Lecture 1-4: Believers Who Disagree
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A People Who Move
- Lecture 1-2: The Law of the Stranger and the Words of Jesus
- Lecture 1-3: The Scattered Church and the Language of Pilgrims
- Lecture 1-4: Believers Who Disagree
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Where My Family and My Congregation Came From
- Lecture 2-1: One Door, Several Rooms: What the Immigrant Congregation Does
- Lecture 2-2: Haven and Closed Door
- Lecture 2-3: Leaders, Money, Buildings and Succession
- Lecture 2-4: One People or Many? Ethnic, Language-Based and Intercultural Congregations
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Walk Through the Door
- Lecture 3-1: First, One-and-a-Half and Second Generation: What Each Carries
- Lecture 3-2: Language and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 3-3: When Generations Quarrel
- Lecture 3-4: Identity and Belonging
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Listening Across a Generation
- Lecture 4-1: The Home as the First Place
- Lecture 4-2: The Congregation: Language, Structures and Leaders
- Lecture 4-3: Those Who Leave and Those Who Return
- Lecture 4-4: Across Traditions: Sacraments, Catechesis and the Rhythm of the Year
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Telling How I Came to Believe
- Lecture 5-1: Two Congregations, One Building, and the Road Toward One Family
- Lecture 5-2: The First Year: How a Congregation Receives a Newcomer
- Lecture 5-3: Insecure Status and Exploited Work: The Church's Ethical Stance
- Lecture 5-4: Strain at Home, Loneliness and Distress
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Newcomer's First Week
- Lecture 6-1: Refugees and People Seeking Asylum: Accompaniment
- Lecture 6-2: Workers, Students, Domestic Workers and Internal Migrants
- Lecture 6-3: Return, and Ties Across Borders
- Lecture 6-4: Migrants and the Mission of the Church, Without Using People
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Covenant of Welcome
So far the chapter has shown a Bible full of people on the move and a law and a gospel that keep returning to the stranger. A reader may now expect a conclusion: so the church should favour this policy or that. This lecture does not give one. Believers who read the same Scripture, and love the same Lord, disagree about how a society should treat those who arrive, and about borders in general. They disagree in every tradition: Catholic, Orthodox, Pentecostal and Protestant.
This course takes no side among them. It is not a course about any country’s law, party, government or border regime, and it will not support or condemn any of these. What it can do is two things. It can set out, as fairly as it can, the different positions that believers hold, each in the form its best supporters would recognise. And it can say what it asks, at minimum, of every believer, whatever the position.
This matters for a very practical reason. A congregation, a parish or a diocese that receives or includes migrants is made of people who hold different views. If the church cannot disagree without breaking, it cannot welcome. And a migrant sitting in the pew is not a topic; she or he is a person who may be listening to the argument, and who may be asked to carry it. A church needs to be able to talk about these questions without making any person into a symbol.
Nothing here is legal advice. Laws about entry, status and work differ from place to place and change, and no lecture can tell a person what applies to them. A qualified immigration adviser, a lawyer or an accredited organisation can. Nothing here refers to any current party, law or event.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Describe five positions believers take on migration and borders, each in its strongest honest form.
- Explain why Romans 13:1-7 and Acts 5:29 should not be used as weapons by either side, and what each passage says in its own setting.
- State what this course requires at minimum of every believer.
- Say honestly what Scripture does and does not settle about policy.
- Describe a way for a congregation to hold disagreement and still welcome.
Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those who exist are ordained by God." — Romans 13:1
World English Bible
Therefore he who resists the authority, withstands the ordinance of God; and those who withstand will receive to themselves judgment." — Romans 13:2
WEB
For rulers are not a terror to the good work, but to the evil. Do you desire to have no fear of the authority? Do that which is good, and you will have praise from the same," — Romans 13:3
WEB
for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn’t bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." — Romans 13:4
WEB
Therefore you need to be in subjection, not only because of the wrath, but also for conscience’ sake." — Romans 13:5
WEB
For this reason you also pay taxes, for they are servants of God’s service, attending continually on this very thing." — Romans 13:6
WEB
Give therefore to everyone what you owe: taxes to whom taxes are due; customs to whom customs; respect to whom respect; honor to whom honor." — Romans 13:7
WEB
But Peter and the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men." — Acts 5:29
WEB
Now which of these three do you think seemed to be a neighbor to him who fell among the robbers?”" — Luke 10:36
WEB
He said, “He who showed mercy on him.” Then Jesus said to him, “Go and do likewise.”" — Luke 10:37
WEB
He who oppresses the poor shows contempt for his Maker, but he who is kind to the needy honors him." — Proverbs 14:31
WEB
Jesus said to him, “‘You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.’" — Matthew 22:37
WEB
This is the first and great commandment." — Matthew 22:38
WEB
A second likewise is this, ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’" — Matthew 22:39
WEB
The whole law and the prophets depend on these two commandments.”" — Matthew 22:40
WEB
Romans 13 and Acts 5 are the two texts most often quoted in arguments about the state. Luke 10:36-37 asks who acted as a neighbour. Proverbs 14:31 and Matthew 22:37-40 stand behind the minimum that this course asks of every believer: honour for every person as one made by God, and love for God and neighbour.
1. Five positions, each stated at its strongest
The positions below are not five parties. They are five concerns, and a thoughtful believer may hold two or three of them at once. They are given one by one so that each can be heard.
1. The welcome of the stranger. This view starts from the long thread in Scripture that lectures 1-1 and 1-2 followed: the law of the ger, God’s love for the foreigner, Jesus the child in Egypt, "I was a stranger, and you took me in." Those who hold this view say that the people of God are marked by hospitality, and that a church and a believer should lean toward welcome when in doubt. They note that people in danger or need are often the least able to wait. M. Daniel Carroll R., in his book on the Bible and immigration, and Matthew Soerens and Jenny Hwang, in their book on welcoming the stranger, make the case from an evangelical standpoint. The Catholic Church’s teaching also carries this strand: the says that wealthier nations are obliged, as far as they are able, to welcome the foreigner who seeks security and the means of living that he or she cannot find at home. Catholic bishops of the United States and Mexico wrote together a pastoral letter on migration, Strangers No Longer, which presses this theme.
2. Respect for law and for the order a society needs. This view starts from a different part of Scripture and from a real concern. A society is not a crowd; it has rules, courts, services and a common life, and the rule of law protects the weak as well as the strong. Those who hold this view say that a country has a right and a duty to decide how newcomers join its life, that rules should be followed and fairly applied, and that people who have waited and followed the rules deserve fair dealing. They appeal to passages such as Romans 13 and to the long tradition that the state bears a God-given responsibility for order. The same Catechism passage cited above also says that political authorities, for the sake of the common good, may make the exercise of the right to immigrate subject to conditions, and that immigrants are bound to respect the laws of the country that receives them. Among Protestant writers, Wayne Grudem’s study of politics and the Bible is one place where such a case is argued, and the political theologian Oliver O’Donovan has written about the legitimacy of political communities and nations.
3. The care of communities who feel the strain of change. This view starts with the neighbours. A town or a district is made of people with homes, work, schools, trust and customs, and sudden change can be hard on them, including on people who are themselves poor or who arrived earlier. Those who hold this view say that love of neighbour includes these neighbours too, and that to dismiss their worry as prejudice is a failure of love. Some Christian thinkers draw on the old idea of an "order of love", found in Thomas Aquinas, that our duties are shaped by nearness and responsibility. Others reply that the story of the Samaritan breaks any such limit, since the neighbour is whoever is placed before you in need. Both sides of that reply appear in the church’s tradition, and each can be held by a person of goodwill.
4. The dignity and rights of every person. This view starts from what is true of every human being: that God made each person "in God’s image" (Genesis 1:27). A person does not lose that dignity by crossing a border, or by lacking papers. Those who hold this view say that rights belong to persons before they belong to citizens, that the vulnerable have claims that states must honour, and that the church must speak when a person’s dignity is threatened. Catholic social teaching has long held that a person has a right to seek a better life in another country for serious reasons, together with the right of states to regulate. Evangelical statements on immigration, such as the principles published by the Evangelical Immigration Table, also begin with dignity and add respect for law.
5. The state and the church as different bodies. This view starts from the question of who does what. The state is charged with order and justice by force; the church is charged with the gospel by witness, worship and love. Christian traditions have drawn the line differently: some, in the Lutheran and Reformed lines, speak of two kingdoms or spheres; some Orthodox writers speak of a harmony between church and state in which each has its work; some Anabaptist thinkers, such as John Howard Yoder, say that the church is itself a kind of alternative society whose practices do not wait for the state. Those who hold this view say that whatever the state decides, the church’s own task is clear: to receive, to pray, and to be a place where every person is treated rightly, and to hold its own conduct to the standard of its Lord.
Pentecostal and charismatic voices are found along all five. Amos Yong’s book on hospitality and the Other is one example of a Pentecostal theologian who takes up these questions, and some Pentecostal congregations are themselves made of migrants and of those who receive them.
This is a point where readers will not agree
Believers differ on how Scripture bears on migration and borders. Some give the first weight to welcome, others to law and order, others to the strain on communities, others to dignity and rights, others to the difference between church and state. The five concerns are not enemies: a believer who is moved by one is not therefore indifferent to the others. This course does not rank them. It asks that each be heard in its best form and that no one be treated as a villain for holding one of them.
2. Two passages used as weapons
Romans 13:1-7 and Acts 5:29 are the two texts that turn up when believers argue. They are often used by opposite sides, and they deserve a plain reading.
Take Romans 13. It is a passage in a letter to believers in Rome about how they should live toward the ruling authorities. It comes after a chapter on how to treat others: bless those who persecute you, practise hospitality (Romans 12:13) and live peaceably. And it leads straight to Romans 13:8-10, where the whole law is summed up in love of neighbour: "Love doesn’t harm a neighbor" (Romans 13:10, WEB). It says that authority comes from God, that a ruler is meant to be "a servant of God to you for good", and it mentions taxes and respect. It does not mention immigration at all. One side may use it to say that believers should obey the laws that govern entry and stay. Another side may point out that Paul speaks of authority as God’s servant "for good", and that a believer must ask what is good. Both uses are applications by analogy, and neither is a reading that the passage itself makes. The passage does show that the authorities have a real place in God’s order, and no believer should treat the state as if it were nothing.
Now Acts 5:29. The apostles have been told by the council to stop teaching in the name of Jesus. They answer: "We must obey God rather than men." The setting is a command to stop doing what God told them to do, which is to proclaim Jesus, and the apostles take the consequences: in the same chapter they are beaten. It is not a general licence to ignore any law a believer dislikes. Some believers argue that a law about migrants may, in a particular case, require a person to disobey a plain command of God. Others hold that it does not, and that obeying the law is a part of loving one’s neighbour. This lecture does not decide. It does say that no one should be taught here how to avoid the law, hide status or evade enforcement, and that anyone who is thinking about what to do in a real situation should ask a qualified adviser, and talk with a pastor or priest.
Both texts, held together
Christian traditions have generally held both Romans 13 and Acts 5:29 at once: that the authorities have a real, God-given place, and that they are not the last word. Neither text, quoted alone and aimed at a neighbour, reads fairly.
3. What this course asks at minimum
The course takes no side in policy. But it does not leave the question empty. At minimum it asks three things of every believer and every congregation, whatever position they hold.
The minimum
Every person’s dignity is to be honoured, because every person is made in God’s image (Genesis 1:27) and one who oppresses the poor "shows contempt for his Maker" (Proverbs 14:31, WEB).
No exploitation and no abuse. No believer may take part in using a person’s work, fear or situation for gain, or in harming a person, and a congregation may not allow it.
Do not turn away someone in need. The one who "showed mercy" is the neighbour, and Jesus says, "Go and do likewise" (Luke 10:37, WEB). This is about what a believer and a church do with a person in front of them: food, shelter, a hearing, a connection to qualified help. It does not decide what any state should do.
Matthew 22:37-40 binds these together. Love of God and love of neighbour are the two commandments on which "the whole law and the prophets depend." A believer who holds any of the five positions above can accept these three as a floor. A person whose position would seem to require breaking the floor is asked to look again at how the position is being applied.
4. What Scripture settles, and what it does not
Here is one honest paragraph on the limits. Scripture tells us what kind of people we are to be: lovers of the stranger, doers of justice, people who remember. It tells rulers to act with justice and to protect the weak. It tells us how the Lord judges. But Scripture does not say how many people a country should admit, by what rules, in what order, or what a government should do when needs outrun capacity. To move from a text to a policy needs more: facts about a place, an estimate of what is possible, a judgement about how to weigh goods that pull against each other. Believers weigh those differently. That is not necessarily a sign that one of them is unfaithful; it may be that they are making different judgements about facts, or giving different weight to goods that are all real. A believer who says "the Bible settles this policy" should be asked which verse, and which facts, and what has been added to get from one to the other. The same question applies to every side.
5. What a church has done well
(An invented case.) In the town of Tarn Hollow, the council of a mid-sized congregation had members who held very different views about the arrival of newcomers in the district. Some wanted to speak publicly; some wanted never to speak; one family had themselves arrived within the last few years, and did not want to be the subject of any debate. The council wrote three agreements on a single page. First, no member would speak of "those people", in the meeting or outside it. Second, the church’s welcome of any person who came through the door would not wait for the argument to end. Third, no one who had come from elsewhere would be asked to speak for others who had.
They did not settle their disagreement. The page did not say they would. What it did was to keep the welcome of persons separate from the argument about policy, and to keep newcomers from being made into symbols. It is a modest and workable rule.
6. A way to hold disagreement
From the example some practical habits can be drawn.
- Say the other position in its best form first. Before you argue, say what a thoughtful person on the other side would say, and ask whether they would agree with your summary.
- Separate the person from the policy. Welcome of the person at the door should not wait on the settlement of an argument.
- Do not ask a migrant to speak for a people. A person who has moved may or may not have a view, and is not an expert on all who share a country of origin.
- Name the floor. When talk heats up, return to the three minimum commitments: dignity, no exploitation or abuse, and not turning away someone in need.
- Know when to stop. If a conversation turns into contempt for any person or group, it has left the course’s ground, and the leader should say so kindly.
Diagram 1. Five concerns and the floor they all stand on
In short
- Believers in every tradition disagree about migration policy and borders, and this course takes no side.
- Five concerns are set out: welcome of the stranger, law and order, the strain on communities, the dignity and rights of the person, and the different roles of state and church.
- Romans 13:1-7 and Acts 5:29 are not to be used as weapons; held together, they say that authority is real and is not ultimate.
- At minimum every believer is asked for dignity of every person, no exploitation or abuse, and not turning away someone in need.
- Scripture shapes the character of God’s people and the justice asked of rulers, but does not by itself settle how many to admit or on what terms.
| Label | Content |
|---|---|
| Topic | Believers who disagree: five concerns about migration and borders, and the minimum this course asks of every believer. |
| Remember | Welcome, law and order, the strain on communities, dignity and rights, church and state: concerns that a believer may hold together. The floor is dignity, no exploitation or abuse, not turning away someone in need. |
| Caution | Do not quote Romans 13 or Acts 5:29 as a weapon, and do not ask a person who has moved to speak for a people. |
| One line to carry into ministry | Welcome the person at the door now; carry the argument about policy with respect and without making anyone a symbol. |
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the five positions is easiest for you to state in its strongest form? Which is hardest? Try saying the hardest one aloud as a person who holds it would.
- The lecture says the five are concerns and not parties. Can one believer hold more than one? What would that feel like?
- Romans 13:1-7 and Acts 5:29 are both used as weapons. What does each say in its own setting? How could they be held together?
- The course requires at minimum dignity, no exploitation or abuse, and not turning away someone in need. Is any of the three unclear to you? Is there a case that would test it?
- The lecture says Scripture does not settle how many a country should admit. How should a believer decide, then, and what should he or she be careful of?
- In Tarn Hollow, the council kept the welcome of persons separate from the argument. What could go wrong with that? What would make it work?