Lecture 4-2: A Way of Reasoning
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Congregational Care Does
- Lecture 1-2: A Map of Who Does What
- Lecture 1-3: Seeing Your Own Limits
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Is Love, Not Retreat
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Range of Care
- Lecture 2-1: A Story Entrusted to You
- Lecture 2-2: How Traditions Hold Secrecy
- Lecture 2-3: Sharing Inside the Community
- Lecture 2-4: Saying It Before You Hear It
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Promise in My Own Words
- Lecture 3-1: When Everyone Knows Everyone
- Lecture 3-2: Spiritual Authority and Its Misuse
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Place, Contact, Gifts and Money
- Lecture 3-4: Seeing the Boundaries as Care
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Sheet
- Lecture 4-1: When Rules Are Not Enough
- Lecture 4-2: A Way of Reasoning
- Lecture 4-3: Scripture, Conscience, Tradition
- Lecture 4-4: A Case Worked Through
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Walking a Case
- Lecture 5-1: Knowing It Is Time
- Lecture 5-2: Saying It Kindly
- Lecture 5-3: Connecting and Staying
- Lecture 5-4: Common Obstacles
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and Where I Will Look
Lecture 4-1 showed that rules do not decide every case. A carer who has only rules is stuck when two of them collide. A carer who has only judgement is at the mercy of mood, fear and fondness. What lies between is a way of reasoning: a short series of steps that can be repeated, shared with others and written down.
This lecture sets out six steps. They are gather the facts, name the duties and values, list the options, consult, decide and write down why, and review afterwards. None of them is clever. Their value is that each one prevents a particular mistake, and the mistakes they prevent are the ones carers actually make: acting on a guess, seeing only one duty, thinking of only two options, deciding alone, deciding without a record, and never learning from the result.
Two warnings come first. This is a way to think about real collisions, not a legal procedure. It does not tell you what the law requires where you live. And it is for cases where there is time. When there is danger, the steps shrink to one: keep the person safe.
What these 17 minutes give you
- Name the six steps of the way of reasoning in order.
- Explain which mistake each step prevents.
- Describe what to do when there is no time because someone is in danger.
- Explain why a carer should not decide a hard case alone, and who may be consulted without breaking confidentiality.
- Say what this way of reasoning is not.
Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22
World English Bible
Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory." — Proverbs 11:14
WEB
Both sayings make the same claim. A plan made alone is fragile. Wise people do not keep their reasoning to themselves.
1. A scene to carry through the steps
(an invented example) Rosa is a member of a small congregation. She tells Grace, a lay carer, that she owes money to a lender and cannot pay this month's rent. She asks Grace two things: not to tell anyone, and to arrange a payment from the church's fund for people in need, which the church council controls. Grace is Rosa's friend. She also sits on the council.
Grace feels the pull of three duties. She wants to keep Rosa's confidence. She is responsible to the council for how the fund is used. And she cares about Rosa. These do not obviously fit together. No person is in danger here, so there is time to think. We will take the six steps in turn.
2. Step 1: Gather the facts
The first mistake is to act on a guess. Before anything else, ask: what do I actually know?
Separate three things. What did I see or hear myself? What was I told by someone else? What am I assuming? Write them in three columns if it helps. Many bad decisions begin when an assumption sits in the column marked "known".
Grace knows that Rosa said she cannot pay the rent. She does not know why, how much is owed, or whether anyone else is affected. She is assuming Rosa would be ashamed if the council knew. She should ask Rosa gently about what she does not know, and she should not guess.
Proverbs 18:13, which we will meet again in lecture 4-4, warns against giving an answer before hearing. Where it is safe and appropriate, listen to more than one side. But where a concern involves possible harm, collecting facts does not mean investigating on your own. Gather what you have seen and heard, and no more.
3. Step 2: Name the duties and values
The second mistake is to see only one duty. When a case feels difficult, it is often because you have noticed one duty strongly and not yet named the others.
List every duty and value that bears on the case. For each, say whom it is owed to. Grace's list:
- To Rosa: keep her confidence; treat her with dignity; do not shame her.
- To the council and the church: handle the fund honestly and openly.
- To Rosa again: help with a real need.
- To herself: stay honest about her own two roles, as a friend and a council member.
Seeing the list changes the problem. The duties are not all equal, and some are not in conflict at all. Rosa's dignity and the council's honesty can both be served.
Ask one more question at this step: is anyone at risk of harm? If a child, a vulnerable person, or anyone may be hurt, stop here. Protection comes first, and the steps change, as the next section explains.
4. Step 3: List the options
The third mistake is to think there are only two choices: tell, or do not tell. There are nearly always more. Write down at least three, including the one you like least and the one that means doing nothing for now.
Grace's options:
- Keep it all private and pay Rosa from her own pocket.
- Take Rosa's request to the council by name, without asking her.
- Ask Rosa if she will allow Grace to bring the request to the council, perhaps with her name left out at first.
- Help Rosa to make the request herself, and sit with her if she wishes.
- Direct Rosa to a source of practical advice about debt in her area, and stay in contact. (She should find the local service; this course names none.)
- Declare her interest and ask another council member to handle the request.
Some of these are weak. Option 2 breaks Rosa's trust. Option 1 hides the problem and puts Grace in a hidden position. Writing them all down is useful, because it shows how many roads there are.
5. Step 4: Consult
The fourth mistake is to decide alone. Proverbs 15:22 and 11:14 are about counsel, and the reason is practical. Another mind sees what yours cannot. You are too close, too tired, too fond, or too frightened. A second person also shares the weight, which matters in the weeks after a decision.
Consulting does not mean telling the story. You may seek advice in ways that protect the person:
- Strip the details. Describe the situation without names or anything that would let the listener identify the person.
- Ask a senior person, or a trusted colleague who is bound by the same confidentiality as you. Your church's policy should say who that is.
- Ask a qualified professional when the question touches on health, on law or on money in ways you cannot judge. If the question is what the law requires, a carer is not the person to answer it; a qualified professional is.
- Read your church's written policy. It may already settle the question.
Anonymising has limits, especially in a small congregation where everyone knows everyone. A story with enough detail identifies the person even without a name. If you cannot describe the problem without identifying the person, you need the person's consent before you consult, or you need to consult the one person your policy names for exactly that purpose.
Grace could speak, without names, to the council chair about how the fund treats requests from people who want privacy. She could ask a trusted senior carer how she might handle being both a friend and a council member.
6. Step 5: Decide, and write down why
The fifth mistake is deciding without a record. Choose one option. Then write, in a few lines, what you decided, which duties you gave most weight, and why.
This looks like paperwork. It does three useful things. It makes you state your reasons clearly enough to see if they are weak. It protects the person, because if the decision is questioned later there is an honest account. And it protects you from remembering the matter differently in six months.
Keep the record minimal and factual, as lecture 6-1 describes. Do not record guesses or the other person's private details.
Grace decides on option 3 with option 6 behind it. She will ask Rosa if she may take the request to the council without Rosa's name; if Rosa agrees, Grace will step back from the vote because she is a friend. If Rosa refuses, Grace will help her put the request herself. She writes four lines recording this and why.
7. Step 6: Review afterwards
The sixth mistake is never learning. After some days or weeks, ask: what happened? Did the person trust me more or less? Did the decision protect what I meant to protect? Would I do it differently? Would our policy need changing?
Review is not a search for blame. The aim is to improve the next decision and, where it is needed, to repair what went wrong. If you made a mistake, lecture 6-3 describes what to do.
8. When there is no time
All six steps assume that there is time. Sometimes there is none. A person says they may harm themselves. Someone says they are afraid for their safety tonight. A child says something that frightens you.
In these moments the steps shrink to one: keep the person safe. Stay with the person. Call your local emergency number if there is immediate danger. Connect them with a qualified professional. In the United States the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is one such service; other countries have their own lines, and you should find the number for a crisis line where you live before you need it. Detailed crisis work belongs to a later course in this group. This course asks only that you know such help exists and that you do not try to carry the moment alone.
Afterwards, when everyone is safe, go back through the steps. Write down what happened and why you acted as you did. Consult. Review. Safety does not remove the need for reasoning; it comes first in time.
9. What this way of reasoning is not
It is not a legal judgement. Whether you must report something, to whom, and what is protected by law all differ by country and change over time. Follow local law and your community's written policy, and if you need to know what applies, ask a qualified professional.
It is not a way to find the one correct answer in every case. In some cases more than one answer can be defended. The steps make sure the choice was made honestly, with the right facts, with other people, and for stated reasons.
It is not a reason to delay. Do not use "I need to consult" to avoid a step that protection requires. If a policy or the law says to report, report.
And it is not a solo performance. The steps are meant to be taken with others. A carer who runs all six steps alone, in private, has done the form and missed the point.
Diagram 1. The six steps, and the one exception
In short
- The way of reasoning has six steps: gather the facts, name the duties and values, list the options, consult, decide and write down why, review afterwards.
- Each step prevents one common mistake, from acting on a guess to never learning from the result.
- Consult without names, and with people bound to confidentiality; for questions of law, health or money, ask a qualified professional.
- When someone is in danger there is no time for six steps: keep the person safe first, then go back through the steps.
- The steps are not a legal judgement and not a solo performance. Follow local law and the written policy.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The six steps | Facts; duties and values; options; consult; decide and write down why; review. |
| Why consult | Another mind sees what yours cannot, and shares the weight (Proverbs 15:22). |
| What to write | A few minimal, factual lines: the decision, the duties weighed, and the reason. |
| When there is no time | One step: keep the person safe, call the local emergency number, then reason afterwards. |
One sentence to remember Reason in steps, with others, and write down why; when someone is in danger, safety comes first.
This week's action Find out who your church's policy names for consultation, and write the name and a way to reach them on a card.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the six mistakes do you think you are most likely to make: acting on a guess, seeing one duty, thinking of two options, deciding alone, deciding without a record, or never learning?
- In the scene of Rosa and Grace, Grace found six options. Can you think of a seventh?
- Why is consulting without names sometimes impossible in a small congregation? What is the next best thing?
- What might go wrong if a carer uses "I need to consult" to delay a step that protection requires?
- Who in your setting could you consult? If the answer is nobody, what does that tell you?