Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
- Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
- Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
- Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
- Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
- Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
- Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
- Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
- Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
- Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
- Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
- Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
- Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
- Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
- Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
- Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
- Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
- Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
- Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
- Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
- Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
- Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
- Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
- Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics
A decision about treatment is rarely made by one person. A patient, a family, a doctor, a nurse, a chaplain, a pastor or priest and a congregation may all be in the room, or in the corridor, or on the telephone. Each has a role, a voice and a burden. When the patient can still speak, the question is how the others help. When the patient cannot, the question is who speaks and how.
This lecture looks at who speaks when the patient cannot, at shared decision-making, at the clinician's conscience and calling, at how a congregation can support without pressing, and at what the church must not say. It gives no legal or medical advice; who may decide, and how, is set by the law and the practice of each country.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Explain what shared decision-making means and why Proverbs 15:22 and Galatians 6:2 fit it.
- Describe who may speak for a patient who cannot, and why this differs by country.
- Describe the conscience and calling of a clinician, and why a clinician is neither a villain nor a final authority.
- Name ways in which a congregation can support a family without pressing it, and things the church must not say.
- Explain the roles of listening and of weeping with those who weep in a hospital setting.
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
World English Bible
So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19
WEB
Romans 12:15 comes from Paul's description of life together in the church. The two short commands ask for a presence that shares the feeling of the other. James 1:19 is general advice about listening before speaking. Neither verse was written for a hospital. We use them as a pattern for how people who care should behave in a room where someone is dying or ill: by listening, by sharing the feeling, and by being slow to give answers. The text does not tell us who should decide. It tells us something of how to be present.
1. Who is in the room
Imagine a gathering around a bed. At the centre is the patient, who may or may not be able to speak. Around the patient may be a spouse, children, parents, brothers and sisters, and perhaps friends. There are clinicians: doctors, nurses, other specialists, perhaps a social worker or a hospital chaplain. And beyond the room are the pastor, the priest, the congregation, the wider family who live elsewhere.
Each has a different kind of knowledge. The patient knows what they value and what they fear, though they may not be able to say it. The family knows the patient's history and character. The clinicians know what the illness is likely to do and what treatments can and cannot do. The pastor or priest knows the tradition's way of thinking, and often knows the family. No one of them knows everything. That is the sense of Proverbs 15:22: where there are many counsellors, plans stand. A decision that draws on all of these is better informed than one made by any one of them alone.
2. Shared decision-making
Shared decision-making is the name often given to a way of working in which the clinicians bring what they know about the illness and the options, the patient (or those who speak for the patient) bring what they know about the person's values and wishes, and the decision is reached by talking together. It differs from two other styles. In one style, the doctor decides and tells the patient. In the other, the doctor lists the options and leaves the patient to choose alone. The first can ignore the person; the second can leave the person alone with a burden. Shared decision-making tries to avoid both.
Not every culture or health system works this way. In some places, doctors are expected to decide, and families are expected to be told. In others, a family may expect to decide on behalf of the patient, and a patient may prefer to leave things to the family. In some places, it is customary not to tell a patient the full news. A student should not assume that one pattern is right everywhere, and should be slow to judge a family or a clinician who works in a different way. What this course asks is that, wherever you are, the patient is treated as a person and not as a case, and that nobody is left to decide alone.
3. Who speaks when the patient cannot
When a patient cannot speak, someone must speak for them, and there are different answers in different places. In some countries the law names a proxy, or recognises a person chosen in an advance document. In others, a family member speaks in an order of priority set by law or custom. In others it is the doctors, or a court, or a community . Some places have no formal system. The course does not describe any of them, and nothing here is legal advice. If you are facing the question, ask the care team, a legal adviser where one is needed, and your pastor or priest.
On the Christian side, a few things can be said. The person who speaks for the patient is, in most traditions' view, asked to speak not for their own wishes but for the patient's: what the patient said, what they valued, and what, as far as can be told, they would have wanted. Where this cannot be known, the person is asked to consider what serves the patient's good. It is a heavy task, and it is done best with others. The family should not be made to feel that they alone carry the weight of a life and death; that is why the clinicians, the pastor and the congregation have a part. Sometimes family members disagree. This is common and does not mean that anyone is wrong or faithless. A pastor or priest, or a chaplain or counsellor, can help them to hear one another.
4. The clinician's conscience and calling
Clinicians are often made into villains in the stories people tell: the cold doctor, the hurried nurse. A fair view must say that they are people with their own consciences and callings. Many see their work as a , a calling in which they serve the sick; many are people of faith, and many are not. They carry the weight of deciding what to offer, of telling hard news, and of sometimes being blamed. They work within the rules of their profession, their hospital and their country, and some of them lie awake after a death.
Clinicians also have consciences, and these sometimes lead them to decline to do something that the law allows or that a family asks for. How far a conscientious refusal should be respected, and where it must give way to a patient's need, is a question where thoughtful people differ, and it is dealt with differently in different laws. What this course says is that a clinician's conscience deserves respect, and that a patient's need to be cared for deserves respect too; neither is a trump card, and both are served when a clinician who cannot do something says so early and helps the patient to find someone who can care for them, where the law and the clinician's conscience allow.
It is equally important to say that clinicians are not the final authority on what the patient should value. They know the medicine. They do not know the person's faith, family or hope unless they are told. A good clinician asks. A family that feels unheard is entitled to say so and to ask for a meeting, a second voice or a chaplain.
5. How a congregation can help without pressing
A congregation has a gift to give in such a time, and also a danger.
The gift is presence and practical help: visits that do not demand attention, meals, a quiet place, someone to mind the children, a lift to the hospital, someone to make phone calls to the wider family, prayer, and the sacraments or rites of the tradition when the family wants them. A congregation can also be a place where a family hears from many voices that they are loved. It can help the family to bring a list of questions. It can help them sleep.
The danger is pressure. It may come in kindly forms: a visitor who says, "We are praying for a miracle, so you must not give up", or one who says, "It is time to let him go", or one who tells a story about someone else's case. It may come as advice from people who are not in the room and will not carry the consequences. It may come from a church leader whose firm view on one of the questions of this week is heard by the family as an instruction. The better pattern is to listen, to ask what the family would find helpful, to offer prayer in the way they want it, and to stay when the decision is made, whichever way it goes.
For a pastor or a priest, this means a kind of restraint. Your tradition has teaching on these questions, and you may be asked to state it. You may state it, and say that conscience and the care team have their part, and that you will stand with the family whichever way they decide. You are not there to win an argument at a bedside.
6. What the church must not say
The following lines have been said to families in many places, usually with good intention, and have done harm. A church that learns not to say them has learned something important.
- "If you had more faith, God would heal him." Faith is not a lever, and the family has not failed.
- "God needs her more than you do," or "It was God's plan." This pretends to know what the speaker cannot know, and can make God seem cruel. We return to this in week 5.
- "You must keep everything going; stopping is giving up." This puts a burden on the family that no tradition places so heavily.
- "You must stop now; it is selfish to keep him here." This treats love as selfishness.
- "Offer it up", or "Others have it worse." This takes the person's pain and uses it for a lesson.
- Any word that suggests that a family who has chosen one way or another is a sinner.
If you are not sure what to say, say less. "I am sorry. I am here. What would help?" is better than the best explanation. This is the sense of Romans 12:15: to weep with those who weep. It is also the sense of James 1:19: to be swift to hear and slow to speak.
7. Where a family disagrees with the care team
Sometimes a family feels the care team is wrong, or the care team feels the family is. This can be painful. It is usually helped by time, by a meeting where each side hears the other, by a second opinion where one is available, and by the help of a person who is trusted by both sides, such as a chaplain or an ethics adviser. A pastor or priest can ask the family what they most fear, and can help them to say it. A pastor or priest should not take sides in a way that closes the door to a dialogue, and should not tell the family to ignore the clinicians or to obey them without question. If a patient's life or safety seems to be in danger because of something that is wrong in the care itself, the family can ask for a senior clinician, a patient advocate or whatever channel the hospital provides. This course cannot say what channels exist where you live.
8. A word to those who carry it afterwards
Those who have been part of such decisions often carry questions for years: "Did we do right?" "Should we have waited?" "Should we have stopped sooner?" A church should know this, and should be ready, long after, to listen. Often what is needed is not an answer, but the freedom to say the questions aloud to someone who will not judge. Some people find comfort in the traditions' prayers for the dead, or in a service of remembrance. Grief and bereavement care is a subject on its own, and this course does not cover it; a pastor or priest, and local services, can help. If you are in distress, please speak to someone today.
Diagram 1. Who is in the room, and what each knows
In short
- A decision about treatment is best made with many counsellors, each knowing something the others do not.
- Shared decision-making avoids both "the doctor decides" and "the patient chooses alone"; patterns differ across cultures and countries.
- The person who speaks for the patient is asked to say what the patient would want, not what they themselves want; the law of each country sets who it is.
- A congregation helps by presence and practical support, and must not press, blame or explain; "I am here" is better than an answer.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Shared decision-making | Clinicians, patient (or the one who speaks for them) and family reach a decision by talking together, each bringing what they know. |
| The one who speaks for the patient | Is asked to say what the patient would want, and where that is unknown, what serves the patient's good. Who it is depends on local law. |
| A clinician | A person with a calling and a conscience, who knows the medicine but not the patient's faith and hopes unless told. |
| What a church may offer | Presence, listening, prayer if wanted, and practical help; not blame, forced answers or pressure. |
One sentence to remember Be swift to hear and slow to speak, and weep with those who weep.
This week's action Write one sentence you could say to a family in a hospital corridor that offers presence and does not explain or blame.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What is shared decision-making, and how does it differ from "the doctor decides" and "the patient chooses alone"?
- When a patient cannot speak, what is the person who speaks for them asked to do? Why should that person not carry the decision alone?
- Why is it unfair to make clinicians into villains, and why are they also not the final authority on what the patient values?
- Describe one kind of support a congregation can give a family, and one kind of pressure it must avoid.
- Choose one of the sentences the church must not say. Why does it hurt, and what could be said in its place?