FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL8E Bioethics and Technology: Genetics, Life Extension and the End of Life

Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis

Contents 31
STEL8E Bioethics and Technology: Genetics, Life Extension and the End of Life
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Bioethics?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Bioethics?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Seeing Bioethics
  1. Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
  2. Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
  3. Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
  4. Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Beginning of Life
  1. Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
  2. Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
  3. Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
  4. Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The Body, Organs and the Definition of Death
  1. Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
  2. Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
  3. Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
  4. Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Prolonging Life and the Limits of Treatment
  1. Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
  2. Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
  3. Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
  4. Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Euthanasia and the Theology of Suffering
  1. Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
  3. Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
  4. Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Justice, Disability and the Community That Discerns
  1. Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
  2. Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
  3. Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
  4. Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Every person is born with a genetic inheritance, a kind of instruction set carried in the body's cells, passed down from parents. In recent decades medicine has learned to read some of it. A person can sometimes be told that they carry a condition, that they may develop one later, or that a child growing in the womb has one. This knowledge can help families prepare, and it can sometimes lead to treatment. It can also bring fear, hard choices, and questions about what it means to be a family.

This lecture is about those tests and the choices that can follow. It speaks carefully, because many readers will have had a test, or waited for a result, or sat in a room where a parent heard hard news. The lecture describes what testing can and cannot tell, in general terms and with no numbers. It describes the right to know and the right not to know. It sets out, with respect, the positions that Christians take when a prenatal diagnosis brings a hard choice. It gives honest weight to the criticism that comes from disabled people and their families. And it asks how a congregation can stand beside people in this place.

The lecture gives no medical advice. It neither urges nor forbids any test. A reader who is facing a real test or decision should speak to a genetic counsellor or care team, and to a pastor or priest. Laws and services differ widely between countries.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Describe in general terms what genetic tests and prenatal tests can and cannot tell a family, and why results are often about probability and not certainty.
  • Explain what is meant by the right to know and the right not to know, and why genetic information belongs to a family as well as to a person.
  • Set out, as its holders would, the main positions Christians take about choices after a prenatal diagnosis, without judging any family.
  • Describe the critique made by disabled people and by some parents, and state why it deserves a serious hearing.
  • Describe how a congregation can accompany people who are testing, waiting, deciding or grieving.

I will give thanks to you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Your works are wonderful. My soul knows that very well." — Psalm 139:14

World English Bible

Can a woman forget her nursing child, that she should not have compassion on the son of her womb? Yes, these may forget, yet I will not forget you!" — Isaiah 49:15

WEB

What the text says. In Psalm 139:14 a person gives thanks that he or she is "fearfully and wonderfully made". The verse speaks of wonder at one's own body, and it makes no distinction between bodies that are healthy and bodies that are not. In Isaiah 49:15 the people of Israel fear that God has forgotten them, and God answers with the picture of a nursing mother: even if a mother could forget her child, God will not forget his people.

A tradition's reading. Many Christians read the first verse as a ground for the worth of every human body, including a body that is weak, ill or different. Many read the second as a picture of a care that does not depend on health, strength or usefulness, and as a word of comfort to anxious parents. Some readers say that these verses are comforts and not instructions, and that they should not be used as an argument to press a person toward a choice.

Our judgement. Scripture does not mention genetic tests or prenatal diagnosis. These two verses do not say whether a test should be taken, or what a family should do with a result. What they can do is shape the spirit in which we meet a family in this place: with a sense of wonder at each human being, and a sense that no one is forgotten.

1. What testing can and cannot tell

We begin with what testing is, in plain words and without numbers.

A genetic test looks at a person's genes, which are the units of inheritance. It may look for a known change in a gene that is linked to a condition. Prenatal testing is testing done during pregnancy, to learn something about the child who is growing. It is often divided into two kinds. Screening looks for a raised chance that a condition is present; it does not tell the family whether it is. Diagnostic testing aims to tell whether a condition is present, and it is often more invasive. We keep the terms general because methods change, and because countries differ in what they offer.

Several things are true of most such tests, and they are worth keeping in mind.

Many results are about probability. A result may say that something is more likely or less likely, not that it will or will not happen. Families can find it hard to live with "a raised chance", and counsellors who explain it well are valuable.

A result may tell little about the person's life. Even when a test shows that a condition is present, it may not show how it will affect the person: how severe it will be, when it will appear, or what the person's life will hold. Two people with the same condition may have lives that are quite different.

A test can be wrong, and it can find things the family did not ask about. Results may need to be checked, and sometimes a test finds something unexpected, about the child or about a parent.

Some conditions can be treated or prepared for, and many cannot. Knowing may open a path to care. Knowing may also be knowledge that cannot be acted on, and may only be a weight.

No test tells us what a person is worth. This is not a medical statement. It is a statement of what a Christian holds about the dignity of every person, and it needs to be said because tests speak in the language of risk and abnormality, and it is easy for that language to creep into our sense of who matters.

2. The right to know, and the right not to know

Many people in health care speak of a right to know: a person may learn what can be learned about their own body. Many also speak of a right not to know: a person may decide that they do not wish to be told. Both rights have good reasons behind them.

The right to know serves preparation, planning and choice. A person who knows that they carry a condition can seek treatment, arrange life around it, and decide about children with open eyes.

The right not to know serves peace. A person may feel that a prediction of a future illness, which cannot be changed, would take the colour out of the years that remain. Another may find it hard to be known by a number. Choosing not to be tested can be a reasonable choice, and it is not a sign of cowardice or of a lack of faith. Choosing to be tested is not a lack of trust in God. A Christian can trust God and ask for information, as a Christian can trust God and ask for a doctor.

3. Information that belongs to a family

Genetic information has a feature that most other medical information lacks: it is shared. If one person learns that they carry a change in a gene, their parents, brothers, sisters and children may carry it too. So a test result is often not only one person's private matter.

This gives rise to hard questions. Should a person tell relatives, who may not wish to know? Should relatives be told if a risk can be reduced by early care? What if a family is divided about whether to be tested? Who in a family should hear what? There are no simple rules here, and laws and customs differ. A pastor or friend can help a person think about how to speak to their family with gentleness, and can remember that those who are told have their own right to decide what to do with what they hear. A congregation also has a duty of confidence: what a person tells a pastor about a result stays there.

4. The weight of choices after a prenatal diagnosis

Now we come to the hardest part of this lecture. A prenatal test may show that the child in the womb has a serious condition, or may show a raised chance of one. A family must then decide how to go forward. They may choose to continue the pregnancy, to prepare for the child's birth and care, and to plan for support. They may choose to end the pregnancy. They may wait for more information, or, in some cases, choose not to test at all. Some families have only days to decide. Others do not have the choice, because of law, or distance, or cost.

This is a point where readers will not agree. We describe the main positions as their holders would put them.

Those who hold that every pregnancy should be continued say that a child with a serious condition is a human being of full worth, and that to end a pregnancy because of a diagnosis is to say that some lives are not worth living. They hold that the church should say this, and should be ready to give help to families who carry such a child. The strongest form of this position says that the test is not neutral: when a society offers testing, and ending pregnancies after a result becomes usual, a pressure builds that falls on the weak. Its weak point, named by critics, is that it may place a very heavy burden on a woman and a family, who live with the consequences, while those who give the advice do not. Holders answer that the church must then share the burden and not only the rule.

Those who hold that the decision belongs to the parents say that it is a decision about a very hard situation: about a child's possible suffering, the family's strength, the mother's health, and the other children. They hold that parents act from love, and that a family that chooses to end a pregnancy after a grave diagnosis does so with grief, and does not deserve condemnation. The strongest form of this position says that moral rules made far from the bedside may not see what the parents see. Its weak point, named by critics, is that if the decision belongs entirely to the parents, it is hard to say what role the child's own claim has, and the position can seem to treat the severity of a condition as a reason that decides a matter that is far from clear, since it is hard to know in advance what a life will be.

Those who stand between say that each situation differs. They may hold that early and late pregnancy, and conditions that are fatal and conditions that are not, call for different judgements. Some of them hold that ending a pregnancy is gravely serious in nearly every case, but that a family who has done so deserves compassion and the church's company. Their weak point, named by critics, is that the position may seem to lack a clear line; its holders answer that the situation does not have one.

Traditions speak differently. The Catholic Church teaches that the life of the unborn child is to be respected from the beginning, and has spoken against ending a pregnancy because of a diagnosis; it has also taught that families who carry a gravely ill child deserve great help and compassion. Orthodox communities, in general, hold the life of the unborn to be sacred and speak with great seriousness about ending a pregnancy, and also ask for . Protestant streams differ: some stand firmly for the continuation of every pregnancy, and others leave room for a family's conscience in the face of grave diagnosis. Within each tradition, individuals hold differing views, and a reader should consult the teaching of their own community.

Lecture 2-1 touched the debate about abortion in general terms. We do not argue it here. We say only: a family in this place is not a case for argument. It is a family in the middle of something very heavy. Some of the people reading this have already made this choice, in one direction or the other, and carry it. It may be that some are in the middle of it now. No sentence in this course is a verdict on them.

If you are in this place now, please talk to your care team, and to a pastor or priest, and if you can, to a person who has been through something like it. Do not carry it alone.

5. The critique from disabled people and from parents

Any honest account must give weight to a critique that comes from disabled people, and from many parents of disabled children.

The critique has several strands. One says that prenatal testing, when it is used mostly to prevent the birth of people with certain conditions, sends a message: that lives like theirs are less worth having. Many disabled people say that they feel this message, and that it hurts them. Another strand says that doctors and society often have a far too dark picture of life with a disability, and that many people with disabilities describe their lives as full of value and joy, as well as of difficulty. Another says that the picture of disability as a tragedy hides the fact that much of the hardship comes from how societies are built, and from the lack of support, and not from the condition itself. A last strand says that what is most needed is not fewer people with disabilities, but a world that welcomes them.

Parents add their own voices. Some say that the fear of raising a disabled child, which testing seems to confirm, is in large part a fear of being alone. Some who have raised such children say that they would not wish their child away, and that the pressure to test and to end a pregnancy made them feel judged. Other parents say that the burden of care was heavy beyond what others knew, and that it is unfair to speak as if a family who ends a pregnancy has simply failed to see the child's worth. They ask not to be condemned.

These voices do not all agree, and they should not be flattened into one. What the course asks is that the reader listens to each of them. It asks the reader to remember that disabled people are not a topic in this lecture, but are among the readers and among the church, and to resist the habit of speaking about disability as a lack or as a burden. The disability critique does not settle what a particular family should do. It does ask that every choice be made with respect for the worth of the people the test is about, and that the church be a community where families who carry a disabled child are supported, and where families who made another choice are not shunned. We return to these questions in lecture 6-2.

6. Caring for families in this place

A congregation can do several things that do not depend on its positions.

Listen first. A person who has had a hard result may not want an opinion. They may want to be heard. Questions are better than answers: "What would help you most now?"

Avoid false comfort and false certainty. Phrases like "Everything happens for a reason", or "God never gives more than we can bear", can leave a person feeling alone, and they say more than anyone can know. Plain presence is better: "I am here. I am sorry. I will pray for you."

Keep confidences. What a family shares about a diagnosis is theirs to share.

Do not press, in either direction. A congregation that has a settled view can say what it holds, with gentleness, but it must not use the family's fear to push them toward a decision. It must not make a family who chose differently feel unwelcome.

Offer practical help. Meals, rides to appointments, care for other children, and company at the waiting room are real forms of love.

Stay afterwards. Families remain affected long after a decision. Some grieve, some live daily with a child who has a condition, some wonder about what might have been. The time when the church is most needed may be long after a result.

This course does not cover grief and bereavement care, or crisis care. A reader who is struggling with these should talk to a pastor or priest, and to local support services; in an emergency, call your local emergency number.


Diagram 1. A test result is the beginning of a conversation

A test result and the people around it What it can tell, what it cannot, and who stands beside the family A test can sometimes tell A raised or lowered chance of a condition Whether a condition is probably present Something that may help a family prepare Something that may point to treatment or care Something that touches relatives too A test cannot tell What a whole life will be like How a person will meet it, or be met What the person is worth What the family should do Whether a result is certain, in every case The right to know and the right not to know Both have good reasons; neither choice shows a lack of faith. Who stands beside a family Care team and genetic counsellor Pastor or priest and trusted friends Families who have walked this road The congregation: presence, meals, silence

In short

  • Genetic and prenatal tests often speak in probability; they rarely tell how a life will go, and they cannot tell what a person is worth.
  • There is a right to know and a right not to know; each has good reasons, and neither choice shows lack of faith.
  • Genetic information is shared in a family, so one person's result can touch others and raises questions of telling and confidence.
  • After a prenatal diagnosis, Christians hold different positions; each has a strong argument and a weak point, and no family is to be judged.
  • Disabled people and many parents critique testing; their voices deserve weight, and disability is never to be written as a lack.
  • A congregation listens first, keeps confidences, does not press in either direction, and stays after the decision.
Front Back
Screening and diagnostic tests Screening raises or lowers the estimated chance of a condition; diagnostic testing aims to say whether it is present.
Right to know / not to know Each protects something: preparation and choice, or peace. A Christian can hold either with a clear conscience.
The disability critique Testing can carry a message that some lives are worth less; many disabled people and parents ask for a world that welcomes them.
What a congregation does Listens first, avoids false comfort, keeps confidences, does not press, offers practical help and stays afterwards.

One sentence to remember A test gives information, not a verdict on a person's worth, and a family in the middle of a hard choice needs company before it needs argument.

This week's action Write one sentence of true comfort you could say to a family waiting for a result, with no advice in it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why are many test results about probability, and not certainty? What difference does that make for a family?
  • What are the reasons for the right to know, and the reasons for the right not to know? Why can a Christian hold either with a clear conscience?
  • Why does genetic information raise questions that most other medical information does not?
  • State two of the positions on choices after a prenatal diagnosis as their holders would, and name the weak point of each, without judging any family.
  • What do disabled people and some parents say about prenatal testing? Why does the course say that their voices deserve weight?
  • What can a congregation do for a family in this place that does not depend on what it thinks about the choice?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.