Lecture 3-2: Spiritual Authority and Its Misuse
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Congregational Care Does
- Lecture 1-2: A Map of Who Does What
- Lecture 1-3: Seeing Your Own Limits
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Is Love, Not Retreat
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Range of Care
- Lecture 2-1: A Story Entrusted to You
- Lecture 2-2: How Traditions Hold Secrecy
- Lecture 2-3: Sharing Inside the Community
- Lecture 2-4: Saying It Before You Hear It
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Promise in My Own Words
- Lecture 3-1: When Everyone Knows Everyone
- Lecture 3-2: Spiritual Authority and Its Misuse
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Place, Contact, Gifts and Money
- Lecture 3-4: Seeing the Boundaries as Care
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Sheet
- Lecture 4-1: When Rules Are Not Enough
- Lecture 4-2: A Way of Reasoning
- Lecture 4-3: Scripture, Conscience, Tradition
- Lecture 4-4: A Case Worked Through
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Walking a Case
- Lecture 5-1: Knowing It Is Time
- Lecture 5-2: Saying It Kindly
- Lecture 5-3: Connecting and Staying
- Lecture 5-4: Common Obstacles
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and Where I Will Look
A pastor, a priest, an elder or a respected teacher holds something that most professionals do not: the voice of God is thought to speak, in some way, through the role. Many believers do not hear such a person's advice as "one opinion among others." They hear it as close to a word from heaven. That is why spiritual care can be a great gift. It is also why it can do great harm.
This lecture is hard to write and hard to read, because it is about how care can turn into something else. It does not accuse any church, tradition or person. Authority is not a bad thing. Every tradition has it, and every healthy community needs it. The lecture asks a narrower question: how does the power of a caring role grow beyond the care, and how can the person who holds it, and the person under it, notice before harm is done?
The lecture centres on the person who might be harmed. It names the signs only in general terms. It also gives that person, and anyone who stands beside them, clear next steps.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Explain why spiritual authority carries more weight than ordinary advice, and why that is both a gift and a risk.
- Describe, in general terms, four signs that care may be turning into control.
- State what a person who feels harmed may do, and what a carer who sees the signs in a colleague should do.
- Explain why abuse, violence and sexual misconduct are not matters for private reconciliation or confidentiality.
- State fairly two ways in which traditions understand the size of spiritual authority.
Jesus summoned them, and said to them, “You know that they who are recognized as rulers over the nations lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. But it shall not be so among you, but whoever wants to become great among you shall be your servant. Whoever of you wants to become first among you, shall be bondservant of all. For the Son of Man also came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”" — Mark 10:42-45
World English Bible
Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly; neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock." — 1 Peter 5:2-3
WEB
Not that we control your faith, but are fellow workers with you for your joy. For you stand firm in faith." — 2 Corinthians 1:24
WEB
Notice that these texts do not say "have no authority." They say what authority is for. In each, it serves the people under it, and the people keep their own standing in faith.
1. Why this authority is heavy
In many congregations, a leader's words carry weight for four reasons.
The role is sacred to the listener. People do not only respect the leader; they connect the role with God. To disagree can feel like disagreeing with God.
The leader knows a great deal. In care, the leader hears the person's fears, failures and secrets. The person knows almost nothing about the leader's inner life. The knowledge goes in one direction.
The person is often in need. People come to a carer when they are frightened, grieving, ashamed or lost. A person in need is less able to weigh advice or to walk away.
The community may side with the leader. In a close congregation the leader may be loved by everyone. A person who has a doubt may fear that nobody will believe them.
None of this is a fault in the leader. It is the shape of the situation. But it means the leader holds more power than the leader can easily see. The more power a role holds, the more closely the one who holds it must be watched, first by themselves and then by others.
2. What Jesus says about power
In Mark 10, two disciples have just asked for the best places in the coming kingdom. Jesus does not tell them that rank is wrong. He tells them how rank works among his followers: it is not like the rulers of the nations, who "lord it over" people. Greatness among his followers is measured by service.
First Peter 5 applies this to the shepherds of a congregation. They are to oversee the flock "not under compulsion, but voluntarily," and not "lording it over those entrusted to you." The flock is "entrusted to" the shepherd; it does not belong to the shepherd. And Paul, in 2 Corinthians 1:24, says that he does not "control" the faith of the people he serves. He is a "fellow worker" for their joy.
Different traditions will read these texts through their own understanding of office. A bishop, a priest, a pastor and a lay leader do not hold the same role. But the direction of the texts is the same in every tradition: authority is given for the good of those under it, and it does not take the place of their own relationship with God.
3. How care can turn into control
Control seldom arrives all at once. It tends to grow in small steps that each seem reasonable, and the person under it often cannot say when it began. The signs below are general. One of them alone proves nothing, and a person who sees one should not conclude that harm is happening. A pattern of several, lasting over time, is what should cause concern.
Control of choices. Guidance that began with a spiritual matter moves into choices that belong to the person: whom to marry, where to work, how to spend money, whether to see a doctor, whom to be friends with. The person feels that they no longer decide.
Guilt used as a lever. Disagreement or doubt is called rebellion, lack of faith or disloyalty to God. The person is made to feel that to say no is a sin. When guilt is the main way a leader gets agreement, something is wrong.
Growing dependence. The person is encouraged to bring every small decision to the leader, to feel unable to cope without them, or to feel that only this carer understands. Other relationships, such as family, friends, other leaders and professional help, are quietly discouraged.
Silencing of questions. Questions are met with displeasure, with long speeches, or with a hint that asking shows a problem in the person. Concerns are not welcome. The person learns to keep quiet.
One more mark is worth adding, because it connects to the previous lecture. It is not a fifth sign but a condition in which all four grow more easily: secrecy. The care happens in private, nobody else knows, and the person is asked to tell no one.
4. A scene (an invented example)
(an invented example) Lena joined a small assembly after moving to a new town where she knew nobody. A leader was warm to her from the first week. When she told him she was lonely and anxious, he met her often, prayed for her and gave her advice. At first she was deeply grateful.
Over a year, small things changed. He began to say which friends were "good for her" and which were not. When she mentioned her sister, who lived in another town and was not a believer, he said that too much contact could "open a door" to trouble. When Lena said she wanted to see a doctor about her sleep, he said that she should first trust God and wait. Once she disagreed with him about a decision at work, and he told her, gently, that she was resisting what God was doing. She felt sick for days. After that, she stopped disagreeing.
She did not feel abused. She felt that she was a bad believer who could not get things right. She did not tell anyone. Who would believe that the kindest person in the assembly was making her small?
Look at Lena's story from her side and not from the leader's. No one in it need be a villain. The leader may sincerely believe he is helping. But from where she stands, her choices have shrunk, her sister is farther away, her doubts are guilt, and she has nowhere to speak. The harm is measured in what happened to her, not in what he intended.
5. If you are the one under the authority
If anything in the last section sounds like your own situation, here is what the course wants you to know.
You may always say no to care you do not want. A pastor, priest or leader may offer help, but you are not required to accept every form of it. Declining a meeting, a prayer, a piece of advice or a private conversation is not a sin and not rebellion.
You may ask questions. A good leader welcomes them.
You may talk to someone else. Choose a person you trust outside the circle that is troubling you: a relative, a friend, another leader in your wider church body, a mentor or a qualified counsellor. You do not need to prove anything first. You need only say, "Something about this is troubling me, and I want to think it through with someone."
You may go to a professional. A doctor for your health, a counsellor for your distress, and, where there are legal questions, a qualified adviser. This does not betray your faith. A carer who cares for you will not oppose it.
If you have been hurt, you are not to blame. If the harm was sexual, violent or threatening, protection comes first. Follow your community's written policy if it has one, and the local law, which may require or allow a report. If you are in immediate danger, call your local emergency number. You are not required to make peace with the person who harmed you, to meet them, or to keep what happened secret. Abuse is not a matter for confidentiality or for reconciliation meetings. Many places also have services for people who have been harmed; find out what exists near you, and ask someone you trust to help you reach them.
6. If you see it in someone else
A carer or leader may notice these signs in a colleague, or in the way a person has changed. This is hard, because it feels disloyal. But loyalty to the person at risk comes before loyalty to the role.
- Do not confront alone, and do not gossip. Neither helps.
- Speak to the person who is receiving the care, kindly, in private, and let them know they may talk to you. Do not press for details.
- Follow the written policy. If there is a person or body to whom concerns are brought, bring it there. If the community has no policy, ask a senior person outside the circle, and take advice from a qualified professional about what must be reported.
- Where there is a risk of harm, report early. Waiting for certainty usually helps the one who holds power.
This lecture does not ask you to judge anyone's heart. It asks you to take seriously a person's account of what is happening to them, and to make sure it is heard by someone with the means to act.
7. If you hold the authority
For the one who holds it, the safeguards are few and plain.
Be correctable. Ask yourself: can I be told no, by those I care for and by my colleagues? Can I be questioned without becoming defensive?
Share the work. Care that always runs through one person grows dependence. Encourage a person to have many sources of support, including family, friends, other leaders and professionals.
Be accountable to someone. Have a person or a team to whom you answer about your care, not only about your doctrine.
Separate God's word from your wish. "I think you should" and "God says you must" are not the same. Do not give your own opinion the weight of heaven.
Welcome the exit. Make it easy and cost-free for a person to leave your care and go elsewhere, and do not take offence.
8. Where traditions differ
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some traditions hold that the pastor, priest or bishop has a real authority from God, given through ordination or , which the faithful are called to respect and in many matters to obey. They argue that without a strong office the flock is left to its own opinions, that obedience is itself a form of humility, and that the long history of the church shows spiritual fathers and mothers guiding souls wisely. Other traditions stress the : every Christian stands directly before God, leaders are servants chosen by the community, and no human being stands between a person and Christ. They argue that the Bible warns repeatedly against leaders who rule over others, and that conscience must be free. Each group knows a failure of the other: the first has seen what happens when a congregation follows no one; the second has seen what happens when a congregation follows one person without question.
This course requires something less than either tradition would ask. Authority serves. A person may always say no to care they do not want. Harm is reported. These three hold whether a community has a strong office or a flat structure.
Diagram 1. From care to control: the signs, and where to turn
In short
- A leader's words carry unusual weight, because the role is sacred to the listener and the person is often in need. The more power a role holds, the more closely it must be watched.
- Four general signs that care may be turning into control: control of choices, guilt used as a lever, growing dependence, and silenced questions. A pattern matters; one sign proves nothing.
- A person under authority may always say no, ask questions, talk to someone outside the circle, and see a professional.
- Abuse, violence and sexual misconduct are not matters for confidentiality or reconciliation. Protection comes first, then the written policy and local law.
- The course asks of every tradition: authority serves, a person may say no to unwanted care, and harm is reported.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why authority is heavy | The role is sacred to the listener, the carer knows more, the person is in need, and the community may side with the leader. |
| Four general signs | Control of choices; guilt as a lever; growing dependence; silenced questions. |
| What the person may do | Say no, ask, talk to someone outside the circle, see a professional. |
| What this course requires | Authority serves; a person may refuse unwanted care; harm is reported. |
One sentence to remember Authority is given for the good of those under it, and the more of it you hold, the more you need others to watch it.
This week's action Write down who is allowed to tell you no in your caring work, and, if the answer is "nobody", one person you will ask.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does a leader's advice carry more weight than the advice of a colleague or a friend? Give two reasons from the lecture.
- In Lena's story, what is the effect on her, and why does it matter that no one in the story is shown as a villain?
- Which of the signs, control of choices, guilt as a lever, dependence, or silenced questions, is hardest for a community to notice from the inside? Why?
- What do the three Scripture passages say authority is for? How does your own tradition express this?
- If you hold a role of authority, who is allowed to tell you no? If nobody is, what could you change?