Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
This is the hardest lecture of the week, and it is written to be plain and short on detail. It gives no description of how harm is done. It speaks of boundaries and responsibility.
The claim is simple to state. A romantic or sexual relationship between a minister and a person in the minister's care is not made acceptable by the other person's agreement. Lecture 1-3 explained why: where one person holds much more power, trust and standing than the other, a "yes" cannot be taken at face value. This lecture applies that argument, and then asks the practical question that matters most to a minister: what do I do when I notice that a feeling is growing?
Cases in which harm has been done are treated in week 6, and the harmed person comes first there. This lecture comes earlier on purpose. Almost all of the wrong in this area could be stopped long before it begins, by a minister who knows the early signs and acts on them.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why agreement does not make a romantic or sexual relationship with a person in your care acceptable.
- Say who is covered by this boundary, and why a relationship with a child or young person is never a question of consent.
- Describe how different traditions (celibate clergy, married ministers, rules of accompaniment) carry this boundary without ranking them.
- Name the early signs of drift, and say what a minister should do when feelings appear.
- State what a minister should do when the feelings are on the other side.
For this is the will of God: your sanctification, that you abstain from sexual immorality," — 1 Thessalonians 4:3
World English Bible
that no one should take advantage of and wrong a brother or sister in this matter; because the Lord is an avenger in all these things, as also we forewarned you and testified." — 1 Thessalonians 4:6
WEB
For God called us not for uncleanness, but in sanctification." — 1 Thessalonians 4:7
WEB
Don’t rebuke an older man, but exhort him as a father; the younger men as brothers;" — 1 Timothy 5:1
WEB
the elder women as mothers; the younger as sisters, in all purity." — 1 Timothy 5:2
WEB
Flee from youthful lusts; but pursue righteousness, faith, love, and peace with those who call on the Lord out of a pure heart." — 2 Timothy 2:22
WEB
Paul writes to the Thessalonians about holiness ("" means being set apart as holy) and about not wronging another person in this matter. Translators and scholars differ over the exact meaning of the verse between these two (verse 4), and this lecture does not rest on it. The verses printed here are enough: holiness, and no one wronged. In his letter to Timothy, Paul tells a young minister to treat those in his care as members of a family, "in all purity" for the younger women, and to flee what is dangerous and pursue what is good.
1. Why agreement is not enough
Suppose a minister says, "She is an adult and she wanted it." Or a parishioner says, "He did not force me. I agreed." Why is this not the end of the matter?
Because of what lecture 1-3 called unequal power. The minister holds more than one kind of power at once:
- Trust. The person has often told the minister things they have told no one else.
- Knowledge. The minister may know the person's weaknesses, history and fears.
- Spiritual standing. To many people the minister speaks for God, or stands between them and God. A "no" to the minister can feel like a "no" to God.
- Dependence. The person may rely on the minister for in a crisis, for belonging, for work or housing, for help with papers, for a place in the community.
Each of these changes what "yes" means. A person may say yes from gratitude. They may say yes from fear of losing the community, or from the belief that the minister must know best, or from the wish to please someone who has been kind in a hard time. They may say yes because they do not see that they could say no. In such cases the word "yes" may be true and still not be free.
That is why this course holds that consent is not a defence where the minister holds power over the other person. The point is not that the other person is foolish or weak. The point is that the arrangement is unequal, and the greater responsibility rests with the one who holds more power. The minister cannot hand that responsibility to the other person by saying "she agreed." It stays with the minister.
A second reason is easy to miss. Even if the other person's yes were wholly free, the relationship would still change the minister's work. The minister now has a personal interest in what the person says and does. Advice becomes less honest. Other members begin to notice. The person's own pastoral care ends, because the one who cared for them is now something else, and they may be left with no one to turn to.
2. Who is covered
The boundary applies to anyone in your care or under your authority, and in particular:
- a member who has come to you for pastoral care, counselling, spiritual direction, confession or help in a crisis;
- a person you are teaching or preparing for baptism, marriage, membership or ordination;
- someone you supervise, employ or lead: a volunteer, a youth worker, a junior minister, a student;
- anyone in a vulnerable season: bereaved, ill, newly arrived, afraid, in debt, in a marriage in trouble.
Notice that the list is made of relationships of power, not of types of person. It does not depend on age, gender or the status of either party.
Children and young people are a different matter altogether. A romantic or sexual relationship between an adult minister and a child or young person is not a question of consent at all. It is abuse. A child cannot agree to it. The course does not discuss this as a boundary to be managed; it is a line that is never crossed, and it is dealt with under safeguarding policy and law. See week 6 and a course on church safety (PT717E). The legal age and the legal duties differ by country: follow local law and your community's written rules.
3. How traditions carry this boundary
All traditions teach that this boundary matters. They carry it in different ways.
Celibate clergy and members of religious orders have made a promise of celibacy. For them a sexual or romantic relationship with anyone breaks the vow, and a relationship with a person in their care breaks the vow and the trust. The two wrongs are different. The vow is a promise made to God and to a community. The trust is a duty owed to the other person. It is possible to speak about one and forget the other. The course asks that the second never be lost behind the first. A person who was harmed is not helped by being told only that a vow was broken.
Married ministers have made a promise of faithfulness to a spouse. A relationship outside the marriage wounds the spouse, the family and the community. Again there are two wrongs. The harm to the person in care does not become smaller because the minister is unmarried, or larger because the minister is married. Its centre is the unequal power.
Rules of accompaniment are used in some traditions for spiritual direction and similar one-to-one care: the place where it happens, the length, a record of when it happens, a supervisor or mentor for the director, a limit on how long one person accompanies another. They exist because this kind of care is private and deep. The course does not require any one such rule. It does say that a form of care that is deep and private should have some form of check around it, and that the check protects both people.
In independent, charismatic and house-church settings there may be no written rules at all, and a minister may be the only authority. In such places the boundary rests the most on the minister's own care, and so it helps most to name an outside adviser in advance (week 5).
This is a point where readers will not agree: may a relationship begin after the care has ended, or between a minister and a member who is not in the minister's care? One position holds that a minister should never begin a romantic relationship with anyone who has ever been in the minister's care or under the minister's authority, because the power does not disappear when the formal relationship ends, and because it is hard for anyone, including the minister, to know whether the care ended for honest reasons. Another position holds that a minister is also a person who may love and marry, that in a small community the person one comes to love may well be a member, and that to forbid every such case is to deny ministers a normal life and to treat adults as unable to decide. Each position has a real concern behind it. This course requires less than the first, and more than "whatever two adults decide." It requires that the person is not in the minister's care or under the minister's authority at the time, and has not been in a season of need with the minister; that the minister has first handed any care and any authority over that person to someone else, so that the care is not ended in order to begin a relationship (which is itself a warning sign); that the minister tells an overseer or a trusted colleague before anything begins; that nothing is hidden; and that the other person has time, and people other than the minister to talk to. Many communities and associations have written rules on this, some of them stricter. Follow your own.
4. The early signs of drift
Harm in this area almost never begins suddenly. It begins with small steps, each of which seems reasonable. A minister should know these steps well, because seeing them in oneself is the best protection.
- Special attention. You find that you think of one person more than the others. You look for them in a room. You are glad to hear their name.
- Extra reasons to meet. You find reasons for another visit, another call, another message. The need that justified the first meeting has passed, but the meetings continue.
- Privacy. You begin to prefer to meet where no one will see. Without quite deciding, you do not mention the meetings to others.
- Sharing your own troubles. You begin to tell this person about your marriage, your loneliness, your tiredness. They become your listener, and the care begins to run in the wrong direction.
- Lingering closeness. Touch lasts longer, or is sought; compliments move from the work to the person; the talk becomes more personal than the matter in hand needs.
- Gifts and favours. Small gifts, small exceptions, small secrets.
- The thought "no one else understands." When you catch yourself thinking that this person understands you as no one else does, take it as a red light.
None of these is a sin by itself, and having a warm feeling for someone is not a sin. A feeling is not an act. The wrong is in what is done with it, and especially in what is hidden. A minister who finds the signs in himself or herself is not a bad person. A minister who finds them and says nothing to anyone has begun to make a bad path for the person in their care.
5. What to do when feelings appear
(An invented example.) A minister has been supporting a woman through the death of her husband. Over a year of visits, the minister comes to notice that the visits are the best part of the week. The woman has begun to say she does not know what she would do without the minister. Neither has said anything improper. But the minister notices, driving home, that the thought has come: "what if this were more?"
The first thing to say is that the minister has done nothing wrong, and has also noticed in time. Here is what a good path looks like.
- Name it, to yourself, early. Do not tell yourself it is nothing and do not tell yourself you are wicked. Say the plain thing: "I am becoming attached to a person in my care."
- Tell someone outside the situation. A trusted colleague, an overseer, a spiritual director, a counsellor, a mentor. The aim is not to be declared free of blame. It is to bring the matter out of the dark, where it grows, and into a place where someone can help you see it. If you are a member of a tradition with confession, this may be one place to speak of it; but because a confessor may not be able to act on what is told, it is wise to speak to a person who can also help with the practical steps below.
- Add distance. Fewer private meetings, shorter meetings, other people present, fewer messages, no late messages (lecture 3-3).
- Change duties. Arrange for another minister, or a trained helper, to take over this person's care, and do so honestly and kindly. The person must not be left feeling dropped. Tell them that the pastoral care will continue with someone else, and why in general terms: "I think someone else could serve you better."
- Do not tell the person about your feelings as a way of easing your own mind. To do so puts a burden on someone who may be unable to refuse it. If something does have to be said, say it with your overseer's or colleague's guidance.
- Do not wait until it is a crisis. Every week of waiting makes the next step harder.
What if the feelings are on the other side? People in distress may become attached to the one who has helped them. This is common and is not shameful. A minister who finds that someone in their care has begun to speak of love, or to look for more, should respond kindly and clearly. Do not mock, shame or use it. Do not respond in a way that leaves it open. Say, calmly, that the relationship is one of care and will remain so; arrange for the person to have another person's help as well; and tell a colleague or overseer so that you are not carrying it alone. The minister is the one who must keep the line, because the minister is the one with the power.
6. A short good case
(An invented example.) Honest early. A priest in a small town realises that an adult member of the parish council, with whom he has worked closely for a year, has become important to him. He does not speak of his feelings to the member. He tells his bishop's delegate at their next meeting and asks for advice. Together they decide that another member of the clergy will oversee the council's work with the member, and that the priest will attend meetings only when others are present. The member is told, truthfully and in general terms, that the priest and the bishop's delegate think the council's work is better shared among more people. The feelings fade over some months; the priest is not sure that they would have, without the plan. No one was harmed, and no one was exposed. A minister who acts early may spare everyone a harm that they would otherwise have borne for years.
7. If you have been harmed, or know of harm
If you think a minister has crossed this line with you, or with someone you know, you are not at fault. Your safety and your voice come first. Speak to a person you trust who is not part of the minister's circle, or to your community's safeguarding person or a qualified professional, and, where law and your community allow, to an authority outside the community. If anyone is in danger now, call your local emergency number. You do not have to keep it secret, and no one may rightly demand your silence. Week 6 explains what a good response looks like. Nothing in this lecture asks you to protect the minister, a ministry or a church's good name above the person who was harmed.
Diagram 1. Why a "yes" may not be free
Diagram 2. What to do when a feeling appears
핵심 요약
- Agreement does not make a romantic or sexual relationship acceptable between a minister and a person in the minister's care: the power is unequal, and the greater responsibility is the minister's.
- The boundary covers anyone in your care or under your authority. With a child or young person it is never a question of consent; it is abuse.
- Vows and marriage add promises; they do not create or remove the unequal power, which is the centre of the harm.
- Drift begins with small steps: special attention, extra reasons to meet, privacy, sharing your own troubles.
- A feeling is not an act. When one appears, tell someone outside the situation, add distance and change duties.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why consent is not a defence | The minister holds more power, so a "yes" may not be free, and the greater responsibility rests with the minister. |
| Never a question of consent | A romantic or sexual relationship between an adult minister and a child or young person: it is abuse. |
| Three early signs | Special attention; extra reasons to meet; privacy or secrecy. |
| When a feeling appears | Name it early, tell someone outside the situation, add distance, change duties, and do not wait. |
One sentence to remember A feeling is not an act, but what you do with it, and what you hide, is yours to answer for.
This week's action Decide, before you need to, whom you would tell if you noticed a growing attachment, and write down their role (not their name).
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In your own words, why is "she (or he) agreed" not a defence where the minister holds power? Which of the four kinds of power (trust, knowledge, spiritual standing, dependence) seems to you the most easily forgotten?
- The lecture says "A feeling is not an act." Why is it useful for a minister to hear this? What would go wrong if a minister believed instead that a feeling was already a sin?
- Which of the early signs would be hardest for you to tell someone about? What could make it easier in your place?
- The invented priest told a bishop's delegate. Who is the equivalent person in your own tradition or place? If there is no one, whom could you ask?
- Read the paragraph beginning "This is a point where readers will not agree." State the position you find least convincing as its holders would state it.