Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
- Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
- Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
- Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
- Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
- Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
- Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
- Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
- Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
- Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
- Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
- Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
- Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
- Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
- Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
- Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
- Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
- Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
- Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
- Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
- Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
- Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
- Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
- Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics
When treatment can no longer turn an illness around, care does not end. Palliative care is the part of medicine that turns toward the whole person: pain and other distress, but also fear, family, and the questions people ask when life is limited. Hospice is a form of this care, in many places a place or a service for the last part of life. Both have deep roots in Christian history, and both are, for many families, the answer to the fear that dying must be a battle or an abandonment.
This lecture looks at what palliative care aims at, the old Christian roots of hospice, a theological misunderstanding that has hurt many people (that pain must be endured as a sign of faith), a classic argument called the double effect, and the burden on the carers. It gives no medical advice, names no drug or dose, and describes no procedure. Practice varies by country and by service; ask the care team about what is available where you live.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe in general terms what palliative care aims at, and say how it differs from treating to cure.
- Say in a few sentences how hospice care grew from Christian hospitality and from the later hospice movement.
- Explain why the idea that Christians must endure pain as a mark of faith is a misunderstanding, and what Scripture and tradition say instead.
- Explain the double-effect argument in one paragraph and state two views on how far it goes, with a weak point of each.
- Describe the burden carried by family carers and what a congregation can do to share it.
Come to me, all you who labor and are heavily burdened, and I will give you rest." — Matthew 11:28
World English Bible
Yahweh is my shepherd: I shall lack nothing." — Psalm 23:1
WEB
Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for you are with me. Your rod and your staff, they comfort me." — Psalm 23:4
WEB
But a certain Samaritan, as he traveled, came where he was. When he saw him, he was moved with compassion," — Luke 10:33
WEB
came to him, and bound up his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. He set him on his own animal, and brought him to an inn, and took care of him." — Luke 10:34
WEB
Matthew 11:28 is an invitation to the tired and burdened; it was spoken to people weighed down by many things, and it is not about illness only, but many readers have heard comfort in it at a bedside. Psalm 23 is a psalm of trust, and verse 4 names the valley of the shadow of death and a presence in it. Luke 10:33-34 is part of the story of the Samaritan, which Jesus told to answer the question "who is my neighbour?": a stranger sees the wounded man, is moved, and does what is needed, including paying for an inn where the man can be cared for. It is a story and not a hospital manual. Many Christians have taken it as a picture of the kind of care that does not pass by. These verses give a frame for compassion; they do not say what care to give in a given case.
1. What palliative care aims at
The word "palliative" comes from an old word that means to cloak or to cover. In medicine it has come to mean care that aims to relieve suffering and to support the person, instead of aiming only at curing the disease. It is not a way of saying "nothing more can be done". Much can be done. Palliative care teams often work alongside treatment that aims to cure, and not only at the end of life. For those who are near the end, they give attention to the body (for example pain and other symptoms), but also to the mind (fear, sadness), to the family, and to what is sometimes called spiritual distress: questions of meaning, guilt, hope and God.
We will say two things about this in general terms. First, palliative care aims at relief of suffering and care of the whole person. It does not aim to hasten death, and it does not aim to delay it at any cost. Second, it recognises that a person is more than a body. This fits closely with the Christian view that a human being is a creature of body, mind and spirit, loved by God. We do not claim that Christians invented this view of care, or that care that is not Christian does not hold it too. Many people of different faiths and of none work in palliative care and do it with great devotion.
2. Christian roots of hospice
The word "hospice" comes from the same root as "hospitality" and "hospital". In the early and medieval church, communities of monks, nuns and lay brothers and sisters, and later religious orders, took in travellers, the poor and the sick. These houses of welcome are often called hospices. They were not only for the dying, and they did not have today's science; but they carried an idea: that the stranger and the sick are to be received as one would receive Christ. That idea can be heard in Matthew 25:35-36, which we meet again in lecture 5-4.
The modern hospice movement, which grew in the later twentieth century, drew on this Christian background in many places. It was begun by people who were struck that the dying were often left alone, or in pain, and who believed that something better could be done. In many countries, hospices were started by churches, religious orders and Christian doctors and nurses, and many of them still are. Today there are hospices and palliative services run by churches, by public services, and by charities of many kinds. We do not name any person or organisation here, and we describe the history only in general terms; if you wish to learn more, a good library or your own tradition's writers will help.
It is also worth saying that in many parts of the world, hospice and palliative care are not available to most people. Where that is so, family, neighbours and the congregation may carry everything. The call to see that good palliative care is available to all is part of the question of justice we come to in week 6.
3. A misunderstanding: that pain must be endured
Now to a misunderstanding that has hurt many people.
Some Christians have said, or have been told, that suffering is a test or a gift from God that must be borne, and that to ask for relief of pain shows a lack of faith. In some places this has been said to patients and to families by people who meant well. It has led some patients to refuse relief they needed, and some families to feel guilty that they asked for it.
We should say plainly that this is not the teaching of the main Christian traditions, and that it is a misreading of Scripture. The Scriptures say that Jesus healed, and fed, and comforted. They say that the Samaritan bound up wounds. The Catholic tradition has said, in general terms, that relieving pain is a good, and that it may be pursued even when the means carry some risk, as the section on double effect below explains; the Orthodox and Protestant traditions, in their own words, say that relief of suffering is an act of mercy. Some believers do find that they can bear pain with the help of God, and some have said that suffering has opened them to something. That is their own testimony and deserves respect. It is a different thing from saying that others must suffer in the same way, or that to seek relief is faithless. Nobody is to be told that faith means enduring pain, and nobody who has asked for relief for themselves or for another has done wrong.
4. The double effect: an argument introduced
Palliative care raises a question that moral theologians have thought about for centuries. Suppose that a good act has a second, foreseen result that is not good. For example, an action meant to relieve severe pain might, in some situation, carry the risk of making a patient less conscious or, some would say, of shortening life. May it be done?
The traditional answer is called the principle of double effect. In the way it is usually stated, an act that has both a good and a bad effect may be permitted if four conditions are met. The act itself must not be wrong in itself. The bad effect must not be what the person intends, but only foreseen and accepted as a side-effect. The bad effect must not be the means of bringing about the good. And there must be a proportionate reason, a good serious enough to justify risking the harm. The principle is used in Catholic moral theology, and has been taken up by many Protestant and other writers. In palliative care it is used to explain why a doctor may act to relieve severe pain, with the aim of relief and not of death, and why this is different from giving a lethal dose in order to cause death.
This is a point where readers will not agree. One group holds that the principle of double effect is a sound and necessary guide. The strongest case for it is that moral life does require us to tell what we aim at from what we merely foresee, that without it a good physician could not act at all, since almost any treatment has risks, and that it marks the line between easing dying and causing death. The weak point of this view is that intentions are hard to see from the outside and may be hard to see even from the inside, that the line may be used to cover acts that are in practice aimed at death, and that some ask whether it adds anything beyond the ordinary rule that a good action may carry a proportionate risk. Another group holds that the principle is not needed, or is stretched too far, or hides a deeper question. Some in this group hold that what matters is the patient's good and the proportion between benefit and risk, and that the language of intention adds confusion. Others, from the opposite side, worry that it allows too much. The strongest reason of the critics is that it asks people to separate what they foresee from what they intend, which can seem like a trick of words. The weak point of the critics is that without some such distinction, it becomes hard to say why relieving pain is allowed and killing is not. What the course requires is that you can state the principle and the two kinds of criticism, and that you see that all sides want relief of suffering and none wants the death of a patient to be the aim. How often the question arises in real practice is a medical matter that this course does not judge.
5. The burden on families and carers
Palliative care, and even more the long days before it, fall on families. A wife may be up every night. A son may leave work. A daughter in another country may feel torn between guilt and distance. A grandchild may be asked to do tasks no child should do. A carer's own health may fail. People in these positions often feel love and exhaustion at the same time and are ashamed of the second.
Here the church has a clear task. It is not to praise carers in a way that adds weight ("what a saint you are") but to share the work in concrete ways: a meal, a night's relief, a lift to the hospital, a visit that does not demand to be entertained, an offer to sit with the patient so that the carer can sleep. It is also to listen to carers without telling them what to feel, and to say, if it is true, that tiredness and anger at the situation are not sins. The words of Matthew 11:28 are for them too: come to me, all who labour and are heavily burdened. They are not a command to carry on; they are an invitation to rest.
How a pastor, a priest or a lay visitor accompanies the dying person day by day is the work of another course, on caring for the elderly and the housebound, and we do not take it up here.
6. What a Christian view of care looks like
Putting this together, a Christian view of palliative care has these marks.
It does not give up on a person when cure is no longer possible. It holds that a dying person is a person, with a name, a history, a family and a God. It aims at relief of suffering. It never says that pain is a test the patient must pass. It welcomes the skills of nurses, doctors, chaplains and others as gifts, and it asks the community to share the weight with the family. And it holds, with the Psalm, that the valley of the shadow of death is a place where God is.
Two cautions. First, palliative care is not available everywhere, and a family without it is not to be blamed; the church may be one of the places that helps to bring it about. Second, none of what this lecture says is advice about a person's care. If you are caring for someone now, talk to the care team, and to a pastor or priest. If you are overwhelmed or in distress yourself, tell someone today, and use your local crisis line or emergency number if you need help at once.
Diagram 1. What palliative care holds together
In short
- Palliative care aims at relief of suffering and care of the whole person; it neither hastens death nor delays it at any cost.
- Hospice grew from Christian hospitality to the sick and the stranger, and from a later movement in which Christians were active.
- It is a misunderstanding that faith requires enduring pain; the traditions see relief of suffering as mercy.
- The double effect separates what is aimed at from what is foreseen; readers differ on how far the principle goes.
- Family carers carry a heavy burden; the church shares the work and does not judge.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Palliative care | Care that aims at relief of suffering and support of the whole person and the family, not only at curing the disease. |
| A harmful misunderstanding | That faith requires enduring pain. The main traditions do not teach it; relieving suffering is an act of mercy. |
| Double effect | A good act with a foreseen bad side-effect may be allowed if the act is not wrong, the bad effect is not intended or used as the means, and the reason is proportionate. Readers differ on how far it goes. |
| What a congregation can do for carers | Share concrete work (a meal, a night's relief, a lift, a visit), listen, and never judge tiredness. |
One sentence to remember Care for the dying is care for the whole person, and relief of suffering is mercy and not a lack of faith.
This week's action Think of one practical thing your congregation or circle could offer to a family carer, and write it down in one sentence.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what does palliative care aim at? How does that differ from treating to cure?
- Why is it a misunderstanding to say that faith means enduring pain? What do you find in Scripture and in the traditions to say otherwise?
- State the principle of double effect in one paragraph. What is the strongest case for it, and what is the weak point?
- What would you say to someone who believes that asking for relief of pain shows a lack of faith?
- What are three concrete things a congregation could do to share the burden of a family carer, without making the carer feel judged or watched?