry it alone, and do not try to settle it in an appraisal.
The preparation sheet
The form in section 4-1 has six parts. In brief:
A. The role and the period. One line: what role is being appraised (by role, not by name), and for what period?
B. The thanks. Three specific things the person did well. Include at least one hidden task. Use facts: "ran the Thursday group through the winter, including the week the heating failed".
C. The concern. One concern only, written in the order what I saw, what it did, what I ask. If you cannot write it in facts, you are not ready to say it.
D. What the role or the community may have contributed. Name at least one cause outside the person: the workload, an unclear instruction, a promise the community did not keep, a lack of training.
E. Questions I will ask. Three open questions, such as "What has been hardest?", "What do you need from me?", "What would you like to learn?".
F. Agreed next steps. Two to four goals, who will do what, the support the community will give, and the date of the next conversation.
Take forty minutes. Work alone and in silence if you are in a group.
Way one: in your own community
Use this way if you supervise or appraise someone, or if you are going to be appraised.
- Choose one role. Write it in box A, by role and not by name.
- Fill in boxes B to F. Use real information, but keep the names out.
- Check three things. Is box C a fact or a verdict? Does box D place the cause only on the person? Do the next steps in box F ask only for effort and offer nothing from the community?
- If you are the one being appraised, fill in the same sheet from your side: what you would like to be thanked for, what concern you expect, what support you need.
- Choose the opening sentence and the hardest sentence. Say them aloud once, alone.
- If a real appraisal is coming, treat the sheet as a draft. Do not hold a real conversation on the strength of one lab.
Way two: the observer's way
Use this way if you do not supervise anyone, or if you would rather not use a real role. Read the invented appraisal record below, then answer the questions after it.
Appraisal Record: Youth and Family Worker, Year Two (an invented example)
Recorded by the senior pastor of Hillside Fellowship, a congregation of about two hundred and fifty. Copy kept in the pastor's own file.
Date: end of November. Present: the senior pastor. The worker, Nomvula, was told about the meeting the day before.
Nomvula is a pleasant person but does not seem to be fully committed. Her attitude is sometimes poor, and several people have said that she is not a natural leader. She is not a team player and the youth do not respect her. She is often late and seems distracted. Her work is below what we hoped.
Positives: she is nice with the children and tries hard.
At our meeting she became defensive and emotional when I raised these matters, which confirmed my concerns. She said she had asked for training last year in working with teenagers, and for a second helper for the Friday group, and that she had been promised both. I explained that the church's budget is tight and that everyone must make sacrifices. I reminded her that this is the Lord's work and that we serve with joy.
Action: Nomvula needs to improve her attitude and her commitment. We will watch closely. If there is no change by spring, we will consider whether she is the right person for this role.
The pastor will decide what to do next. This record has not been shown to Nomvula.
Questions for the observer:
- Find at least four places where the record is vague or gives a verdict and not a fact. Rewrite each as facts, effect and request.
- Find the unkept promises. What should the record have done with them?
- Find the place where "the Lord's work" is used to close down a fair request. How could the pastor have answered Nomvula honestly?
- What is missing that Nomvula had a right to expect (think of the criteria beforehand, self-assessment, other voices, a right to reply, a second person, a copy of the record)?
- What does the final line, and the phrase "we will consider whether she is the right person", tell you about the purpose of the meeting? Which of the signs of a pretext can you find?
- Write a better record of the same meeting in six plain lines, using only what the record supports. Invent only plain, modest details and mark them (invented).
Then fill in the preparation sheet as if you were a board member asked to help the pastor prepare a fair appraisal of this role.
Way three: the partner's way
Use this way with a trusted partner, in person or by call. Take turns. Each of you plays the giver (the supervisor) and the receiver (the worker), for about fifteen minutes each. Use an invented role, such as "a part-time administrator" or "a children's worker", and invented, modest facts. Nobody should play themselves in a real dispute.
The giver has box B (thanks) and box C (one concern) written down. They say:
- The purpose of the meeting and what it is not for.
- The three thanks, with details.
- The one concern, in the order what I saw, what it did, what I ask.
- A question: "What do you see? What would help?"
- One next step, with support from the community.
The receiver replies as a real person would, but not in a way that makes the exercise a fight. They may agree, explain a cause the giver did not know, or ask for something. At least once, the receiver says something the giver did not expect.
Rules for both. Keep to the invented role. Do not use real names or real cases. The receiver may say "pass" and step out of the role at any time. The giver does not argue with the receiver's explanation; they listen and write one line.
When both have had a turn, talk for five minutes. Ask only about feeling: "What was it like to give that? What was it like to receive it?" Do not ask what the other person said.
The leader's note
Running this lab in a small group
Say the four promises first, and out loud. Say them even if you said them last week. People write honestly only when they are sure no one will read the sheet.
Fill in your own sheet. Sit down and write with them. A leader who walks around reading over shoulders turns the room into an examination.
Give forty minutes. Do not fill the silence with talk or music.
Offer the three ways. Some will use their own role, some the record, some a partner. Do not ask who chose which.
Keep the role-play invented. If a participant starts to describe a real dispute with a real person, gently stop and say, "Let us keep this to an invented role." Offer to speak with them afterwards, or point them to a trusted pastor, priest or adviser.
Afterwards, ask about feelings, never about contents. Ask "What was it like to do that?" and not "What did you write?" Allow anyone to pass, and move on without a pause that makes passing costly.
If someone says something that suggests harm (abuse, threat, theft, danger, or serious distress), do not carry on with the lab. Stay with them. Afterwards help them to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and if anyone is in danger now, to the local emergency number.
Do not use the observer's record to mock anyone. It is invented. Most supervisors have written a sentence like some in it, under pressure. The point is to practise reading and rewriting with care.
4-1. The form: Appraisal Preparation Sheet
4-2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises aloud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Gave forty minutes without filling the silence | [ ] |
| Offered all three ways, without asking who chose which | [ ] |
| Kept the role-play to invented roles | [ ] |
| Did not ask "what did you write?" | [ ] |
| Did ask "what was it like to do that?" | [ ] |
| Allowed anyone to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Knew whom I would call if harm came to light | [ ] |
In short
- The task is to prepare one appraisal conversation and practise the opening and the hardest sentence, not to build a case against a real person.
- Three ways in: your own role, the observer's way with the invented record, or a partner's role-play with invented facts.
- The four promises: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
- If the lab brings harm to light, it stops, and the student speaks to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and to emergency services if there is danger now.
- In the observer's record, look for verdicts, vagueness, unkept promises, "the Lord's work" used to close a request, a hidden record and signs of a pretext.
- The giver begins with thanks, states one concern in facts, effect and request, asks a question and agrees next steps with support.
- A leader asks about feelings, never about contents.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The preparation sheet | Six boxes: role and period, thanks, one concern, what the community contributed, questions, next steps. |
| Four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| What the observer's record shows | Verdicts, vagueness, unkept promises, a hidden record and a decision already half made. |
| The leader's question | Not "what did you write?" but "what was it like to do that?" |
One sentence to remember Speak the truth in love: thank first, say one thing in facts, ask, listen and agree what the community will do too.
This week's action Fill in the preparation sheet for one role. Practise the opening and the hardest sentence aloud once, and note one promise your community has made that is still unkept.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What was it like to do that? Answer with a feeling, not with contents.
- Which box was hardest to fill in, and what does that tell you about how appraisal is done where you serve?
- In the observer's record, which sentence could you most easily have written under pressure? Why?
- What would help your community to hold appraisals that are known in advance and fair?
- If you wish to say what the hardest sentence was, do so. If you would rather not, pass.