Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
The earlier lectures of this week looked at the people a minister serves. This one looks at the people a minister lives with: a spouse, children, parents, brothers and sisters, or, for a person in a religious community, the community itself. These people did not apply for the work. They did not receive the training or the title, and they often receive the costs.
The lecture asks three questions. How can a minister's household take part in the church's life without being used by it? When a minister's relatives work in the church, or sit among its members, how are power and fairness kept honest? And how can a minister's work be done without crowding out the family that the minister also owes love and care?
Lecture 3-1 spoke of dual roles. A minister's family is the oldest dual role of all, because the one person is spouse or parent at home and pastor in the church, and the household and the congregation are often linked by a shared building, a shared income and shared gossip.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Say how a minister's spouse and children may take part in ministry without being treated as part of the minister's equipment.
- Explain why employing or placing relatives in a church creates a conflict of interest, and what makes it safe.
- Describe how ministry can crowd out the family, and name practical protections.
- Read 1 Timothy 3:4-5 and 5:8 in their context, without making either a tool of pressure.
- Describe how households differ in different traditions, including celibate and religious ministers.
one who rules his own house well, having children in subjection with all reverence;" — 1 Timothy 3:4
World English Bible
(but if a man doesn’t know how to rule his own house, how will he take care of the assembly of God?)" — 1 Timothy 3:5
WEB
But if anyone doesn’t provide for his own, and especially his own household, he has denied the faith, and is worse than an unbeliever." — 1 Timothy 5:8
WEB
These verses are often quoted to ministers. The first two come from a list of qualities Paul gives for an overseer, a person with responsibility in the church. The third comes from a passage about the care of widows and of relatives in need. How they should be read, and how they should not, is part of this lecture.
1. Reading the verses fairly
The first two verses are in a list of qualities of an overseer in the church. The point Paul makes is that the way a person leads in the household shows something of how they will serve the church. Taken in context, the verses say that the household is a place where a minister's character can be seen, and where it matters. They do not say that a minister's family must be perfect, or that a child's trouble is a sign of the parent's failure. They are not a licence to put pressure on a minister's spouse or children to act in a certain way for the sake of the church's image. And they were written in a world where those who led were commonly men with households; in other traditions, and for ministers who are women, single, widowed or celibate, the same concern shows itself in other ways: how the person treats those they live with, whether that is a family, a community or a house of friends.
The third verse comes in a passage about the care of widows and of relatives in need. It says that a person who does not provide for their own relatives, and especially for their own household, has turned away from what faith asks. It is a hard verse, and it is about material and practical care: food, shelter, support. It is not about how many hours a person spends at church. Read fairly, it reminds the minister that the family is also a part of the minister's and not only its rival. A minister who gives everything to the congregation and leaves a household in need has not served better; the minister has served one duty and abandoned another.
Taken together the three verses say the same thing from two directions: a minister's home is part of the minister's service, and it needs care.
2. The spouse and children in the work
(An invented example.) A new pastor and her husband arrive at a small church. On the first Sunday, three members say to him, "We are glad to have you both. Will you lead the men's breakfast?" and, "Can you run the sound desk?" Within a month his name is on the list of duties for four tasks. Nobody asked what he wanted, and he is too polite to refuse.
Churches in many cultures expect a minister's spouse to take part: to teach, to cook, to host, to sing, to visit. Some spouses love this and are gifted for it. For others it is a burden they never chose. The ethics here are plain.
- A spouse is not an unpaid assistant. The minister was called, and was appointed. The spouse was not. A church that wants the spouse's work should ask, as it would ask anyone, and be ready to hear no.
- Roles should be agreed openly. If the spouse works in the church, the work should have a name, a limit and, where the church's custom allows, fair recognition. This protects the spouse. It also protects the minister from the view that the spouse is only "an extension" of the minister's power.
- A spouse's private life is the spouse's. The minister must not use what the spouse knows or says as an instrument in church affairs, and the spouse should not be asked to carry the minister's confidences, or to carry the church's.
- The spouse also needs care. A minister who gives care to a congregation and none to the spouse has made the spouse into a second layer of unpaid care. A spouse also needs a friend, a place to speak, and someone who is not only a member of the minister's church.
Children are not part of the ministry. Three habits are worth avoiding. First, using children as illustrations in sermons or in appeals without their consent, in a way that would shame them in front of their peers. Second, holding them to a standard others are not held to, because they are "the minister's children." Third, making them part of the church's work as if they had no other life. Children need ordinary childhood: friends who are not members, afternoons that are not about the church, a parent who is at home at times.
It is also worth saying that children in a minister's house often hear more than they should: telephone calls, visitors at the door, a parent upset after a meeting. A minister should take care what a child overhears, because a child cannot keep what is not theirs to keep.
3. Employing relatives and placing family
(An invented example.) A pastor of a village church needs a caretaker. His younger brother is out of work and honest. The church can pay little, and nobody else has applied. The pastor says to the church council, "I am glad to offer my brother. If you prefer someone else, I will understand." The council, grateful to the pastor and not wishing to give offence, agrees at once.
Is this wrong? Not necessarily. It is common in small communities, and it can be a kindness. But look at the structure: the pastor holds the power to recommend, and the council is not in a free position to refuse. The brother, once employed, answers to the church but is also the brother of the person who leads the church. If he does the work badly, who corrects him? If the church's money is short, whose job goes first? If another member quarrels with the brother, does the quarrel become a quarrel with the pastor?
This is a conflict of interest: the minister has a personal interest in a decision that he or she also helps to make. Week 2 (lecture 2-2) described this in money matters, and week 5 describes structures for oversight. Here are the practical rules that follow.
- Disclose it. Say plainly that the person is a relative.
- Do not decide alone. The minister should not hire, set pay, supervise or dismiss a relative. Another person or group, who is free to say no, should decide.
- Write down the terms. The role, the pay, who supervises, who the relative can go to with a complaint.
- Review it. After some months, someone other than the minister asks: is this working fairly for the church and for the relative?
- Do not shield the relative from ordinary correction. A relative who is treated gently because of the family tie is not treated fairly, and the others see it.
The same logic applies to relatives of a minister who sit in the congregation or on a council. A minister's family are members like any others, with the same rights and no more. They should not be favoured, and they should not be silenced.
Where laws about employment and family relationships apply, they differ by country. Follow local law and ask a qualified person.
4. When ministry crowds out the family
(An invented example.) A minister has said yes to every request for six years: weddings, sick visits, a youth camp, a committee, a late call. The house is neglected. The minister's spouse has long since stopped asking when the minister will be home. A child has stopped saying "when you are home." The minister believes this is sacrifice, and the congregation praises it.
There is a long and honourable tradition of sacrifice in ministry, and this lecture does not despise it. But sacrifice that is chosen by one person and paid by another is of a different kind. The one who pays has not chosen. The lecture asks the minister to hear two things together: ministry asks much, and ministry is not allowed to take what belongs to the people at home.
Protections that many ministers find useful:
- A day of rest, held. A fixed time, announced and respected, with the church's leaders agreeing in advance what counts as an emergency.
- A protected evening, or a protected meal. A small fixed commitment is easier to keep than a large and vague one.
- A spouse's and children's voice. Ask them, at fixed times, whether the balance is right, and listen.
- A second person for the church. If everything waits on one minister, the household pays. A church that trains elders, deacons, lay leaders and helpers has made it possible for the minister to be absent.
- Honest limits to the congregation. To say "I cannot come on that day" is not neglect; it is a way of keeping a promise to the household.
A minister's own spiritual life, calling and burnout are the subject of Spiritual Formation for Ministers (FS103E, planned). Here only one point is made: the family is not the price the minister pays for the work.
5. Households in different traditions
A minister's household takes many forms, and this course ranks none.
In many Protestant, Pentecostal and independent churches, ministers are married, and the family lives in a house provided by the church or near it. The risks are the ones above: the spouse's unpaid work, the children's visibility, the home that is also the office. In Orthodox churches, parish priests are commonly married, and the priest's wife has a recognised place in the parish; this has its own traditions of respect and its own pressures. In the Catholic tradition, most priests are celibate (some Eastern Catholic churches have married priests), and many belong to religious orders or communities whose members share a household. For them, "family" includes both the community they live with and the relatives they came from. A priest or sister may owe care to ageing parents as well as duties to a community and a bishop or superior, and these may pull against each other. In small and independent communities, the minister may be both pastor and the sole provider for a household, with few resources and no one to relieve them.
What is shared across all of these is that the minister's closest relationships are not a private matter outside ethics. They are where much of the minister's own character shows, and where the minister's power is either checked by love or unchecked.
This is a point where readers will not agree: should a minister's spouse hold office, or work on the staff, in the same church? Some say yes. They say that a couple working together is a witness to the church, that a shared calling can strengthen a marriage, and that in a small community there may be no one else with the gifts or the time. Others say no, or not often. They say that it puts power in one household, that a spouse who works under the minister cannot easily disagree, that it removes the refuge of a home outside the church, and that if the minister falls into trouble the family loses both home and work. Both have seen it go well and go badly. This course requires less than a ban and more than good intentions. It requires that the spouse's role be agreed freely and written down; that someone other than the couple decides pay, hours and discipline; that the spouse is free to say no or to step back; and that the congregation has a way to raise a concern that does not run through the couple.
Diagram 1. The household and the church
Diagram 2. Questions before placing a relative in a role
| Question | A sound answer |
|---|---|
| Who decides? | Someone other than the minister, who is free to say no |
| Is it known? | Yes: the relationship is disclosed to those who decide |
| Is it written? | Role, pay, who supervises, who hears a complaint |
| Will it be reviewed? | After a fixed time, by someone outside the family |
| Can the relative be corrected? | Yes, as anyone else would be |
핵심 요약
- A minister's household is part of the minister's service; it is not equipment for the work.
- A spouse is not an unpaid assistant: roles are asked for, agreed freely and written down; the spouse may say no.
- Children are not part of the ministry: no use as sermon illustrations without consent, no extra standard, an ordinary childhood.
- A relative in a church role is a conflict of interest: disclose it, someone else decides, write the terms, review them.
- Ministry may not take what belongs to the people at home; protect rest, a meal, and the household's voice.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| 1 Timothy 3:4-5 read fairly | The household is a place where character shows; it does not mean a minister's family must be perfect. |
| A spouse in the work | Asked, agreed freely, written down; the spouse may say no and may step back. |
| Employing a relative | Disclose it; someone free to say no decides; write the terms; review it; correct as with anyone. |
| What a minister may not do | Take from the household what belongs to it, and call the cost a sacrifice that only others pay. |
One sentence to remember A sacrifice chosen by one person and paid by another is not yet a sacrifice; it is a cost passed on.
This week's action Ask one member of your household, in your own words, whether the balance between ministry and home is right, and listen without defending.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What does your community expect of a minister's spouse and children? Which of these expectations were agreed, and which were simply assumed?
- The lecture reads 1 Timothy 3:4-5 as saying that the household is a place where character shows, not that a minister's family must be perfect. Why might that distinction matter to a child who grew up in a minister's home?
- Think of a role in your church held by a relative of a leader. What would make that arrangement fair? What would make it unfair to others, or to the relative?
- What protections for family time would be realistic in your place? Who would have to agree?
- Read the paragraph beginning "This is a point where readers will not agree." Which position fits your tradition more closely? What would the other say in reply?