Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
In many fields of life people ask a simple question about an act: did the other person agree? If the answer is yes, the matter often seems closed. Between equals, agreement counts for a great deal.
Between a minister and someone in the minister's care, it counts for much less. The reason is not that the other person is weak or foolish. The reason is that the two are not standing on level ground, and agreement that is given across a slope is not the same as agreement given on the flat. The one who holds more power has a greater responsibility, and that responsibility cannot be handed to the other person by saying, "But she wanted it," or "He said yes," or "They chose it."
This lecture sets out where the slope comes from, who is most exposed to it, and why consent is not a defence when a minister holds power over the other person. Later chapters rely on this principle, especially those on money, on closeness and on what to do when wrong comes to light. The lecture is not about how harm is done, and it gives no detail of that. It is about where the responsibility lies.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Describe four kinds of imbalance between a minister and a person in the minister's care: trust, knowledge, spiritual standing and dependence.
- Name situations in which people are more exposed to a minister's power.
- Explain why "she wanted it" or "he agreed" does not settle a question when a minister holds power over the other person.
- Explain why the greater responsibility rests with the one who holds more power.
- Say what a minister can do in place of relying on the other person's consent.
Son of man, prophesy against the shepherds of Israel, prophesy, and tell them, even to the shepherds, Thus says the Lord Yahweh: Woe to the shepherds of Israel who feed themselves! Shouldn’t the shepherds feed the sheep? You eat the fat, and you clothe yourself with the wool, you kill the fatlings; but you don’t feed the sheep. You haven’t strengthened the diseased, neither have you healed that which was sick, neither have you bound up that which was broken, neither have you brought back that which was driven away, neither have you sought that which was lost; but with force and with rigor you have ruled over them." — Ezekiel 34:2-4
World English Bible
but he who didn’t know, and did things worthy of stripes, will be beaten with few stripes. To whomever much is given, of him will much be required; and to whom much was entrusted, of him more will be asked." — Luke 12:48
WEB
Let not many of you be teachers, my brothers, knowing that we will receive heavier judgment." — James 3:1
WEB
Ezekiel speaks against leaders who used their flock for themselves and left the weak unhelped. Jesus and James, in different places, say that responsibility grows with what has been given or taken on. None of the three says that the people in the flock are to blame for what is done to them.
1. Four ways the ground is not level
Lecture 1-1 listed the sources of a minister's power. Here we ask how that power looks from the other side: from the position of the person who comes to the minister for help, teaching, prayer or care. Four kinds of imbalance matter most.
Trust. A person who comes to a minister has usually decided, before saying anything, that this is a safe person. They may have been told so by their family, their church or their own faith. The minister has not had to earn that trust in the particular case; it comes with the role. A person who trusts in this way is less likely to ask the questions they would ask of a stranger. They may not check, doubt or push back, because to do so would feel like an insult to someone who has been kind.
Knowledge. The minister knows more about the Bible, the community's rules, the stages of grief, the way the church works and what is considered normal. The other person often cannot judge whether what they are told is accurate, whether it is the minister's opinion or the church's teaching, or whether the person speaking is staying within the proper limits of the role. A person who does not know what a minister should and should not do is poorly placed to say, "This is not right."
Spiritual standing. Many people believe, quite sincerely, that a minister speaks for God, or stands closer to God, or can bring blessing or loss. This can be true in a limited and proper sense. It also means that a minister's word carries weight in the believer's conscience. When the minister says, "I think this would be good," the believer may hear, "God thinks this would be good," and a refusal can feel like disobedience to God.
Dependence. A person may depend on the minister for comfort, friendship, work, money, a place to live, the people they know, help with a government office, or the only conversation they have in their own language. The more a person depends, the greater the cost of disagreeing, and the harder it is to say "no" freely. Dependence is not always visible. A smiling, active person may be depending on this relationship more than any other.
None of the four is a fault in the other person. Each is simply a part of what it means to come to a minister. They explain why a minister's power is greater than it feels.
2. Who is more exposed
Everyone who comes to a minister stands on a slope. Some people stand on a steeper one. It is the minister's duty to know who they may be, and to take more care, not less, with them. The following are examples. The list is not complete, and it is not a way to label persons: anyone, at some point, can be in a more exposed position.
- A person in crisis: grief, illness, divorce, a loss of work, fear, a death in the family. People in crisis seek help with less caution and more need.
- A person who is isolated: someone with little family nearby, or whose other relationships are strained, so that the minister is the main contact.
- Children and young people. They have less experience, less power to refuse an adult, and a developing sense of what is normal. For a child or a young person, the question of consent as the law and the church understand it differs by country and by community; follow local law and your community's written rules. In every case, the responsibility is the adult's.
- Newcomers: someone new in a church, or new to a country, who does not yet know the unwritten rules and wants to belong.
- Migrants and refugees: people who may depend on a congregation for housing, documents, work, or the only trusted community. A person whose legal position is uncertain has less ability to complain.
- People who face a language barrier: a person who speaks the minister's language less well may not understand what is being asked, and may not be able to explain what is wrong.
- People with disabilities, older people, and people with little money: each may rely more heavily on the minister's goodwill.
- A person who has been harmed before: who may find it hard to refuse, because refusing has once been unsafe.
A minister who serves in a poor or isolated place often serves many such people at once. This is not a reason to avoid them. It is a reason to take the greater care.
3. Why "she wanted it" does not settle it
The phrase "she wanted it" or "he agreed" is heard in many forms. A minister who has made a close, private or financial arrangement with someone in his or her care may say, in good faith, "The other person agreed. Nobody was forced." This lecture says that, where the minister holds power over the other person, this is not enough, and it is not a defence. There are four reasons.
First, agreement given across unequal ground is not free in the same way. A person who depends on the minister, who trusts the minister, who fears to lose the minister's good opinion, or who believes that to refuse is to refuse God, may say yes without having a real choice. They may say yes because it is the safest answer. A "yes" that is the safest answer is not a free one.
Second, the minister is the one who can see the slope. The person in care may not realise how much depends on the minister's goodwill. The minister can. The one who can see the danger carries the duty to avoid it. It does not move to the other person because they said yes.
Third, the minister is the one with the role. A minister's role includes keeping to certain limits for the sake of those who come to him or her. When a person goes to a doctor or a teacher, that person does not become responsible for the limits of the doctor or the teacher. The same holds for ministers. The limits are part of the work.
Fourth, later feelings are not the test. A person who agreed at the time may, later and with more distance, see that the agreement was not free. Or they may never say so, out of loyalty, shame or fear. A minister who relies on "she never complained" is treating silence as consent. It is not.
None of this means that the other person is treated as a child or as having no will. It means that the minister does not get to decide that the other person's "yes" is enough. A minister's own responsibility is not settled by the answer of the person with less power.
Consent and power
Where a minister holds power over another person, that person's agreement does not move the responsibility off the minister. The more power a person holds, the more the responsibility for limits rests on that person. Later chapters rely on this, for money and gifts (week 2) and for closeness and sexual boundaries (week 3).
4. What this principle covers, and what it does not
It covers any situation in which the minister holds power over the other person: a person who comes for counsel, who belongs to the minister's congregation or group, who depends on the minister for work, housing or help, or who is a child or young person under the minister's care. It covers money, gifts, favours, secrets, closeness of every kind, and requests for help.
It does not mean that a minister can never have a friend, never receive a gift, or never be loved. It does not mean that members of a congregation cannot form friendships, marry, do business together or help each other. Two adult members, neither of whom holds power over the other, stand on a different footing. The principle applies where the minister is the one who holds the power.
How long the slope lasts
This is a point where readers will not agree: when, if ever, does the slope end? Some hold that a minister who has been the other person's pastor remains in that position, in practice, for as long as the person looks to him or her as pastor, and that any relationship of closeness is therefore always forbidden, however long after. Others hold that the pastoral relationship can truly end, and that after it has ended, and enough time has passed, and the person has found other support, the two are equal in a way they were not before. Each position is held out of care for the person who has trusted. This course requires less than either position fixes: that the minister never treats the other person's agreement as the answer, that the minister speaks with an overseer or a trusted colleague before anything is done, and that the question of timing is treated in week 3 with the rules of the community and local law. It does not require any one answer on how long.
5. Two small cases
(An invented example.) A newcomer and a favour. A church in a port city welcomes a man who has recently arrived in the country. He speaks the local language poorly and has no relatives nearby. The pastor helps him find work and speaks to a landlord for him. After some months the pastor asks him to do unpaid repairs at the pastor's own house on weekends, saying, "You would be helping the church." The man says yes at once, and says he is glad to help. What was crossed: the pastor used his place, and the man's dependence on him for work and housing, to obtain a service for himself. The man's "yes" was quick because a "no" could cost him a great deal. That the man seemed happy does not change this. A better path: if the repairs are needed, the pastor tells the church council and asks them to arrange the work or to pay for it openly, from a person who is not dependent on the pastor. If he wants to thank the man for help already given, he does it where others can see.
(An invented example.) Closeness and grief. A minister has been supporting a woman for the year since her husband died. She tells the minister that she values him more than anyone else in her life, and that she would like the relationship to become something more. He is lonely too, and feels the same. What is the situation? She is grieving, isolated, and has come to rely on him for comfort and company. He holds the role of pastor and the trust that comes with it. He may truly feel what he says he feels. And she may truly mean what she says. What would be a mistake: to say, "She is an adult and she asked." Her request, made from where she stands, does not remove his responsibility. It makes his responsibility greater. A better path: he tells her kindly that he cannot continue as her pastor in this way, and he arranges that someone else takes over her . He speaks, before anything else happens, to his overseer or a trusted colleague, and asks for help in looking at his own feelings. He does not blame her. He does not hide it. Whether a relationship could ever properly follow is a question he does not answer alone. Handing over her care must never be used as a way round the limit. Week 3 returns to it.
In neither case does the minister have to be a bad person. Both show how easily a person with good intentions may lean on consent, and what it looks like to put the responsibility back where it belongs.
6. What a minister does instead of leaning on consent
It is not enough to say what is not allowed. Here are the habits that take the place of relying on "they agreed."
- Notice the slope. Ask: what does this person depend on me for? What would it cost them to say no?
- Ask what a refusal would cost, and make refusal cheap. "You may say no, and nothing will change in how I treat you." Then act that way.
- Move the decision into the open. If it is a matter of money, work, closeness or favour, tell a colleague, an overseer or a council, before the thing is done.
- Let another person do what you should not. If a service or a gift is needed, ask someone who does not depend on you.
- Step back or hand over. When closeness begins to cross a limit, change the role: transfer pastoral care, add distance, or add people.
- Take the first step yourself. Do not wait for the other person to protect themselves. They are standing lower on the slope.
7. A word to people who have been on the lower ground
Some readers will recognise, in this lecture, something from their own life. If so, nothing in this lecture says that you were at fault. If you want to speak with someone, a trusted pastor or priest, a safeguarding person (someone your church or group names to protect people from harm) or a qualified professional can help. If you are in danger now, call your local emergency number. The Practice Lab for this week never asks you to disclose anything, and you may stop at any point.
Diagram 1. Agreement across a slope
핵심 요약
- Four imbalances separate a minister from a person in care: trust, knowledge, spiritual standing and dependence. None is a fault in the other person.
- Some people are more exposed: those in crisis or isolated, children, newcomers, migrants, people facing a language barrier, those who depend on the minister.
- Where a minister holds power over the other person, "she wanted it" or "he agreed" is not a defence: agreement across a slope is not free in the same way.
- The greater the power, the greater the responsibility for limits, and it cannot be handed to the other person.
- Instead of leaning on consent: notice the slope, make refusal cheap, bring it into the open, hand over, step back.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four imbalances | Trust, knowledge, spiritual standing, dependence. |
| Why consent is not a defence | Agreement across unequal power is not free in the same way, and the minister is the one who sees the slope and holds the role. |
| Luke 12:48 | To whom much is given, much will be required. |
| What to do instead | Notice the slope, make refusal cheap, bring the matter into the open, hand over or step back. |
One sentence to remember When a minister holds the power, the limit is the minister's to keep, whatever the other person says.
This week's action Write down two people who depend on you in some way, and one thing you will do this week to make it easy for each of them to say no.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the four imbalances (trust, knowledge, spiritual standing, dependence) is most easily forgotten by the one who holds the power? Why?
- Think of the people in your community who might be more exposed to a minister's power. What would it mean to take more care with them, not less?
- In your own words, why does "she wanted it" not settle the question when a minister holds power over the other person? State it so that someone who disagreed could not say you had misrepresented the other side.
- In the case of the newcomer and the repairs, what could the pastor have done so that the help he needed was given and nobody's dependence was used?
- The paragraph beginning *This is a point where readers will not agree* sets out two views on how long the slope lasts. State each as its holders would want it stated, and say what this course requires whichever is right.