Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
- Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
- Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
- Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
- Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
- Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
- Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
- Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
- Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
- Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
- Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
- Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
- Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
- Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
- Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
- Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
- Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
- Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
- Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
- Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
- Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
- Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
- Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
- Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics
Lecture 5-1 gave the words and listened to the reasons people give for asking to die. This lecture sets out the two main answers that thoughtful people give to the question itself: should it be allowed that a person's life be ended on purpose, at that person's request, to end suffering? One answer says no. The other says that, in a few cases and under strict rules, yes.
The aim is not to decide for you. The aim is that you can state each side so well that a person who holds it would say, "Yes, that is what I mean", and that you can also say honestly where each side is weakest. A student who can only state the side he or she agrees with has not yet understood the question.
This is a point on which Christians disagree, and this lecture is written for readers on every side, including those who have sat at a bedside or are sitting there now. Nothing here names a method, a drug, a procedure, a law or a number.
What these 22 minutes give you
- State the case against euthanasia and assisted suicide in its strongest form, in four parts, with a weak point for each.
- State the case for allowing them in limited cases in its strongest form, in four parts, with a weak point for each.
- Describe the range of positions within Christian traditions, only as each would describe itself.
- Separate what the Bible says, what a tradition has read in it, and what you judge.
- Describe how Christians can disagree on this without condemning each other.
I call heaven and earth to witness against you this day, that I have set before you life and death, the blessing and the curse. Therefore choose life, that you may live, you and your descendants;" — Deuteronomy 30:19
World English Bible
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
WEB
What the text says. Deuteronomy 30:19 is spoken by Moses to Israel at a turning point: choose life and blessing over death and the curse. It is about the whole way of a people's life with God. It does not mention illness, medicine or a request to die. Galatians 6:2 tells believers to carry one another's burdens. It does not say what the burden is, or how it may be carried.
A tradition's reading. Many who oppose euthanasia read "choose life" as a call to guard every life, including the last days of a very ill person. Many who would allow it read "bear one another's burdens" as a call to share a sufferer's pain, even to the point of a merciful end. Both readings go beyond what the verses say. The two verses are not decisive proof for either side; readers differ, and a careful student says so.
1. How to read a hard debate
This lecture uses a plain pattern for each argument: first its strongest form, as its holders would say it; then its weak point, as a fair critic would say it. The weak points are not refutations. Each side has answers to them, and we give the answers in brief. They are there so that no argument is left standing alone, as if no one could question it.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that euthanasia and assisted suicide are always wrong. Some hold that they are wrong in nearly every case but that compassion can make it hard to say so about the last, hardest cases. A smaller number hold that, in a very few cases of unrelievable suffering and under strict rules, they may be allowed. People in all three groups love God, love the sick, and have often stood beside the dying. What this course requires of you is not that you join one group, but that you can state each fairly, name its weak point, and give your own reasons for your own judgement.
2. The case against: four arguments
Life as gift. Strongest form. Life is given by God. We did not make ourselves, and our bodies are entrusted to us, not owned by us (lecture 3-1). A life does not become less a gift when it becomes weak, dependent or painful. To end a life on purpose, even at the person's own wish, is to act as if we were its owners. The tradition of faith that has said this in many forms also says that a person is not required to cling to life at any cost: treatment may be refused when it is too burdensome, and death may be accepted when it comes (lecture 4-1). The line falls between accepting death and causing it.
Weak point. The argument rests on a view of God as the giver of life, which a person who does not share that view will not find persuasive on its own. Even for those who do share it, a critic asks why a gift may be refused in the form of a treatment but not in the form of an act that is performed; the distinction between letting die and causing death seems clear to some and thin to others. A further risk is that, said badly, the argument sounds like a demand that the sufferer endure.
Pressure on the weak. Strongest form. If the law or the custom of a society allows a person to ask for death, then an old person, a poor person, a disabled person or a sick person may begin to feel that she ought to ask. What begins as a right may turn into an expectation. The people most likely to feel this are those already made to feel they are in the way. A good society protects those who are most at risk of feeling they are a burden, and does not offer them an exit.
Weak point. This is a claim about what would happen in a society, and it depends on evidence that is disputed and may be different from place to place. Those who would allow assisted dying answer that careful rules can protect the weak, and that refusing every request for the sake of possible pressure on others also puts a burden on the person who suffers now and has asked freely. The argument does not by itself answer that person.
The slippery slope. Strongest form. A practice allowed for a few, in strict cases, tends to widen. What was allowed only for the dying may come to be allowed for the chronically ill, and then for those who are only tired of life. A line that is moved once can be moved again. It is wiser not to cross the first line.
Weak point. Whether this happens is a question of fact, not of theology, and the facts are disputed. A slippery slope argument can be raised against nearly any change, so by itself it proves too much. Supporters answer that the limits can be held. The argument also does not say whether the first step would be wrong if there were no slope.
Care as the answer. Strongest form. Most of what lies behind a request to die (pain, loneliness, fear, being a burden) can be met by good care and by a community that stays. The right answer to suffering is to remove the suffering, not the sufferer. A society that offers death before it offers care has failed. The Christian answer is accompaniment, and lectures 4-3 and 5-4 say what that means.
Weak point. Good care is not always available, and where it is available it does not remove every kind of suffering. To say that care is the answer may sound like a promise that cannot always be kept. It may also seem to the person who has asked, and been given care that did not help, as though the question were being avoided.
3. The case for allowing: four arguments
Autonomy. Strongest form. A person's life is his or her own to live, and the end of it is the most personal choice of all. A competent adult who has thought long and calmly about the end, and who has been offered every form of help, should not be forbidden by others to decide. To refuse this is to treat the person as a child. The Christian tradition itself honours conscience, and a person who is dying has a right to be heard.
Weak point. Autonomy does not stand alone. A person's choices are shaped by pain, fear, low mood, worry about the family, and what care is on offer. A request is not always as free as it looks. And Christian faith, which this course has set out, says that we are not the owners of our lives. For the many who hold that, autonomy cannot be the last word. Supporters answer that the same worries should not silence the person who is clear and settled.
Compassion. Strongest form. Love does not stand and watch someone suffer without any hope of relief. When suffering cannot be eased by any means and the person begs for release, compassion may call us to grant it. A merciful God, it is said, does not require pain to the end. To say no to this person is to put a principle above a human being.
Weak point. Compassion also moves people to stay, to hold and to keep company. It can be hard to tell compassion for the sufferer from a wish to be relieved of watching. The same motive of mercy has been used at times to end lives that had not asked. Compassion is a good guide, but it needs rules, and critics ask who is to make them. Those on this side answer that rules can exist and that the alternative is to leave the very ill in their pain.
Dignity. Strongest form. Some people feel that a life lived in great dependence, without the powers that made them who they were, is no longer a life that they would choose. This is not a small feeling. For them, to be able to say "this far and no further" is a way of holding on to themselves. To deny them is to deny them a dignity that they define for themselves.
Weak point. If dignity depends on what one can do, then people who cannot do much are said to have less of it. Disabled people, and those who care for them, have said clearly that this is wrong and that it harms them. Christian faith says that dignity is given by God and does not depend on ability (Week 6 returns to this). Those who hold the other side answer that they speak of one person's own sense of dignity, and say nothing about anyone else's worth.
A last mercy. Strongest form. There are rare cases where, whatever is done, a person's suffering cannot be relieved. For those cases, a last mercy should not be refused. Most requests may disappear with good care; a few do not. To make a rule that has no door for them is to be cruel to the people who most need kindness.
Weak point. It is hard to say how rare these cases are, and who judges that nothing more can be done. Hard cases are the cases from which general rules are made, and a rule made for a few may reach many. It also changes what a doctor or a carer is asked to be. Those on this side answer that careful wording can limit it, and that a few cases are enough to matter.
4. The range inside Christian traditions
We describe each as it would describe itself, and only as far as we are sure.
Catholic teaching holds that euthanasia and assisted suicide are gravely wrong, because they take an innocent human life, which belongs to God. It also holds that a person may refuse treatment that is burdensome or out of proportion, and that relieving pain is good even when it may shorten life, if the aim is not death. This is found, for example, in the encyclical letter Evangelium Vitae (1995), which we summarise and do not quote.
Orthodox churches hold, in general, that life is a gift of God and that ending it by one's own act or by another's is wrong. They stress the mystery of life and death, the place of prayer and of the sacraments for the dying, and the companionship of the church. As with every tradition, practice among believers is not always as tidy as the teaching, and we say only what we are sure of.
Protestant streams are many. Reformed, Lutheran, Anabaptist, Evangelical and Pentecostal bodies have in the main spoken against euthanasia and assisted suicide, and have stressed that life is God's, that the weak must be protected, and that care must not be withdrawn. Within some Protestant churches, and among some individual theologians and members, there are voices that struggle with the question or that argue for allowing it in limited cases, on grounds of compassion or of conscience. They are a minority voice, and they are not outside the faith.
There are also people in every tradition who hold the official view and yet find it hard to say to a person in pain. That difficulty is not a failure of faith. It is what happens when a teaching meets a bed.
5. Disagreeing without condemning
Here are some ways Christians can differ on this question and still be one body, as Romans 14 asks of believers on other contested matters.
State the other side's argument so well that its holder would nod. Do not say that anyone who holds the other view does not love God, or does not love people. Do not use a person's own case as a debating point: a man who is dying is a person, not an example. Do not judge a family for what they chose, or a patient for what he asked, or a clinician for the work she does. Remember that most who hold either view hold it because they care about the weak.
And remember that a debate in a church hall is different from a bed in a hospital. Someone in the congregation may be sitting there with a request in the family, or a memory. Speak as if they were.
6. What this course requires
This course requires that you can state both sides fairly, name the weak point of each, and say why you judge as you do. It does not require you to choose a side to pass. It also asks one more thing: that whatever you decide, you will not leave the person who suffers alone with the question. That is the subject of lecture 5-4.
Diagram 1. Two cases, each with its weak point
In short
- The case against rests on life as gift, pressure on the weak, the slippery slope and care as the answer.
- The case for allowing rests on autonomy, compassion, dignity and a last mercy for rare cases.
- Each argument has a weak point; the weak points are not refutations, and each side has answers.
- Most Christian traditions oppose euthanasia and assisted suicide, while allowing refusal of burdensome treatment; some voices struggle or argue otherwise.
- Verses such as Deuteronomy 30:19 and Galatians 6:2 are not decisive proof for either side.
- Christians can disagree without condemning each other, and nobody may leave the sufferer alone.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four arguments against | Life as gift; pressure on the weak; the slippery slope; care as the answer. |
| Four arguments for allowing | Autonomy; compassion; dignity; a last mercy for rare cases. |
| A weak point of autonomy | Choices are shaped by pain, fear and worry for the family, and Christian faith says we are not the owners of our lives. |
| A weak point of "care as the answer" | Good care is not always available and does not remove every suffering, so the answer may sound like a promise that cannot be kept. |
One sentence to remember State each side so well that its holder would nod, and then name its weak point.
This week's action Write the strongest argument of the side you disagree with, in four sentences, and its weak point in one.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Take the argument "life as gift". Say it so that a person who holds it would agree with your wording, and then name its weak point.
- Take the argument "compassion". Say it so that a person who holds it would agree with your wording, and then name its weak point.
- Why does the claim of "pressure on the weak" depend on facts that a theology lecture cannot settle? What does that mean for how we use it in church?
- Why is the dignity argument a hard one for disabled people, and why do its holders say that they speak of one person's own sense of dignity?
- How can two Christians, one on each side, stay in one body, according to the pattern of Romans 14, and what must each avoid saying?